nomad2u2001
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,302
Joined: Nov 2006
Reputation: 450
I Root For: ECU
Location: NC
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 08:08 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:55 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
I agree. I have had 4 men from my family play college football (one State, one UVa, one SCSU, and one is at ECU now), they'll all tell you that going in is when your dreams are the strongest. After sitting on the bench a season and seeing the talent of an incoming class quickly changes their minds.
I will say that the amount of time required DOES affect GPA's, field of study, etc. See how accommodating a coach is if a class conflicts with a practice or workout.
One thing that did bother me somewhat is that the medical costs are not covered by the university. When my son had knee surgery - my insurance is what paid the freight. Now mind you, since I had insurance, it wasn't a big deal. But what about a 10K deductible Obama policy - who pays that?
What about the poor kid from the inner city - he's dropped on a campus with NO money for spending and he can't work a part time job - NCAA no-no. They don't need much - just enough for movie night, etc. Remember - they're not allowed to work part time jobs.
Yeah, my cousin had a meniscus surgery and it had to go through his mom's insurance. ECU did cover part of it though.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 08:14 PM |
|
oklalittledixie
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,443
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 129
I Root For: Oklahoma
Location: Oklahoma City
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 07:25 PM)Fo Shizzle Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:16 PM)oklalittledixie Wrote: Totally ridiculous.
Yes...and welcome back Okie.
Thanks man
|
|
| 03-26-2014 08:52 PM |
|
oklalittledixie
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,443
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 129
I Root For: Oklahoma
Location: Oklahoma City
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 07:29 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: I'm not for this union thing or paying players, but there needs to be reform. In no way is it fair that a school should be able to use a player to get as big of a payoff as they do. It has been shown that the player's own signature isn't his own property, and that is BS to me.
Joey Harrington had a full picture of himself on a skyscraper back in 02.
RGIII basically paid for Baylor's new stadium by himself.
There are many other examples.
I know that the players put themselves into an agreement, knowing almost everything they were stepping into, but that doesn't make all the terms of said agreement right.
They're kids for Christ sake. They are not professionals. Unions are not the answer to a greedy NCAA. Absolutely ridiculous. This country has gone off the deep end.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 08:54 PM |
|
nomad2u2001
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,302
Joined: Nov 2006
Reputation: 450
I Root For: ECU
Location: NC
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 08:54 PM)oklalittledixie Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:29 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: I'm not for this union thing or paying players, but there needs to be reform. In no way is it fair that a school should be able to use a player to get as big of a payoff as they do. It has been shown that the player's own signature isn't his own property, and that is BS to me.
Joey Harrington had a full picture of himself on a skyscraper back in 02.
RGIII basically paid for Baylor's new stadium by himself.
There are many other examples.
I know that the players put themselves into an agreement, knowing almost everything they were stepping into, but that doesn't make all the terms of said agreement right.
They're kids for Christ sake. They are not professionals. Unions are not the answer to a greedy NCAA. Absolutely ridiculous. This country has gone off the deep end.
These people have beards and children. They ain't kids.
Like I said, I don't think the union is an answer, but what is?
(This post was last modified: 03-26-2014 08:57 PM by nomad2u2001.)
|
|
| 03-26-2014 08:56 PM |
|
smn1256
I miss Tripster

Posts: 28,847
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation: 337
I Root For: Lower taxes
Location: North Mexico
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
So will the kids pay union dues? Will the students in every other department that generates revenue for the school be considered employees, like when the band puts on a concert? I don't know if Northwestern leans left or right but I'm guessing left - so it surprises me that they'd be against unionizing; of course, when money is at stake, people's views change.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 09:03 PM |
|
nomad2u2001
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,302
Joined: Nov 2006
Reputation: 450
I Root For: ECU
Location: NC
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 09:03 PM)smn1256 Wrote: So will the kids pay union dues? Will the students in every other department that generates revenue for the school be considered employees, like when the band puts on a concert? I don't know if Northwestern leans left or right but I'm guessing left - so it surprises me that they'd be against unionizing; of course, when money is at stake, people's views change.
Good questions. The kids already say that they have no money. Do they get the school to pay union dues? That would be a hard one for the university to swallow.
In my experience, the band does get paid. I did a couple seasons when I went back to school and we got paid. Outside of that, music students could get gigs for some cash. The same with dance, theatre, art and other things that bring in any revenue.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 09:24 PM |
|
smn1256
I miss Tripster

Posts: 28,847
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation: 337
I Root For: Lower taxes
Location: North Mexico
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 09:24 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 09:03 PM)smn1256 Wrote: So will the kids pay union dues? Will the students in every other department that generates revenue for the school be considered employees, like when the band puts on a concert? I don't know if Northwestern leans left or right but I'm guessing left - so it surprises me that they'd be against unionizing; of course, when money is at stake, people's views change.
Good questions. The kids already say that they have no money. Do they get the school to pay union dues? That would be a hard one for the university to swallow.
In my experience, the band does get paid. I did a couple seasons when I went back to school and we got paid. Outside of that, music students could get gigs for some cash. The same with dance, theatre, art and other things that bring in any revenue.
Another thing to consider is will the money the kids get be negotiable? Can a very highly sought after player get more than a walkon? How about performance bonuses? This could get out of hand pretty fast.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 09:29 PM |
|
nomad2u2001
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,302
Joined: Nov 2006
Reputation: 450
I Root For: ECU
Location: NC
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 09:29 PM)smn1256 Wrote: (03-26-2014 09:24 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 09:03 PM)smn1256 Wrote: So will the kids pay union dues? Will the students in every other department that generates revenue for the school be considered employees, like when the band puts on a concert? I don't know if Northwestern leans left or right but I'm guessing left - so it surprises me that they'd be against unionizing; of course, when money is at stake, people's views change.
Good questions. The kids already say that they have no money. Do they get the school to pay union dues? That would be a hard one for the university to swallow.
In my experience, the band does get paid. I did a couple seasons when I went back to school and we got paid. Outside of that, music students could get gigs for some cash. The same with dance, theatre, art and other things that bring in any revenue.
Another thing to consider is will the money the kids get be negotiable? Can a very highly sought after player get more than a walkon? How about performance bonuses? This could get out of hand pretty fast.
I was asking my dad today whether or not it would be legal to exclude other athletes in the long run. Women's sports will say no to its legality; non-revenue sports will do the same.
This is union work. You can't pay those who excel much more than someone else at his position or year unless they are extreme exceptions.
|
|
| 03-26-2014 09:35 PM |
|
gdunn
Repping E-Gang Colors

Posts: 34,756
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3144
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: In The Moment
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
Okla's back.. There goes the neighborhood.
Did you enjoy your "vacation" from this place?
|
|
| 03-27-2014 07:40 AM |
|
Fo Shizzle
Pragmatic Classical Liberal

Posts: 41,888
Joined: Dec 2006
Reputation: 1206
I Root For: ECU PIRATES
Location: North Carolina
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 08:08 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:55 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
I agree. I have had 4 men from my family play college football (one State, one UVa, one SCSU, and one is at ECU now), they'll all tell you that going in is when your dreams are the strongest. After sitting on the bench a season and seeing the talent of an incoming class quickly changes their minds.
I will say that the amount of time required DOES affect GPA's, field of study, etc. See how accommodating a coach is if a class conflicts with a practice or workout.
One thing that did bother me somewhat is that the medical costs are not covered by the university. When my son had knee surgery - my insurance is what paid the freight. Now mind you, since I had insurance, it wasn't a big deal. But what about a 10K deductible Obama policy - who pays that?
What about the poor kid from the inner city - he's dropped on a campus with NO money for spending and he can't work a part time job - NCAA no-no. They don't need much - just enough for movie night, etc. Remember - they're not allowed to work part time jobs.
I can see the problem with not allowing part time jobs off campus...but...why not on campus where it could be controlled away from abuse. Every school employees hundreds of students. I would have no problem with a schools booster program paying for better health insurance coverage or even an "injury" policy in the case of career ending injury. I just don't want the athlete to have access to cash that the other students receive. I understand the issues college athletes face..but..we do not want to set them apart from the general student population any more than necessary. Full scholarship athletes get housing and meals free. It does seem reasonable to me to allow some avenue to them for additional spending money. On campus work could be the answer IMO. It of course would have to be done in a very transparent way with plenty of documentation and oversight.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 07:49 AM |
|
VA49er
Legend

Posts: 32,611
Joined: Dec 2004
Reputation: 1423
I Root For: Charlotte
Location:
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
Reality will set in for these guys when they get their W2 forms. Hey, they are the ones that wanted to be considered employees.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 07:51 AM |
|
QuestionSocratic
Banned
Posts: 8,222
Joined: Jul 2013
I Root For: Buffalo
Location:
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 03:59 PM)AngryAphid Wrote: It’s possible that the NCAA will view a union rep as an agent.
THE most salient point made on this thread.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 07:55 AM |
|
Crebman
Heisman

Posts: 9,412
Joined: Apr 2007
Reputation: 564
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 07:49 AM)Fo Shizzle Wrote: (03-26-2014 08:08 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:55 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
I agree. I have had 4 men from my family play college football (one State, one UVa, one SCSU, and one is at ECU now), they'll all tell you that going in is when your dreams are the strongest. After sitting on the bench a season and seeing the talent of an incoming class quickly changes their minds.
I will say that the amount of time required DOES affect GPA's, field of study, etc. See how accommodating a coach is if a class conflicts with a practice or workout.
One thing that did bother me somewhat is that the medical costs are not covered by the university. When my son had knee surgery - my insurance is what paid the freight. Now mind you, since I had insurance, it wasn't a big deal. But what about a 10K deductible Obama policy - who pays that?
What about the poor kid from the inner city - he's dropped on a campus with NO money for spending and he can't work a part time job - NCAA no-no. They don't need much - just enough for movie night, etc. Remember - they're not allowed to work part time jobs.
I can see the problem with not allowing part time jobs off campus...but...why not on campus where it could be controlled away from abuse. Every school employees hundreds of students. I would have no problem with a schools booster program paying for better health insurance coverage or even an "injury" policy in the case of career ending injury. I just don't want the athlete to have access to cash that the other students receive. I understand the issues college athletes face..but..we do not want to set them apart from the general student population any more than necessary. Full scholarship athletes get housing and meals free. It does seem reasonable to me to allow some avenue to them for additional spending money. On campus work could be the answer IMO. It of course would have to be done in a very transparent way with plenty of documentation and oversight.
I don't disagree with that. However, I will say that given the track record of schools that have been caught cheating in the classes/grading world - you don't think this would be ripe for abuse as well.
Frankly, the amount of money that is now generated for collegiate athletics is WHY university after university admits kids that really aren't college material academically. Once you've sold your academic soul for the athletic dollar, it's pretty hypocritical too pretend that it's all about amateur student athletes - because it's not. It isn't even close to that anymore.
The athletes are powerless in this system. The whole set-up is totally skewed for the benefit of the schools. Take for example the National Letter of Intent. Sign your name on the dotted line and you are committed to the school and can't get out. The school is only obligated for 1 year of scholarship, then they can not renew. For the athlete, if he leaves after that year - he has to sit out a year, and the school can limit where he can go. How one-sided is that.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:07 AM |
|
Bull_In_Exile
Eternal Pessimist

Posts: 21,736
Joined: Jun 2009
Reputation: 461
I Root For: The Underdog
Location:
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 03:56 PM)smn1256 Wrote: I reckon a free education along room and board wasn't enough. Compounding the problem is that most college athletes wouldn't have the grades to get into college on their own merit or the money to pay for it.
Well there are some issues which need to be addressed and the players now have no good way to air grievances. Im not thrilled with what this will me for college sports but the NCAA really should have given players a venue to complain about practice hours, travel times, ....
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:21 AM |
|
Bull_In_Exile
Eternal Pessimist

Posts: 21,736
Joined: Jun 2009
Reputation: 461
I Root For: The Underdog
Location:
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 08:07 AM)Crebman Wrote: The athletes are powerless in this system. The whole set-up is totally skewed for the benefit of the schools. Take for example the National Letter of Intent. Sign your name on the dotted line and you are committed to the school and can't get out. The school is only obligated for 1 year of scholarship, then they can not renew. For the athlete, if he leaves after that year - he has to sit out a year, and the school can limit where he can go. How one-sided is that.
Wait what? ( http://www.ubbullrun.com/2011/4/6/209446...es-Be-Paid)
An indentured servant is one who signs and is bound to work for another for a specified time especially in return for payment of travel expenses and maintenance. While it's true that players sign a letter of intent to attend a school that letter only 'binds' them to that school for the following year. They can wait a year to enroll in college or transfer to another school.
A player can walk away from their scholarship and school at any time. Many do leave school before they complete their degree, many leave for other schools, and some drop out.
That is not the same thing as "can't get out"... And you can go to an FCS school or lower division right away. And if they go FBS they still get a scholarship at the new school while sitting out the one year to transfer.
Now I support 4 years scholarships but let's not paint the student athletes in a worse situation then the one they are actually in.
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2014 08:26 AM by Bull_In_Exile.)
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:26 AM |
|
LSU04_08
Deo Vindice

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 04:35 PM)Smaug Wrote: ...said a fan of an $EC school. 
True, but the school I'm a fan of has brought in more than any other school besides Alabama, this century, to the SEC. Northwestern, not so much. See below:
2000 - 8-4 (won bowl)
2001 - 10-3 (won bowl BCS)
2002 - 8-5 (lost bowl)
2003 - 13-1 (won bowl BCSNC)
2004 - 9-3 (lost bowl)
2005 - 11-2 (won bowl)
2006 - 11-2 (won bowl BCS)
2007 - 12-2 (won bowl BCSNC)
2008 - 8-5 (won bowl)
2009 - 9-4 (lost bowl)
2010 - 11-2 (won bowl)
2011 - 13-1 (lost bowl BCSNC)
2012 - 10-3 (lost bowl)
2013 - 10-3 (won bowl)
The BCS bowls are high dollar, and of course, the BCSNCs are very high dollar...
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:32 AM |
|
LSU04_08
Deo Vindice

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
Matt Mauck took LSU to the National Championship victory in 2003. He was a good QB, but hung around his Sr year to finish with a degree in dentistry. When he realized that he wasn't going to go far in the NFL, he had his degree and now makes great money outside of football.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:39 AM |
|
dcCid
All American

Posts: 2,538
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 37
I Root For: ACC, Big East
Location: Ft Lauderdale, FL
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 07:49 AM)Fo Shizzle Wrote: (03-26-2014 08:08 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:55 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
I agree. I have had 4 men from my family play college football (one State, one UVa, one SCSU, and one is at ECU now), they'll all tell you that going in is when your dreams are the strongest. After sitting on the bench a season and seeing the talent of an incoming class quickly changes their minds.
I will say that the amount of time required DOES affect GPA's, field of study, etc. See how accommodating a coach is if a class conflicts with a practice or workout.
One thing that did bother me somewhat is that the medical costs are not covered by the university. When my son had knee surgery - my insurance is what paid the freight. Now mind you, since I had insurance, it wasn't a big deal. But what about a 10K deductible Obama policy - who pays that?
What about the poor kid from the inner city - he's dropped on a campus with NO money for spending and he can't work a part time job - NCAA no-no. They don't need much - just enough for movie night, etc. Remember - they're not allowed to work part time jobs.
I can see the problem with not allowing part time jobs off campus...but...why not on campus where it could be controlled away from abuse. Every school employees hundreds of students. I would have no problem with a schools booster program paying for better health insurance coverage or even an "injury" policy in the case of career ending injury. I just don't want the athlete to have access to cash that the other students receive. I understand the issues college athletes face..but..we do not want to set them apart from the general student population any more than necessary. Full scholarship athletes get housing and meals free. It does seem reasonable to me to allow some avenue to them for additional spending money. On campus work could be the answer IMO. It of course would have to be done in a very transparent way with plenty of documentation and oversight.
A sport is their job; revenue generating or not. Maybe everyone in college should be required to spend x amount of time working on campus. This may help remove the stigma for those who need to work on campus.
As far as additional spending money – maybe it should be needs based so that someone from a lower economic bracket can go home at times. Or make it so the school pays to bring all parents in for some games each year.
A degree is just a piece of paper that opens doors. It does not mean you are smarter than anyone else. Maybe a different degree for a sports payer, or car mechanic.
As far as medical insurance – my opinion is that any injury on campus needs to be covered by the school.
I for one am not anti-union. Unions are the primary reasons Americans have a 40 hour work week & a string middle class. However I have trouble grasping what it will mean for college sports.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:50 AM |
|
DaSaintFan
Dum' Sutherner in Midwest!

Posts: 17,170
Joined: Mar 2010
Reputation: 595
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: Stuck in St. Louis
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-26-2014 03:45 PM)LSU04_08 Wrote: Political sports... SMH.
http://www.foxnews.com/sports/2014/03/26...ency-says/
"In a ruling that could revolutionize college athletics, a federal agency ruled Wednesday that college football players at Northwestern University can unionize.
NCAA President Mark Emmert has pushed for a $2,000-per-player stipend to help athletes defray some of expenses. Critics say that isn't nearly enough, considering players help bring in millions of dollars to their schools and conferences."
So here's my simple question. How much will union dues be and where will these players get that money.. i mean we apparently don't pay the players (yet). So I'm guessing the union will want part of that stipend?
and what will that money go toward?
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2014 08:54 AM by DaSaintFan.)
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:53 AM |
|
dcCid
All American

Posts: 2,538
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 37
I Root For: ACC, Big East
Location: Ft Lauderdale, FL
|
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 08:39 AM)LSU04_08 Wrote: (03-26-2014 07:51 PM)Crebman Wrote: (03-26-2014 04:36 PM)gdunn Wrote: I'm not saying all, but I'd say a vast majority of college football players seem to view college as a stepping stone to the NFL.. I feel bad for the player that is in his senior year, blows out his knee and can never play again, and hates all he got was a degree in Daycare.
I'd say that you're wrong. I think entering their freshman year they all have those dreams, but if they are very smart - realize what the odds are and at least get their degree. I had a son that played not long ago which obviously gave me access to lots of players on that team.
Matt Mauck took LSU to the National Championship victory in 2003. He was a good QB, but hung around his Sr year to finish with a degree in dentistry. When he realized that he wasn't going to go far in the NFL, he had his degree and now makes great money outside of football.
He is the exception to many. Back in the 80's David Robinson played for Navy. In a Navy Duke game in the NCAA tournament the announcers said it was probably the first tournament game in history when all the players could actually spell their major:)
That said there are different types of inelegance, so how do others receive some piece of paper.
|
|
| 03-27-2014 08:55 AM |
|