Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
Author Message
JMUDunk Offline
Rootin' fer Dukes, bud
*

Posts: 32,512
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 2187
I Root For: Freedom
Location: Shmocation
Post: #141
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 03:33 PM)john01992 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:30 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:26 PM)john01992 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:24 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:23 PM)john01992 Wrote:  ok then say one of the kids owned a shotgun....either way the point stands
OK.. He owns a shotgun, the gun is in the car. Gun hasn't been fired. Dunn stands trial for murder. Kids might get something for having a gun.

and dunn's stand your ground defense holds a sh.tload of more weight to it because of the very existence of that shotgun
Not really.

The story goes they pointed a gun at him and he reached in his glove box and pulled out a weapon.

There's the mutha f*cker of it all.. If kids pull a shotgun and you fear for your life, you're not going to call time out and reach for a pistol on the other side of the car. His story was unbelievable. A person fearing for his life will get the hell out of dodge before going for a gun on the other side of the car and he damn sure ain't going to go all cowboy and keep shooting after the car pulls out. SYG was never used in this case.

his story was so unbelievable that he got a hung jury on the murder charge........

What are you even trying to argue here? That if this guy could have accurately GUESSED that there was a shotgun in the car, that was never brandished and Voila!!! there happened to be one, then that would have possibly led to an acquittal cause the accused, now convicted, is white? Therefore the law is RACIST 03-hissyfit03-hissyfit03-hissyfit

Really? srsly?!? If he were to hit THAT money ball I'd be trotting his lucky a$$ off to Vegas as soon as he walked from the court room. Probably one in a billion shot. Why not say they brandished a big knife, or a machete or a really, really mean looking snake? Why not claim ALL of those things and hope one pops up in the car?

Ridiculous argument. Even more ridiculous conclusion.
03-06-2014 04:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
LSU04_08 Offline
Deo Vindice
*

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
Post: #142
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 04:47 PM)JMUDunk Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:33 PM)john01992 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:30 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:26 PM)john01992 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 03:24 PM)gdunn Wrote:  OK.. He owns a shotgun, the gun is in the car. Gun hasn't been fired. Dunn stands trial for murder. Kids might get something for having a gun.

and dunn's stand your ground defense holds a sh.tload of more weight to it because of the very existence of that shotgun
Not really.

The story goes they pointed a gun at him and he reached in his glove box and pulled out a weapon.

There's the mutha f*cker of it all.. If kids pull a shotgun and you fear for your life, you're not going to call time out and reach for a pistol on the other side of the car. His story was unbelievable. A person fearing for his life will get the hell out of dodge before going for a gun on the other side of the car and he damn sure ain't going to go all cowboy and keep shooting after the car pulls out. SYG was never used in this case.

his story was so unbelievable that he got a hung jury on the murder charge........

What are you even trying to argue here? That if this guy could have accurately GUESSED that there was a shotgun in the car, that was never brandished and Voila!!! there happened to be one, then that would have possibly led to an acquittal cause the accused, now convicted, is white? Therefore the law is RACIST 03-hissyfit03-hissyfit03-hissyfit

Really? srsly?!? If he were to hit THAT money ball I'd be trotting his lucky a$$ off to Vegas as soon as he walked from the court room. Probably one in a billion shot. Why not say they brandished a big knife, or a machete or a really, really mean looking snake? Why not claim ALL of those things and hope one pops up in the car?

Ridiculous argument. Even more ridiculous conclusion.

Hi, I'm a liberal. I read only this part and talked myself into believing that you would take him to Vegas for killing a black kid. I refused to read the rest in order to overlook logic, so in conclusion, I've decided that you, sir, are a racist.


Thanks,

liberal
03-06-2014 05:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #143
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 04:25 PM)john01992 Wrote:  um did you miss the whole zimmerman fiasco.

a dude chases down a kid and inititates the contact......somehow a fight starts....could of been Martian could of been zimmerman.

because zimmerman is the sole survivor we only know his story.

SYG gives us far to many examples of all races where you have to go WTF. those trying to defend it is what makes me realize how stupid certain people in this country are.

while i doubt syg was intended to be racist the fact is that there always will be components to our justice system that allows for the unequal treatment of people. while it is not intentional it is unavoidable and SYG makes it far easier for that to be exploited.

Slow down. First, SYG was not used in the Zimmerman trial.

Second, let's get our facts straight because most of the facts are in dispute. The two of them meet, for whatever reason. Let's say Zimmerman followed Martin...that's not illegal. They meet and get into a scuffle. The evidence shows Trayvon was on top and the witness says Trayvon was pounding Zimmerman. He has bruising and scratches on his head consistent with it making some contact with the concrete. I don't believe he had any bruising on his fists, so it would appear that Trayvon was both the aggressor in the fight and also was getting the better of Zimmerman. Forget about the going for the gun crap. Zimmerman was in reasonable fear that Trayvon wouldn't stop and he would be killed.

That is textbook self-defense. Not even a good law school crimlaw question. Also, Zimmerman identifies as Hispanic.

Additionally, I put up the stats from Fla on SYG. There's really not a difference between white on black as black on white. In fact, it hasn't really been used that much since it was passed in 2005.
03-06-2014 05:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartOfDixie Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 24,572
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 945
I Root For: Alabama
Location: Huntsville AL
Post: #144
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
The idea that stand your ground is racist is a general opinion, and a legal fallacy, not a fact. Let's just leave it at that.
03-06-2014 05:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fitbud Offline
Banned

Posts: 30,896
Joined: Dec 2011
I Root For: PAC 12
Location:
Post: #145
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:10 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 04:25 PM)john01992 Wrote:  um did you miss the whole zimmerman fiasco.

a dude chases down a kid and inititates the contact......somehow a fight starts....could of been Martian could of been zimmerman.

because zimmerman is the sole survivor we only know his story.

SYG gives us far to many examples of all races where you have to go WTF. those trying to defend it is what makes me realize how stupid certain people in this country are.

while i doubt syg was intended to be racist the fact is that there always will be components to our justice system that allows for the unequal treatment of people. while it is not intentional it is unavoidable and SYG makes it far easier for that to be exploited.

Slow down. First, SYG was not used in the Zimmerman trial.

Second, let's get our facts straight because most of the facts are in dispute. The two of them meet, for whatever reason. Let's say Zimmerman followed Martin...that's not illegal. They meet and get into a scuffle. The evidence shows Trayvon was on top and the witness says Trayvon was pounding Zimmerman. He has bruising and scratches on his head consistent with it making some contact with the concrete. I don't believe he had any bruising on his fists, so it would appear that Trayvon was both the aggressor in the fight and also was getting the better of Zimmerman. Forget about the going for the gun crap. Zimmerman was in reasonable fear that Trayvon wouldn't stop and he would be killed.

That is textbook self-defense. Not even a good law school crimlaw question. Also, Zimmerman identifies as Hispanic.

Additionally, I put up the stats from Fla on SYG. There's really not a difference between white on black as black on white. In fact, it hasn't really been used that much since it was passed in 2005.

Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?

Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?
03-06-2014 05:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #146
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
Also, as to Dunn. Let's let at the Florida statute on first degree murder.

Quote:782.04Murder.—

(1)(a)The unlawful killing of a human being:
1.When perpetrated from a premeditated design to effect the death of the person killed or any human being;

2.When committed by a person engaged in the perpetration of, or in the attempt to perpetrate, any:
a.Trafficking offense prohibited by s. 893.135(1),
b.Arson,
c.Sexual battery,
d.Robbery,
e.Burglary,
f.Kidnapping,
g.Escape,
h.Aggravated child abuse,
i.Aggravated abuse of an elderly person or disabled adult,
j.Aircraft piracy,
k.Unlawful throwing, placing, or discharging of a destructive device or bomb,
l.Carjacking,
m.Home-invasion robbery,
n.Aggravated stalking,
o.Murder of another human being,
p.Resisting an officer with violence to his or her person,
q.Aggravated fleeing or eluding with serious bodily injury or death,
r.Felony that is an act of terrorism or is in furtherance of an act of terrorism; or

3.Which resulted from the unlawful distribution of any substance controlled under s. 893.03(1), cocaine as described in s. 893.03(2)(a)4., opium or any synthetic or natural salt, compound, derivative, or preparation of opium, or methadone by a person 18 years of age or older, when such drug is proven to be the proximate cause of the death of the user,

is murder in the first degree and constitutes a capital felony, punishable as provided in s. 775.082.

Pray tell, how is what Dunn did, first degree murder under Florida's statute.
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 05:16 PM by pharaoh0.)
03-06-2014 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Owl 69/70/75 Offline
Just an old rugby coach
*

Posts: 82,008
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 3446
I Root For: RiceBathChelsea
Location: Montgomery, TX

DonatorsNew Orleans Bowl
Post: #147
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 04:25 PM)john01992 Wrote:  um did you miss the whole zimmerman fiasco.
a dude chases down a kid and inititates the contact......somehow a fight starts....could of been Martian could of been zimmerman.
because zimmerman is the sole survivor we only know his story.

You realize that your recitation of "facts" is not remotely close to being enough to prove murder, right?
And what evidence introduced at trial supports the "chases down" and "initiates contact" parts of it?
And you realize that Zimmerman's story was not in evidence because he did not testify, right?
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 05:15 PM by Owl 69/70/75.)
03-06-2014 05:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartOfDixie Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 24,572
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 945
I Root For: Alabama
Location: Huntsville AL
Post: #148
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:10 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 04:25 PM)john01992 Wrote:  um did you miss the whole zimmerman fiasco.

a dude chases down a kid and inititates the contact......somehow a fight starts....could of been Martian could of been zimmerman.

because zimmerman is the sole survivor we only know his story.

SYG gives us far to many examples of all races where you have to go WTF. those trying to defend it is what makes me realize how stupid certain people in this country are.

while i doubt syg was intended to be racist the fact is that there always will be components to our justice system that allows for the unequal treatment of people. while it is not intentional it is unavoidable and SYG makes it far easier for that to be exploited.

Slow down. First, SYG was not used in the Zimmerman trial.

Second, let's get our facts straight because most of the facts are in dispute. The two of them meet, for whatever reason. Let's say Zimmerman followed Martin...that's not illegal. They meet and get into a scuffle. The evidence shows Trayvon was on top and the witness says Trayvon was pounding Zimmerman. He has bruising and scratches on his head consistent with it making some contact with the concrete. I don't believe he had any bruising on his fists, so it would appear that Trayvon was both the aggressor in the fight and also was getting the better of Zimmerman. Forget about the going for the gun crap. Zimmerman was in reasonable fear that Trayvon wouldn't stop and he would be killed.

That is textbook self-defense. Not even a good law school crimlaw question. Also, Zimmerman identifies as Hispanic.

Additionally, I put up the stats from Fla on SYG. There's really not a difference between white on black as black on white. In fact, it hasn't really been used that much since it was passed in 2005.

Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?

Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?

It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.
03-06-2014 05:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #149
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:18 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?

Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?

It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.

^^^This. SYG is an affirmative defense that the defendant must allege. He never tried to use it and instead his counsel defended the case on standard self-defense. Which is what the jury agreed with.
03-06-2014 05:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Owl 69/70/75 Offline
Just an old rugby coach
*

Posts: 82,008
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 3446
I Root For: RiceBathChelsea
Location: Montgomery, TX

DonatorsNew Orleans Bowl
Post: #150
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:21 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:18 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?
Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?
It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.
^^^This. SYG is an affirmative defense that the defendant must allege. He never tried to use it and instead his counsel defended the case on standard self-defense. Which is what the jury agreed with.

Actually, not exactly. The jury never even got to self defense, becuase the state failed to prove its prima facie case. Basically, the way criminal procedure works, the state has to prove its case before the defendant has to prove anything. If the state succeeds in proving its case, then the defendant raises affirmative defenses such as self-defense. This trial never got to that point.
03-06-2014 05:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
LSU04_08 Offline
Deo Vindice
*

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
Post: #151
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:10 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 04:25 PM)john01992 Wrote:  um did you miss the whole zimmerman fiasco.

a dude chases down a kid and inititates the contact......somehow a fight starts....could of been Martian could of been zimmerman.

because zimmerman is the sole survivor we only know his story.

SYG gives us far to many examples of all races where you have to go WTF. those trying to defend it is what makes me realize how stupid certain people in this country are.

while i doubt syg was intended to be racist the fact is that there always will be components to our justice system that allows for the unequal treatment of people. while it is not intentional it is unavoidable and SYG makes it far easier for that to be exploited.

Slow down. First, SYG was not used in the Zimmerman trial.

Second, let's get our facts straight because most of the facts are in dispute. The two of them meet, for whatever reason. Let's say Zimmerman followed Martin...that's not illegal. They meet and get into a scuffle. The evidence shows Trayvon was on top and the witness says Trayvon was pounding Zimmerman. He has bruising and scratches on his head consistent with it making some contact with the concrete. I don't believe he had any bruising on his fists, so it would appear that Trayvon was both the aggressor in the fight and also was getting the better of Zimmerman. Forget about the going for the gun crap. Zimmerman was in reasonable fear that Trayvon wouldn't stop and he would be killed.

That is textbook self-defense. Not even a good law school crimlaw question. Also, Zimmerman identifies as Hispanic.

Additionally, I put up the stats from Fla on SYG. There's really not a difference between white on black as black on white. In fact, it hasn't really been used that much since it was passed in 2005.

Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?

Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?

Martin DID retreat, and instead of going to his house 25 feet away, he hid behind a bush until Zimmerman came around the corner. Don't get me started on this trial, I know every detail that was proven between phone calls, store stops, etc, and timing was EVERYTHING in this case.
03-06-2014 05:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ummechengr Offline
C'mon....really!?!?!
*

Posts: 4,281
Joined: Aug 2005
Reputation: 234
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Memphis, TN
Post: #152
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 04:35 PM)gdunn Wrote:  John.. SYG was never used in Dunn's trial or Zimmerman's trial.

03-banghead03-bangheadTHIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS03-banghead03-banghead
03-06-2014 06:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #153
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 05:30 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:21 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:18 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?
Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?
It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.
^^^This. SYG is an affirmative defense that the defendant must allege. He never tried to use it and instead his counsel defended the case on standard self-defense. Which is what the jury agreed with.

Actually, not exactly. The jury never even got to self defense, becuase the state failed to prove its prima facie case. Basically, the way criminal procedure works, the state has to prove its case before the defendant has to prove anything. If the state succeeds in proving its case, then the defendant raises affirmative defenses such as self-defense. This trial never got to that point.

Yes, I get what you are saying, but, Florida does this a bit differently. In Florida, justifiable homicide instructions are included with the murder instructions. It is not a separate finding in that state. Under 2nd degree murder, the prosecutor must prove that the killing was unlawful. However, if justified, the killing is lawful. Jurors are provided with what qualifies as justifiable homicide in order to determine whether the killing was lawful and therefore whether the prosecutor met the burden of 2nd degree. Essentially, the prosecutor has the burden of proving that the murder was unjustified in Florida. Therefore self-defense is not an affirmative defense in Florida.

Jury Instructions in the Zimmerman trial
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 06:35 PM by pharaoh0.)
03-06-2014 06:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Owl 69/70/75 Offline
Just an old rugby coach
*

Posts: 82,008
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 3446
I Root For: RiceBathChelsea
Location: Montgomery, TX

DonatorsNew Orleans Bowl
Post: #154
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 06:31 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:30 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:21 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:18 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:14 PM)Fitbud Wrote:  Why does "Stand your ground" not apply to Treyvon?
Couldn't it have been said that he feared for his life and under that law, had the right to stop his retreat and use deadly force against Zimmerman?
It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.
^^^This. SYG is an affirmative defense that the defendant must allege. He never tried to use it and instead his counsel defended the case on standard self-defense. Which is what the jury agreed with.

Actually, not exactly. The jury never even got to self defense, becuase the state failed to prove its prima facie case. Basically, the way criminal procedure works, the state has to prove its case before the defendant has to prove anything. If the state succeeds in proving its case, then the defendant raises affirmative defenses such as self-defense. This trial never got to that point.

Yes, I get what you are saying, but, if I'm not mistaken, Florida does this a bit differently. In Florida, justifiable homicide instructions are included with the murder instructions. It is not a separate finding in that state. Under 2nd degree murder, the prosecutor must prove that the killing was unlawful. However, if justified, the killing is lawful. Jurors are provided with what qualifies as justifiable homicide in order to determine whether the killing was lawful and therefore whether the prosecutor met the burden of 2nd degree. Essentially, the prosecutor has the burden of proving that the murder was unjustified in Florida.

Jury Instructions in the Zimmerman trial

I think we're saying the same thing slightly differently. The prosecution has to prove that it was not self defense in order to make its prima facie case. If the prosecution fails to do that, the defendant walks without putting on any evidence. The defense counsel doesn't have to defend the case using self-defense or anything else if the prosecution doesn't get this far. If and only if the prosecution makes its prima facie case, then the defense has the opportunity to put on witnesses to controvert the elements of the prosecution's prima facie case. All the defense has to do is raise reasonable doubt about any one of the required elements, and the defendant must walk.

Here the prosecution never proved that it wasn't self-defense, and therefore failed to make its prima facie case.
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 06:45 PM by Owl 69/70/75.)
03-06-2014 06:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #155
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 06:44 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 06:31 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:30 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:21 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 05:18 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  It doesn't apply because the defense didn't use it.
^^^This. SYG is an affirmative defense that the defendant must allege. He never tried to use it and instead his counsel defended the case on standard self-defense. Which is what the jury agreed with.

Actually, not exactly. The jury never even got to self defense, becuase the state failed to prove its prima facie case. Basically, the way criminal procedure works, the state has to prove its case before the defendant has to prove anything. If the state succeeds in proving its case, then the defendant raises affirmative defenses such as self-defense. This trial never got to that point.

Yes, I get what you are saying, but, if I'm not mistaken, Florida does this a bit differently. In Florida, justifiable homicide instructions are included with the murder instructions. It is not a separate finding in that state. Under 2nd degree murder, the prosecutor must prove that the killing was unlawful. However, if justified, the killing is lawful. Jurors are provided with what qualifies as justifiable homicide in order to determine whether the killing was lawful and therefore whether the prosecutor met the burden of 2nd degree. Essentially, the prosecutor has the burden of proving that the murder was unjustified in Florida.

Jury Instructions in the Zimmerman trial

I think we're saying the same thing slightly differently. The prosecution has to prove that it was not self defense in order to make its prima facie case. If the prosecution fails to do that, the defendant walks without putting on any evidence. The defense counsel doesn't have to defend the case using self-defense or anything else if the prosecution doesn't get this far. If and only if the prosecution makes its prima facie case, then the defense has the opportunity to put on witnesses to controvert the elements of the prosecution's prima facie case. All the defense has to do is raise reasonable doubt about any one of the required elements, and the defendant must walk.

Here the prosecution never proved that it wasn't self-defense, and therefore failed to make its prima facie case.

Actually, and no offense, I don't think you understand the statute. We are not saying the same thing.

'Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:Actually, not exactly. The jury never even got to self defense, becuase the state failed to prove its prima facie case. ... If the state succeeds in proving its case, then the defendant raises affirmative defenses such as self-defense.
Yes, the jury did get to self-defense. They HAVE TO in a 2nd degree murder case in Florida, due to the way the statute is written. In many states this is an affirmative defense, meaning the defendant must prove to a standard (it varies). In Florida, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove that the killing was unjustified. There is no affirmative defense called self-defense in Florida. SYG is an affirmative defense though.
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 08:02 PM by pharaoh0.)
03-06-2014 08:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Owl 69/70/75 Offline
Just an old rugby coach
*

Posts: 82,008
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 3446
I Root For: RiceBathChelsea
Location: Montgomery, TX

DonatorsNew Orleans Bowl
Post: #156
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
Not having practiced in Florida, I will accept your interpretation of the statute. I think it's more a semantic than substantive difference. It probably actually makes the point I've been making cleaner.
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 10:16 PM by Owl 69/70/75.)
03-06-2014 10:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartOfDixie Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 24,572
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 945
I Root For: Alabama
Location: Huntsville AL
Post: #157
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
Do we have a Florida lawyer on here? We have just about every state nearby.

Alabama, Georgia, Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina, Illinois, and I want to say California.
03-06-2014 10:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #158
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 10:20 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  Do we have a Florida lawyer on here? We have just about every state nearby.

Alabama, Georgia, Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina, Illinois, and I want to say California.

That's really funny. You should do a roll call thread. You can add me to your list (VA&DC)
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2014 11:11 PM by pharaoh0.)
03-06-2014 10:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pharaoh0 Offline
Triggered by Microaggressions
*

Posts: 2,918
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 156
I Root For: Duke, L'ville
Location:
Post: #159
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 10:16 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  Not having practiced in Florida, I will accept your interpretation of the statute. I think it's more a semantic than substantive difference. It probably actually makes the point I've been making cleaner.

Let's not beat a dead horse silly. 05-deadhorse I don't practice in FL either, but I did read about it a bunch during the Martin case and looked it up. It was a unique thing that interested me.
03-06-2014 10:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fitbud Offline
Banned

Posts: 30,896
Joined: Dec 2011
I Root For: PAC 12
Location:
Post: #160
RE: NAACP: “Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Part of “Institutional Racism”…
(03-06-2014 10:58 PM)pharaoh0 Wrote:  
(03-06-2014 10:16 PM)Owl 69/70/75 Wrote:  Not having practiced in Florida, I will accept your interpretation of the statute. I think it's more a semantic than substantive difference. It probably actually makes the point I've been making cleaner.

Let's not beat a dead horse silly. 05-deadhorse I don't practice in FL either, but I did read about it a bunch during the Martin case and looked it up. It was a unique thing that interested me.

I was on summer break during the trial and watched almost every minute of it.
03-07-2014 02:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.