Quote:False. Does this make them unfit for public service?
It makes them unfit for my support, yes, barring the choice between a candidate whose decisions on other matters I find more disconcerting (aka; !AMERICAN POLITICS IN GENERAL!)
Quote:I personally believe the earth is between 0 and 5 billion years old.
The problem with this particular question, and the answer that religious fundamentalists give on it (really, it is only the fundamentalists who respond this way, the Catholic Church accepts the scientific consensus on the age of the earth, as do most protestants), is that to truly believe the earth is 6,000 or 10,000 years old, one must ignore all semblance of understanding our worlds structure/shape/biology/history/chemistry/etc. It's not a theological, moral, or even philosophical question at all, it's not a question about the topic of abiogenesis for instance, it's a basic component of a rational view of the world as it physically exists.
I don't want someone in office who doesn't understand simple concepts like this, or when confronted by scientific concepts he/she/it/ROBO-PRES_00069 doesn't understand, refers to the strict literalism of a book of parables. Would you want a president wondering if a new influenza strain was caused by a talking snake and phones the pope, or one who mobilizes immunology and pathology experts to eradicate it?
This is not to say all religious beliefs remove one from consideration or even from rationality, they certainly don't. But one that goes directly against basic tenets of almost every single one of the hard sciences is hard to accept in a leader.