(09-29-2013 08:03 PM)BruceMcF Wrote: (09-29-2013 09:24 AM)NIU007 Wrote: I don't know why we would add 2, we already have 13. There's concern from a lot of posters that adding another team just dilutes whatever revenue we get while adding another bottom MAC team, the assumption being that JMU would be a bottom team, at least initially, and maybe for some time to come. I think JMU has the potential to be a good MAC team though.
Yes, the principle reason to go to 14 is balanced divisions, and in particular with Toledo/Bowling Green in the same division.
That's not a "survival level" motive, which is why the MAC should only take a school that seems likely to become established as a long term contributor to the conference: no footloose schools and no schools taken because they were the only ones available.
There are several potential options here for the MAC of varying quality so its tough to predict what MAC leadership will ultimately do and what will motivate it.
1) Drop UMass and return to 12 (great idea). Going back to 12 is one of the best possible ideas but does MAC Leadership have the guts to pull the trigger?
2) Status quo and stay at 13 (weak idea). The MAC thus far has not found a replacement for Temple 18 months after their departure. I don't think this is as much a wait and see thing as not being able to get a deal done when ODU was still on the table. Can 13 continue to be alright in the short term? That short term may be 10 years, we really don't know at this point.
3) Add one more FB only for 14 (okay idea). The idea of yet another FB only agreement with a school leaves a bad taste in some MAC mouths but it is at least higher ground if done with JMU or Delaware than where the MAC sits at 13 currently. A new agreement and a new buyout clause could help things.
4) Add one more and go 14 all sports (good idea). Bringing in Delaware and JMU all sports to go along with UMass is something that would be welcomed however that is not the direction UMass necessarily wants to go in.
5) Add two more and go to 15 in FB, 14 in BB (okay idea). In this situation the MAC takes both JMU and Delaware in all sports while UMass remains as a FB only member. The MAC rescues two schools from the dying CAA at once to convince the other to go. The MAC is still able to move BG to the West like it wants and schools like Miami and Ohio don't have to shift through the directionals on the schedule.
6) Go to 16 all sports (okay idea). Perhaps to entice UMass the MAC decides to add a full compliment of eastern schools (UMass, Stony, UDel, JMU). The problem I see is that 16 forces the MAC to split the Ohio schools down the middle which I don't think some of the Ohio schools want. Its also unwieldy in size for a conference that only has 4-5 bowl games.
7) Go to 16 with 4 FB only schools (weak idea). There is no point in having 4 FB only schools in the MAC when 2 FB only is all you need.
8) Go to 16 in FB, 14 in BB (okay idea). Here the MAC trys something like UDEL/JMU all sports UMass/Missouri St football only. If the MAC really wants to get to 16 and really wants the most promising football schools on the table then I can see where taking Missouri St, JMU and Delaware could make some sense with Missouri St due to travel staying FB only to balance UMass FB only in the East.
-Out of all the possibilities I like going to 15 in FB with UDel/JMU all sports the best. Both schools have very nice budgets that would be at the upper end of the MAC. UMass for the time being can hang around as an FB only school. When realignment hits, JMU will be more likely to stay in the MAC over going to CUSA if Delaware is also in the MAC. It pads the MAC more from future defections and additional FB only situations down the road. JMU and Delaware don't have great basketball programs to protect right now so MAC hoops makes a lot of sense for them.