MaumeeRocket Wrote:KlutzDio I Wrote:Maumee, you said it. Killing is killing and one thing our soldiers do overseas is killing. Don't sugar coat it with all this empty rhetoric of Democratizing the region, or fighting for the advancement of values. Killing is killing and when we do it in a military capacity it is still killing--and consequently still wrong!
It would be a much better world if nobody had to pick up a gun or kill their unborn child. Killing is terrible no matter who does it. I dont support out troop being anywhere but here, but unfortunately the world dosent work like that. They have to be overseas and i will support them. Second i think if took a poll of all 130,000 men and women i dont think killing other peoples babies is high on their list, they want to come home and most of them realize they signed up for it and have to finish out their duty.
So basically what you are getting at is you hate killing in general and you hate even more some people's rationalizations for unnecessary killings, i.e. abortion.
Abortion lovers rationalize their act of killing by claiming that the fetus is not really a life yet, or they can't care for the fetus, or the father took off so what's the point, or I'm too young to have a baby, or I can't get into my prom dress all big, fat and pregnant, or I can't get into my wedding dress all big, fat and pregnant.
In short, the abortion crowd rationalizes killing to absolve them of responsibility for their actions.
Likewise, soldiers rationalize unnecessary killings in a variety of ways.
1. Following orders, yet all U.S. servicemen and women have one superceding order that they can ignore or challenge any cleary unethical or immoral orders.
2. Killing these heathens (whether Japanese, German or A-Rabs) protects my family.
3. Killing Arabs overseas protects my individual freedom.
4. Killing Arabs overseas protects my country, nevermind the fact that the Iraqis were incapable of attacking the United States.
5. Killing Arabs or anyone who steps to me protects my nation's collective freedom.
6. Killing will land me that next stripe, or those Captain bars.
7. Killing will land me some medals so that way, one day I can be a big-wig at the local VFW chapter.
8. Why should I care about killing, let God sort them out!
And there are many other rationalizations for killing by our servicemen and women.
Key to this discussion are the rationalizations our leaders use that put our military personnel in the theatre that makes killing all the more possible. Those rationalizations are varied, yet many are the same as the ones our soldiers use to justify unnecessary killing.
So, what we have here Maumee is you disagree with rationalizing murder that absolves one of irresponsibility. Yet, at the same time you agree with many of the rationalizations our leaders use to murder. Many of the rationalizations for killing in the present two conflicts overseas were constructed to absolve our government of irresponsible actions due to past policies.
We propped up Saddam, we left the Afghanis high and dry after the Soviet pullout. We turned the blind eye to the Taliban, and we provided Saddam with the chemicals to gas and kill.
Likewise, we fund and provide Israel with their war machine. This is another irresponsible policy on the part of our government, and one day a big war will be rationalized in order to absolve us of responsibility in that matter.