UTVOLS Wrote:It doesn't take 20 to 30 years to build a program. We live in the " I want it now" society. If coaches are not winning in 3 to 4 years - they are gone. But in OM tradition - even if you are winning (Clutcliff) you are still fired. Nobody waits 20 years anymore. You guys got rid of the best coach you have had in a while.
And what is the deal with Tuberville leaving us high and dry comment? I don't understand that. He knew that he would never get it done at OM so he went to Auburn where he could.
Georgia sucked before Richt came along. Alabama has been through scholarship reductions and almost the death penalty and they get it done. LSU got it turned around with Saban. Florida sucked with Zook.
I think the trend here is coaching. And believe me, Coach O will not have a winning tradition at OM. You will stay in your mediocre state dreaming of the day that Archie was there.
Memphis will win because of West. He is a good coach and UT grad so he knows what he is doing.
Tradition may make for good talk and look good on paper. But it is what you are doing lately that makes it happen. Ask Fulmer. He has the winningest % in football, won a NC, and has a few SEC titles - that is tradition. He went 5-6 last year and he is on the hot seat.
I wouldn't expect you to understand what it takes to build a program, because UT has always invested in football. My point is that it takes a long time to build the type of athletic budget that it takes to compete on a year in year out basis (not just for a short stretch) with the big boys of college football.
I agree with you that it's a what have you done for me lately thing. That's why we fired Cut. Our administration could see what had happened, and that the future didn't look to be different if changes weren't made. Cut refused to offer any suggestions for changes, so he was axed. Essentially, he was in the same boat Fulmer was this season. The difference is Fulmer offered to fire his OC. Had Cut gotten rid of his DC, he'd have had another year or two to turn it around. By the way, in the end, Cut should be glad we let him go, because he could've died had we kept him around another season, but that's another story.
Here is my reason why it takes 20-30 years to build a "program" at that level.
I think we can all agree that college football starts and ends with the coaches, like you said, because they do the recruiting to bring the players. They have the system that is used. The team doesn't run itself successfully. I agree that you can build a "team" on a high level at Ole Miss or Memphis, but if you do build a "team" that's that good, you'll see other teams come after your coaches, and eventually schools like ours simply couldn't afford to keep those coaches.
This is what happened to us with Tubberville. He, in a very short period, built a "team" that could compete with a lot of people. It wasn't on the highest level, but keep in mind his first two seasons had major scholarship reductions, so the level he had Ole Miss at in that period of time was phenomenal. (His 1999 team was only 15 points from undefeated.) He became worth more money than we were willing to pay, so he jumped ship. It wasn't just the money either. He also was asking for an indoor practice facility and stadium expansion, which we needed if he was going to take that next step. Our AD at the time said he couldn't promise that, so Tubby knew he wouldn't be able to compete with the rest of the SEC in the long run if he stayed.
Like I said, this opened our alumni and athletic department's eyes to the fact that we weren't going to be able to win in the long run just by hiring the right coach and keeping him with an average salary. Coaches don't just stay at your school because they love it. They stay because you offer them a good chance at long term success, financially and professionally. So far for Memphis, they haven't had quite enough success yet for Tommy to become a hot commodity nationally. If they were to move to the SEC and have a very solid 5 year run through the conference, the big money schools would come along to steal him away. I know Tommy is loyal to Memphis and all, but when you get offers to double your salary and have much better stadium and facilities to recruit to, you usually go.
The only exception I can think of is a guy like Rich Rodriguez who is coaching at his alma mater successfully. Sometimes in that case, money isn't everything and a coach is willing to stay to lead his alma mater to the top.
Anyway, a "program", by my definition, isn't 5 years of sustained success, because one or two great players can make that happen. A "program" is 10-15 years of continually playing at a championship level, which means you've gone through the entire turnover of the team 2-3 times and produced the same level of results. It's tough to achieve that if your stadium, facilities, and budget for salaries isn't on par with the rest of the top teams in college football.
To our administration's credit, they've realized this and began making strides by building new facilities, expanding the stadium and making more room in the budget for coaching salaries, but we still have a lot of catching up to do before we could consider being financially on the level of an LSU or Alabama because we gave them a 20-30 year head start. Anyone who's ever taken a finance class knows that giving someone that much of a head start is hard to make up.
Memphis would be in that same boat, being even further behind those schools. If they could luck out and have that kind of success and somehow keep Tommy (a la Rodriguez at WVU), they could potentially sustain that level of success until he retired. Of course, at that point, you start all over, and you're looking for a new face. Schools with the facilities and finances can afford to hire the best new coaches to keep that tradition rolling. If by that point Memphis didn't have the facilities and finances to attract a top national coach, they'd slide back to mediocre.
I guess to summarize, a school like UT doesn't have to worry about ever dropping off the face of college football, because they can afford to stay there. Let's say Fulmer retires, and UT makes a bad hire for his replacement. It's no big deal. They can fire the guy and immediately hire one of the best coaches in the country to bring them back. Memphis and Ole Miss on the other hand don't have the same luxury. If a coach doesn't work out for us, we can't just hire the No. 1 prospect in the country or go the NFL route to hire the best coaches.