bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,938
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Illini’s Bielema says they’d be a top 15 team in the SEC
(11-08-2026 11:38 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (11-08-2026 09:07 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-08-2026 05:17 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I’m an unabashed Illini homer.
I don’t think Illinois is a top 15 team.
However, I’m definitely sick of the “virtuous circle” that the SEC always seems to get. That is, when a highly ranked team in the SEC gets upset, then that’s evidence of how deep the SEC is. In contrast, whenever a highly ranked team in the Big Ten (or Big 12 or ACC, for that matter), that’s evidence of how that highly ranked team is overrated and then give little credit to the team that beat them.
I don’t question that Georgia is an elite team. They’re the best team that I’ve seen all year. However, I do question why LSU and Ole Miss keep getting the benefit of the doubt in the rankings, why Missouri was ever ranked in the first place, why has Kentucky been constantly ranked higher than Iowa, etc. I think that second level beyond the true first tier of the SEC is continuously overrated.
The virtuous circle thing happened a lot in 2024 and 2025 in the B1G, too, but this year, everybody except UCLA and Indiana is having an average to down year, while ND and half the Big 12 (and 2/3 of the SEC) are all having above average years.
Here's an interesting question. When was the last time that OSU, Michigan and PSU all had 3 losses apiece in an entire season, much less in 3/4 of one? If OSU loses again then none of the 3 will be ranked for, I dunno, probably the first time since PSU joined the Conference. Just looking at OSU, since 2002, they've only had at least 3 losses 3 times: 2004, 2008, and 2011. If Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee and Texas had 4 losses apiece right now instead of 1-2, the SEC probably wouldn't look so mighty, either. I would go further and say that in a year like this, when EVERYBODY is struggling in the B1G, even USC has 2 losses and Oregon has 3, it should be a major upset for the B1G to get 3-4 CFP teams, and yet you're still in the running to do exactly that. You still have 6 in the top 21 in the current AP poll, I'd say that all 6 of those schools still have a chance.
What? The SEC had 5 teams in last year's playoff while the Big Ten only had three. And yet Big Ten teams won 5 playoff games while SEC teams only won 3. If anything the Big Ten was unfairly under-ranked last year and should have gotten more teams in over, at least, Alabama.
3 really good teams that were better than SEC #1-3 but then 15 that were all weaker than SEC #4-16 feels like an apt description of last year. This year is just a weird year at the top in the B1G with OSU getting killed by injuries, Michigan and PSU with new and struggling coaches, and Oregon also getting killed by injuries. When you have to rely on UCLA, Indiana and any team coached by Lincoln Riley, I mean, that's probably not Petitti's dream scenario.
Putting things in perspective, if we had a hypothetical matchup of the top 5 of the B1G vs the top 5 of the Big 12 on Saturday, it would probably split 3-2, and I'm unsure of who would be the 3 and who the 2.
Utah - UCLA
Indiana - Texas Tech
BYU - USC
Houston - Iowa
Arizona - OSU
Those all look pretty even to me. There is just nobody who is dominant the way Indiana finished last year. Maybe one of the top contenders will separate themselves in CFP, though that team could easily come from any of the P4 or ND right now. Perhaps we end up with a Wake Forest - Houston National Title game?
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2026 12:59 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|