bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 04:42 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote: (10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote: If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.
If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. It's the only thing official thus far.
JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.
The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.
There might eventually be a next version, but we've just seen how very easy it is to kill a bill like this. Is this version a bit more freindly towards the Texas Techs and less friendly towards the Texases of the world? Sure, but everyone can live with it. Try to ramrod something that a significant portion of the P4 objects to and it will be DOA, certainly with anything remotely like our current legislators in office. Perhaps in 20-30 years something else could get passed over the objections of most of the P4, though I doubt it. And in the meantime, even if something eventually does pass down the road, the bigger schools will start making plans to aggressively deal with the hand we've been dealt by Congress with Title IX, the EO over the past 50 years with its interpretation of Title IX to go far beyond the original texas, and, ultimately, the Supreme Court's foray into this mess that the other branches created.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 08:16 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|
| 10-26-2026 08:14 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 08:14 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (10-26-2026 04:42 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote: (10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote: If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.
If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. It's the only thing official thus far.
JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.
The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.
There might eventually be a next version, but we've just seen how very easy it is to kill a bill like this. Is this version a bit more freindly towards the Texas Techs and less friendly towards the Texases of the world? Sure, but everyone can live with it. Try to ramrod something that a significant portion of the P4 objects to and it will be DOA, certainly with anything remotely like our current legislators in office. Perhaps in 20-30 years something else could get passed over the objections of most of the P4, though I doubt it.
The problem Bryan is not what the P4 approves of or objects to. The problem is the SCOTUS doesn't give a damn what the Big Ten and SEC thinks, or any of the others.
If Congress can't get it together, regardless of what the P4 do or don't approve of, the new reality will be the recent and continued SCOTUS rulings. And frankly if Congress becomes even more muddled, and the large school / small school issues in the light of the enrollment drop off does require cuts, I suspect the Representatives will let nature take its course and avoid direct responsibility for a no win scenario. Whether to piss off a lot of smaller state schools and their alumni, or the alumni of the two largest state schools, is a no-win voter issue. My guess is they'll let the demographics do their work for them while making blanket statements of support for all. But make no mistake a winnowing is coming not just with a P4 separation but likely at the state levels of support. And if Congress is deadlocked intentionally or unintentionally it provides political cover and leaves the SCOTUS rulings as the directive to the schools. Supreme Court Justices don't stand for election. Occam's Razor. And it would kill the caps and waiting period but would force a new school / player relationship and one not all will be able to afford to follow, and that increases the supply of athletes for those who can afford it. The players get to be paid and have a say. The schools take on more overhead but with expanded playoffs and scheduling agreements there to cover it. My guess is something like this will be the political solution for the reasons stated. A conservative SCOTUS gets to lead on reform. The big schools get their salary caps but through negotiation, players are under contract which constrains the portal issue, and the cost brings a larger supply of athletes to a smaller number of schools overcoming a decline in available athletes. It's a win/win which will look like a victory for the players. End of story.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 08:40 PM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 10-26-2026 08:32 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote: If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.
If Congress wants to take the matter up again (I’m not sure that happens), I’d expect the same. Coaches’ compensation will get a closer look, as will the athletes’ ability to organize and negotiate collectively.
These elements could be grafted onto some of the more widely supported features of the current PCSA. Fortuitous timing could yield a result in a law showing more balance. We’ll see.
__
(This post was last modified: 10-27-2026 07:36 AM by Gitanole.)
|
|
| 10-26-2026 09:17 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
Since Kavanaugh's ruling, we have college sports as is. I'm seeing more urgency getting legislation passed than anyone reverting to his ruling.
|
|
| 10-27-2026 06:24 AM |
|