Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Rank The American, Week 9
Author Message
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,476
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #1
Rank The American, Week 9
Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.
(This post was last modified: 10-24-2026 10:34 PM by Ned Low.)
10-24-2026 10:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #2
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I think you have Navy a bit high, USF FAU and ECU too low. Otherwise, I'd say the others are about right.

Memphis and UNT could be switched maybe, but I'm fine with it. I agree with UTSA right now.

We still have a shot at a Championship game, but we have a tough road ahead. UNT plays UTSA still and one of them has to lose. Army has a legit chance too.

Still wide open
10-25-2026 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank Grimes Offline
One of "Kent's People"
*

Posts: 3,764
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 687
I Root For: UAB,Springfield Isotopes
Location: 205/Springfield
Post: #3
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

Almost impossible to rank this league. I’d just group them in buckets.

Think 1-3 on your list are the top tier, then 4-11 are all capable of beating one another, then teams 12-14 are together.
10-25-2026 11:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UofMemphis Away
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack
*

Posts: 49,759
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)

Donators
Post: #4
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
Army @ Memphis should be a very telling game for both teams IMHO.
10-25-2026 11:43 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #5
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I didn't change your rankings -- it's pertinent to highlight what I feel are indefensible disconnects in logic. Was your list meant to be satire?

1. UTSA (4-0):
Undefeated in conference play. They deserve this position until proven otherwise.

2. UNT (3-0):
They're more consistent than Memphis, but can't play defense at all.

3. Memphis (3-1):
Variance is their Achilles heel and the Tigers deserve to be below UTSA and UNT, but the talent and potential is there to take it all if they can execute consistently.

4. Army (4-1):
No strong pushback. Army has been consistent thus far.

5. Tulsa (1-3):
This is far too high for a team who's 1-3 in the AAC and is impossible to justify.

6. Navy (1-4):
This is an even worse lapse in critical thinking and egregiously high for a team who's 1-4 in the AAC. Objectively delusional.

7. Tulane (1-2):
I'm seeing a clear bias here. Tulane is 1-2 in the AAC and will struggle to garner more wins. I could see Charlotte beating them this Friday. The only reason they have a conference win at all is due to Memphis imploding and cutting their own throats in New Orleans, not because Tulane is particularly talented or well coached.

8. UAB (2-1):
The Blazers are 2-1 in the AAC. In what universe are they below the aforementioned? UAB humiliating ECU bias, beating the Pirates by 13 in overtime?

9. USF (1-2):
USF is 1-2 in the AAC and could have easily lost at home to Kent State -- among the worst teams in FBS -- last week if not for highly suspect calls. Why reward USF when they've done nothing while punishing Temple in spite of beating USF? This is a team that has yet to put up 30 points against any FBS opponent with the weakest non-conference slate in DI football.

10. ECU (1-2):
Potentially a better team than USF and should objectively be above them. ECU appears to have a pulse and has broken the 30-point ceiling against FBS competition unlike USF.

11. FAU (2-1):
They're 2-1 in the AAC yet you have them at 11th place? What?

12. Charlotte (1-2):
They're 1-2 in the AAC just like ECU, USF, Tulane, and Temple. This feels like more ECU bias, considering Charlotte objectively owns the series against ECU.

13. Rice (0-4):
The only winless team in conference play. They are last by any objective measure and having them above Temple is impossible to justify. Records matter.

14. Temple (1-2):
Should be clustered with Charlotte, ECU, USF, and Tulane. Let's not pretend that they didn't beat USF who you oddly ranked higher. In what universe can Temple be dead last? From what I've seen, the 1-2 teams are all of similar quality, and until proven otherwise, all 1-2 teams should be above winless Rice.
10-25-2026 11:44 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,476
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #6
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-25-2026 11:44 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I didn't change your rankings -- it's pertinent to highlight what I feel are indefensible disconnects in logic. Was your list meant to be satire?

1. UTSA (4-0):
Undefeated in conference play. They deserve this position until proven otherwise.

2. UNT (3-0):
They're more consistent than Memphis, but can't play defense at all.

3. Memphis (3-1):
Variance is their Achilles heel and the Tigers deserve to be below UTSA and UNT, but the talent and potential is there to take it all if they can execute consistently.

4. Army (4-1):
No strong pushback. Army has been consistent thus far.

5. Tulsa (1-3):
This is far too high for a team who's 1-3 in the AAC and is impossible to justify.

6. Navy (1-4):
This is an even worse lapse in critical thinking and egregiously high for a team who's 1-4 in the AAC. Objectively delusional.

7. Tulane (1-2):
I'm seeing a clear bias here. Tulane is 1-2 in the AAC and will struggle to garner more wins. I could see Charlotte beating them this Friday. The only reason they have a conference win at all is due to Memphis imploding and cutting their own throats in New Orleans, not because Tulane is particularly talented or well coached.

8. UAB (2-1):
The Blazers are 2-1 in the AAC. In what universe are they below the aforementioned? UAB humiliating ECU bias, beating the Pirates by 13 in overtime?

9. USF (1-2):
USF is 1-2 in the AAC and could have easily lost at home to Kent State -- among the worst teams in FBS -- last week if not for highly suspect calls. Why reward USF when they've done nothing while punishing Temple in spite of beating USF? This is a team that has yet to put up 30 points against any FBS opponent with the weakest non-conference slate in DI football.

10. ECU (1-2):
Potentially a better team than USF and should objectively be above them. ECU appears to have a pulse and has broken the 30-point ceiling against FBS competition unlike USF.

11. FAU (2-1):
They're 2-1 in the AAC yet you have them at 11th place? What?

12. Charlotte (1-2):
They're 1-2 in the AAC just like ECU, USF, Tulane, and Temple. This feels like more ECU bias, considering Charlotte objectively owns the series against ECU.

13. Rice (0-4):
The only winless team in conference play. They are last by any objective measure and having them above Temple is impossible to justify. Records matter.

14. Temple (1-2):
Should be clustered with Charlotte, ECU, USF, and Tulane. Let's not pretend that they didn't beat USF who you oddly ranked higher. In what universe can Temple be dead last? From what I've seen, the 1-2 teams are all of similar quality, and until proven otherwise, all 1-2 teams should be above winless Rice.

You make some fair points. I feel confident in my Top 4 but in truth, teams ranked 5 through 12 are fairly interchangeable at this moment based on the data at hand.

This group is where we’ll see the most movement in the coming weeks.

Charlotte beating Tulane would not shock me, to be honest. We agree on that one… something is definitely “off” in New Orleans.
(This post was last modified: 10-25-2026 01:35 PM by Ned Low.)
10-25-2026 01:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


BeatNavy Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,702
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 285
I Root For: Army
Location: NH
Post: #7
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-25-2026 01:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 11:44 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I didn't change your rankings -- it's pertinent to highlight what I feel are indefensible disconnects in logic. Was your list meant to be satire?

1. UTSA (4-0):
Undefeated in conference play. They deserve this position until proven otherwise.

2. UNT (3-0):
They're more consistent than Memphis, but can't play defense at all.

3. Memphis (3-1):
Variance is their Achilles heel and the Tigers deserve to be below UTSA and UNT, but the talent and potential is there to take it all if they can execute consistently.

4. Army (4-1):
No strong pushback. Army has been consistent thus far.

5. Tulsa (1-3):
This is far too high for a team who's 1-3 in the AAC and is impossible to justify.

6. Navy (1-4):
This is an even worse lapse in critical thinking and egregiously high for a team who's 1-4 in the AAC. Objectively delusional.

7. Tulane (1-2):
I'm seeing a clear bias here. Tulane is 1-2 in the AAC and will struggle to garner more wins. I could see Charlotte beating them this Friday. The only reason they have a conference win at all is due to Memphis imploding and cutting their own throats in New Orleans, not because Tulane is particularly talented or well coached.

8. UAB (2-1):
The Blazers are 2-1 in the AAC. In what universe are they below the aforementioned? UAB humiliating ECU bias, beating the Pirates by 13 in overtime?

9. USF (1-2):
USF is 1-2 in the AAC and could have easily lost at home to Kent State -- among the worst teams in FBS -- last week if not for highly suspect calls. Why reward USF when they've done nothing while punishing Temple in spite of beating USF? This is a team that has yet to put up 30 points against any FBS opponent with the weakest non-conference slate in DI football.

10. ECU (1-2):
Potentially a better team than USF and should objectively be above them. ECU appears to have a pulse and has broken the 30-point ceiling against FBS competition unlike USF.

11. FAU (2-1):
They're 2-1 in the AAC yet you have them at 11th place? What?

12. Charlotte (1-2):
They're 1-2 in the AAC just like ECU, USF, Tulane, and Temple. This feels like more ECU bias, considering Charlotte objectively owns the series against ECU.

13. Rice (0-4):
The only winless team in conference play. They are last by any objective measure and having them above Temple is impossible to justify. Records matter.

14. Temple (1-2):
Should be clustered with Charlotte, ECU, USF, and Tulane. Let's not pretend that they didn't beat USF who you oddly ranked higher. In what universe can Temple be dead last? From what I've seen, the 1-2 teams are all of similar quality, and until proven otherwise, all 1-2 teams should be above winless Rice.

You make some fair points. I feel confident in my Top 4 but in truth, teams ranked 5 through 12 are fairly interchangeable at this moment based on the data at hand.

This group is where we’ll see the most movement in the coming weeks.

Charlotte beating Tulane would not shock me, to be honest. We agree on that one… something is definitely “off” in New Orleans.

Army is consistent in having at least one WTF offensive drive in each game. The most recent example is after Tulsa scored to cut Army's lead from 14 to 7 early in the 3rd quarter:

put backup QB in because he needs experience

delay of game before 1st down

2 yd run on QB run (not option play)

put starter in
no gain on QB run (not option)

completion for 1st down on 3rd & 13 negated by C being too far downfield looking for someone to block

10 yd QB run

50 yard punt on 4th & 8, but illegal formation gave Tulsa an extra 5 yards after no return

3 plays, 2 yards -- but could be called -3 yards if you consider the 5 yard penalty on the punt
(This post was last modified: 10-25-2026 07:05 PM by BeatNavy.)
10-25-2026 07:03 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Side.Show.Joe Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,127
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 1344
I Root For: North Texas
Location:
Post: #8
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
1. UTSA
1. North Texas
3. Army
4. South Florida
5. UAB
6. Memphis
7. Navy
8. FAU
9. Tulsa
10. Tulane
11. ECU
12. Charlotte
13. Temple
14. Rice
10-25-2026 09:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Meow Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 674
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 118
I Root For: UTSA
Location: Bee Cave, TX
Post: #9
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
1. UTSA
2. North Texas
3. Memphis
4. Army
5. South Florida.
6. FAU
7. UAB
8. Tulsa
9. Tulane
10. ECU
11. Navy
12. Temple
13. Rice
14. Charlotte
10-25-2026 09:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
goliath74 Offline
5318008
*

Posts: 10,090
Joined: Nov 2013
Reputation: 759
I Root For: FAU, FSU
Location: Boca Raton, Florida
Post: #10
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
Remember, during the first few weeks we kept noting that it is hard to separate most of the teams in the conference. Aren't we still there?
10-25-2026 09:33 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,642
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2234
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #11
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-25-2026 09:33 PM)goliath74 Wrote:  Remember, during the first few weeks we kept noting that it is hard to separate most of the teams in the conference. Aren't we still there?

This week's games should do much to figure out the pecking order without so much guesswork.
10-25-2026 10:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #12
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-25-2026 09:07 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  1. UTSA
1. North Texas
3. Army
4. South Florida
5. UAB
6. Memphis
7. Navy
8. FAU
9. Tulsa
10. Tulane
11. ECU
12. Charlotte
13. Temple
14. Rice

How many beers did you have in you when you made this list?
10-26-2026 05:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #13
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-25-2026 07:03 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 01:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 11:44 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I didn't change your rankings -- it's pertinent to highlight what I feel are indefensible disconnects in logic. Was your list meant to be satire?

1. UTSA (4-0):
Undefeated in conference play. They deserve this position until proven otherwise.

2. UNT (3-0):
They're more consistent than Memphis, but can't play defense at all.

3. Memphis (3-1):
Variance is their Achilles heel and the Tigers deserve to be below UTSA and UNT, but the talent and potential is there to take it all if they can execute consistently.

4. Army (4-1):
No strong pushback. Army has been consistent thus far.

5. Tulsa (1-3):
This is far too high for a team who's 1-3 in the AAC and is impossible to justify.

6. Navy (1-4):
This is an even worse lapse in critical thinking and egregiously high for a team who's 1-4 in the AAC. Objectively delusional.

7. Tulane (1-2):
I'm seeing a clear bias here. Tulane is 1-2 in the AAC and will struggle to garner more wins. I could see Charlotte beating them this Friday. The only reason they have a conference win at all is due to Memphis imploding and cutting their own throats in New Orleans, not because Tulane is particularly talented or well coached.

8. UAB (2-1):
The Blazers are 2-1 in the AAC. In what universe are they below the aforementioned? UAB humiliating ECU bias, beating the Pirates by 13 in overtime?

9. USF (1-2):
USF is 1-2 in the AAC and could have easily lost at home to Kent State -- among the worst teams in FBS -- last week if not for highly suspect calls. Why reward USF when they've done nothing while punishing Temple in spite of beating USF? This is a team that has yet to put up 30 points against any FBS opponent with the weakest non-conference slate in DI football.

10. ECU (1-2):
Potentially a better team than USF and should objectively be above them. ECU appears to have a pulse and has broken the 30-point ceiling against FBS competition unlike USF.

11. FAU (2-1):
They're 2-1 in the AAC yet you have them at 11th place? What?

12. Charlotte (1-2):
They're 1-2 in the AAC just like ECU, USF, Tulane, and Temple. This feels like more ECU bias, considering Charlotte objectively owns the series against ECU.

13. Rice (0-4):
The only winless team in conference play. They are last by any objective measure and having them above Temple is impossible to justify. Records matter.

14. Temple (1-2):
Should be clustered with Charlotte, ECU, USF, and Tulane. Let's not pretend that they didn't beat USF who you oddly ranked higher. In what universe can Temple be dead last? From what I've seen, the 1-2 teams are all of similar quality, and until proven otherwise, all 1-2 teams should be above winless Rice.

You make some fair points. I feel confident in my Top 4 but in truth, teams ranked 5 through 12 are fairly interchangeable at this moment based on the data at hand.

This group is where we’ll see the most movement in the coming weeks.

Charlotte beating Tulane would not shock me, to be honest. We agree on that one… something is definitely “off” in New Orleans.

Army is consistent in having at least one WTF offensive drive in each game. The most recent example is after Tulsa scored to cut Army's lead from 14 to 7 early in the 3rd quarter:

put backup QB in because he needs experience

delay of game before 1st down

2 yd run on QB run (not option play)

put starter in
no gain on QB run (not option)

completion for 1st down on 3rd & 13 negated by C being too far downfield looking for someone to block

10 yd QB run

50 yard punt on 4th & 8, but illegal formation gave Tulsa an extra 5 yards after no return

3 plays, 2 yards -- but could be called -3 yards if you consider the 5 yard penalty on the punt

Nobody is more Jekyll and Hyde within any given game than we are. Huff needs to start crackin' the whip on his NIL boys. Reminds me of another coach we just had. "The players love him"...and that's a flaw.
10-26-2026 06:04 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Side.Show.Joe Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,127
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 1344
I Root For: North Texas
Location:
Post: #14
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-26-2026 05:58 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 09:07 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  1. UTSA
1. North Texas
3. Army
4. South Florida
5. UAB
6. Memphis
7. Navy
8. FAU
9. Tulsa
10. Tulane
11. ECU
12. Charlotte
13. Temple
14. Rice

How many beers did you have in you when you made this list?

I don’t drink. What is your issue with my list?
10-26-2026 06:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #15
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-26-2026 06:13 AM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 05:58 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 09:07 PM)Side.Show.Joe Wrote:  1. UTSA
1. North Texas
3. Army
4. South Florida
5. UAB
6. Memphis
7. Navy
8. FAU
9. Tulsa
10. Tulane
11. ECU
12. Charlotte
13. Temple
14. Rice

How many beers did you have in you when you made this list?

I don’t drink. What is your issue with my list?

My issue is you're a troll, and you're not good at it. Joe's list:

1. UTSA
1. North Texas
3. Army
4. South Florida
5. UAB
6. Memphis
7. Navy
8. FAU
9. Tulsa
10. Tulane
11. ECU
12. Charlotte
13. Temple
14. Rice

FIFY
10-26-2026 06:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BeatNavy Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,702
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 285
I Root For: Army
Location: NH
Post: #16
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-26-2026 06:04 AM)Memphis Yankee Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 07:03 PM)BeatNavy Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 01:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-25-2026 11:44 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(10-24-2026 10:33 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  Here's how I see it after today's results:

1. UTSA: The game vs. Tulane is not over yet but UTSA appears to have a commanding lead. They are the best right now.
2. UNT: They beat Navy, which is never easy.
3. Memphis: Won in OT. If they play with with an up-tempo offense, they are good enough to make the title game and perhaps win it.
4. Army: Beat Tulsa.
5. Tulsa: Lost a close one vs. Army.
6. Navy: Lost to UNT in a high scoring affair.
7. Tulane: Losing to UTSA convincingly.
8. UAB: Off this weekend.
9. USF: Off this weekend.
10. ECU: Lost in OT AGAIN.
11. FAU: Beat Rice by 2.
12. Charlotte: Off this weekend.
13. Rice: Lost to FAU in a close one.
14. Temple: Has ECU next week in a game that I fully expect them to play well in.

I didn't change your rankings -- it's pertinent to highlight what I feel are indefensible disconnects in logic. Was your list meant to be satire?

1. UTSA (4-0):
Undefeated in conference play. They deserve this position until proven otherwise.

2. UNT (3-0):
They're more consistent than Memphis, but can't play defense at all.

3. Memphis (3-1):
Variance is their Achilles heel and the Tigers deserve to be below UTSA and UNT, but the talent and potential is there to take it all if they can execute consistently.

4. Army (4-1):
No strong pushback. Army has been consistent thus far.

5. Tulsa (1-3):
This is far too high for a team who's 1-3 in the AAC and is impossible to justify.

6. Navy (1-4):
This is an even worse lapse in critical thinking and egregiously high for a team who's 1-4 in the AAC. Objectively delusional.

7. Tulane (1-2):
I'm seeing a clear bias here. Tulane is 1-2 in the AAC and will struggle to garner more wins. I could see Charlotte beating them this Friday. The only reason they have a conference win at all is due to Memphis imploding and cutting their own throats in New Orleans, not because Tulane is particularly talented or well coached.

8. UAB (2-1):
The Blazers are 2-1 in the AAC. In what universe are they below the aforementioned? UAB humiliating ECU bias, beating the Pirates by 13 in overtime?

9. USF (1-2):
USF is 1-2 in the AAC and could have easily lost at home to Kent State -- among the worst teams in FBS -- last week if not for highly suspect calls. Why reward USF when they've done nothing while punishing Temple in spite of beating USF? This is a team that has yet to put up 30 points against any FBS opponent with the weakest non-conference slate in DI football.

10. ECU (1-2):
Potentially a better team than USF and should objectively be above them. ECU appears to have a pulse and has broken the 30-point ceiling against FBS competition unlike USF.

11. FAU (2-1):
They're 2-1 in the AAC yet you have them at 11th place? What?

12. Charlotte (1-2):
They're 1-2 in the AAC just like ECU, USF, Tulane, and Temple. This feels like more ECU bias, considering Charlotte objectively owns the series against ECU.

13. Rice (0-4):
The only winless team in conference play. They are last by any objective measure and having them above Temple is impossible to justify. Records matter.

14. Temple (1-2):
Should be clustered with Charlotte, ECU, USF, and Tulane. Let's not pretend that they didn't beat USF who you oddly ranked higher. In what universe can Temple be dead last? From what I've seen, the 1-2 teams are all of similar quality, and until proven otherwise, all 1-2 teams should be above winless Rice.

You make some fair points. I feel confident in my Top 4 but in truth, teams ranked 5 through 12 are fairly interchangeable at this moment based on the data at hand.

This group is where we’ll see the most movement in the coming weeks.

Charlotte beating Tulane would not shock me, to be honest. We agree on that one… something is definitely “off” in New Orleans.

Army is consistent in having at least one WTF offensive drive in each game. The most recent example is after Tulsa scored to cut Army's lead from 14 to 7 early in the 3rd quarter:

put backup QB in because he needs experience

delay of game before 1st down

2 yd run on QB run (not option play)

put starter in
no gain on QB run (not option)

completion for 1st down on 3rd & 13 negated by C being too far downfield looking for someone to block

10 yd QB run

50 yard punt on 4th & 8, but illegal formation gave Tulsa an extra 5 yards after no return

3 plays, 2 yards -- but could be called -3 yards if you consider the 5 yard penalty on the punt

Nobody is more Jekyll and Hyde within any given game than we are. Huff needs to start crackin' the whip on his NIL boys. Reminds me of another coach we just had. "The players love him"...and that's a flaw.

The worst thing about that "drive" against Tulsa is that it showed problems in BOTH coaching [it's good to get the backup QB experience, but immediately after Tulsa cut the lead to 7? and if he's going in, get him in, don't risk delay of game; also punt formation penalty] AND player concentration/discipline [delay of game may have been QB's fault, C being downfield, punt formation penalty]
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 08:45 AM by BeatNavy.)
10-26-2026 08:45 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


panicstricken Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,467
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 315
I Root For: Tulsa
Location: Folly Beach
Post: #17
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
1 UNT







12: Tulsa
13: Memphis
10-26-2026 09:05 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Memphis Yankee Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,390
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1943
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Lake Mills, WI
Post: #18
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-26-2026 09:05 AM)panicstricken Wrote:  1 UNT







12: Tulsa
13: Memphis

That's more like it. +3
10-26-2026 09:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,590
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 672
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #19
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
1. UTSA 7-1, (4-0)
2. North Texas 5-2, (3-0)

3. Army 5-2, (4-1)
4. Memphis 5-2, (3-1)

5. FAU 5-2, (2-1)
6. UAB 4-3, (2-1)

7. USF 5-2, (1-2)
8. Tulane 3-4, (1-2)
9. ECU 3-4, (1-2)
10. Tulsa 4-4, (1-3)

11. Temple 2-5, (1-2)
12. Navy 2-5, (1-4)
13. Charlotte 1-6, (1-2)
14. Rice 1-7, (0-4)
10-26-2026 09:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UofMemphis Away
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack
*

Posts: 49,759
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)

Donators
Post: #20
RE: Rank The American, Week 9
(10-26-2026 09:05 AM)panicstricken Wrote:  1 UNT







12: Tulsa
13: Memphis

my man
10-26-2026 10:03 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.