(11-11-2026 10:34 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:09 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: Let’s talk about some of the garbage programs you folks keep voting for:
2. New Mexico — their best OOC win is against a bottom half of the MAC team, CMU. The rest of those wins are an FCS beat down, NMSU, and a bunch of wins against a severely weakened MWC slate
4. Liberty— they didn’t schedule a single A4 and their best OOC win is a toss up between a pair of 3 win squads CCU and Ball St. The rest is padding from a weak C-USA.
7. North Dakota St — there are hard schedules and there are soft schedules. What we have here is a cool whip schedule. No A4; fellow FCS transitioner Sac St, still FCS Fordham, a 9th MWC OOC game, and then the 1 OOC game of note—Jacksonville St. That win looks noteworthy on the surface until you see how weak their schedule is too. They’ve still managed to lose 2 games.
8. JMU — Again, no A4 opponents. Liberty is a decent win and San Diego St looked better prior to falling into the middle of the pack on the Pac 12.
Again, I think too many folks are voting and making 2 fatal flaws—
looking simply at wins and losses without factoring in who took losses from the A4 and wins from FCS.
Acting as if having the same record in all 6 conferences means the same thing. They don’t—some are a head and shoulders above the others.
Left these garbage programs
1 Boise St who has a South Dakota win and Memphis who has win over Ark St and a bunch of weak PAC schools
3 North Texas Has the Houston Christian and UNLV who has the win against winless Akron then weak AC conference games
5 Memphis look above not much
6 La Tech did beat NW State and an Army team with zero OOC wins, only wins in weak AC. Rest is weak conference game wins
9 UTSA Has win against UTRGV and Tx St who had to get into league to look better and then weak conference games
10 Ohio has the JaX State win and lost to middle of the road SBC South Alabama then weak conference games.
People are giving too much credit to Boise for having the best brand name.
Your details didnt give much of a reason to agree with your opinion after looking at the others you left out.
Boise played a quality Oregon team and kept it close. They are the class of one of the top 2 G6 league and yes, that Memphis win looks good. Whether you want to admit it or not, the Pac 12 is way better than the MWC—they are unfortunately beating up on each other, or in Oregon St’s case scheduled strong OOC and came up short against 2 A4 teams.
North Texas — the UNLV win looked better before they fell to the middle of the MWC. Their wins against AC teams are far more respectable than running through a weak league like the MAC, MWC, or C-USA.
LA Tech — toss out the A4 losses and this team is undefeated against G6 play. Can NDSU say that? Can JMU? Can Liberty? They are better than all 3.
Memphis — Their only losses are G6 #1 Boise and
Tulane. 2 losses in the AC > 2 losses in any other G6
UTSA — granted their road loss to FAU was bad, but it’s their only G6 loss.
Ohio— I put them at 10 and was torn between them and Toledo. This was prior to them losing their rivalry game to Miami. Prior to that, like UTSA, they had just 1 G6 loss.
Again, I put far more weight in winning AC and PAC 12 games because those leagues are better than the others. I’m also not going to punish the teams that played A4 teams.