(09-14-2026 12:34 PM)GreenBison Wrote: Should we all stop scheduling P4 schools in hopes we go undefeated and get a CFP spot? Is this a better gamble?
No.
The CFP is making it very clear that schedule matters. There is already a clean split in the minds of the everyday fan. There's Boise, and then there's everyone else. Based also on last year where we were the beneficiary of a fluke set of circumstances where they had no choice but to give JMU that final spot, and get taken to the woodshed by Oregon, we have so little standing in the eyes of the many. Yes Tulane was worse, but the American has also been accepted as part of the higher end of the G6.
And if that wasn't proof enough, they changed the rules to make sure this never happens again.
All this is to say that 13-0 with no P4 games does zero for anyone not named Boise, and maybe USF and Memphis could get away with that too.
Look at WMU as an example. If Michigan can right itself and have a good season, an 12-1 MAC champ WMU will likely be neck and neck with a 12-1 Boise and their loss to Oregon for the spot in large part because of their showing in week 1.
All of us not named Boise have basically zero room for error, and need something outstanding on the resume to get in. 13-0 against an entire G6/FCS schedule does not count as outstanding when it comes to a playoff spot.
I'll use us as an example. Our playoff chances will be dead if we don't beat NC State in two weeks, the rest of the season won't matter in that regards unless we get a lot of help from the outside. 12-1 with our schedule will leave us outside unless the American and PAC12 can't produce a 2-loss or better champ. Yes I think a 2-loss PAC12 or AAC champ gets in ahead of a 12-1 App with our schedule.