(09-03-2026 08:59 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-03-2026 08:54 AM)Bear Catlett Wrote: Well I’m pleased that they rightfully did not list Ohio $tate for the Cincinnati market
As Matt Brown noted in his full article, that was an error in reality or Nielsen looking at geographic proximity too narrowly. The reality is that Ohio State gets huge ratings in the Cincinnati market (and frankly everywhere).
Once again, as I pointed elsewhere, the scale matters. 100% of Birmingham and certainly Des Moines is still a fraction of the LA market. My main pushback on the critiques of USC and the LA market is that fans act like just because they don’t have an SEC small market level of fandom, then they must be like Rutgers in NYC, which is totally wrong.
Yeah, I don't love the methodology they used to determine who the "flagship" team is in a particular TV market, but I also think it's by far the least important part of the graph.
And yes, you're right, at some point, the sheer scale of market size can overwhelm deeper penetration in a smaller market (i.e LA vs Birmingham). But once you get outside of New York and LA, the differences matter less than you might think...because college football games don't typically capture 10% of a massive market.
The example I gave in the story (Chicago vs Columbus) is closer to the week to week reality of actual linear TV ratings. A big B1G game in Columbus can capture 10% of the market, which is equal (in raw eyeballs) to around 3% in Chicago. There will be weeks where Columbus will *actually draw more eyeballs than Chicago*, despite Chicago's DMA being roughly 3x as large. Won't be every week or every broadcast....but it'll happen.
The data is old, but I do remember when I was talking to some ESPN folks about this for my book project, they showed me data from the mid 2010s that showed a few top 15 markets (specifically Boston) as drawing smaller *actual eyeballs* than areas like Salt Lake, Kansas City, Oklahoma City, etc.
There are lots of reasons why it is good to be relevant in larger markets beyond just reaching raw eyeballs, since not all eyeballs are equally valuable. But the actual math might be closer week in and week out than you might think