(09-02-2026 08:55 PM)NotoriousOne Wrote: (09-02-2026 02:02 PM)TerryD Wrote: These limiting rules on participation/economic activity cannot be imposed upon the players from above by fiat without their consent, unless you have an anti-trust exemption granted by Congress.
Anything bargained and agreed upon can be enforced between the NCAA or a conference and a player/union under a CBA.
Terry, are you saying that the NFL can impose such a rule because the players association agreed to it but the NCAA cannot unless they collectively bargain with a union of college players?
Yes, or they obtain an antitrust exemption from Congress.
Why do you think things are so messed up? It is because college sports currently have neither one.
Under Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, separate universities (in the same conference or not) are considered competitors.
(That is why I don't think that "silos" or a breakaway works to shield schools from the Sherman Act)
For antitrust purposes, a conference is considered 16 or 18 entities, not a single one. The NCAA is considered a number of universities, not a single entity.
When competing schools in a conference (or not) or in the NCAA band together to unilaterally set uniform rules on player compensation, transfers, or eligibility, that constitutes a "horizontal agreement" among competitors to restrict the market, and courts will strike it down.
(The company you work for can set those things internally, but if a number of companies get together in an industry to do so, that is an antitrust violation)
The "uniform rules" people want for college sports are actually walking antitrust violations unless a CBA or exemption exists.
(Recall that the NCAA had "uniform rules" on television appearances that were struck down by the courts as an antitrust violation in 1984)
Why do you think the conferences are begging Congress to help and protect them? They are basically on their knees, hoping and praying that Congress grants some antitrust protection.
Agreements between a conference (or the NCAA) and a player's union are considered exempt from antitrust scrutiny under the Non-Statutory Labor Exemption, a judicially created doctrine that shields such agreements.
In that situation, courts will prioritize national labor policy over antitrust laws. Federal labor law encourages such free collective bargaining.
Also, if a freely bargained agreement exists between the "owners" and the players, it is not something simply imposed by those who control the market and will not be struck down.
Things will not change unless one of these things occurs: a CBA or an antitrust exemption.