bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,984
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Embarrassing attendance at USC
(09-01-2026 10:13 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-01-2026 08:20 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (09-01-2026 08:08 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-01-2026 06:38 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (08-31-2026 11:14 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Probably the big one is Michigan being directly in Metro Detroit and that’s at the top of the food chain in terms of brand and attendance. I’ve got to say that Detroit is an underrated across-the-board sports town (and I say that as a Chicagoan that hates all of their teams). Really strong pro sports fans for all of the teams (even when they’re hapless) and a real split of Michigan and Michigan State households (where there’s so much national focus on the Michigan-Ohio State rivalry that there’s a sneaky Alabama-Auburn-like local dynamics between UM and MSU except at a much larger city scale).
In 2015, I spent a weekend with my brother-in-law (who lived in the Detroit area at the time) going to a Red Wings game on Friday, Michigan-Michigan State on Saturday, and Bears-Lions on Sunday. This was the famous and absolutely bonkers “Trouble with the Snap” Game in Harbaugh’s first year as UM coach and MSU won on the last play of the game on the punter fumble.
In any event, throughout the whole Red Wings game the night before, the whole crowd was screaming back and forth at each other with “Go Blue” and “Go Green” chants. This is a legit major city with a pro team in every sport, but everyone still picks a side between Michigan and Michigan State. I’ll be honest - I was quite impressed. How many other major cities would you ever see that a local college rivalry so directly be so clear at a separate sold out NHL game or any other pro sports event? Detroit *loves* the Red Wings, too, so this wasn’t a matter of the attendees not caring about the product on the ice, either.
This is an example of what I talk about with so much of the Midwest being different where the pro vs. college dichotomy is not really a thing in the way that it seems to be in the South. We’re stuck inside all winter - we just straight up watch way more sports across the board than all of you people that can go outside without losing your toes in February.
Ann Arbor is 43 miles outside Detroit and is distinctly a college town. Heck, you can't even see the Detroit skyline from Ann Arbor. Detroit is surrounded by a ton of large Rust Belt suburban populations from Flint down to Toledo. This is not the same as the Deep South.
Ypsilanti is closer, how's their attendance benefiting from Detroit?
Yes, Ann Arbor is a distinct college town, but it’s directly in Metro Detroit. That is my only point - it is directly in a major market as opposed to its own isolated entity.
Also, the definition of a metro area is certainly not whether you can see the skyline. You can’t even see the Chicago skyline from whole swaths of the city itself (much less its suburbs) and we have the tallest skyline in the US besides NYC by a large margin. (We have 30 buildings taller than the tallest building in Detroit by comparison.) That’s one of the strangest comments that I’ve ever heard about attempting to define a metro area.
It may be in the Detroit metro area based on urban sprawl, but Ann Arbor is distinctly an entirely separate world vs Detroit. The way your post read would have one of our dear readers believe Ann Arbor is some indistinct enclave of Detroit, which is entirely untrue.
Source: I've been to Ann Arbor and Detroit many times.
• • •
As far as large cities supporting universities, Michigan is a GIANT state university. Everyone born in the entire state has rights to claim them including Detroiters (great show btw). On the flip side, Southern Cal is distinctly a SoCal private (albeit huge) and specifically LA—which they share with UCLA, a GIANT state university.
There is just a bit more nuance here under the surface that I believe showcases why Southern Cal probably has half of Michigan's attendance in their respective openers. That is all.
Not at all. My very first statement is that Ann Arbor is a distinct college town - I fully acknowledge that it is not a traditional suburb.
The nuance that I think a lot of people fail to realize is that people think “metro area” and think that it’s automatically less than a state. The LA metro area by itself has more people than EVERY state in the country other than Texas, Florida and New York (plus California but LA is actually in that state). This isn’t even the Chicago or Dallas markets when we talk about large markets. The LA market by itself would be the 5th most populous state in the country (if you separated the rest of California as its own state). If the broader Southern California region (including LA and San Diego) was its own state and split off from the rest of California, it would be the 2nd most populous state in the country - only the State of Texas would have more people. I think people that just see arbitrary state lines as being inherently larger than metro area sizes aren’t seeing just how simply overwhelming massive the LA market and broader Southern California market is by comparison.
Going down to the market level, if 100% of the Birmingham, Alabama market (which is what the media networks use to judge Alabama and Auburn home market games) - and I mean *every* single household - watches a Bama game, that amount to approximately 777,000 households. The LA market has over 5.9 million households - it takes only 13% of the LA market to watch a sporting event to equal what it would be if every single household in Birmingham to watch a game AND those viewers are more affluent on top of it (AKA more desirable to advertisers). It doesn’t take a really high percentage of LA viewers to completely dwarf a saturation level of viewership in a place like Birmingham.
In any event, think of it this way: the LA market by itself would be the 5th highest population state in the country. Not only are there only 2 P4 schools in that hypothetical 5th largest state, but they are also the only 2 *FBS* programs at all… and this is one of the best football recruiting areas in the country!
If you expand it out to overall Southern California, that would be the 2nd largest state and would still have only 2 P4 schools plus only 1 other FBS school (San Diego State).
That’s what makes USC/UCLA so disproportionately valuable. Imagine if Florida and Florida State were not only the only P4 schools in the State of Florida, but the only *FBS* schools at all in the State of Florida. That is how much population and recruiting area that USC and UCLA have to themselves.
This is why the Pac-12 ultimately fell apart almost immediately with just USC/UCLA leaving while the Big 12 arguably 2 more valuable members (UT and OU) plus a slew of other high value schools (A&M, Nebraska, etc.) and still survived. USC and UCLA have a literal FBS (not just P4) monopoly on the 2nd most valuable TV market and one of the top handful of football recruiting areas in the country. Hence my earlier point at USC would go higher in a “realignment draft” compared to what their straight financial valuation might state and even UCLA (whose financial value might look like a bottom half of the P4 team) would go far higher than most would think, as well. They are really key pieces on the conference realignment Risk map.
USC and, to a lesser extent, UCLA have coaching execution problems with respect to on-the-field performance. There are not core market/fan problems in the way that a lot of people seem to make it seem where there schools somehow can’t win in the future. That’s so ridiculous.
Actually, the Pac fell apart so quickly b/c Colorado had a better offer from the Yormarks and Washington/Oregon had a better offer from the B1G. Or, if we go back a few decades, it's b/c Larry Scott couldn't close the Pac 16 deal, or go back even further it's b/c Stanford blocked Texas joining in 1990. Pick your reasoning, but, ultimately, the Pac 12 died b/c it lost its 4 biggest Brands in a compressed time frame and had no viable options for replacement. The Big 12 LIVED b/c it lost it's biggest brands last instead of first, and it viable replacement options like TCU and WVU that kept ESPN and the 8 leftovers happy in 2011, then even after OUT left, NOBODY wanted any of the Hateful 8 so they were forced to reload with what proved to be an excellent foursome. If nobody had been interested in the 8 Pac leftovers, they'd still be around, too, and they'd look much like the Big 12 does today...not quite on the level of the ACC overall, but close, and far, far above the level of the g6.
I know how much you love beating that LA drum, and on paper it looks accurate, but there's something wrong with that place that's allegedly such a football hotbed but had 8x the households of birmingham and puts about 1/3 as many butts in the seats and maybe half as many eyeballs on the tv sets on saturdays. I think that SoCal USED TO be a football hotbed, but now it's more like NYC in that few there seem to care much about the sport anymore. Kudos to Chicago, you guys have not abandoned football. In fact, I predict that in 20 years, Chicagoland will be closer to Greater LA in total population than it is today, despite the many and varied issues with the area (my chief issue being the insane cold), because Chicago and its sports fans still have that, it seems weird to say that, but that animal energy that we see manifested so aggressively with burning couches in WV or murdered trees in Alabama. We love to say that it just means more in the SEC, but really it means more in most of the country, just not in Greater LA or NYC metro.
|
|