(09-14-2026 03:52 PM)ShadyP Wrote: No need to let facts get in the way of this scheduling narrative rant some folks seem to have. I mean up your donation level significantly with a lot of 0's if these folks want to have the AD's ear and maybe Matt Roan will care about your opinion.
You don't seem to let facts get in the way of all that much either, and keep the "tough guy" line ready whenever someone disagrees with you.
My point, which I know is kinda complicated (is that why you call it a narrative?), is that JMU has a fixed number of games to play and are in a position where everyone else is looking for an excuse to not take us seriously. Another fact in the situation is that when we schedule a game, it's impossible to know if that opponent will be any good when the game comes. Suppose we schedule UNT because they were in the discussion for the playoffs last year. Then they make the playoffs, their whole coaching staff gets poached, and the year we play them they suck. Or maybe an opponent was in the PAC-12 when we signed them, and then their conference evaporated. So there goes OUR shot at making a name for ourselves, not because of anything we did, but because we got unlucky with our OOC schedule.
When that's the case, the ONLY thing you can do to make yourself get noticed is to load up your schedule with as many lottery tickets as you can. We scheduled UConn when they were down there with UMass as the worst teams in the game. Then they got good, but our game with them missed that window by a year. If we'd beaten UConn last year, maybe we would have edged ahead of Tulane. I know we lost to Louisville and that's the big deal. And if we'd beaten Louisville we'd have been ahead of Tulane. HOWEVER, if we'd lost to Louisville and replaced beating Weber State with beating UConn, would we have been ahead of Tulane in the popularity contest that is polling? Maybe.
And THAT is my point -- you may have a low chance of improving your OOC resume by scheduling "any MAC team". But you have NO chance of improving your OOC resume by scheduling any FCS team. None. We could have even beaten NDSU by 30 in Fargo and that would have mattered less to the committee than beating Charlotte again.
So when you interpreted my position as "the committee didn't like us because we played Weber State", you were incorrect. My position was "we passed up an opportunity to play any other FBS team, who might have been good enough to make us clearly the top G6 team in the country.