(10-12-2026 07:32 AM)bjk3047 Wrote: I'm sorry but you're overplaying "looks completely lost" and "lows are pretty low." Dude's taken 8 sacks over 6 games, has 11 TDs over 1 INT (+ 1 TD rushing). Passer rating of 147.7. Barnett was 138.3 last year.
Does he have things to work on? Absolutely! We see the decision making challenges from time to time. But the catastrophic turnovers simply are not there. A first year FBS QB looking this poised is pretty impressive.
To be fair, 92Dukes said "
Then there are times he looks completely lost" which aligns with your note on the decision making challenges. And ABIII had a 143.4 passer rating his first year and faced plenty of criticism.
ABIII's play, especially game to game, had a much larger spread than what we have seen from Coleman thus far (and admittedly that inconsistency led to some of ABIII's criticism I noted despite similar RTGs). So I have to disagree with the "enigma" comment as I believe Coleman's consistency is why he could remain QB1.
Passer rating and QBR ranges:
ABIII 2024: RTG 87 to 214; QBR 6 to 97
ABIII 2025: RTG 76 to 252; QBR 11 to 98
Coleman (excl. Liberty): RTG 125 to 171; QBR 36 to 67
Even taking out the lows and highs, ABIII still had much larger swings.
ABIII 2024: RTG 100 to 209; QBR 10 to 90
ABIII 2025: RTG 78 to 194; QBR 26 to 95
*Obligatory note that you should expect wider ranges in 14 games vs 5. Also, the Weber St and Louisville games were not the outermost (i.e., first list) nor second outermost (i.e., second list) and those ABIII's wide ranges were during times he was the clear #1 (and further from his injury).