Purple
Heisman

Posts: 8,476
Joined: Sep 2017
Reputation: 245
I Root For: JMU
Location: Earth
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 08:27 AM)92DukeS Wrote: (09-14-2026 04:20 AM)Longhorn Wrote: (09-13-2026 10:22 PM)JMUNation Wrote: (09-12-2026 06:45 AM)Longhorn Wrote: (09-12-2026 06:29 AM)JMUNation Wrote: The reality is that the QB position came down to a competition between our third and fourth team QBs from last year.
Seriously, you want to go down this path?
All positions have depth charts, and as players mature they tend to move upwards.
Last year's 2nd or 3rd string players aren't inert. They progress, and contribute in more important ways to a team as their abilities improve. It's normal!
I am unsure what path you are referencing.
I was concerned about the QB position going into the season. After two games, I am concerned even more. Neither Coleman nor Evans has shown much in the passing game. Both have looked fairly average. I didn’t say any player on the squared was inert though.
You're obviously entitled to your opinion, but my eyes tell me that both Coleman and Maiden are both far better than "average" as QBs. I'm also comfortable with either playing, and that their passing and running abilities will not be an issue this season.
I'm far more concerned about the D team's inability to tackle, the pass rush, and cover receivers defending against a good passing team.
+1
I am so not concerned about our QB play. In fact I am totally fine with any of them in there. The lack of pass rush is going to be a dagger though if we don't find a way to get to the QB against good teams. This is my MAIN concern two games in, plain and simple.
Seriously. If Wagner stuffed our pass rush, we are in real trouble come conference play time, especially considering our waaaaay subpar pass defense.
(This post was last modified: 09-14-2026 06:29 PM by Purple.)
|
|
| 09-14-2026 06:00 PM |
|
JMURocks
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,155
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 159
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Amazing how many problems our fans can find with the Wagner performance, not that the game was much of a true benchmark. It’s just hard to be much more dominating with 2nd/3rd/4th string players getting game time.
Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 06:16 PM |
|
Longhorn
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,812
Joined: Oct 2012
Reputation: 113
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 06:16 PM)JMURocks Wrote: Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
I actually read a post by some knucklehead who was seriously arguing that JMU should have been signaling fair catches on punts (and I assume kickoffs) to help keep the score down.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 06:25 PM |
|
92DukeS
Bench Warmer

Posts: 122
Joined: Jun 2025
Reputation: 8
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 06:16 PM)JMURocks Wrote: Amazing how many problems our fans can find with the Wagner performance, not that the game was much of a true benchmark. It’s just hard to be much more dominating with 2nd/3rd/4th string players getting game time.
Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
I can't speak for the other JMU fans but any football fan with half a brain can tell that two games in we have pass rush problem. Sure tackling is an issue but that's a byproduct of no-hit practices and scrimmages for 9 months so that at least is understandable and conventional wisdom suggests it'll get better over time. But to get so few hands on the QB -- again, not necessarily bringing him down -- flies in the face of everything JMU fans have known in the FBS years and it's a huge warning sign of things to come if it's not rectified.
Considering our defensive coordinator has no actual coordinating experience also doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies that it will be fixed. Hopefully I'm wrong.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 08:06 PM |
|
Longhorn
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,812
Joined: Oct 2012
Reputation: 113
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 08:06 PM)92DukeS Wrote: (09-14-2026 06:16 PM)JMURocks Wrote: Amazing how many problems our fans can find with the Wagner performance, not that the game was much of a true benchmark. It’s just hard to be much more dominating with 2nd/3rd/4th string players getting game time.
Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
I can't speak for the other JMU fans but any football fan with half a brain can tell that two games in we have pass rush problem. Sure tackling is an issue but that's a byproduct of no-hit practices and scrimmages for 9 months so that at least is understandable and conventional wisdom suggests it'll get better over time. But to get so few hands on the QB -- again, not necessarily bringing him down -- flies in the face of everything JMU fans have known in the FBS years and it's a huge warning sign of things to come if it's not rectified.
Considering our defensive coordinator has no actual coordinating experience also doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies that it will be fixed. Hopefully I'm wrong.
JMU's new DC is on the spot. Definitely have questions about what he's doing. As fans we're used to much more aggressive Ds, and the D has been too passive in my opinion.
On the other hand I like our new OC and Special Team coach.
Can understand being underdogs given the travel. Dukes will have to improve to win this game, but believe they can do it.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 08:21 PM |
|
JMURocks
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,155
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 159
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 08:06 PM)92DukeS Wrote: (09-14-2026 06:16 PM)JMURocks Wrote: Amazing how many problems our fans can find with the Wagner performance, not that the game was much of a true benchmark. It’s just hard to be much more dominating with 2nd/3rd/4th string players getting game time.
Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
I can't speak for the other JMU fans but any football fan with half a brain can tell that two games in we have pass rush problem. Sure tackling is an issue but that's a byproduct of no-hit practices and scrimmages for 9 months so that at least is understandable and conventional wisdom suggests it'll get better over time. But to get so few hands on the QB -- again, not necessarily bringing him down -- flies in the face of everything JMU fans have known in the FBS years and it's a huge warning sign of things to come if it's not rectified.
Considering our defensive coordinator has no actual coordinating experience also doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies that it will be fixed. Hopefully I'm wrong.
Not sure we have enough data points on that yet.
Game 1 vs LU - they have a fairly stout OL that has some large P4 / 4* caliber players. Their fans were saying the exact opposite - that we dominated their OL. Game plan may have focused on containing a fairly potent run game.
Game 2 vs Wagner - we may have been playing vanilla and not want to show a lot on tape yet in terms of different looks and stunts. Also had a lot of different combinations of depth players getting game time. The game was never really in doubt.
Lots of reasons in my mind that its too early to say whether this is a real issue or not. SDSU is arguably the first big test. If we stuff the run and they throw for 500 yards, then sure, it needs to be fixed. But if their QB looks like he did against UCLA, then don't really care how many times he gets sacked. Often the plan is tailored to the opponent. Just win.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 08:36 PM |
|
JMUNation
Heisman

Posts: 5,315
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
The concerns for our pass defense are legit. We might be in real trouble there.
Tackling has been poor at times for sure. Our defensive players know how to hit someone. They just need to wrap and tackle them too.
|
|
| 09-14-2026 09:54 PM |
|
bjk3047
All American

Posts: 2,935
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 154
I Root For: JMU DUKES.
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 08:06 PM)92DukeS Wrote: Considering our defensive coordinator has no actual coordinating experience also doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies that it will be fixed. Hopefully I'm wrong.
Maybe I’m not understanding what you’re saying here, but this strikes me as a really strange claim. Straight from Robert Bala’s wiki:
Coaching career
2009–2010 Snow (LB)
2011–2013 Palomar (DC)
2014 Oakland Raiders (intern)
2015–2016 Palomar (DC)
2017 OUAZ (ST)
2018–2021 Southern Utah (DC/LB/CB)
2022 Liberty (analyst)
2023 Alabama (LB)
2024 Washington (ILB)
2025 Florida ( co-DC/ILB)
2026–present James Madison (DC)
|
|
| 09-14-2026 10:35 PM |
|
fishingduke12
Heisman

Posts: 5,410
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation: 63
I Root For: JMU
Location: NYC
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Dont forget Plungas is still on the staff from last year and is the assistant head coach/OLBs. He has coordinator experience and saw what worked last year. May just be as simple as figuring out the right combination of guys to send out there. Same thing with the backend. All preseason every coach has said the talent is there just need to figure out who is playing when/where and the first two games definitely show that.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 05:26 AM |
|
Uncle Ron's Valet
Water Engineer

Posts: 71
Joined: Dec 2017
Reputation: 5
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-15-2026 05:26 AM)fishingduke12 Wrote: Dont forget Plungas is still on the staff from last year and is the assistant head coach/OLBs. He has coordinator experience and saw what worked last year. May just be as simple as figuring out the right combination of guys to send out there. Same thing with the backend. All preseason every coach has said the talent is there just need to figure out who is playing when/where and the first two games definitely show that.
Excellent point and while we've had dominant defense for a long while now, let's not forget that Cigs teams also were vulnerable to the deep ball while selling out to stop the run. And Chesney's first year was solid but not what I would call dominant.
This week provides a big test; despite their offensive struggles against JMUCLA, SDSU has a lot of talent on O. Their two backs are among the best we will see this year and they have good receivers. The question is whether Denegal can connect on a couple of deep shots, because so far they appear to be run, run, shot play. Field position will be huge, as I don't think they can consistently put together sustained drives.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 06:51 AM |
|
2Buck
All American

Posts: 4,222
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 372
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Cackalacky
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-15-2026 05:26 AM)fishingduke12 Wrote: Dont forget Plungas is still on the staff from last year and is the assistant head coach/OLBs. He has coordinator experience and saw what worked last year. May just be as simple as figuring out the right combination of guys to send out there. Same thing with the backend. All preseason every coach has said the talent is there just need to figure out who is playing when/where and the first two games definitely show that.
Yeah, I'm changing my whole perspective on how players are used, even QBs.
With the player musical chairs every year we're going to see this staff giving 2nd and 3rd string players more and more playing time. From a program perspective, seeing what we got and letting players get the real experience helps ensure they're not left with an inexperienced empty cupboard when the stars move on. Napier has said as much and I don't blame them.
What it also does is sheds light on those players that excel in games vs practice so we uncover talent sooner than we would have otherwise, and it helps develop great depth. How many times have we seen players jump from riding the bench to being a stud when it seems all they needed was some actual game experience? Remember Mac Patrick stepping in against NDST in the red zone? Yes, some players just tank, but some simply don't click until they get put into that setting.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 10:37 AM |
|
Dukester
Moderator

Posts: 12,134
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 09:54 PM)JMUNation Wrote: The concerns for our pass defense are legit. We might be in real trouble there.
Tackling has been poor at times for sure. Our defensive players know how to hit someone. They just need to wrap and tackle them too.
Pass rush & defend. That said, only 2 games have been played. We'll learn a lot more the next two weeks.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 10:41 AM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-15-2026 10:37 AM)2Buck Wrote: (09-15-2026 05:26 AM)fishingduke12 Wrote: Dont forget Plungas is still on the staff from last year and is the assistant head coach/OLBs. He has coordinator experience and saw what worked last year. May just be as simple as figuring out the right combination of guys to send out there. Same thing with the backend. All preseason every coach has said the talent is there just need to figure out who is playing when/where and the first two games definitely show that.
Yeah, I'm changing my whole perspective on how players are used, even QBs.
With the player musical chairs every year we're going to see this staff giving 2nd and 3rd string players more and more playing time. From a program perspective, seeing what we got and letting players get the real experience helps ensure they're not left with an inexperienced empty cupboard when the stars move on. Napier has said as much and I don't blame them.
What it also does is sheds light on those players that excel in games vs practice so we uncover talent sooner than we would have otherwise, and it helps develop great depth. How many times have we seen players jump from riding the bench to being a stud when it seems all they needed was some actual game experience? Remember Mac Patrick stepping in against NDST in the red zone? Yes, some players just tank, but some simply don't click until they get put into that setting.
I think it's great Napier is doing that. So many players are leaving, so why not develop more and more so when guys leave, the next ones up are ready.
The devil's advocate part of that is it also gives schools potentially more players to steal from as they've seen more potential guys that could contribute. Or more players know they can contribute and not only enter the portal, but get grabbed by someone because they actually have tape.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 10:43 AM |
|
2Buck
All American

Posts: 4,222
Joined: Mar 2014
Reputation: 372
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Cackalacky
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-15-2026 10:43 AM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-15-2026 10:37 AM)2Buck Wrote: (09-15-2026 05:26 AM)fishingduke12 Wrote: Dont forget Plungas is still on the staff from last year and is the assistant head coach/OLBs. He has coordinator experience and saw what worked last year. May just be as simple as figuring out the right combination of guys to send out there. Same thing with the backend. All preseason every coach has said the talent is there just need to figure out who is playing when/where and the first two games definitely show that.
Yeah, I'm changing my whole perspective on how players are used, even QBs.
With the player musical chairs every year we're going to see this staff giving 2nd and 3rd string players more and more playing time. From a program perspective, seeing what we got and letting players get the real experience helps ensure they're not left with an inexperienced empty cupboard when the stars move on. Napier has said as much and I don't blame them.
What it also does is sheds light on those players that excel in games vs practice so we uncover talent sooner than we would have otherwise, and it helps develop great depth. How many times have we seen players jump from riding the bench to being a stud when it seems all they needed was some actual game experience? Remember Mac Patrick stepping in against NDST in the red zone? Yes, some players just tank, but some simply don't click until they get put into that setting.
I think it's great Napier is doing that. So many players are leaving, so why not develop more and more so when guys leave, the next ones up are ready.
The devil's advocate part of that is it also gives schools potentially more players to steal from as they've seen more potential guys that could contribute. Or more players know they can contribute and not only enter the portal, but get grabbed by someone because they actually have tape.
True, but I think the risk of losing more is offset by being able to better assess the roster at the end of the year and where you want to put your NIL/rev share. The only way JMU keeps elevating the program is if we keep more known talent that can continue to develop within the program vs starting from scratch every year.
It's just like in business- the cost (risk) of acquisition is much greater than retaining and developing from within.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 12:20 PM |
|
92DukeS
Bench Warmer

Posts: 122
Joined: Jun 2025
Reputation: 8
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-14-2026 08:36 PM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-14-2026 08:06 PM)92DukeS Wrote: (09-14-2026 06:16 PM)JMURocks Wrote: Amazing how many problems our fans can find with the Wagner performance, not that the game was much of a true benchmark. It’s just hard to be much more dominating with 2nd/3rd/4th string players getting game time.
Scoreboard said they had 3pts? Yeah, awful.
Oh, forgot - we scored too much and should have kneeled instead.
I can't speak for the other JMU fans but any football fan with half a brain can tell that two games in we have pass rush problem. Sure tackling is an issue but that's a byproduct of no-hit practices and scrimmages for 9 months so that at least is understandable and conventional wisdom suggests it'll get better over time. But to get so few hands on the QB -- again, not necessarily bringing him down -- flies in the face of everything JMU fans have known in the FBS years and it's a huge warning sign of things to come if it's not rectified.
Considering our defensive coordinator has no actual coordinating experience also doesn't give me the warm and fuzzies that it will be fixed. Hopefully I'm wrong.
Not sure we have enough data points on that yet.
Game 1 vs LU - they have a fairly stout OL that has some large P4 / 4* caliber players. Their fans were saying the exact opposite - that we dominated their OL. Game plan may have focused on containing a fairly potent run game.
Game 2 vs Wagner - we may have been playing vanilla and not want to show a lot on tape yet in terms of different looks and stunts. Also had a lot of different combinations of depth players getting game time. The game was never really in doubt.
Lots of reasons in my mind that its too early to say whether this is a real issue or not. SDSU is arguably the first big test. If we stuff the run and they throw for 500 yards, then sure, it needs to be fixed. But if their QB looks like he did against UCLA, then don't really care how many times he gets sacked. Often the plan is tailored to the opponent. Just win.
I agree just win. And I agree that it may be too early to say whether the pass rush or lack thereof is a real issue or not but the two games in the pass rush doesn't pass the eye test yet.
I understand the points you've made, including we played a lot of depth this past Saturday and we don't want to show a lot on tape, but just call me concerned. We'll know a lot more about our pass rush in the next couple of weeks.
|
|
| 09-15-2026 10:13 PM |
|
boozeANDammo
2nd String

Posts: 291
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 8
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Seattle, WA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Back to the QBs and thread topic for a sec... re-watched the Wagner game yesterday and one thing stood out to me and that was Maiden's arm strength. Good grief that was impressive. He looked accurate too. Granted, that was clean up duty against an FCS from Stanten Is. but those raw skills most definitely popped on screen. How in the world was he the third string QB coming out of camp (was my first thought)? Gave me a little more comfort with the state of the QB room with JC getting nicked up.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 09:01 AM |
|
JMUNation
Heisman

Posts: 5,315
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 09:01 AM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Back to the QBs and thread topic for a sec... re-watched the Wagner game yesterday and one thing stood out to me and that was Maiden's arm strength. Good grief that was impressive. He looked accurate too. Granted, that was clean up duty against an FCS from Stanten Is. but those raw skills most definitely popped on screen. How in the world was he the third string QB coming out of camp (was my first thought)? Gave me a little more comfort with the state of the QB room with JC getting nicked up.
Good observation Booze. I would add that he is also the biggest QB. He can flatten some defenders.
It could be that his deficiencies are not with his athletic abilities. I am fairly sure the coaches see what you see. Some of these guys come to college with an inflated sense of themselves. I recall Cig not starting McCloud because of this. Maybe Maiden isn’t a good team guy, is slow to read defenses, has trouble picking up the playbook or poor practice habits? Hard to know for us fans but I saw all the same things you saw so it makes me wonder how he is 3rd team as well.
Whatever Maiden’s deficiencies are, he has some tools for sure. If he is willing to listen to his coaches, I see a lot of potential in him.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 10:01 AM |
|
DoubleDogDare
All American

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 09:01 AM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Back to the QBs and thread topic for a sec... re-watched the Wagner game yesterday and one thing stood out to me and that was Maiden's arm strength. Good grief that was impressive. He looked accurate too. Granted, that was clean up duty against an FCS from Stanten Is. but those raw skills most definitely popped on screen. How in the world was he the third string QB coming out of camp (was my first thought)? Gave me a little more comfort with the state of the QB room with JC getting nicked up.
I hate to drop a 'trust me bro' but this was my conversation with someone that shouldn't be questioned.
Me - How was the QB competition, as close as Napier implied?
Them - Yeah, really close.
Me - In comparison to Sluka vs. Barnett?
Them - Much closer.
Me - What about Arrington?
Them - *chuckle*
Me - Ha, you have to give me more.
Them - Big gap.
That lead to my post prior to Wagner so his performance left me pleasantly surprised.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 10:27 AM |
|
Purplehazed
Heisman

Posts: 8,817
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 211
I Root For: James Madison Dukes
Location: Virginia
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026 12:14 PM by Purplehazed.)
|
|
| 09-16-2026 12:13 PM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 12:13 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
He did. I thought he'd be a good QB. But perhaps Evans and Coleman have been better from the spring to the start of the season.
One game against our weakest opponent in garbage time doesn't mean the staff has misjudged the QB room.
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026 12:43 PM by JMad03.)
|
|
| 09-16-2026 12:42 PM |
|