People keep referring to JC's size, and it is impressive (even though JC's not 6'5"...he's 6'4 and a quarter"). And he's not that much bigger than CC (he's only 1 inch taller and 10 pounds heavier).
The question is can JC pass, as well as run. Can JC recognize defenses and perform under pressure?
Again, I'm going be happy with any QB who starts if they win. That's the unanswered question. AB3 obviously won the starters job in practice, but in his first start really stank the place up, and subsequently sat on the bench.
As an aside, I've become a big fan of Delvin. He knows FB and is becoming a very polished speaker/analyst.
What's are board's thought on this idea...could Delvin handle play by play?
People keep referring to JC's size, and it is impressive (even though JC's not 6'5"...he's 6'4 and a quarter"). And he's not that much bigger than CC (he's only 1 inch taller and 10 pounds heavier).
The question is can JC pass, as well as run. Can JC recognize defenses and perform under pressure?
Again, I'm going be happy with any QB who starts if they win. That's the unanswered question. AB3 obviously won the starters job in practice, but in his first start really stank the place up, and subsequently sat on the bench.
As an aside, I've become a big fan of Delvin. He knows FB and is becoming a very polished speaker/analyst.
What's are board's thought on this idea...could Delvin handle play by play?
I could see Evans, but if you listen to the Napier pressure yesterday the DNR ask a pointed question about Camden. Napier was complimentary and high on Camden. Could that be because the question was specific or is there a leaning from the answer.
Napier also stated both QBs made a lot of mistakes in yesterday's scrimmage.
(08-18-2026 07:35 AM)hburg Wrote: I could see Evans, but if you listen to the Napier pressure yesterday the DNR ask a pointed question about Camden. Napier was complimentary and high on Camden. Could that be because the question was specific or is there a leaning from the answer.
Napier also stated both QBs made a lot of mistakes in yesterday's scrimmage.
The DNR has been writing about each guy. This week happens to be Coleman. If Napier went out of his way to talk about Coleman then I might take that as him having a lead. But even then a lot can change in a week.
In this case, I think Napier was just trying to boost his guy as they were writing a piece about him. No more, no less.
Quick tangent from QB battle but Delvin said Chesney was Ted Lasso ("quintessential motivator") and that Napier "runs circles around Chesney" on the Xs and Os. Delvin believes Napier is speaking about running a program (and not Xs and Os) when he talks about seeing things at JMU that he really liked and would adopt. If the superior ball knowledge caused Napier to succeed at Louisiana, and missing the other components caused struggles at Florida, hopefully he puts it all together and we get the complete/upgraded Napier.
I could listen to Delvin do a show like that more than once a week. He did a one-man show with Vad out just now, and it was immensely more enjoyable than listening to the regular JMUSN programming do their sardonic/edgy routine with bouts of chuckling. I think those guys do a lot for JMU sports with their written content, social presence, and player interviews but their pod style is not my cup of tea personally.
My only complaint with Delvin's show is the "what choo talking about" section - there's no need to give amplification to voices in the media that are obviously paid-for and intentionally trying to get clicks by denigrating g6. I have no interest in listening to this content, I don't know why he gives it any additional attention.
Could Delvin do play by play? Absolutely, he's knowledgeable, polished, and respects the game enough to not consistently mispronounce names or misread what's happening on plays. He's an unabashed homer which is a good thing for our home broadcasts, but again respects the institution of college football enough to respect our opponents as well. I love that he's the first in line to say he's not rooting for Chesney or any of the UCLA transfers this year - I actually disagree with that stance myself, but I respect him for holding so true to it.
(This post was last modified: 08-18-2026 10:35 PM by DukesHoldDoors.)
I appreciate Delvin's stance on UCLA, Chesney, or any players that transfer out. None of them are 'my guys' representing the purple and gold anymore so quite frankly I just don't care. I also agree with his take that Napier is a superior Xs and Os coach and that Chesney is akin to Ted Lasso.
(08-19-2026 07:39 AM)ShadyP Wrote: I appreciate Delvin's stance on UCLA, Chesney, or any players that transfer out. None of them are 'my guys' representing the purple and gold anymore so quite frankly I just don't care. I also agree with his take that Napier is a superior Xs and Os coach and that Chesney is akin to Ted Lasso.
While it may be true that Napier is more of an X's and O's guy than Chesney, but frankly I'm not sure that is a good thing in this day in age of football for most coaches not named Cignetti. Head coaches have so many things to do outside of coaching football these days that it is very difficult for a HC not to trust his coaches on the X's and O's.
Not saying this is going to be an issue with Billy, but his decision to have and offensive coordinator is a recognition of the above. As far as Chesney the guy is an incredible builder of teams and culture which is exactly what UCLA needs and I expect him to be very successful there.
(08-19-2026 07:39 AM)ShadyP Wrote: I appreciate Delvin's stance on UCLA, Chesney, or any players that transfer out. None of them are 'my guys' representing the purple and gold anymore so quite frankly I just don't care. I also agree with his take that Napier is a superior Xs and Os coach and that Chesney is akin to Ted Lasso.
While it may be true that Napier is more of an X's and O's guy than Chesney, but frankly I'm not sure that is a good thing in this day in age of football for most coaches not named Cignetti. Head coaches have so many things to do outside of coaching football these days that it is very difficult for a HC not to trust his coaches on the X's and O's.
Not saying this is going to be an issue with Billy, but his decision to have and offensive coordinator is a recognition of the above. As far as Chesney the guy is an incredible builder of teams and culture which is exactly what UCLA needs and I expect him to be very successful there.
Cignetti by his own admission isn't the Xs & Os guy he always said he sees himself as the CEO of the team and let's his coordinators have a lot of leeway managing their sides of the ball. If anything he might be the blueprint of how to build and manage a successful program.
(08-19-2026 07:39 AM)ShadyP Wrote: I appreciate Delvin's stance on UCLA, Chesney, or any players that transfer out. None of them are 'my guys' representing the purple and gold anymore so quite frankly I just don't care. I also agree with his take that Napier is a superior Xs and Os coach and that Chesney is akin to Ted Lasso.
While it may be true that Napier is more of an X's and O's guy than Chesney, but frankly I'm not sure that is a good thing in this day in age of football for most coaches not named Cignetti. Head coaches have so many things to do outside of coaching football these days that it is very difficult for a HC not to trust his coaches on the X's and O's.
Not saying this is going to be an issue with Billy, but his decision to have and offensive coordinator is a recognition of the above. As far as Chesney the guy is an incredible builder of teams and culture which is exactly what UCLA needs and I expect him to be very successful there.
Cignetti by his own admission isn't the Xs & Os guy he always said he sees himself as the CEO of the team and let's his coordinators have a lot of leeway managing their sides of the ball. If anything he might be the blueprint of how to build and manage a successful program.
I wouldn't say that is completely true. On one hand he lets his coaches coach the players and doesn't get real involved there, but when it comes to watching film/tendencies, etc. I don't know if there is a coach who does more of that than Cig.
Talk to anyone who has been around him and they will tell you the man eats, sleeps, and lives football. The only other thing he cares about all is his wife and family. One person I know who was very close to the program the last 5 years called him a football "autistic" as he was so laser focused, but awkward at the same time.
(08-18-2026 10:17 PM)DukesHoldDoors Wrote: I could listen to Delvin do a show like that more than once a week. He did a one-man show with Vad out just now, and it was immensely more enjoyable than listening to the regular JMUSN programming do their sardonic/edgy routine with bouts of chuckling. I think those guys do a lot for JMU sports with their written content, social presence, and player interviews but their pod style is not my cup of tea personally.
You’re not the only one turned off by these two gigglyfux that can’t be taken serious in other endeavors due the way they act on the podcast.
(08-18-2026 10:17 PM)DukesHoldDoors Wrote: I could listen to Delvin do a show like that more than once a week. He did a one-man show with Vad out just now, and it was immensely more enjoyable than listening to the regular JMUSN programming do their sardonic/edgy routine with bouts of chuckling. I think those guys do a lot for JMU sports with their written content, social presence, and player interviews but their pod style is not my cup of tea personally.
You’re not the only one turned off by these two gigglyfux that can’t be taken serious in other endeavors due the way they act on the podcast.
Not just their podcast but a lot of their articles and posting elsewhere make me want to gag. I viewed them more as wanna be hacks.
Delvin OTOH is a solid dude. Had a nice convo with him at Duke Club event in Oregon prior to the game. Humble and easy to talk to, and has a lot of knowledge to share. Happy he is still engaged with JMU.
(08-18-2026 07:10 AM)Longhorn Wrote: People keep referring to JC's size, and it is impressive (even though JC's not 6'5"...he's 6'4 and a quarter"). And he's not that much bigger than CC (he's only 1 inch taller and 10 pounds heavier).
The question is can JC pass, as well as run. Can JC recognize defenses and perform under pressure?
You’re right, everyone keeps hanging on to size as his greatest attribute, but it’s not like Cam is 5’11” 185lbs., he’s not far off at all. Also, JC is now in his 3rd year of college ball and has never had to read a defense, probably ever. In high school he was on loaded teams, chuck the ball up and your guy gets under it. In college he’s been tasked with running a glorified wildcat offense, his only completion was for 1 yard on a play they called a run and he audible out to a pop pass. To think he’ll come out firing and picking apart a defense is really some wishful thinking.
He may not have been playing on the field, but do you think the staffs don't work with them at practice on how to read a defense?
What do you think they watch tape for?
I suppose if JC missed all of those sessions or was just playing on his phone we wouldn't have learned anything. But that's what they call "developing a quarterback". It's not just about the throws. It's about reading a defense, making adjustments, etc.
CC has more experience in actual game settings, I can't argue that. But to make a blanket statement like that is just unfair.
(08-20-2026 08:49 AM)JMad03 Wrote: He may not have been playing on the field, but do you think the staffs don't work with them at practice on how to read a defense?
What do you think they watch tape for?
I suppose if JC missed all of those sessions or was just playing on his phone we wouldn't have learned anything. But that's what they call "developing a quarterback". It's not just about the throws. It's about reading a defense, making adjustments, etc.
CC has more experience in actual game settings, I can't argue that. But to make a blanket statement like that is just unfair.
Doing it in practice against your teammates and doing it in games while under fire in front of thousands are two different things. We all saw how ABIII ended up, do you remember how he started out? He too lit it up in practice and then found the actual game to be much more difficult, and we’re not opening up with Bucknell.
(08-20-2026 08:49 AM)JMad03 Wrote: He may not have been playing on the field, but do you think the staffs don't work with them at practice on how to read a defense?
What do you think they watch tape for?
I suppose if JC missed all of those sessions or was just playing on his phone we wouldn't have learned anything. But that's what they call "developing a quarterback". It's not just about the throws. It's about reading a defense, making adjustments, etc.
CC has more experience in actual game settings, I can't argue that. But to make a blanket statement like that is just unfair.
Doing it in practice against your teammates and doing it in games while under fire in front of thousands are two different things. We all saw how ABIII ended up, do you remember how he started out? He too lit it up in practice and then found the actual game to be much more difficult, and we’re not opening up with Bucknell.
I agree. (he does have a really good defense to play against, so I wouldn't totally discount that)
My point is that it isn't about reading a defense... it's about responding to the in game pressure. Totally different. The most fundamentally perfect guy can be the worst QB if he can't translate what he's learned into a game. And that pressure is incredibly hard to replicate.
How will JC respond if he's selected as the starter? No idea. He could be the absolute worst. He could also be the best QB we've ever had.
The staff has a really tough decision to make and I certainly wouldn't want to be in their shoes.