XLance
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,160
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1262
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
|
RE: How Fox priorities could change realignment.
(07-06-2026 06:43 AM)Lurker Above Wrote: (07-06-2026 04:39 AM)XLance Wrote: (07-05-2026 09:05 PM)Lurker Above Wrote: (07-05-2026 01:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (07-04-2026 01:59 PM)XOVERX Wrote: I kind of feel like Frank the Tank has taken me out to the woodshed: “It’s about football, stupid”. Well, okay, he didn’t say “stupid”, but he makes his point emphatically. Frank’s UConn point is especially devastating.
Frank argues it’s all about FSU, Miami, Clemson, and, for a combination of factors, UNC. In Florida, Frank’s B1G emphasis seems to be that FSU + Miami is ideal, but Miami + GT will work for the B1G perfectly fine.
Let’s take a short survey:
Skyhawk: To the SEC: FSU, Clemson, UNC, UVA or VPI. This comports most closely with my guess.
bb777/Flugar: To the B1G: Clemson, Utah, Miami, maybe GT. This guess seems mostly like an outlier than me, but who knows?
XLance, an ACC poster, opines that Miami + FSU to the SEC would be least disruptive to the ACC. I assume those schools alone to the B1G would also be least disruptive to the ACC.
That brings us to JR, who is all over the map. In JR’s defense, the variables are many and abstruse. JR’s “Grand Slam” (to mix metaphors) is grand, indeed: An SEC of 24 schools, with 8 additions consisting of: UVA, VPI, UNC, Duke, NCSU, Clemson, FSU, and KU. That’s a breathtaking SEC expansion. JR hangs it on, at least in part, beating the federal legislation timeframe. JR concedes Miami and GT to the B1G, most likely not because he wants to, but because going beyond 24 seems to be an expansion “too far”.
Personally, I think the SEC might - maybe - go to 20, but it is just so hard for me to get to 24. Is it about football - Frank’s core point - or is it about “football + positioning for a potential breakaway” - which I consider to be JR’s core point?
Obviously, ESPN and money are the biggest factors in SEC size. I think another factor is-, or ought to be-, conference coherence. What size will work to maintain a league that promotes “connection”?
I think the SEC current league of 16 is great. For the past 2 years, Texas played “one side” of the SEC (plus Texas’ 3 traditional rivals), and this year Texas gets the “other side” of the SEC (and we still get our 3 traditional rivals).
Does 18 schools work for Texas (or most others)? Not really, no. While we get 9 conference games, we only get 1 protected rivalry game, not 3. Who does the SEC cut out? Oklahoma? Texas A&M? Arkansas? Eighteen is a big negative.
So, here’s the numbers.
• 16 members: 9 Conference games of which 3 are protected rivalries; Play the whole SEC every 2 years | 3 out-of-conference games.
• 18: 9C / 1PR / 2-cycle | 3 OOC
• 20: 9C / 4PR / 3-cycle | 3 OOC
• 21: 11C / 2PR / 2-cycle | 1 OOC
• 22: 9C / 3PR / 3-cycle | 3 OOC
• 24: 9C / 2PR / 3-cycle | 3 OOC
It seems that the best size is 20, 22, or 24. 18 is not a great size. 21 will work, but, for Texas, most likely we would have to give up Arkansas (at least every year).
If football’s the game - and most of us concede Frank is right - if new markets retain some vitality, and if ESPN has limits, I wonder if the optimal combination, all factors considered, is 21 for the SEC: FSU, Clemson, Miami, UNC (or NCSU), and UVA (or VPI). I remain wary of Miami, but that’s just me (standing up to my ankles in a puddle of seawater in downtown Miami in full sunshine).
I wonder if ESPN would agree to 21? Is there a deeper “grand scheme”? But if they do, and if they permit 2 more, to 24, maybe you shore up winter sports with Duke and KU? Or maybe more football with VPI and another school?
I don’t necessarily agree with JRsec’s reasoning on everything (e.g. I believe that the ESPN factor is vastly overrated), but I do agree with the conclusion that UNC and FSU are the most important pieces because they are effectively the “swing” votes where getting either of them makes it more likely for either the Big Ten and SEC to end up with more of the schools that they want beyond just UNC and/or FSU. Clemson is a clearly SEC-coded school while Miami is a clearly B1G-coded school - while either of those schools would clearly want to end up in either of the P2 compared to staying in the ACC, they also have clear preferences between the P2. UNC and FSU are different - there are going to be different factions depending on what’s emphasized.
There’s also a scarcity/history angle that we have to acknowledge. Every school in the Big 12 has been passed up at LEAST once by the Big Ten and SEC since 2020 and multiple times since 2010. Every Big 12 school tried to get any lifeline that they could following both the 2010 realignment and 2021 UT/OU defections, while every former Pac-12 school looked for every lifeline that they could in 2022-23. So, every one of those schools has been outright rejected by both the Big Ten and SEC very recently. Stanford and Cal came up for a vote for the Big Ten and they’d almost certainly be in the league today if the league had a pro rata rights fee increase in their TV contracts, but since expansion required Fox to agree to kick in more money, they didn’t get voted in. Everyone else was outright rejected. We shouldn’t lose sight of this fact whenever we see a current Big 12 school suggested for either the B1G or SEC because the argument that “If they really wanted them, they would have added them already” definitely has a lot of validity.
In contrast, the ACC schools have NOT been free agents since they signed their GOR following Maryland’s defection. So, at a minimum, we don’t have any empirical evidence of the P2 rejecting any ACC school other than the B1G with Stanford/Cal (and once again they came up for a presidential vote, which wouldn’t have happened unless the presidents really wanted to add them). There’s a lot more variability there.
At the same time, the scarcity piece is critical. The Big Ten can add in, say, any of the Four Corners schools at any time. They’re not concerned about the SEC ever wanting those schools. In contrast, losing FSU, Miami, and/or UNC to the SEC likely means losing them *forever* and vice versa. There’s a different urgency that comes in when both of the P2 may want different assets for different reasons. People seem to love Kansas on this forum, but once again, both the Big Ten and SEC have had multiple chances to take them where KU was *begging* for an invite and it has never happened.
Ultimately, I think Clemson ends up in the SEC and Miami ends up in the Big Ten. FSU and UNC are the toss-ups and they’re critical since they further end up determining where schools like Duke, UVA, and Georgia Tech end up. I don’t think the ESPN factor matters nearly as much as the balance between the T-shirt fans and maybe alums (which generally favor the SEC) and school leadership interests (which generally favor the Big Ten) along with the preferences of rivals (which maybe weirdly favors the Big Ten because UVA, Duke and Miami are *very* B1G-coded and I continuously find it disingenuous when people argue otherwise, just as I fully acknowledge that UT’s rivals of OU and A&M were very clearly SEC-coded and that provided an advantage for the SEC to get UT) and local political issues (which I don’t believe favors either league as I don’t believe either league wants to provide a spot to schools like NC State or Virginia Tech in order to get their corresponding flagships).
With every ACC school that could garner a P2 invite, a major factor is which conference does the clear majority of its fans and boosters want to join? The fans and boosters of almost every ACC school strongly prefers the SEC, with the exceptions being Duke and UVA, and the Cavaliers are split. I predict Miami will feel the appeal of the B1G, but will ultimately choose the SEC to play both FSU and Florida annually, to avoid winter games in artic conditions and to play in the best conference not only for football, but also basketball and baseball.
Btw, I'll bet you a dollar and a donut that if UVA goes to the B1G, then VT will end up in the SEC. That would be devastating to the Cavaliers, imo.
How is it that you "know" this?
Do you have access to some secret fan polling data base that is not available to the rest of us?
Of course not. Just Google searches and message board chatter. I concede your point, but I still think I am correct. Do you disagree? Do you not believe a majority of UNC fans and boosters prefer the SEC over the B1G, dispite your apparent antipathy to the idea?
I know that the BMD's prefer the B1G.
The T-shrt fans who would be posters on 24/7 or on3 prefer the SEC primarily because the boards administrators push them in that direction..it's their audience, and they are out to make a living, so they push the SEC.
|
|