(06-26-2026 10:33 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-26-2026 10:17 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: There’s a reason to not trust AI on a lot of matters.
I’m saying this as an alum of a school whose value would be *greatly* higher if basketball materially mattered in these media rights valuations.
It doesn’t matter. I don’t know what else in the past 20-plus years of conference realignment could have possibly taught anyone. This is about football brand, power and elite status. The most successful basketball program this century - UConn - is a flagship school of a wealthy state with most of their alums concentrated in the single most valuable market of them all in NYC. That has done *nothing* to move the needle for UConn for the P4. There’s basically not anything more that UConn can do when it comes to basketball performance and TV ratings.
Stanford and Cal might get into the Big Ten because they have a singularly unique combo of academics and market location, but make no mistake that Fox doesn’t care about that, either. The Big Ten was going to invite Stanford and Cal, but *Fox* killed it because they wouldn’t kick in more money to add them.
Otherwise, we need to “dumb it down” with realignment analysis. Believe me that I wish my old Big Ten Expansion Index that took into account multiple factors beyond football would still work today. I’m telling you as the writer of that index that still gets clicks on it today over 16 years later that it doesn’t apply anymore. The normal fans used to be the ones that were totally wrong about what was important in realignment, but we’ve now come full circle that the last pieces in the marketplace that would add value to the Big Ten and SEC are the biggest pure normal fan football brands that are left in the ACC.
This next round of realignment (to the extent that it is allowed under applicable law) is all about Florida State, Miami, Clemson and UNC (where the overall sports brand plus flagship status in a key state for both the B1G and SEC overrides their lack of football credentials). UVA and Duke might get reprieves on similar grounds as UNC, too. Georgia Tech will need to convince the Big Ten that they have value to that league. Stanford and Cal may still have specific value to the Big Ten. Everyone else is at serious risk. The financial bar just to breakeven with expansion is so high in both the Big Ten and SEC that just “good solid singles and doubles” for expansion don’t work as they did in the 2010s when conference networks were growing in value.
There’s no reason to twist in knots trying to figure out diamonds in the rough at this point. There’s no “hack” like the Big Ten making a ton of money off of Rutgers and Maryland with the BTN available today. This is about pure football brand power with a touch of market value. That’s it.
I have been gradually coming to the view that the key pieces in realignment today are Florida State and Miami. I would not be surprised if the B1G tried a preemptive strike with those two, but I would be surprised if they only want one of them. That's too remote an island. Precisely because the SEC might also conclude that those are B1G targets, I would be surprised if they haven't already let those two know that they are an alternative.
Miami works with Georgia Tech. They both have international air hubs located in their cities, so they have ease of access working for them. And that would work for the Big Ten and FOX's new bedspread across America approach.
FSU with the U of Florida gives ESPN what it wants 77% of the college sports viewers in the state of Florida. UNC & Duke gives ESPN what it wants to keep enhanced from the ACC should it diminish. UNC adds to football as the flagship university of a state of nearly 11 million people and the pair gives them the winter jewels in their lineup protected in a more stable conference. The question for the SEC and ESPN would be #4. Do you pair Kansas back up with Missouri and create a solid former Big 12 division of 5 to the West. Do you take Virginia just for the market? Or do you double down in a state of 5 million with Clemson?
The SEC decision makers have acknowledged the importance of keeping rivalries together, but they haven't to date double dipped anywhere but Texas. I definitely believe they will double dip in Florida. They could claim that taking Duke with UNC was rivalry protection and it would be for hoops. Virginia Tech is worth more than UVa athletically speaking but not by much and neither one pays their way in. How important is that market to the ESPN revenue structure? I honestly don't know. Clemson multiplies content value for all SEC brands they play, they travel well, and they are literally what they have been called, Auburn by the Lake. What is Auburn? The second state school in a state of 5 million with a bitter rivalry with the other school, top 15 though sliding in wins, a couple of national championships in football, solid academically but not AAU, and a sold out Stadium of 86,000 at Auburn and about 81,000 at Clemson. And both drive ratings when playing another SEC brand. Clemson is solidly middle of the SEC. You can't say that for UNC or Duke. Kansas generates more revenue than either of the North Carolina schools but wouldn't be middle of the SEC for football. And there's this, UNC will go to whichever conference takes Duke with them. If you go all football, you add no new markets (Miami, FSU, Clemson), and don't have room for a pairing with North Carolina.
The question in my mind is if it is perceived that the window for no government interference with realignment is going to close, do the networks head on to 24 schools each, stay at 20, or perhaps have some other plan. I don't see different numbers of schools in each conference because eventually they will be voting on matters in whatever governing structure is formed over them. Therefore, if the SEC moves to 24 do they simply add the Mag 7 plus Kansas and preserve the current business model of ESPN, or do they add 2 schools in North Carolina, Florida State and Clemson? Or some other variation that has been mentioned or discussed? Seven schools from the ACC leaves 10 plus Notre Dame and Kansas is the last school of value from the old Big 8 / Big 12.
If ESPN is looking at their marketing / profit structure then moving the two Virginia schools, three North Carolina schools, Clemson and FSU isn't unreasonable and taking Kansas makes sense for them. They then have a conference that still keeps the old 12 member SEC intact, adds the very best of the Big 12 sans Nebraska, and the compelling portions of the Virginia and North Carolina market while picking up the two most SEC like schools from the ACC. And that gives the total leverage in every state within the new SEC footprint which were also the same states they had leverage in by holding rights to two conferences at 100% and a third at 50%.
Realignment is beyond what conferences want. Who was added from the PAC to the Big Ten proved that. If ESPN wants North Carolina and Virginia, they will pay the SEC pro rata to take them. Then they can beef up what the SEC wants with Clemson and FSU, and augment the new SEC West with Kansas.
If FOX wants into the Atlanta and Miami DMAs they take Miami and Georgia Tech, go after San Francisco with Cal and Stanford, and build a bridge with Colorado and an Arizona school.