(06-27-2026 12:40 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (06-27-2026 12:48 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote: The Learfield Directors Cup is not a useful tool for a comparison between the MWC and Pac, as the SDSU and Air Force example illustrates.
Nearly evey poster in this thread is using the Director’s Cup ranking as a basis for comparing conferences or schools. In a separate post you yourself concluded UCLA had “a good year” by finishing third in the overall ranking and first among Big 10 schools. But somehow it’s not a useful tool for comparing the MWC and Pac?
A more accurate statement would be the Director’s Cup isn’t the only useful tool for comparing those two conferences (or any conferences).
The unique value of the Director’s Cup ranking is that it’s based primarily on each school’s ability to reach end-of season national championship tournament competitions and perform well in those competitions versus other schools that got there. Regular season records don’t matter. In-conference dominance doesn’t matter. Polls, SOS indexes and RPIs don’t matter. The ranking is driven almost entirely by finishing strong on the field or the court with a national title at stake.
That’s also its limitation. It doesn’t take into account the complete body of work by an athletic department over the course of every sport’s season. By that measure San Diego State had a fine year. But the Aztecs football team didn’t reach the CFP or even win its bowl game. Neither the men’s nor women’s basketball teams made it into the NCAA tournament. In national championship competition the school was a no-show.
It may be legitimate to critique the Director’s Cup top-100 finishes of New Mexico, Air Force and Hawaii because they earned their points by finishing their seasons strong in niche sports rather than mainstream sports. But San Diego State wasn’t even able to do that. To their credit, four other future Pac schools (including Texas State) did achieve top-100 finishes. I think it’s just as reasonable to give weight to those accomplishments as it is to give weight to UCLA’s.
On UCLA, I mentioned that they had a good year overall despite the lousy football team and the underperformance of their two No. 1 ranked teams in the NCAA tournament. I added that they were No. 1 in the Big Ten Conference in the Learfield Director's Cup Standings in 2025-2026. Those are factual statements. I did not compare UCLA to any school one school or the Big Ten to any other conference.
You made the statement, "If the comparison were between the nine Pac schools and the top nine MWC schools, the MWC would have the advantage with a 140.1 average." Also, you said that "Moreover it’s surprising to see San Diego State at the bottom of the Pac ranking. That’s incongruous for an athletic program that aspires to power conference membership." You are making the comparisons.
Air Force has 17 men's varsity sports, SDSU has 6. Air Force can go 4-8 in football and 3-29 in men's basketball and it does not affect their Director's Cup Rankings. Air Force got their points from men's cross country, men and women's fencing, women's gymnastics, and men's track & field (indoor and outdoor). SDSU does not participate in any of these sports. SDSU football finished the regular season in a four-way tie for first place, the men's basketball team finished second to Utah State in men's basketball and lost to USU in the championship game, the women's basketball team won the regular season title, and the baseball team won the regular season title. SDSU football, despite beating Boise State 17-7, lost the tiebreaker for the MWC CCG to Boise State, the eventual champion. That is an athletic program bringing value to the conference.
The sports that really count for a conference are football and basketball. The Air Force Director's Cup rankings are deceiving. Air Force ranked 77, Gonzaga 188. Does that mean Air Force athletics bring more value than Gonzaga? SJSU was ranked 211, SDSU 216. Does that mean SJSU is about the same as SDSU? Nevada is at 148; Boise State is at 156. Should the Pac have taken Nevada?
Again, you are the one that decided to compare conferences based on the Learfield Director's Cup Standings. The Learfield Director's Cup Standings are a good measure of a schools overall athletic strength, particularly among the Top 25 schools, but is not useful for conference realignment, which is what you were trying to say with your comparison.