High Country Student
1st String

Posts: 1,416
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 66
I Root For: App. State
Location:
|
RE: CollegAD: SBC Quietly Looking to Raise Exit Fees
(07-23-2026 09:49 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (07-23-2026 08:26 PM)High Country Student Wrote: (07-23-2026 07:34 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (07-23-2026 06:44 PM)High Country Student Wrote: (07-23-2026 06:17 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: Whether or not JMU would be interested in joining the American likely depends on what's left of the American.
If the American is left in tact or only loses USF, JMU would almost certainly be interested.
If the American loses USF and Tulane, JMU would probably still be interested, especially if a school like App State or ODU moved with us.
If the American loses USF, Tulane, and Memphis, then things start to become less clear. If we could move with along with two others from App State, ODU, and Marshall, I think it could be appealing. That assumes the service academies stay with the American (50/50 in that scenario IMO). A conference with mid-Atlantic/NE peers like App State/ODU/Marshall, ECU, Army, Navy, and Temple could hold appeal, given where JMU pulls students from and where our alumni live.
If the American loses USF, Tulane, Memphis, and ECU, I think that's a clear tipping point. I think the service academies almost certainly go independent at that point. What's left of the American doesn't hold much appeal to JMU fans and the SBC may even have the opportunity to selectively poach a couple American schools, because their media deal would be destroyed.
Whether you want it or not, money talks and your AD will move you if the money is more.
Agreed, but that's the main factor in my assessment of what JMU would want. An American with no USF, Tulane, Memphis, ECU, Army, or Navy would likely have a media deal that's not substantially better than the SBC's. It's unclear whether it would be worth paying SBC exit fees and increasing travel costs to move to a conference like that. I suspect that the money wouldn't be there, which is why I say JMU wouldn't support the move.
edit- I also think there's a scenario where ECU joins the SBC. If USF, Tulane, and Memphis join P4 conferences, and Army and Navy go independent, I think there's a scenario where the SBC could add a few American teams including ECU.
A lot of it depends on timing. Remember, a lot of people said the PAC-12 would fold and the remaining teams would just join the Mountain West. It got all the way down to two teams in the PAC and instead of the two teams joining the Mountain West, five teams from the Mountain West joined the two teams because the money was still better due to exit fees and the name prestige that the PAC 12 already holds. Additionally, there was a time where the Big 12 got down to 8 teams and people rumored that the AAC might pull a few teams based on the teams left because it may no longer be appealing to join the remaining teams. The next thing you know, Cincinnati, UCF and Houston are joining the Big 12. This was due to the name prestige the Big 12 had and the media rights contract they already had in place paying more. Unless it takes a lot longer for those teams to leave the AAC and the AAC to need these new teams than expected, the AAC will likely still be paying way a fair amount more based on the current media rights contract and the AAC name still holds more weight over the Belt because of the success of all of the teams that have made the CFP (even though most are no longer in the conference) which means the Belt teams would likely go to the AAC rather than the other way around. The only way I could see it working out for the Belt is if the Tulane, USF’s and/or Memphis’s of the world leave the AAC right before they have to renegotiate their new media rights deal and the AAC doesn’t have time to replace them before those negotiations begin so the AAC makeup for that negotiation is something like:
Army
Temple
Navy
ECU
Charlotte
FAU
UAB
UTSA
Rice
North Texas
Tulsa
If that happens and the current teams in the Belt when the Belt next negotiates, there MIGHT be a world where our media rights contracts are close enough that if we could and would be willing to raise and fund ECUs exit fees from the AAC and entrance fees to the SBC, they would do it. No guarantee, but it MIGHT happen and even then, no guarantee the AAC contract would be equal or less than the Belt and no guarantee that if it is, ECU would even do it or the Belt could and would raise all of that money and use it towards getting ECU in. Don’t think you’d get everyone to agree on using that much money toward it.
But like I said, if the AAC looks like that, JMU would probably join especially assuming App State, ODU, and potentially Marshall also join.
Let's assume the same timing, but say the AAC looks like this:
Temple
ECU
Charlotte
FAU
UAB
UTSA
Rice
North Texas
Tulsa
If the service academies bail when USF, Tulane, and Memphis leave, that's what the AAC looks like. In my view, it's a toss up at that point as to whether the AAC raids the SBC or the other way around. If ECU also goes to the P4, I think the scale tips in the SBC's favor (regardless of historical brand).
When a conference gets raided deeply enough, things can flip. That's what happened in 2021 between the SBC and CUSA. Traditionally CUSA had a better brand and had raided the SBC, but the large-scale raid of CUSA weakened the conference to the point that the SBC was able to flip things.
AAC exit fees are the wild card.
I still think if the media rights contracts have the AAC making what they are now, JMU would move because the teams involved can still change before the negotiations and in the present, JMU is still making multiple times what they would be making in the belt for the remainder of that term which equates to multiple years of media rights payment in the belt for the remainder of their contract. It would be one thing if they were right at negotiation for the AAC and projections showed their contract about to decrease on a per team basis to basically equate to the Belt at that point or what the Belt was projected to be if it was being renegotiated that same year for instance.
|
|