(06-09-2026 11:11 AM)Just Joe Wrote: (06-09-2026 11:00 AM)Ned Low Wrote: According to a journalist (Ross Dellinger, I believe), the B12 could expel Texas Tech for conduct detrimental to the league’s reputation.
My hunch is that Texas Tech will wind up caving on this issue. Sorsby will be paid and will attend school but he will not suit up. This would be a reasonable decision by Tech. They’ve screwed the pooch on this one; it’s now time to own it, make amends and move forward.
Still, the damage has been done to the B12 and they may be forced to make some drastic decisions.
I don't expect Tech to be expelled AT ALL but we're well beyond Tech even being able to cave in the way you suggest. Sorsby is free and clear to play (barring a sudden appeal being heard and acted upon sooner than expected) and I'd think Tech would be facing a lawsuit from him if they tried to remove him from the team based on this. The president of the university also laid it on real thick about how the full weight of the university would support this young man, etc so it's impossible to suddenly reverse that when you've already defined part of supporting him as letting him play. I'm guessing they never thought he'd win his appeal and wanted to show their boosters they were willing to fight for him. Well the dog caught the car so they have to figure out what to do with it now.
The moralizing in this thread is almost as hilarious as your extremely apt analogy. The dog indeed caught the car. The NCAA needs to go away. It can't control anything, enforce anything, and there is a very simple reason. They died on the hill of strict amateurism when the SCOTUS decided the NIL matter and piled on with pay for play and strongly suggested we move to a model which could be controlled through business law.
The NCAA as a virtuous model is a big a myth as any school being completely virtuous. One of the most successful times of bending and warping and breaking rules for one SEC school resulted much to my amazement in their president becoming the head of the NCAA. And for those who love their scripture the verse about muzzling the ox when it is treading out the grain should have resonated when so many student athletes became second class citizens of their campuses because they had no car, and had no money, and couldn't earn any using their athletic gifts lest they violate amateurism. It reminds me of the American Olympic Committee stripping Jim Thorpe of his gold medal in track because he earned eating money playing for a semi-pro baseball team. The "virtuous" NCAA violated a principle of our Constitution by making college athletes indentured servants for the signing of a grant and aid. Gee that never stopped point shaving on basketball at certain schools caught in the act, nor did it stop vastly underpaid officials of collegiate sports from shading the results through the whistle or flag. And as to state's rights, I would argue that it was never kosher to take first football money and lastly basketball tournament revenue and use it to help institutions which couldn't afford sports to have them when those institutions which had revenue siphoned were from states that didn't receive the siphoned funds. There is something fundamentally wrong with the taxpayers of a sovereign state having their schools which they fund receive less so schools in other states can receive more.
The NCAA did provide a rules structure which it very imperfectly enforced.
And the paying of players under the table was immoral because it forced young people to be tax evaders. They couldn't claim the money or pay taxes on it without losing their scholarships.
The only system which can govern this more consistently is contract law. The young athletes can file taxes, the players can organize and agree with their employers to the code of conduct, and states will not have any extraneous quasi bureaucratic entity granted exemption by the government that can siphon the fruit of their tax dollars off to another state's institution. And most importantly it places the onus of operating within your means squarely on each school and/or on its state's legislature.
I held jobs while I was a student through undergraduate and my masters. My roommate who played football didn't have the spare time to do so and wouldn't have been permitted to except in the offseason, and then it could not have any relationship to what he could do athletically. It was summertime mill work for him. He's now suffering the accumulation of the athletic wear and tear on his body, is past retirement age and can't afford to retire. He worries about medical insurance. He played college ball for the same reason many do. He couldn't afford to go to school any other way. He was used up and the school got wealthier for it. Fine life lesson to learn, huh? All made possible by the existence of the NCAA and its Victorian Era claims of amateurism, which by the way allowed the sons of the wealthy to be the Olympic Athletes of their countries as all others had to work to eat.
Now add to that nearly two decades of following up on recruiting violations while in a job that put me where that action was happening and I can say soberly and with a straight face that I don't believe in the virtue of the schools, of the NCAA, or of any of it. What I do believe in is what can be enforced by contract because it comes with a discernable legal quid pro quo. The sooner we get there the better. And when it happens and we have had the passage of time, neither will it be perfect, but it will be far superior to what we had under the NCAA and far superior to the in-between space we occupy now.