Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Protect College Sports Act
Author Message
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,384
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #3421
RE: Protect College Sports Act
There's plenty of kids who do want to unionize. They're not the stars but if it goes to the courts then the fact that some people would vote no isn't enough to stop it.
11-10-2026 01:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,994
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13547
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #3422
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 01:11 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  There's plenty of kids who do want to unionize. They're not the stars but if it goes to the courts then the fact that some people would vote no isn't enough to stop it.
The player's union only needs to exist for those who want it. Membership in most states would not be compulsory. I find the argument that many players wouldn't want it to be irrelevant. The option must exist to appease the courts. Stars won't need it or want it, 3rd stringers will. Contracts will have to exist because it will be the only legal means of restraining the portal. If somebody wants one of your players they'll have to buy him/her out. The reason we have abnormal parity right now is no great team truly has what would be a second team. Second stringers hit the portal for playing time so scouts will notice them.

Player's unions as an option for all players, and contracts will straighten out most of the mess and then setting Caps on NIL legally and on payment of players by collective bargaining solves most of the rest.
11-10-2026 01:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3423
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 11:14 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:41 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:15 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:07 AM)bullet Wrote:  While that is creative, they will not spend the time to create an entirely new category of "employee." That would be a massive undertaking to try to fit around all existing laws and deal with all the unintended consequences. You think the schools have lawsuits now?

That is an option the discussion has included for several years now.

New designations wouldn’t be ‘fitting around existing law’ so much as creating new law that other things now need to fit around. The goal is to make things cleaner. It starts the clock on a fresh body of case law.

Up until last week, universities and conference commissioners and others in the ‘management’ side felt pretty confident they could get a PCSA passed without needing to deal much with athlete rights at all. Unilateral caps, mandated. But that in itself is an engraved invitation to file lawsuits.

With a new Congress, the matter of a bargaining structure for such things comes back onto the table.

You've got all kinds of laws that relate to employee status, starting with benefits.

The point exactly.

As soon as we speak of ‘employees’ and ‘unions’, “all kinds of laws that relate to employee status” do enter the picture, yes.

That is why some interest has existed in carving out new categories that would apply to student athletes who are simultaneously doing compensated work as public representatives of their university.


This idea has been mentioned several times on these boards… but has it ever been mentioned as a possibility by lawmakers?

As for the folks who state that the student-athletes “don’t want to be employees”, I’ll add this: what they want does not matter. They either will be deemed to be employees or their status as contractors will be allowed to continue; bureaucrats or judges will make the decision.

Athletes have rights. Rights matter.

When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.

The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.

If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.)

Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.

(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)
11-10-2026 03:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3424
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 12:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  ....
1. The kids don't want to unionize
....

You know this because you asked them?
11-10-2026 03:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3425
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-09-2026 03:37 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  ....
I also do not see a means to unionize 250,000 student athletes across 1,000 schools from Texas A&M to Bowdoin.

I recommend looking at a few current union memberships.

It can be done.

The image dies hard here of student athletes as dormitory-dwelling pizza eaters living on a shoestring who are tickled pink to play an extra game in exotic Shreveport if they should get so lucky, rather than moneyed young adults with access to professional legal advice, AFL-CIO advisors, and experienced agents.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 04:15 PM by Gitanole.)
11-10-2026 03:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TerryD Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 16,986
Joined: Feb 2006
Reputation: 1282
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location: Grayson Highlands
Post: #3426
RE: Protect College Sports Act
The conferences are not going to get a straight up anti-trust exemption from Congress, just because.

If they want that, and they do, they will have to give something in return.

So, it is either the Protect College Sports Act (or something similar) or employee status with unionization.

There is no Plan C.

Otherwise, it will continue to be the Wild West indefinitely, with $50 + million dollar rosters and unlimited transfer portal.

That is okay by me personally. ND seems to be a adapting and doing fine with this new setup.

However, if anyone else doesn't like or want the Wild West to continue, there are only two options.

Pick your "poison".
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 04:24 PM by TerryD.)
11-10-2026 04:17 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Claw Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,564
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1566
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Orangeville HELP!
Post: #3427
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 03:50 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 12:57 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  ....
1. The kids don't want to unionize
....

You know this because you asked them?

The ones with million dollar NIL's probably don't. There are a lot more of the other guys. I don't think a vote either way is a given.
11-10-2026 04:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,991
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #3428
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 11:14 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:41 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:15 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  That is an option the discussion has included for several years now.

New designations wouldn’t be ‘fitting around existing law’ so much as creating new law that other things now need to fit around. The goal is to make things cleaner. It starts the clock on a fresh body of case law.

Up until last week, universities and conference commissioners and others in the ‘management’ side felt pretty confident they could get a PCSA passed without needing to deal much with athlete rights at all. Unilateral caps, mandated. But that in itself is an engraved invitation to file lawsuits.

With a new Congress, the matter of a bargaining structure for such things comes back onto the table.

You've got all kinds of laws that relate to employee status, starting with benefits.

The point exactly.

As soon as we speak of ‘employees’ and ‘unions’, “all kinds of laws that relate to employee status” do enter the picture, yes.

That is why some interest has existed in carving out new categories that would apply to student athletes who are simultaneously doing compensated work as public representatives of their university.


This idea has been mentioned several times on these boards… but has it ever been mentioned as a possibility by lawmakers?

As for the folks who state that the student-athletes “don’t want to be employees”, I’ll add this: what they want does not matter. They either will be deemed to be employees or their status as contractors will be allowed to continue; bureaucrats or judges will make the decision.

Athletes have rights. Rights matter.

When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.

The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.

If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.)

Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.

(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)

That's an awfully thin precedent b/c it came through the NLRB instead of a Federal District Court. Even in the unlikely event that it is eventually revived under a future Democratic administration, and even if the NLRB were to rule in favor of the palintiffs, it would still only apply to the Ivy League, or perhaps any others that are fully composed of private schools.

The issue isn't whether it's common sense or not that kids playing sports should be considered employees, the issue is that these extremely wealthy and powerful entities (aka the schools) don't want them to be considered employees, and most of the kids don't want it, either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free and they can transfer any time they get benched, the coach gives them a dirty look, that Miami booster shows up with $2m in a bag, whatever.

It seems that this whole argument just extreme conservatives and extreme liberals shouting over each other rather than listening to the parties involved. The PCSA does a good job of simply ignoring the issue...let the kids and the schools do it if they want to in the future, but if they don't that's ok, too.
11-10-2026 05:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bluesox Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,546
Joined: Jan 2006
Reputation: 93
I Root For:
Location:
Post: #3429
RE: Protect College Sports Act
I’d like to see a clause where the allow 1 neutral site basketball game per year for schools, keep the games on campus.
11-10-2026 07:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3430
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 05:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 11:14 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:41 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:33 AM)bullet Wrote:  You've got all kinds of laws that relate to employee status, starting with benefits.

The point exactly.

As soon as we speak of ‘employees’ and ‘unions’, “all kinds of laws that relate to employee status” do enter the picture, yes.

That is why some interest has existed in carving out new categories that would apply to student athletes who are simultaneously doing compensated work as public representatives of their university.

This idea has been mentioned several times on these boards… but has it ever been mentioned as a possibility by lawmakers?

As for the folks who state that the student-athletes “don’t want to be employees”, I’ll add this: what they want does not matter. They either will be deemed to be employees or their status as contractors will be allowed to continue; bureaucrats or judges will make the decision.

Athletes have rights. Rights matter.

When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.

The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.

If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.[)

Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.

(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)

That's an awfully thin precedent b/c it came through the NLRB instead of a Federal District Court. Even in the unlikely event that it is eventually revived under a future Democratic administration, and even if the NLRB were to rule in favor of the palintiffs, it would still only apply to the Ivy League, or perhaps any others that are fully composed of private schools.

The issue isn't whether it's common sense or not that kids playing sports should be considered employees, the issue is that these extremely wealthy and powerful entities (aka the schools) don't want them to be considered employees, and most of the kids don't want it, either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free and they can transfer any time they get benched, the coach gives them a dirty look, that Miami booster shows up with $2m in a bag, whatever.

It seems that this whole argument just extreme conservatives and extreme liberals shouting over each other rather than listening to the parties involved. The PCSA does a good job of simply ignoring the issue...let the kids and the schools do it if they want to in the future, but if they don't that's ok, too.

A thin precedent is nevertheless a precedent. It tells you how the law looks to people whose job it is to know the law.

The larger precedent is in the Allston and House cases. Athletes’ rights have been doing very well in court for some time now, and the NCAA has been getting shredded.

It is one reason the PCSA effort was mounted—to create a firewall against the traditional NCAA powers losing more ground.

All this, before we even consider how collective bargaining has long been the norm in pro leagues.

This is why I see it as a tossup whether sports legislation goes forward now. The inclination among many elected officials, especially but not only Democrats, is to sit out any involvement and let the courts continue to sort things out. The athletes are already doing fine there.

What sparks involvement is if enough people in the college sports sector do find legislation useful. That would likely need to include athletes at this point. If grass-roots interest in Congressional action is truly present, lawmakers have these wish lists to begin with in crafting new law.

In any case, athletes retain their rights. The burden of proof is on anyone claiming the ability to unilaterally set caps on revshare and NIL in the absence of negotiation with those whose options are capped. Legally, in the US, that is a difficult argument to make.

Odds are that collective bargaining of some sort is on the way. We will have employment and unions, or something that kinda sorta works like employees and unions.

We’ll see how things go.
__
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 10:07 PM by Gitanole.)
11-10-2026 09:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,101
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #3431
RE: Protect College Sports Act
What gives me some confidence is the fact that there is a bipartisan effort to protect some sanity regarding the window of college athletics. It is a special time in a young person's life and opportunity turnover should be protected. IMO, this is where exemptions are necessary to preserve some sanctity.

I don't mind the athletes bargaining for revenue sharing. BUT hitting a revenue sharing cap is not mandatory and I already illustrated earlier in this thread that there aren't that many schools that are projected to consistently hit that anyway. So what are they bargaining for and what will come of it? My prediction is more equitable distributions that don't reflect what the elite athletes bring in. Non-rev and female athletes will see gains (and good for them because they sweat and bleed as well), but the elite football players some folks are so worried about will actually earn less rev than what they would under the PCSA. They're the vast minority of college athletes and they won't be able to throw their weight around in a union.
(This post was last modified: 11-10-2026 11:18 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
11-10-2026 11:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ouflak Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 317
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation: 69
I Root For: University of Oklahoma
Location:
Post: #3432
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 05:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free

The players pay taxes on all of their NIL income. I do think though that for the university affiliated collectives, aren't donations to those tax-free? That's still a good deal as that allows more to go to the players (even though they pay more taxes on it).

(11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  (It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)

Also right to Freedom of Speech which covers the right to do NIL deals.

There are a lot of inherent rights the PCSA is/was trying to squash to the benefit of a few.
11-11-2026 05:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
XLance Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,165
Joined: Mar 2008
Reputation: 1265
I Root For: Carolina
Location: Greensboro, NC
Post: #3433
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 04:17 PM)TerryD Wrote:  The conferences are not going to get a straight up anti-trust exemption from Congress, just because.

If they want that, and they do, they will have to give something in return.

So, it is either the Protect College Sports Act (or something similar) or employee status with unionization.

There is no Plan C.

Otherwise, it will continue to be the Wild West indefinitely, with $50 + million dollar rosters and unlimited transfer portal.

That is okay by me personally. ND seems to be a adapting and doing fine with this new setup.

However, if anyone else doesn't like or want the Wild West to continue, there are only two options.

Pick your "poison".

The current path that college football is on will create a de facto "super league" on it's own, which in turn will kill the sport, if it hasn't already.
11-11-2026 06:00 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #3434
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-09-2026 04:33 PM)ouflak Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 03:45 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 03:37 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 03:09 PM)Claw Wrote:  Do any of you think a Democratic-controlled Congress will push for player unionization? It would seem likely on the surface.

They have bigger fish to fry. I also do not see a means to unionize 250,000 student athletes across 1,000 schools from Texas A&M to Bowdoin.

And do they want to be employees?

And even if they somehow were made 'employees' (state? federal?), would they at all be interested in a union (state? federal?) whose main reason for existing seems to be to limit their own mobility and ability to maximize their own individual pay?
The NLRA could be amended to cover commercial sports enterprises. Football workers are not the same as prison guards or DMV clerks as far as engaging in interstate commerce.

In other industries, associations of employers contract with unions (e.g. plumber and electricians).
11-11-2026 11:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3435
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-11-2026 11:35 AM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(11-09-2026 04:33 PM)ouflak Wrote:  And even if they somehow were made 'employees' (state? federal?), would they at all be interested in a union (state? federal?) whose main reason for existing seems to be to limit their own mobility and ability to maximize their own individual pay?
The NLRA could be amended to cover commercial sports enterprises. Football workers are not the same as prison guards or DMV clerks as far as engaging in interstate commerce.

In other industries, associations of employers contract with unions (e.g. plumber and electricians).

Everybody has a wish list.

NFL players have a union. They find something to negotiate.

People here are talking as if collective representation bodies for college athletes are some sort of conjectural, vaporware thing. Reality? They already exist.

07-coffee3
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2026 12:22 PM by Gitanole.)
11-11-2026 11:48 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,952
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2823
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #3436
RE: Protect College Sports Act
Daniel Libit, Sportico:

The college sports landscape is undergoing a profound transformation, one that increasingly demands input beyond the governing body. In response, a handful of nonprofit organizations have asserted themselves as crucial stakeholders in the reform conversation, competing for limited resources while navigating a system dominated by powerful financial interests.

Here are six notable organizations seeking to shape the future of intercollegiate athletics.


Details follow about:

Knight Commission on Intercollegiate Athletics

National College Players Association

Athletes.org

College Football Players Association

United College Athletes Association

The Drake Group and Drake Group Education Fund

https://www.sportico.com/leagues/college...234842108/
11-11-2026 12:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #3437
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 10:13 AM)bullet Wrote:  They have 3 categories in the House settlement and any athlete groups would probably be around those:
1) Men's football and basketball players;
2) Women's basketball players; and
3) All other student-athletes.

Groups 2) and 3) aren't really an issue as far as NIL. Its enforcing all the other rules like eligibility.
These were for claimed damages, and the first two were limited to the P4. The reason women's and men's basketball players were distinct is that there was not a credible claim that there would be a video game based on women's basketball. The other student-athletes was for those who could have received NIL payments prior to the NCAA rules being changed (most of these damages went to P4 football/basketball players), and had received NIL money afterwards, though there were exceptions such as Olivia Dunne.

The NCAA knew that if the settlement covered only P4, they would be immediately sued by other athletes, so they let the plaintiffs amend their complaint. The damages were for so-called Broadcast NIL (BNIL). The NCAA denies there is such a thing, and their new rules forbid payment for BNIL. But they gave a big bag of cash to be distributed as if their was BNIL. The plaintiff's expert then took the amounts of media contracts and began chopping it up: 75% football, 15% men's basketball, 5% women's basketball, and 5% everything else. They then recognized the Big East basketball contract, and the American and MWC contracts as being more valuable. I think SEC baseball got a special allotment. They then divided the residual by everyone else, and came up with a figure of about $100, which would be paid out over 10 years, with 20% cut out for the lawyers.

The P4 agreed to pay up to $20.5 million to athletes. There is No minimum. The settlement does not specify how this will be paid, or whether it was for NIL or some sort of direct payment. There is no exemption for Title IX, and the settlement is being challenged on Title IX grounds.

Other schools were permitted to Opt In, so they could spend up to $20.5 million.
11-11-2026 12:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,849
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #3438
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 09:59 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 05:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 11:14 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 10:41 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  The point exactly.

As soon as we speak of ‘employees’ and ‘unions’, “all kinds of laws that relate to employee status” do enter the picture, yes.

That is why some interest has existed in carving out new categories that would apply to student athletes who are simultaneously doing compensated work as public representatives of their university.

This idea has been mentioned several times on these boards… but has it ever been mentioned as a possibility by lawmakers?

As for the folks who state that the student-athletes “don’t want to be employees”, I’ll add this: what they want does not matter. They either will be deemed to be employees or their status as contractors will be allowed to continue; bureaucrats or judges will make the decision.

Athletes have rights. Rights matter.

When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.

The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.

If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.[)

Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.

(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)

That's an awfully thin precedent b/c it came through the NLRB instead of a Federal District Court. Even in the unlikely event that it is eventually revived under a future Democratic administration, and even if the NLRB were to rule in favor of the palintiffs, it would still only apply to the Ivy League, or perhaps any others that are fully composed of private schools.

The issue isn't whether it's common sense or not that kids playing sports should be considered employees, the issue is that these extremely wealthy and powerful entities (aka the schools) don't want them to be considered employees, and most of the kids don't want it, either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free and they can transfer any time they get benched, the coach gives them a dirty look, that Miami booster shows up with $2m in a bag, whatever.

It seems that this whole argument just extreme conservatives and extreme liberals shouting over each other rather than listening to the parties involved. The PCSA does a good job of simply ignoring the issue...let the kids and the schools do it if they want to in the future, but if they don't that's ok, too.

A thin precedent is nevertheless a precedent. It tells you how the law looks to people whose job it is to know the law.

The larger precedent is in the Allston and House cases. Athletes’ rights have been doing very well in court for some time now, and the NCAA has been getting shredded.

It is one reason the PCSA effort was mounted—to create a firewall against the traditional NCAA powers losing more ground.

All this, before we even consider how collective bargaining has long been the norm in pro leagues.

This is why I see it as a tossup whether sports legislation goes forward now. The inclination among many elected officials, especially but not only Democrats, is to sit out any involvement and let the courts continue to sort things out. The athletes are already doing fine there.

What sparks involvement is if enough people in the college sports sector do find legislation useful. That would likely need to include athletes at this point. If grass-roots interest in Congressional action is truly present, lawmakers have these wish lists to begin with in crafting new law.

In any case, athletes retain their rights. The burden of proof is on anyone claiming the ability to unilaterally set caps on revshare and NIL in the absence of negotiation with those whose options are capped. Legally, in the US, that is a difficult argument to make.

Odds are that collective bargaining of some sort is on the way. We will have employment and unions, or something that kinda sorta works like employees and unions.

We’ll see how things go.
__
The athletes agreed to the cap under the House Settlement. Incoming athletes agree to the settlement before they play.
11-11-2026 12:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ouflak Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 317
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation: 69
I Root For: University of Oklahoma
Location:
Post: #3439
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-11-2026 12:38 PM)jimrtex Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 09:59 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 05:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 03:48 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(11-10-2026 11:14 AM)Ned Low Wrote:  This idea has been mentioned several times on these boards… but has it ever been mentioned as a possibility by lawmakers?

As for the folks who state that the student-athletes “don’t want to be employees”, I’ll add this: what they want does not matter. They either will be deemed to be employees or their status as contractors will be allowed to continue; bureaucrats or judges will make the decision.

Athletes have rights. Rights matter.

When courts have decided. it has been because athletes were plaintiffs. They, as citizens holding rights, asked courts to decide.

The idea of a new category has been discussed in player organizations and among ADs, with lawyers advising.

If no new category is created by law, courts are on course—using existing law—simply to rule athletes employees. (See Dartmouth for precedent.[)

Some people really don’t want this, which is in part why the PCSA got as far as it did with the lawmakers it did. But the topic of a collective bargaining mechanism—whatever form it takes—appears to be back on the table for discussion.

(It would have been taken up as a topic in court anyway had the original PCSA passed. Athletes’ rights again: right to petition for redress of grievances, right to freedom of association.)

That's an awfully thin precedent b/c it came through the NLRB instead of a Federal District Court. Even in the unlikely event that it is eventually revived under a future Democratic administration, and even if the NLRB were to rule in favor of the palintiffs, it would still only apply to the Ivy League, or perhaps any others that are fully composed of private schools.

The issue isn't whether it's common sense or not that kids playing sports should be considered employees, the issue is that these extremely wealthy and powerful entities (aka the schools) don't want them to be considered employees, and most of the kids don't want it, either b/c right now they can get their NIL checks tax free and they can transfer any time they get benched, the coach gives them a dirty look, that Miami booster shows up with $2m in a bag, whatever.

It seems that this whole argument just extreme conservatives and extreme liberals shouting over each other rather than listening to the parties involved. The PCSA does a good job of simply ignoring the issue...let the kids and the schools do it if they want to in the future, but if they don't that's ok, too.

A thin precedent is nevertheless a precedent. It tells you how the law looks to people whose job it is to know the law.

The larger precedent is in the Allston and House cases. Athletes’ rights have been doing very well in court for some time now, and the NCAA has been getting shredded.

It is one reason the PCSA effort was mounted—to create a firewall against the traditional NCAA powers losing more ground.

All this, before we even consider how collective bargaining has long been the norm in pro leagues.

This is why I see it as a tossup whether sports legislation goes forward now. The inclination among many elected officials, especially but not only Democrats, is to sit out any involvement and let the courts continue to sort things out. The athletes are already doing fine there.

What sparks involvement is if enough people in the college sports sector do find legislation useful. That would likely need to include athletes at this point. If grass-roots interest in Congressional action is truly present, lawmakers have these wish lists to begin with in crafting new law.

In any case, athletes retain their rights. The burden of proof is on anyone claiming the ability to unilaterally set caps on revshare and NIL in the absence of negotiation with those whose options are capped. Legally, in the US, that is a difficult argument to make.

Odds are that collective bargaining of some sort is on the way. We will have employment and unions, or something that kinda sorta works like employees and unions.

We’ll see how things go.
__
The athletes agreed to the cap under the House Settlement. Incoming athletes agree to the settlement before they play.

Any and all top athletes opt out of the House Settlement. They could care less about some sliver of the revenues when they are set to rake in NIL. This was a major part of the motivation for the PCSA - to force all student athletes into that kind of agreement whether they wanted it or not, and kneecap their ability to go to the courts to do something about those lost fundamental rights mentioned in an earlier post above.
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2026 04:19 PM by ouflak.)
11-11-2026 01:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
EdwordL Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,443
Joined: Sep 2020
Reputation: 500
I Root For: KU, WVU
Location:
Post: #3440
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(11-10-2026 07:32 PM)bluesox Wrote:  I’d like to see a clause where the allow 1 neutral site basketball game per year for schools, keep the games on campus.

Idk. Conferences, especially the P2, do not seem anxious to monetize basketball. Kansas, Duke, UNC, UConn, et al all seem to do well playing in neutral site early season tournaments. Got to get on tv as often as possible with as many good OOC matchups as possible,
11-12-2026 12:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.