Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 06:41 AM)Lurker Above Wrote: (06-03-2026 06:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-03-2026 01:38 AM)IWantToTalkToRalphSampson Wrote: Wouldn’t this accelerate a breakaway B1G-SEC led Super League outside the NCAA? Forcing either league to subsidize other conferences through legislation seems like a taking of their property, the media rights granted to them by their members, without compensation.
Well, the legislation as-is very specifically states that there cannot be any merger, consolidation, or joining of media rights of any conference that makes more than $1 billion in revenue as of the effective date of the Act. The only 2 leagues that fit that criteria are the Big Ten and SEC. In theory, either the SEC or Big Ten could breakaway individually, but they can’t join together in a Super League.
I think I Want to Talk's point is maybe the SEC and B1G breakaway before this bill becomes law. Even if they think they can stop or improve this bill, the fact that a bill with such terms has been introduced into the Senate may be enough to discourage the SEC and B1G from thinking the highly desired government solution is worth the risk of there being a greater undesired government problem causing them to say to heck with it, let's bail now.
Another point. Note the market disruption a law would have to the SEC and B1G that prevents them from adding other members, but other conferences would be allowed to invite their members. Presently, no SEC or B1G school would leave either P2 conference, but young billionaires are bold, and maybe Campbell, who I believe has had more influence on this bill than anyone, might have a bigger longterm plan for his Red Raiders. This bill may prevent his beloved school from getting a P2 invite, which likely would never come, but it would allow for the longterm possibly that if the money, and college football's rules, could one day align sufficiently the Big12, or some other future conference that would include the Red Raiders, could pull in P2 schools into its conference. If that sounds out there to you, remember the recent plant to create 7 conferences with 10 schools each? Those factions are still out there with investment backing. If you are a super Texas Tech booster, you not only want your school to win championships, but you want your school to be in a conference that is top a power conference. His play may be, if TT cannot get a P2 invite, then game the system so I can help creat a true pier P3 for his Red Raiders.
Sure - the Big Ten and SEC could try to do that, but any breakaway would still be subject to antitrust law generally. The fact that a bill got this far with a specific outright prohibition of those two leagues merging or consolidating (led by Senators in states with P2 schools, no less) heavily indicates that regulators would seek to block any attempt under existing laws. The proposed bill just makes it *explicitly* illegal and leaving no doubt as to the interpretation. Clearly, there are enough people in the federal government on both sides of the aisle (a key point) that hate the idea of a B1G/SEC Super League. So, it’s not as if though the P2 can just casually slip this under the radar or merge simply by moving quicker because the federal government would still have to approve that merger.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 07:12 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:05 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: I have an idea: media bundling without conference restrictions. 
But we all know the barnacles in the B1G and SEC won't go for it because they'd take a deserved pay cut.
Wait, maybe we're going the wrong way... no media bundling for anyone!
|
|
| 06-03-2026 07:21 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:09 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: Well, it’s always easier to oppose rather than to create. There’s no need for the NFL to worry about the third weekend in December’s Saturday media rights when the Petulant2 haven’t yet coalesced on their future vision.
I started to gravitate towards Predatory 2, but yours has a better ring to it
|
|
| 06-03-2026 07:23 AM |
|
CliftonAve
Heisman

Posts: 23,849
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1400
I Root For: Jimmy Nippert
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
I think we’ve reached the point where everyone outside of the B10/SEC plus a hand full of elites don’t GAF whether there is a split. To borrow a quote from Ivan Drago in Rocky IV “If it dies, it dies.”
|
|
| 06-03-2026 07:27 AM |
|
Lurker Above
1st String

Posts: 2,232
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 330
I Root For: UGA
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:12 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-03-2026 06:41 AM)Lurker Above Wrote: (06-03-2026 06:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-03-2026 01:38 AM)IWantToTalkToRalphSampson Wrote: Wouldn’t this accelerate a breakaway B1G-SEC led Super League outside the NCAA? Forcing either league to subsidize other conferences through legislation seems like a taking of their property, the media rights granted to them by their members, without compensation.
Well, the legislation as-is very specifically states that there cannot be any merger, consolidation, or joining of media rights of any conference that makes more than $1 billion in revenue as of the effective date of the Act. The only 2 leagues that fit that criteria are the Big Ten and SEC. In theory, either the SEC or Big Ten could breakaway individually, but they can’t join together in a Super League.
I think I Want to Talk's point is maybe the SEC and B1G breakaway before this bill becomes law. Even if they think they can stop or improve this bill, the fact that a bill with such terms has been introduced into the Senate may be enough to discourage the SEC and B1G from thinking the highly desired government solution is worth the risk of there being a greater undesired government problem causing them to say to heck with it, let's bail now.
Another point. Note the market disruption a law would have to the SEC and B1G that prevents them from adding other members, but other conferences would be allowed to invite their members. Presently, no SEC or B1G school would leave either P2 conference, but young billionaires are bold, and maybe Campbell, who I believe has had more influence on this bill than anyone, might have a bigger longterm plan for his Red Raiders. This bill may prevent his beloved school from getting a P2 invite, which likely would never come, but it would allow for the longterm possibly that if the money, and college football's rules, could one day align sufficiently the Big12, or some other future conference that would include the Red Raiders, could pull in P2 schools into its conference. If that sounds out there to you, remember the recent plant to create 7 conferences with 10 schools each? Those factions are still out there with investment backing. If you are a super Texas Tech booster, you not only want your school to win championships, but you want your school to be in a conference that is top a power conference. His play may be, if TT cannot get a P2 invite, then game the system so I can help creat a true pier P3 for his Red Raiders.
Sure - the Big Ten and SEC could try to do that, but any breakaway would still be subject to antitrust law generally. The fact that a bill got this far with a specific outright prohibition of those two leagues merging or consolidating (led by Senators in states with P2 schools, no less) heavily indicates that regulators would seek to block any attempt under existing laws. The proposed bill just makes it *explicitly* illegal and leaving no doubt as to the interpretation. Clearly, there are enough people in the federal government on both sides of the aisle (a key point) that hate the idea of a B1G/SEC Super League. So, it’s not as if though the P2 can just casually slip this under the radar or merge simply by moving quicker because the federal government would still have to approve that merger.
Yes, of course antitrust would still apply, and more so for a super league, but the SEC and B1G leaving separately is still a possibility, though not a probability at this point.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 08:28 AM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-02-2026 09:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: That's the problem with any unrestrained system that was thought up by some academic in his study, things get disorganized and chaotic in the real world. In my opinion, in theory, an unrestrained free market is my default favorite type of market by a huge margin, but that's only in relation to other types of classically defined markets. In the real world, some sort of regulation ends up being necessary to keep the system from collapsing upon itself, as we are seeing these days in College Sports.
Adam Smith never advocated a no-restraints free-for-all. He was very interested in mercantile law. Smith just observed that economic systems are already, to an important extent, self-regulating.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 08:36 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
Look, the issues have not changed.
1. All athletes, whether of revenue or non-revenue sports are entitled to compensation for their work on behalf of the school.
2. All athletes, whether of revenue or non-revenue sports are entitled to endorsement revenue resulting from their name, image, or likeness.
3. The reporting Supreme Court judge, Justice Cavanaugh encouraged collective bargaining which requires player's unions.
4. Contracts are the natural restraint on what we call the transfer portal as in order to transfer the athlete must first fulfill their contract, or the party interested in them must buyout their contract before they can move. All of us could change employment if we desired to do so, therefore why can't athletes?
5. Every one of these rulings and rights were circumvented by an archaic NCAA which functioned to ensure the indentured servitude of athletes to a grant and aid which too frequently did not produce an education for them, and frequently cost many of them injuries related to the wear and tear on their body from sports.
6. There is no longer a need for the NCAA as their organizing principal of strict Victorian Era amateurism is dead. They cling to sprawling tournaments for basketball, baseball and softball among others because they maintain the right to profit from them.
7. SCOTUS has ruled that revenue athletics at major universities are businesses or part of the business of the athletic department of the school. Therefore contract law is all that need govern them.
8. The SCORE ACT and other such nonsense is simply an end around attempt at bypassing some of the impact of the SCOTUS ruling. In other words it is major state and private institutions trying to hold on to some of what they gleaned from the free work of others. Now I'm rather conservative on many fiscal matters and it is egregious that an industry that makes millions, sometimes hundreds of millions a year can't pay its athletes, and it is sickening that the institutions that profited from the free labor of others should call themselves enlightened and fight to keep their own student athletes indentured for an education most never finish.
9. The purpose for the NCAA's continuation has ceased to exist at all levels of collegiate athletics beyond the Division level play. FCS & FBS are subject to employment and possibly taxes. And frankly that's as it should be because in almost every state the taxpayers have been subsidizing 25% of the cost of athletics at many schools, or higher, some going up to almost a 75% subsidy. The P conferences should have 0% subsidized. The rest of FBS should be able to offer the number of sports they can afford. Why? Because that's how business works at almost every level in our society. The stated objective of a university is to educate. Athletics at the intramural level were offered to enhance the body as well as the mind. We long ago surpassed the intramural level of sports and did so for a buck and for prestige and yet refuse to call it what it is, profit from a business.
10. It needs to now be treated as what it is and governed by existing law for what it is....a damned business, and big damned business at that! All other nattering about this topic usually ends in hypocrisy!
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026 10:21 AM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:15 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 06:06 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-03-2026 01:38 AM)IWantToTalkToRalphSampson Wrote: Wouldn’t this accelerate a breakaway B1G-SEC led Super League outside the NCAA? Forcing either league to subsidize other conferences through legislation seems like a taking of their property, the media rights granted to them by their members, without compensation.
Well, the legislation as-is very specifically states that there cannot be any merger, consolidation, or joining of media rights of any conference that makes more than $1 billion in revenue as of the effective date of the Act. The only 2 leagues that fit that criteria are the Big Ten and SEC. In theory, either the SEC or Big Ten could breakaway individually, but they can’t join together in a Super League.
Sure there could. Disband the conferences, everyone goes independent for one year, then everyone leaves the NCAA along with anyone else we like. That's but one of numerous loopholes in this bill. Without an authority figure to call balls and strikes, it will still be anything goes, we'll just have to bob and weave in different directions.
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026 10:50 AM by bryanw1995.)
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:49 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 06:34 AM)TerryD Wrote: (06-02-2026 05:33 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (06-02-2026 11:07 AM)TerryD Wrote: (06-02-2026 10:33 AM)domer1978 Wrote: (06-01-2026 03:51 PM)Hokie Mark Wrote: You do realize if all but 12 teams go bankrupt, Notre Dame WILL be forced to join the ensuing conference?
I do, but my free market principles have to be consistent.
12 independents, scheduling each other. All with individual TV deals.
I could live with that.
Could we all make "independence" our core identity, even though we played the same 11 other schools every season in a very conference-like arrangement? That would be fun!
None of the trappings or baggage of a conference.
No championship. No conference games or standings. No commissioner. No all-conference teams.
It would be glorious. Yes, you could make independence a core part of your identity.
Many schools did so for 100-150 years.
I'll start thinking about Independence when PSU leaves the B1G to go back to it.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:51 AM |
|
domer1978
All American

Posts: 3,752
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 441
I Root For: Notre Dame/Chaos
Location: Arizona/Georgia
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
Watching this hearing it is just dump on the Big 10 conference with an occasional jab at the SEC....
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:51 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:09 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (06-02-2026 05:55 PM)domer1978 Wrote: ![[Image: HJ1xUZfWIAAJK4a?format=jpg&name=large]](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HJ1xUZfWIAAJK4a?format=jpg&name=large)
Well, it’s always easier to oppose rather than to create. There’s no need for the NFL to worry about the third weekend in December’s Saturday media rights when the Petulant2 haven’t yet coalesced on their future vision.
The statement does at least suggest that they’d like to negotiate. It’s now been five years since the Supreme Court defanged the NCAA rule-making authority. It be nice if Sankey or Pettiti were willing to share their visions for common rules.
A large point of any breakaway would be that it would then be possible make some rules, but neither Sankey nor Petitti would be making them. The Presidents would make the rules, then the Commissioners would enforce them. It doesn't matter what the Commissioners want, it took Sankey 18 months to get the SEC to add an extra game, and Petitti can't even get his schools to accept a $100m++ check.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:55 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 10:51 AM)domer1978 Wrote: Watching this hearing it is just dump on the Big 10 conference with an occasional jab at the SEC....
I bet you're loving that...
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:56 AM |
|
domer1978
All American

Posts: 3,752
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 441
I Root For: Notre Dame/Chaos
Location: Arizona/Georgia
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 10:56 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (06-03-2026 10:51 AM)domer1978 Wrote: Watching this hearing it is just dump on the Big 10 conference with an occasional jab at the SEC....
I bet you're loving that...

Yes and no, I respect good arguments. Many of them are baaaaddddd, so that is frustrating.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 10:59 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:21 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:05 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: I have an idea: media bundling without conference restrictions. 
But we all know the barnacles in the B1G and SEC won't go for it because they'd take a deserved pay cut.
Wait, maybe we're going the wrong way... no media bundling for anyone!
![[Image: Snidely-Whiplash.jpg]](https://www.toonarific.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Snidely-Whiplash.jpg)
Does anyone alive and under 65 or 70 even know who Snidely Whiplash was other than Sweet Nell and Dudley Do-Right?
(This post was last modified: 06-03-2026 11:02 AM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:00 AM |
|
FULL_MONTY
1st String

Posts: 1,058
Joined: Jun 2005
Reputation: 134
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
I find it amusing that people think the free market should reign and that what we see today is the result of a free market. 90% of the Universities are "Public" universities. They weird the power of the State and in combination of other State agencies use that to favor some Institutions in their remit.
Louisiana is going to pass a law to shield the payments made to athletes. Some States have proposed laws to not tax the athletes incomes. Some Universities have sued local boards to shutter competitor programs. Some boards have been forced to allocate dollars from one University to another. And I am just scratching at the surface of this "free market" activity.
I think everyone needs to actually dig deep into what is a free market.
But yes, we are in a feee market. Absolutely hilarious.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:21 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 11:00 AM)JRsec Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:21 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:05 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: I have an idea: media bundling without conference restrictions. 
But we all know the barnacles in the B1G and SEC won't go for it because they'd take a deserved pay cut.
Wait, maybe we're going the wrong way... no media bundling for anyone!
![[Image: Snidely-Whiplash.jpg]](https://www.toonarific.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Snidely-Whiplash.jpg)
Does anyone alive and under 65 or 70 even know who Snidely Whiplash was other than Sweet Nell and Dudley Do-Right?
I do and I'm in my 40's. Thank my parents!
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:28 AM |
|
cubucks
Heisman

Posts: 5,595
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 641
I Root For: tOSU/UNL/Ohio
Location: Athens, Ohio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
Saban is probably the greatest to ever coach college football. With that said, shut the hell up you damn hypocrite. He sounds no different than a Hollywood celebrity complaining about the rich, all while hiding in their gated mansion.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:38 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:49 AM |
|
cubucks
Heisman

Posts: 5,595
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 641
I Root For: tOSU/UNL/Ohio
Location: Athens, Ohio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 11:38 AM)cubucks Wrote: Saban is probably the greatest to ever coach college football. With that said, shut the hell up you damn hypocrite. He sounds no different than a Hollywood celebrity complaining about the rich, all while hiding in their gated mansion.
Or maybe stop paying coaches stupid amounts of money and use it to fund Olympic sports. Why doesn't Saban ever suggest that?
|
|
| 06-03-2026 11:54 AM |
|
Wahoowa84
Heisman

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-03-2026 07:23 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:09 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: Well, it’s always easier to oppose rather than to create. There’s no need for the NFL to worry about the third weekend in December’s Saturday media rights when the Petulant2 haven’t yet coalesced on their future vision.
I started to gravitate towards Predatory 2, but yours has a better ring to it
LOL. Either one works. Now, they’re tone deaf to the political reality of receiving an antitrust exemption…as if Federal legislators owe them this favor for being so successful in achieving whatever they deem best.
The B1G has transformed its “Alliance” to a new Skull & Bones (an elitist, ultra-secretive collegiate sports group) partnership with the SEC - the Petulant 2 Society…”P2S” to their cognoscenti.
Their leaders don’t need to explain themselves, nor seek compromise, nor provide a vision. If their members go rogue, that’s fine. They profess to want rules and standards, but only those that somehow restrict the less entitled. Five years after Alston, they’ve concluded that ever increasing chaos is better than resolving problems. Until some B1G and SEC athletic departments face significant difficulties, Sankey & Pettiti will revel in their P2S.
|
|
| 06-03-2026 12:36 PM |
|