bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,954
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(06-02-2026 11:38 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-02-2026 09:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (06-01-2026 10:22 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-01-2026 09:19 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-01-2026 03:33 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Newsflash: no crap, Sherlock as to the actual law in place which I’ve probably read and studied more times than anyone else on this forum, but Congress just changing a law that directly applies to the NFL that has been in place for the last 65 years without the NFL’s input is, at a minimum, going to have the NFL’s owners (who all have direct ties across the political spectrum) and lobbyists in full press mode. It would be one thing if the change to that law was merely about the college conferences being able to aggregate their sports rights, but another thing to include more restrictions on the NFL. Not to mention that the NFL is far, far, FAR more powerful than it was in 1961 when the law was first instituted.
NFL owners vs the amount of lobbyists, politicians, and filthy rich alumni of hundreds of universities? Somebody check under the bed for the boogie man!
I think you’re *seriously* and insanely misjudging the power balance here. The NFL owners are 32 of the richest people in the world (all of whom by definition are multi-billionaires just with the value of their teams and most made a lot more money elsewhere where football is a side hobby). We’re talking real concentrated GLOBAL power - two different teams with heirs to the Walmart fortune, another team with an heir to the Microsoft fortune, another heir to the Johnson & Johnson fortune, the founder of Home Depot, heirs to the Ford dynasty, etc.
More importantly, despite this group constituting the greatest concentration of wealth of any entity in the history of the world (and that’s not hyperbole), they are all incredibly disciplined and in lock step on NFL governance and financial matters. When Roger Goodell speaks, he has the backing of all of those 32 multi-billionaires. They might bicker about suspensions or on-the-field rule changes, but they have incredible and frankly scary total alignment when it comes to money and media rights matters.
That is the inherent problem with college sports. Absolutely no one is in lock step with each other. The two most valuable college sports conferences likely don’t even support this bill (at least the parts that are clearly targeted at restricting them or reducing their power). As a result, college sports will have countless different lobbyists saying countless different things with countless different objectives and angles.
Contrast this with the NFL where 32 of the world’s richest people are going to speak in a unified voice. That doesn’t even get into the super close direct ties that Robert Kraft, Jerry Jones and Woody Johnson (who was even named US Ambassador to the United Kingdom in 2017-2021 which is historically the post given to the most important donor to the President) have with the current administration.
Getting anyone in college sports to agree on anything is like herding cats, whereas the NFL owners are a coordinated and totally aligned pack of wolves.
Anywhere Elon Musk goes is a "greater concentration of wealth" than all the NFL owners, times 2. According to a BetMGM article from 6 days ago, NFL owners have a total combined wealth between all of them of about $400b. Warren Buffet's old bridge club probably had more wealth every time he and Bill Gates sat down at the table. You constantly and vocally overestimate the strength of the NFL. The current US President has a huge axe to grind with the NFL, and I think we can agree that he has a lot more actual power than the combined might of the 32 NFL owners.
https://sports.betmgm.ca/en/blog/nfl/ran...ners-bm17/
https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/
Lots of those billionaires are close to the total combined wealth of the entire NFL. Additionally, most of the power and wealth of most owners is concentrated in their teams. In fact, in all but the top 4 cases, at least 2/3 of their wealth is really just based upon the theoretical value of their NFL team.
My old boss is a self-made billionaire who races cars for fun. I used to make fun of him about it, but he'd always say that it was mostly just on paper, and he was right. He had almost every penny tied up in car dealerships and race cars/teams, though he has branched out more in recent years. I still remember him bitching at AT&T about an $800 phone bill one month, he had the CFO jacking with it for weeks to get it sorted out. In retrospect, that seems like a huge waste of time, but he didn't want to take any of his money out of productive use to "waste" it on an AT&T mistake. These NFL owners are no doubt much the same, ESPECIALLY the self made ones. They largely support the NFL and its overarching mission, but they're not anxious to spend any of their personal wealth on an "overall NFL public good" type of project unless they get something tangible in return. The NFL would need to hire a lobbying firm, and bill every team, say, a million a year, 5m a year, 25m a year, whatever, if they wanted to get serious about pushing Congress or the Oval office on an issue. Contrast that with people like Phil Knight or Cody Campbell, who want nothing from the millions, probably billions in PK's case, that they've invested into State U. Well, nothing except more Ws ofc. Heck, Cody Campbell probably has more influence on the overarching sports landscape than every NFL owner combined right now.
I truly didn’t want to turn this into a debate about the NFL, but it’s just that all of this positioning and misalignment about who has the most power and influence is so wrong.
You can look up the lobbying expenditures of entities at Open Secrets. The NFL has highly coordinated lobbying efforts to the point that Open Secrets themselves specifically noted it:
https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2025/10...overnment/
The Open Secrets records show that the NFL has historically outspent the NCAA by twice as much or more on lobbying efforts year-over-year even in recent years when the NCAA has been directly trying to get all of these various college sports bills passed. This doesn’t include each of the owner’s personal non-NFL-specific lobbying efforts for their respective businesses and industries or contributions to political candidates. (And once again, whatever supposed axe there is to grind in the White House, the fact remains that the single biggest “reward” that the White House can provide to a donor - the position of US Ambassador to the United Kingdom - directly went to one of the wealthiest and most powerful NFL owners in the first term.) Sure, individual conferences may also have their own lobbying efforts, but they aren’t coordinated or on the same page at all. That is my whole point.
And look, I just said above that this Act could very well get passed. Upon reading the text of the Act, it seems more “bark” than “bite” with respect to the provisions that superficially seem to target the Big Ten and SEC. This has much more of a chance of passing compared to the continued morass occurring in the House.
However, just take a step back for two seconds: it’s not exactly controversial that the NFL is coordinated with a clear top-down structure (even with all of the billionaires involved) in a way that college sports has *never* been. That’s why college conferences want these bills in the first place in concept but then have had such an hard time agreeing on what those bills should actually say.
The NFL has 32 teams and everyone is trying to make money. FBS has 137 teams (or so, I keep losing count), and 90% of them don't make money but are funded through some combination of altruistic billionaires and student fees. Additionally, the #32 (least valuable) NFL team, the Bengals, have ~ 46% of the revenues of the Cowboys and 40% of the franchise value of the Cowboys.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes_lis..._NFL_teams
Using a comparison the 32nd ranked school by revenue in FBS from this thread:
https://csnbbs.com/thread-1028397.html
the #32 school in revenues, UCLA, is almost exactly 50% of the revenues of #1 Texas, not all that different from the 46% and 40% of the Bengals when compared to the Cowboys.
If we were talking about the wishes of the 32 wealthiest FBS schools, I think that it wouldn't be all that hard to get everybody on the same page, but there are another 105 (or so) schools with far less than UCLA's $173m in revenues, going all the way down to Louisiana-Monroe at $20m, with many others in the 30m-50m range. That's like the NFL being forced by the NCAA or some other entity to subsidize their version of AAA, AA, and A all at the same time, but they also play some games that actually count against some of these AA clubs, and the AA clubs keep lobbying their politicians and clamoring online for a greater say in everything from the composition to the structure of the CFP and NCAAT.
Your point about the NFL is valid, but all of their lobbying means little in comparison to direct access to the President, which Cody Campbell has, and the President has a huge impact on Congress when his party controls the Executive, House, Senate and has a 6-3 majority on the Supreme Court. In a couple years, sure, that worm will turn and whoever is in the White House won't have a personal axe to grind with the NFL, so all they need to do is weather the next couple years relatively unscathed. I was unaware that they were planning to bid out 3rd weekend Saturday games in December in their next contract, and I agree that they'll fight that one tooth and nail, but I also think that $200m a year isn't all that much money to any one club, and they'll probably be pretty happy in 2028 if that's all they lose from govt intervention between now and then.
(This post was last modified: 06-02-2026 05:56 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|