Wahoowa84
Heisman

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
|
RE: Protect College Sports Act
(05-31-2026 11:20 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (05-30-2026 04:47 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (05-30-2026 03:29 PM)CliftonAve Wrote: (05-30-2026 02:15 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (05-30-2026 11:46 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: However, an outright prohibition on Big Ten and SEC expansion seems to be a total specific targeting that I can’t believe would pass. I don’t see how senators from states with schools in those leagues would reasonably vote for it, although who knows since this is Cruz’s baby (and he’s obviously from a heavy SEC state).
Its not just Cruz, Cantwell is is also from a P2 state, and one that doesn't even have M2 representation to boot. I think you just need to accept that gutting the ACC and making the Big XII largely irrelevant just isn't popular outside of hyper partisan conference warriors.
Even though he has Texas and Texas A&M in his backyard, everything I have heard from Cruz indicates he doesn’t want to see the elites break off and/or for the second class schools to be weakened. In fact he has specifically mentioned he does not want to see Baylor, TCU, Texas Texas Tech, Houston, SMU/Rice to lose anything in this deal.
Congress is not going to pass legislation that further benefits an elite few universities. No matter how upset passionate sports fans get, providing antitrust exemptions will come with significant strings.
The P2 have zero credibility with Federal legislators on this matter (they will receive no sympathy because they are admitted predators in the industry). The SEC crazies that suggest a breakaway are only hurting themselves and the industry by publicly promoting their elitist vision. Contrary to SEC and B1G fans' wishes, the role of Congress is not to enable monopolies or oligarchies.
The A4 has a low level of support (because they took the risk of supporting the House Settlement), but there is general distrust that "power" universities truly need legislative support. The NCAA has some empathy (the organization strives for inclusivity) and represents over 1,000 universities. It's doubtful that Congress can actually help the G6 or most members of the NCAA, but any legislation that passes will attempt to do just that.
Who are you calling "predators"? The ACC nabbed 6 schools from the Big East (Miami, VT, BC, Pitt, Syracuse and Louisville) over a 10 year period ending in 2014. Since then, the SEC has added 2 schools, and we added 2 during the ACC's rampage across the BE. Additionally, the ACC raided 2 from Pac 12, leaving WSU and OSU to twist in the wind, and another one from the (former) BE in 2024. Thus:
ACC: added 9 schools, 7 of them from the BE, between 2004 and 2024
SEC: added 4 schools from the Big 12 since 2004
B1G: added 7 total schools from various conferences since 2010
The ACC has raided almost as many schools from other conferences as the SEC and B1G combined in the 21st century, yet you call US predators? Look in the mirror, it's going on everywhere. Not to mention that you pretend that it's the conference rather than the school that started realignment conversations in the first place. Hint: it's ALWAYS the school. Texas pursued the Pac 8/10/12 for decades until finally deciding to give it up, A&M pursued the SEC for 20+ years before we could get our State Govt on board, VT wanted to be with UVA for how long, etc etc etc. In every single case, the school's leadership felt that their own interests were better served in a different conference. How is that the SEC's or B1G's fault? Or even the ACC's fault? You guys were merely accepting applications after all, right? The only difference is that, today, the ACC isn't getting all the applications any more, and you don't like that very much.
The last round of expansion had different types of power conference expansion:
1) Aggressive & predatory,
a) Texas & Oklahoma - puts B12 in survival mode while elevating SEC above the P5 norm
b) USC & UCLA - puts PAC in survival mode while elevating B1G to SEC level
2) Defensive - kill shots to reduce/eliminate threats
a) Colorado, Arizona, ASU & Utah - PAC no longer a competitor to B12
b) Oregon & Washington - eliminates chance that ACC benefits from chaos
3) Defensive for survival/stability
a) BYU, UCF, Cincinnati & Houston
b) Cal, Stanford & SMU
IMO, the politicians are bright enough to understand the dynamics in collegiate athletics. It’s not an accident that a Republican senator from an SEC state and a Democrat senator from a B1G state have bipartisan concern about what the SEC and B1G will do with an antitrust exemption.
Somewhat surprised that you’re arguing this point…the majority of threads on this board assume that the B1G and SEC will soon/inevitably expand with the best brands not yet in their control.
(This post was last modified: 05-31-2026 10:15 PM by Wahoowa84.)
|
|