Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,073
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-04-2026 12:43 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:56 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:16 AM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-03-2026 09:19 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:54 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: “nobody cares about FCS success and that’s a fact”.
That’s your moronic stance, Doc. Trying to change the subject doesn’t make you right or look so great either. It makes you look small and hypocritical. As you said, you’re nuts.
Try another thread.
It appears we are arguing from different perspectives: you as a fan, and me from an administrative standpoint.
The facts are W&M, UR, and even VMI tried and failed to remain 1-A. There are others like Tennessee State and even the Ivies made a stink about being demoted. Obviously as the Ivies de-emphasized they reduced stadium capacity, so there is a direct correlation there, but that’s a different argument.
Sure, if your argument is you’d rather play on the Korn Ferry tour because you have a better chance to win, who am I to say you’re wrong. I am merely pointing out to you that people making the decisions do not care about the Korn Ferry tour, they care about the PGA tour, and that’s why we see the numbers moving up and not down.
If it were up to me Carolina would be in an eight or nine team ACC playing the likes of UR, W&M, and Navy OOC…
You’re making a 50 year old argument from the late 70s which has long been settled. I’m not disputing anything you claim from that period. That ship long sailed.
That has nothing to do with your statement now 50 years later that nobody cares about FCS success. That’s not the case and certainly not true for W&M. No one has been arguing for FBS at W&M for decades. That’s largely because W&M has built an excellent program at the FCS level. We draw bigger crowds today than we did playing FBS teams in the 70s. The fanbase cares about success at the level we’re playing.
The Korn Ferry tour, whatever that is, would better describe the lower level conferences of FBS today, at least from a W&M perspective. This narrative that somehow playing Georgia State or Middle Tennessee is somehow more attractive than playing Villanova or Lehigh would be laughable to W&M fans.
And it’s not just W&M. How does the statement that no one cares link with the fact 35,000 attended last years championship game. It doesn’t.
W&M is a very old school and when they had the opportunity to remain at the top level, they tried, exhausted all options and they failed. Faculty rallied the NIMBYs and it was all over. As you know, there were other efforts before then to go "big time." The point is once they blew that chance, it wasn't happening.
Anyway, this topic is about people attempting to convince UMass and Temple to withdraw to FCS or drop their programs. Not only is it insulting to the fans here, it's going against the reality that nobody making that decision cares about FCS—and PLENTY of evidence has been presented to support that.
The FCS fans here come across as petty attempting to convince everyone else their product is better for others.
• • •
This is my actual quote you have taken out of context: Nobody cares about FCS success, and that's a fact. The most successful FCS program of all-time couldn't wait to spend a ton of money to move up. Donations go up when you play at the top level.
UMass, App State, NDSU, JMU, Delaware, etc. all former champs, and none of them were satisfied with FCS accolades. Nobody there made decisions based on FCS success.
• • •
The Korn Ferry tour is absolutely FCS, while the G6 is still in the PGA. If you're on the PGA tour, you can win a freaking PGA. You can't do that on the KF tour. You also make A LOT more money regardless of whether or not who have a large fan following. It's an excellent comparison.
No one has taken your bolder comment out of context. The issue is you made a ridiculous assertion and can’t back it up. It’s very straight forward. It’s just wrong, insulting in your words to all the members who play at FCS level, and unsurprisingly, backed with opinions and no facts.
It’s fine if schools who want to move into G6 from FCS but it’s not for everybody. I think the G6 crowd just doesn’t understand why a Montana or Villanova doesn’t want to go there. It’s not the PGA lol. It’s AAA vs AA. Big deal. The upside is debatable. That’s why there is a thread here. Schools have to decide if it’s worth the sacrifice to compete at that level.
Nobody cares about FCS when contemplating a move to FBS. I figured we all could understood the context of the statement.
Of course people care about success within the FCS framework. Like maybe the coaches and the players to start with.
What's ridiculous is you creating an argument out of something that isn't there.
|
|
| 06-04-2026 12:55 PM |
|
Sitting bull
All American

Posts: 4,513
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 144
I Root For: W&M
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-04-2026 12:55 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 12:43 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:56 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:16 AM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-03-2026 09:19 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: It appears we are arguing from different perspectives: you as a fan, and me from an administrative standpoint.
The facts are W&M, UR, and even VMI tried and failed to remain 1-A. There are others like Tennessee State and even the Ivies made a stink about being demoted. Obviously as the Ivies de-emphasized they reduced stadium capacity, so there is a direct correlation there, but that’s a different argument.
Sure, if your argument is you’d rather play on the Korn Ferry tour because you have a better chance to win, who am I to say you’re wrong. I am merely pointing out to you that people making the decisions do not care about the Korn Ferry tour, they care about the PGA tour, and that’s why we see the numbers moving up and not down.
If it were up to me Carolina would be in an eight or nine team ACC playing the likes of UR, W&M, and Navy OOC…
You’re making a 50 year old argument from the late 70s which has long been settled. I’m not disputing anything you claim from that period. That ship long sailed.
That has nothing to do with your statement now 50 years later that nobody cares about FCS success. That’s not the case and certainly not true for W&M. No one has been arguing for FBS at W&M for decades. That’s largely because W&M has built an excellent program at the FCS level. We draw bigger crowds today than we did playing FBS teams in the 70s. The fanbase cares about success at the level we’re playing.
The Korn Ferry tour, whatever that is, would better describe the lower level conferences of FBS today, at least from a W&M perspective. This narrative that somehow playing Georgia State or Middle Tennessee is somehow more attractive than playing Villanova or Lehigh would be laughable to W&M fans.
And it’s not just W&M. How does the statement that no one cares link with the fact 35,000 attended last years championship game. It doesn’t.
W&M is a very old school and when they had the opportunity to remain at the top level, they tried, exhausted all options and they failed. Faculty rallied the NIMBYs and it was all over. As you know, there were other efforts before then to go "big time." The point is once they blew that chance, it wasn't happening.
Anyway, this topic is about people attempting to convince UMass and Temple to withdraw to FCS or drop their programs. Not only is it insulting to the fans here, it's going against the reality that nobody making that decision cares about FCS—and PLENTY of evidence has been presented to support that.
The FCS fans here come across as petty attempting to convince everyone else their product is better for others.
• • •
This is my actual quote you have taken out of context: Nobody cares about FCS success, and that's a fact. The most successful FCS program of all-time couldn't wait to spend a ton of money to move up. Donations go up when you play at the top level.
UMass, App State, NDSU, JMU, Delaware, etc. all former champs, and none of them were satisfied with FCS accolades. Nobody there made decisions based on FCS success.
• • •
The Korn Ferry tour is absolutely FCS, while the G6 is still in the PGA. If you're on the PGA tour, you can win a freaking PGA. You can't do that on the KF tour. You also make A LOT more money regardless of whether or not who have a large fan following. It's an excellent comparison.
No one has taken your bolder comment out of context. The issue is you made a ridiculous assertion and can’t back it up. It’s very straight forward. It’s just wrong, insulting in your words to all the members who play at FCS level, and unsurprisingly, backed with opinions and no facts.
It’s fine if schools who want to move into G6 from FCS but it’s not for everybody. I think the G6 crowd just doesn’t understand why a Montana or Villanova doesn’t want to go there. It’s not the PGA lol. It’s AAA vs AA. Big deal. The upside is debatable. That’s why there is a thread here. Schools have to decide if it’s worth the sacrifice to compete at that level.
Nobody cares about FCS when contemplating a move to FBS. I figured we all could understood the context of the statement.
Of course people care about success within the FCS framework. Like maybe the coaches and the players to start with.
What's ridiculous is you creating an argument out of something that isn't there.
What’s ridiculous is you make a moronic statement and then change the context and create unrelated arguments so you don’t look so stupid.
|
|
| 06-04-2026 01:06 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,073
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-04-2026 01:06 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 12:55 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 12:43 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:56 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:16 AM)Sitting bull Wrote: You’re making a 50 year old argument from the late 70s which has long been settled. I’m not disputing anything you claim from that period. That ship long sailed.
That has nothing to do with your statement now 50 years later that nobody cares about FCS success. That’s not the case and certainly not true for W&M. No one has been arguing for FBS at W&M for decades. That’s largely because W&M has built an excellent program at the FCS level. We draw bigger crowds today than we did playing FBS teams in the 70s. The fanbase cares about success at the level we’re playing.
The Korn Ferry tour, whatever that is, would better describe the lower level conferences of FBS today, at least from a W&M perspective. This narrative that somehow playing Georgia State or Middle Tennessee is somehow more attractive than playing Villanova or Lehigh would be laughable to W&M fans.
And it’s not just W&M. How does the statement that no one cares link with the fact 35,000 attended last years championship game. It doesn’t.
W&M is a very old school and when they had the opportunity to remain at the top level, they tried, exhausted all options and they failed. Faculty rallied the NIMBYs and it was all over. As you know, there were other efforts before then to go "big time." The point is once they blew that chance, it wasn't happening.
Anyway, this topic is about people attempting to convince UMass and Temple to withdraw to FCS or drop their programs. Not only is it insulting to the fans here, it's going against the reality that nobody making that decision cares about FCS—and PLENTY of evidence has been presented to support that.
The FCS fans here come across as petty attempting to convince everyone else their product is better for others.
• • •
This is my actual quote you have taken out of context: Nobody cares about FCS success, and that's a fact. The most successful FCS program of all-time couldn't wait to spend a ton of money to move up. Donations go up when you play at the top level.
UMass, App State, NDSU, JMU, Delaware, etc. all former champs, and none of them were satisfied with FCS accolades. Nobody there made decisions based on FCS success.
• • •
The Korn Ferry tour is absolutely FCS, while the G6 is still in the PGA. If you're on the PGA tour, you can win a freaking PGA. You can't do that on the KF tour. You also make A LOT more money regardless of whether or not who have a large fan following. It's an excellent comparison.
No one has taken your bolder comment out of context. The issue is you made a ridiculous assertion and can’t back it up. It’s very straight forward. It’s just wrong, insulting in your words to all the members who play at FCS level, and unsurprisingly, backed with opinions and no facts.
It’s fine if schools who want to move into G6 from FCS but it’s not for everybody. I think the G6 crowd just doesn’t understand why a Montana or Villanova doesn’t want to go there. It’s not the PGA lol. It’s AAA vs AA. Big deal. The upside is debatable. That’s why there is a thread here. Schools have to decide if it’s worth the sacrifice to compete at that level.
Nobody cares about FCS when contemplating a move to FBS. I figured we all could understood the context of the statement.
Of course people care about success within the FCS framework. Like maybe the coaches and the players to start with.
What's ridiculous is you creating an argument out of something that isn't there.
What’s ridiculous is you make a moronic statement and then change the context and create unrelated arguments so you don’t look so stupid.
You manipulated the quote out of context. Why else would you do that? When you leave out the statement I'm responding to, you can make up any context you want, and in your case you made it an extreme blanket statement.
Another poster (not you) and I were specifically talking about schools moving between FCS/FBS. Idaho did NOT move down to FCS to "be successful." They were kicked out of the Sun Belt and faced the uncertainty of being an Independent. Anything else is BS.
I am not owning up to the argument you're having in your head. Sorry, bub.
(This post was last modified: 06-04-2026 04:05 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
|
|
| 06-04-2026 04:04 PM |
|
Sitting bull
All American

Posts: 4,513
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 144
I Root For: W&M
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-04-2026 04:04 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 01:06 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 12:55 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-04-2026 12:43 PM)Sitting bull Wrote: (06-04-2026 11:56 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: W&M is a very old school and when they had the opportunity to remain at the top level, they tried, exhausted all options and they failed. Faculty rallied the NIMBYs and it was all over. As you know, there were other efforts before then to go "big time." The point is once they blew that chance, it wasn't happening.
Anyway, this topic is about people attempting to convince UMass and Temple to withdraw to FCS or drop their programs. Not only is it insulting to the fans here, it's going against the reality that nobody making that decision cares about FCS—and PLENTY of evidence has been presented to support that.
The FCS fans here come across as petty attempting to convince everyone else their product is better for others.
• • •
This is my actual quote you have taken out of context: Nobody cares about FCS success, and that's a fact. The most successful FCS program of all-time couldn't wait to spend a ton of money to move up. Donations go up when you play at the top level.
UMass, App State, NDSU, JMU, Delaware, etc. all former champs, and none of them were satisfied with FCS accolades. Nobody there made decisions based on FCS success.
• • •
The Korn Ferry tour is absolutely FCS, while the G6 is still in the PGA. If you're on the PGA tour, you can win a freaking PGA. You can't do that on the KF tour. You also make A LOT more money regardless of whether or not who have a large fan following. It's an excellent comparison.
No one has taken your bolder comment out of context. The issue is you made a ridiculous assertion and can’t back it up. It’s very straight forward. It’s just wrong, insulting in your words to all the members who play at FCS level, and unsurprisingly, backed with opinions and no facts.
It’s fine if schools who want to move into G6 from FCS but it’s not for everybody. I think the G6 crowd just doesn’t understand why a Montana or Villanova doesn’t want to go there. It’s not the PGA lol. It’s AAA vs AA. Big deal. The upside is debatable. That’s why there is a thread here. Schools have to decide if it’s worth the sacrifice to compete at that level.
Nobody cares about FCS when contemplating a move to FBS. I figured we all could understood the context of the statement.
Of course people care about success within the FCS framework. Like maybe the coaches and the players to start with.
What's ridiculous is you creating an argument out of something that isn't there.
What’s ridiculous is you make a moronic statement and then change the context and create unrelated arguments so you don’t look so stupid.
You manipulated the quote out of context. Why else would you do that? When you leave out the statement I'm responding to, you can make up any context you want, and in your case you made it an extreme blanket statement.
Another poster (not you) and I were specifically talking about schools moving between FCS/FBS. Idaho did NOT move down to FCS to "be successful." They were kicked out of the Sun Belt and faced the uncertainty of being an Independent. Anything else is BS.
I am not owning up to the argument you're having in your head. Sorry, bub.
There is no argument. You were caught with your foot in your mouth, tried to wriggle out like a snake and resort to making up new arguments. Sorry, thats what losers do. Bub. Make a stupid statement, take responsibility instead of running away from it like a frightened little girl.
|
|
| 06-04-2026 06:44 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,073
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-03-2026 11:34 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 08:06 AM)ccd494 Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:59 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:56 AM)ZooMass84 Wrote: (06-03-2026 07:27 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: People - no one is dropping down from FBS to FCS.
The word “downgrade” is an absolute *killer* in academia right now.
Just look at the thread about the American Conference revenue. By definition, Temple is receiving top 5 conference revenue among the G6 schools.
This thread makes no sense, particularly with how we see how much schools like North Dakota State and Sacramento State are paying just for football-only FBS memberships. This whole thread completely neglects how valuable it is right now to have *any* slot in FBS (and in the case of Temple, it’s actually the most valuable spot in the G6). It’s all nonsensical and, once again, just an opportunity for people to rip on Temple or UMass or, in a lot of cases, think that their school that is much lower in importance in academia can feel like they’re somehow superior to Temple or UMass.
no one is dropping down from FBS to FCS. except for Idaho
Which was a mistake because they'd be in the Mountain West right now.
....And going 2-10. They'd also be at the absolute bottom of the league in every other sport. Instead they've spent most of the last five years in the FCS top ten and made the quarterfinals twice. They made the basketball tournament this year for the first time in 46 years. They also made the women's tournament.
Idaho is at the proper level. Who cares how much more revenue the athletic department would bring in, they'd have to spend it all anyways, and they wouldn't be gaining ground against the larger resourced schools in the Mountain West.
You don't know that.
Nobody cares about FCS success, and that's a fact. The most successful FCS program of all-time couldn't wait to spend a ton of money to move up. Donations go up when you play at the top level.
...and how exactly did you get that from this chain of comments? The argument I quoted was Idaho is more successful at FCS therefore their situation is objectively better and "Who cares how much more revenue the athletic department would bring in?"
Who cares? The people moving up FCS programs every other year. Potential success at the FCS did not come into play when they moved down. Being kicked out of the Sun Belt did. If that mattered to ANYONE, then we would see schools moving down. They don't.
You put the BULL in Sitting Bull.
Now move along, junior. You've taken more L's today than New Yorkers.
|
|
| 06-04-2026 07:50 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
I did a list of the Carnegie I research universities back in 2019 by conference. There are more now, but at that point in time there were 131. 63 were power teams, 20 were G schools. Only 31 were other Division I schools, 6 of which were University of California or University of Texas schools without football and 8 Ivy League and included only 7 public FBS schools. Only 17 were in Division II and III and 8 of those 17 were in the University Athletic Association.
There are just almost no peers to UMass or Temple anywhere but FBS.
|
|
| 06-14-2026 09:53 PM |
|
DFW HOYA
Heisman

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-14-2026 09:53 PM)bullet Wrote: There are just almost no peers to UMass or Temple anywhere but FBS.
UMass' peer institutions, below. Surprisingly, perhaps, only one New England school is in its consideration set.
https://www.umass.edu/uair/sites/default.../peers.pdf
|
|
| 06-14-2026 10:01 PM |
|
TUowl06
1st String

Posts: 1,640
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-14-2026 10:01 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote: (06-14-2026 09:53 PM)bullet Wrote: There are just almost no peers to UMass or Temple anywhere but FBS.
UMass' peer institutions, below. Surprisingly, perhaps, only one New England school is in its consideration set.
https://www.umass.edu/uair/sites/default.../peers.pdf
Similar if not the same metrics were used to establish Temple's peers...
Quote:Temple University
COMPARISON GROUP
Comparison group data are included to provide a context for interpreting your institution’s indicators. If your institution did not define a custom comparison group for this report by July 15, 2023 NCES selected a comparison group for you. (In this case, the characteristics used to define the comparison group appears below.) The customized Data Feedback Report function available at https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/use-the-data/ can be used to reproduce the figures in this report using different peer groups.
The custom comparison group chosen by Temple University includes the following 7 institutions:
Pennsylvania State University-Main Campus (University Park, PA)
University of Arizona (Tucson, AZ)
University of Cincinnati-Main Campus (Cincinnati, OH)
University of Pittsburgh-Pittsburgh Campus (Pittsburgh, PA)
University of South Carolina-Columbia (Columbia, SC)
University of South Florida (Tampa, FL)
University of Utah (Salt Lake City, UT)
https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/dfr/2023/Repor...tId=216339
|
|
| 06-14-2026 11:41 PM |
|
ZooMass84
Special Teams

Posts: 713
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 62
I Root For: UMass, Wisconsin
Location: Casino
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
|
|
| 06-15-2026 05:31 AM |
|
Bill Marsh
All American

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
|
|
| 06-15-2026 03:21 PM |
|
NWBearcat
Water Engineer

Posts: 91
Joined: Feb 2026
Reputation: 2
I Root For: NW Missouri, Creighton
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(05-26-2026 09:22 AM)HartfordHusky Wrote: (05-26-2026 09:08 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: No disrespect to either program but the dream scenario for both of these schools, a northeastern based top level FBS league (Big East fb 1.0 or 2.0) no longer exist, and will never exist. One school is stuck in a Midwestern league while the other is in a league that spans most of the Southeast. To me, the wiser investment would be to shudder those programs, reinvest that money into basketball, and buy their way into the Big East—the basketball conference. Returning to their roots and reviving their identity as a northeastern basketball program worked wonders for UConn and I think it would have a similar effect for the Minutemen and Owls.
Assuming they could buy their way into the Big East, wouldn't it make more sense for them to explore the UConn Independent FBS model first? Or do you think that given the lower overall level of institutional support for them compared to UConn, that is not feasible?
For the record, I don't think either program really has a realistic shot at Big East admittance.
It makes ZERO sense for them to explore that model.
UMass tried to do it and they are where they are.
They will not be able to buy into the Big East. The Big East has enough problems with too many weak programs as it is.
Even with zero payout they wouldn't get in.
|
|
| 06-18-2026 08:59 PM |
|
Bill Marsh
All American

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-18-2026 08:59 PM)NWBearcat Wrote: (05-26-2026 09:22 AM)HartfordHusky Wrote: (05-26-2026 09:08 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: No disrespect to either program but the dream scenario for both of these schools, a northeastern based top level FBS league (Big East fb 1.0 or 2.0) no longer exist, and will never exist. One school is stuck in a Midwestern league while the other is in a league that spans most of the Southeast. To me, the wiser investment would be to shudder those programs, reinvest that money into basketball, and buy their way into the Big East—the basketball conference. Returning to their roots and reviving their identity as a northeastern basketball program worked wonders for UConn and I think it would have a similar effect for the Minutemen and Owls.
Assuming they could buy their way into the Big East, wouldn't it make more sense for them to explore the UConn Independent FBS model first? Or do you think that given the lower overall level of institutional support for them compared to UConn, that is not feasible?
For the record, I don't think either program really has a realistic shot at Big East admittance.
It makes ZERO sense for them to explore that model.
UMass tried to do it and they are where they are.
They will not be able to buy into the Big East. The Big East has enough problems with too many weak programs as it is.
Even with zero payout they wouldn't get in.
Of course it makes no sense for them to explore that model with Big East membership as their goal. The Big East is not adding any public schools. That much is clear. They are not interested in the level of transparenvpcy that would bring. Been there, done that. UConn was the exception for a lot of reasons and they are the only exception. If the Bug East expands, it will be with schools which are similar to the other members they already have.
|
|
| 06-18-2026 11:59 PM |
|
lance99
1st String

Posts: 1,284
Joined: Jun 2013
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Akron Zips
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
Here is the thing with these two Schools in question and I will start with Temple First:
Temple was Kicked off the Big East Football Island because they was so bad. I remember in the 1990's Miami and Virginia Tech fans complaining(Paraphrasing) 'By just having them on the Schedule and not even playing them yet, they dropped OUR SOS!' That was HUGE problem for the Big East..... That is why they got Kicked out!
People have to remember: It got so bad there that the School held a vote to Disband the Program and they were ONE VOTE AWAY from that happening and that is simi-recent History! That is a Major Red Flag!
It is not even about a Stadium for them(Franklin Field is a Option, but see other post about working around Penn for that. There issue is the fact that the Fans: they just don't care. Philadelphia is a Pro Sports City for Football(and don't bring me the the crap about sold out games at the Linc for Temple. They were there to see Notre Dame and Navy, Ect. and not Temple).
UMass on the other hand, is self inflected. When they joined the MAC(The day Temple decided to leave) the first time, it was conditional and they knew that. Go back and look at the threads here when they made the Sweet 16. There was a reason the MAC gave the ultimatum during that run(We can play a very mean Hand of Cards when we need to). They made them do a forced decision with everyone watching, they decided to leave, and it cost them for Years!
Heck, even one of the longest Threads on this Website for years revolved around the UMass question!
I will be honest, I have no idea if they are committed enough in Football to survive in the MAC(Even my own School that I follow can be questioned at this point). The Stadium need to be upgraded. Even by MAC Standards, is pretty bad. IDK if they can get Fan support consistently, even if they are Mediocre at best in some years.
Yes, they do spend a ton of Money on Coaches for our Conference Level. However they have not decided if they want to be a Football School, A Basketball School, Or a Hockey School. I am more than happy if they choose one of these and focus on that. Trying to be all three will DOOM a School like UMass!
I just do not know without having another School in the General Area Like Stony Brook, Albany, New Hampshire, Ect(I consistently said I want nothing to do with UConn). They can survive Long Term in FBS.....
|
|
| 06-20-2026 06:32 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,073
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-20-2026 06:32 PM)lance99 Wrote: Here is the thing with these two Schools in question and I will start with Temple First:
Temple was Kicked off the Big East Football Island because they was so bad. I remember in the 1990's Miami and Virginia Tech fans complaining(Paraphrasing) 'By just having them on the Schedule and not even playing them yet, they dropped OUR SOS!' That was HUGE problem for the Big East..... That is why they got Kicked out!
People have to remember: It got so bad there that the School held a vote to Disband the Program and they were ONE VOTE AWAY from that happening and that is simi-recent History! That is a Major Red Flag!
It is not even about a Stadium for them(Franklin Field is a Option, but see other post about working around Penn for that. There issue is the fact that the Fans: they just don't care. Philadelphia is a Pro Sports City for Football(and don't bring me the the crap about sold out games at the Linc for Temple. They were there to see Notre Dame and Navy, Ect. and not Temple).
UMass on the other hand, is self inflected. When they joined the MAC(The day Temple decided to leave) the first time, it was conditional and they knew that. Go back and look at the threads here when they made the Sweet 16. There was a reason the MAC gave the ultimatum during that run(We can play a very mean Hand of Cards when we need to). They made them do a forced decision with everyone watching, they decided to leave, and it cost them for Years!
Heck, even one of the longest Threads on this Website for years revolved around the UMass question!
I will be honest, I have no idea if they are committed enough in Football to survive in the MAC(Even my own School that I follow can be questioned at this point). The Stadium need to be upgraded. Even by MAC Standards, is pretty bad. IDK if they can get Fan support consistently, even if they are Mediocre at best in some years.
Yes, they do spend a ton of Money on Coaches for our Conference Level. However they have not decided if they want to be a Football School, A Basketball School, Or a Hockey School. I am more than happy if they choose one of these and focus on that. Trying to be all three will DOOM a School like UMass!
I just do not know without having another School in the General Area Like Stony Brook, Albany, New Hampshire, Ect(I consistently said I want nothing to do with UConn). They can survive Long Term in FBS.....
Why did you ignore that period where Temple was routinely going to bowl games and sending coaches to P4/5 programs?
|
|
| 06-20-2026 07:20 PM |
|
TUowl06
1st String

Posts: 1,640
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
Temple's core fan base for both basketball and football is quite small. There are a multitude of factors (of varying degrees) for this; Temple was a commuter school/graduate-centric institution until roughly a generation ago (late 90s, early 00s), football's history of losing/negative perception, Northeast college athletic culture, unique blend of historic rivals in football, basketball was the gravitational pull for athletics but now exists in the shadows among other forces. And a quick follow-up with hoops, much of Temple's greatest success came when the Owls played the vast majority of their home games at the 4,000 seat McGonigle Hall. The Spectrum and Palestra (non-Big 5 games) were used a couple of times a year.
However, what Temple has in their favor is a large alumni base that has proven it will invest when there's a valid reason. Philly will also support Temple Athletics if given a reason so the bandwagon effect is real; similar but not quite to the extent of St. John's. Sure there were Notre Dame and Penn State fans at the Linc and people rooting for Duke or Kansas when their hoops programs played in Philadelphia, but not to the extent the stereotype would lead one to believe. The video doesn't lie.
Temple is simply a quirky institution that has struggled to find its position and place for decades. Subpar leadership at the executive level is a contributing factor. As are deep rooted ideological principles that still usher the decision making. Obviously, these two variables do not exist in a mutually exclusive state...
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 07:53 PM by TUowl06.)
|
|
| 06-20-2026 07:48 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-20-2026 06:32 PM)lance99 Wrote: Here is the thing with these two Schools in question and I will start with Temple First:
Temple was Kicked off the Big East Football Island because they was so bad. I remember in the 1990's Miami and Virginia Tech fans complaining(Paraphrasing) 'By just having them on the Schedule and not even playing them yet, they dropped OUR SOS!' That was HUGE problem for the Big East..... That is why they got Kicked out!
People have to remember: It got so bad there that the School held a vote to Disband the Program and they were ONE VOTE AWAY from that happening and that is simi-recent History! That is a Major Red Flag!
It is not even about a Stadium for them(Franklin Field is a Option, but see other post about working around Penn for that. There issue is the fact that the Fans: they just don't care. Philadelphia is a Pro Sports City for Football(and don't bring me the the crap about sold out games at the Linc for Temple. They were there to see Notre Dame and Navy, Ect. and not Temple).
UMass on the other hand, is self inflected. When they joined the MAC(The day Temple decided to leave) the first time, it was conditional and they knew that. Go back and look at the threads here when they made the Sweet 16. There was a reason the MAC gave the ultimatum during that run(We can play a very mean Hand of Cards when we need to). They made them do a forced decision with everyone watching, they decided to leave, and it cost them for Years!
Heck, even one of the longest Threads on this Website for years revolved around the UMass question!
I will be honest, I have no idea if they are committed enough in Football to survive in the MAC(Even my own School that I follow can be questioned at this point). The Stadium need to be upgraded. Even by MAC Standards, is pretty bad. IDK if they can get Fan support consistently, even if they are Mediocre at best in some years.
Yes, they do spend a ton of Money on Coaches for our Conference Level. However they have not decided if they want to be a Football School, A Basketball School, Or a Hockey School. I am more than happy if they choose one of these and focus on that. Trying to be all three will DOOM a School like UMass!
I just do not know without having another School in the General Area Like Stony Brook, Albany, New Hampshire, Ect(I consistently said I want nothing to do with UConn). They can survive Long Term in FBS.....
Well during the later years in the Big East they were pretty consistently beating Rutgers. But they only had 14 conference wins in 14 years. 5 vs. Rutgers, 3 vs. Pitt and 6 scattered among 4 other schools.
|
|
| 06-20-2026 08:08 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-20-2026 07:20 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-20-2026 06:32 PM)lance99 Wrote: Here is the thing with these two Schools in question and I will start with Temple First:
Temple was Kicked off the Big East Football Island because they was so bad. I remember in the 1990's Miami and Virginia Tech fans complaining(Paraphrasing) 'By just having them on the Schedule and not even playing them yet, they dropped OUR SOS!' That was HUGE problem for the Big East..... That is why they got Kicked out!
People have to remember: It got so bad there that the School held a vote to Disband the Program and they were ONE VOTE AWAY from that happening and that is simi-recent History! That is a Major Red Flag!
It is not even about a Stadium for them(Franklin Field is a Option, but see other post about working around Penn for that. There issue is the fact that the Fans: they just don't care. Philadelphia is a Pro Sports City for Football(and don't bring me the the crap about sold out games at the Linc for Temple. They were there to see Notre Dame and Navy, Ect. and not Temple).
UMass on the other hand, is self inflected. When they joined the MAC(The day Temple decided to leave) the first time, it was conditional and they knew that. Go back and look at the threads here when they made the Sweet 16. There was a reason the MAC gave the ultimatum during that run(We can play a very mean Hand of Cards when we need to). They made them do a forced decision with everyone watching, they decided to leave, and it cost them for Years!
Heck, even one of the longest Threads on this Website for years revolved around the UMass question!
I will be honest, I have no idea if they are committed enough in Football to survive in the MAC(Even my own School that I follow can be questioned at this point). The Stadium need to be upgraded. Even by MAC Standards, is pretty bad. IDK if they can get Fan support consistently, even if they are Mediocre at best in some years.
Yes, they do spend a ton of Money on Coaches for our Conference Level. However they have not decided if they want to be a Football School, A Basketball School, Or a Hockey School. I am more than happy if they choose one of these and focus on that. Trying to be all three will DOOM a School like UMass!
I just do not know without having another School in the General Area Like Stony Brook, Albany, New Hampshire, Ect(I consistently said I want nothing to do with UConn). They can survive Long Term in FBS.....
Why did you ignore that period where Temple was routinely going to bowl games and sending coaches to P4/5 programs?
That didn't happen during their first stint in the Big East. Only when it was CUSA 1.0 moved into the American.
|
|
| 06-20-2026 08:09 PM |
|
TUowl06
1st String

Posts: 1,640
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
Also, while Temple was for the most part inept during their time in the Big East, so too was Rutgers. In fact, without having the data directly in front of me I believe the Scarlet Knights were worse than Temple when comparing common metrics (W/L, point differential, head-2-head, etc). I'll never forget hearing "West Virginia 80, Rutgers 7" on the radio in the early 2000s. However, Rutgers was a "made" program once they gained all sports membership into the group. Temple never gained acceptance into the inner-circle. Or at least in time to leverage it....
If nothing else, one could consider Temple as "competitively/spiritedly bad" during their time in the Big East. Temple had a few ugly losses against Miami, Syracuse (Orange were legit in the 90s), and Virginia Tech but in the vast majority of the Ls the Owls didn't embarrass themselves from a competitive standpoint.
|
|
| 06-20-2026 08:30 PM |
|
billybobby777
The REAL BillyBobby

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-20-2026 08:30 PM)TUowl06 Wrote: Also, while Temple was for the most part inept during their time in the Big East, so too was Rutgers. In fact, without having the data directly in front of me I believe the Scarlet Knights were worse than Temple when comparing common metrics (W/L, point differential, head-2-head, etc). I'll never forget hearing "West Virginia 80, Rutgers 7" on the radio in the early 2000s. However, Rutgers was a "made" program once they gained all sports membership into the group. Temple never gained acceptance into the inner-circle. Or at least in time to leverage it....
If nothing else, one could consider Temple as "competitively/spiritedly bad" during their time in the Big East. Temple had a few ugly losses against Miami, Syracuse (Orange were legit in the 90s), and Virginia Tech but in the vast majority of the Ls the Owls didn't embarrass themselves from a competitive standpoint.
I will give you that. Rutgers was much more pathetic during that era than Temple was. In fact, the Big East was hot stinky a$$ during that period. Putrid football.
|
|
| 06-20-2026 08:59 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,073
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Temple and UMass should drop football and reinvest in basketball
(06-20-2026 08:09 PM)bullet Wrote: (06-20-2026 07:20 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-20-2026 06:32 PM)lance99 Wrote: Here is the thing with these two Schools in question and I will start with Temple First:
Temple was Kicked off the Big East Football Island because they was so bad. I remember in the 1990's Miami and Virginia Tech fans complaining(Paraphrasing) 'By just having them on the Schedule and not even playing them yet, they dropped OUR SOS!' That was HUGE problem for the Big East..... That is why they got Kicked out!
People have to remember: It got so bad there that the School held a vote to Disband the Program and they were ONE VOTE AWAY from that happening and that is simi-recent History! That is a Major Red Flag!
It is not even about a Stadium for them(Franklin Field is a Option, but see other post about working around Penn for that. There issue is the fact that the Fans: they just don't care. Philadelphia is a Pro Sports City for Football(and don't bring me the the crap about sold out games at the Linc for Temple. They were there to see Notre Dame and Navy, Ect. and not Temple).
UMass on the other hand, is self inflected. When they joined the MAC(The day Temple decided to leave) the first time, it was conditional and they knew that. Go back and look at the threads here when they made the Sweet 16. There was a reason the MAC gave the ultimatum during that run(We can play a very mean Hand of Cards when we need to). They made them do a forced decision with everyone watching, they decided to leave, and it cost them for Years!
Heck, even one of the longest Threads on this Website for years revolved around the UMass question!
I will be honest, I have no idea if they are committed enough in Football to survive in the MAC(Even my own School that I follow can be questioned at this point). The Stadium need to be upgraded. Even by MAC Standards, is pretty bad. IDK if they can get Fan support consistently, even if they are Mediocre at best in some years.
Yes, they do spend a ton of Money on Coaches for our Conference Level. However they have not decided if they want to be a Football School, A Basketball School, Or a Hockey School. I am more than happy if they choose one of these and focus on that. Trying to be all three will DOOM a School like UMass!
I just do not know without having another School in the General Area Like Stony Brook, Albany, New Hampshire, Ect(I consistently said I want nothing to do with UConn). They can survive Long Term in FBS.....
Why did you ignore that period where Temple was routinely going to bowl games and sending coaches to P4/5 programs?
That didn't happen during their first stint in the Big East. Only when it was CUSA 1.0 moved into the American.
So what, did you read his argument about “simi-recent” history? What they’ve done in the American proves they’ve invested in a winning program by hiring great coaches, including the current FCS championship winning coach.
|
|
| 06-20-2026 09:11 PM |
|