(02-13-2026 11:23 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (02-13-2026 09:39 PM)JRsec Wrote: (02-13-2026 09:13 PM)Ned Low Wrote: (02-13-2026 04:42 PM)JRsec Wrote: (02-13-2026 04:27 PM)bullet Wrote: Amusing that they call it a compromise when apparently the only change is that there are no first round rematches.
Now that part I can go along with.
edit-found one more change. They get rid of one of the two G5/6 schools. Maybe that is something the SEC wanted.
At this juncture we should just enhance our scheduling agreement with the ACC and Notre Dame, breakaway, define how we will delineate the NIL, have contracts to control the portal a little bit, pocket our own playoff revenue and let the ACC do the same, and have a new champions championship game with the ACC and simply lock down all of that national audience and pocket our own earnings on our own ratings.
If the Big Ten then wants to have a huge championship meeting with the SEC/ACC champ then we bid that out and split the proceeds 50/50.
The SEC and ACC will earn more than they earn now. Notre Dame is secured in independence with an access to the playoff game through the ACC's wildcard slot for their own internal playoffs, and the Big Ten can do what they please.
The audience for what is offered in the region of the SEC/ACC/and best brands of the Big 12 would be massive and profitable.
I don't see anything to be gained by trying to compromise with the Big Ten's desires in this matter. Let them do what they wish, but without focing us to be a part of it.
JR, I think that you may be overlooking an important possibility when it comes to your desire to essentially further regulate NIL: not all SEC or ACC members want it to be regulated beyond what it already is.
I’m fairly certain Texas, Texas A&M, Tennessee, LSU and some others in the SEC are probably happy with the status quo. In the ACC, Miami snd SMU are probably content as well.
Is it possible that that your idea could lead to an exodus of members from this SEC-lead model?
Ned, I made a distinction in an early post in this thread which apparently you only glanced at. The NIL question to be answered is it only corporate sponsorship money or these booster groups that count. Booster groups can fund the athletic department which can use the funds for the pay for play portion of the equation, but if NIL is only commercial endorsement revenue, or event revenue then everyone has to operate by the same rules which is all they are seeking. I don't think that's going to cause any division at all. Both sets of funds are used to the schools' advantage, but it defines NIL in a way that is verifiable.
But that's ancillary to the separation which allows the SEC and anyone that part of their breakaway to create their own revenue and playoff system. There is a litany of reasons for this to happen and the Big Ten's monkey wrench in the playoff changes is reason #1 to do it. We are never going to agree because what is best for them is not best for us and vice versa. Time to separate and both need to separate from the NCAA.
Thank you for your reply.
Correct me if I’m wrong but NIL is already defined and rules are in place; the problem is that there’s no enforcement and some schools are playing by their own rules, regulations be dammed. In addition, some states (TN, for example) are exempting themselves / schools under their legal purview from such collective regulation or are at least attempting to.
What would keep Texas, A&M or TN from choosing to align with the B10-lead group in s scenario like you’ve described?
This just seems like a Pandora’s Box to me. I’m intrigued by the idea but the risk seems great.
It is left to the conferences to determine what constitutes NIL. The Court ruled and left its interpretation to be handled by the conferences. When there is a power vacuum someone will always step in. In this case certain schools urging their states to get included.
All of this becomes much simpler with a breakaway and the establishment by consensus of what is NIL compliance and what is Booster related for each conference's member schools.
Placating those schools to gain consensus might entail more lucrative conference business. That could entail anything from an expanded internal playoff system which could be sold for extra conference revenue which more than offsets the booster led efforts at those schools, and possibly a future basketball tournament where more revenue can be shared annually than the 1/6th of a share that is given annually now.
For any of that to happen the conferences need to become independent of the system we have now. The CFP serves the networks who pay the schools which participate. An internal playoff, like the championship game serves the conference and the networks pay them for the right to broadcast their championship game and all schools in the conference benefit, but the participants rightly benefit more and the profit to the conference is much higher.
Why isn't everyone upfront about this? Because if the major conferences pull away and market their own product that won't leave the NCAA the operational money they rely upon.
It's a ticklish situation and institutions are reluctant to leave others in the lurch though the enrollment cliff is a real issue, and all of the larger schools are building to accept more students because hard times are coming for the smaller ones.
It's much better that the Big Ten and SEC reach an impasse and the story is about NIL and how it is defined and how many also rans make the playoffs and how they are picked. There is enough plausible deniability there for Joe average fan to gripe about and for the true believers to deny that it was about anything else.
The upper tier breakaway is about revenue enhancement, the compiling of high interest games, constant exposure, and control of the game in a way that highlights the schools and also paints them as what they are, a farm system for the NFL. The gambling interest is counting on it.
I told this board in my first post that all of this was a hostile takeover of a profitable but undeveloped cottage industry beloved by the country, and that corporations through the networks were taking it over and capitalizing upon its popularity for themselves.
They've used money and realignment as product placement to enhance those profits. Now they've allowed other outside industries to profit by it, like the gambling industry which is openly hawked with picks and the offering of spreads from networks owned by other entities in the entertainment field. They were of course going to glean all they could and the NCAA's Victorian Era restrictions were easy prey.
If there is a breakaway it will be the first act that the conferences have made to protect their own interests. The Kabuki is on for that purpose and there will be casualties most likely those dependent upon the NCAA.
It's not popular to own it. But the schools, any of them including the P5, are victims of the takeover as surely as everyone else and the culprits are the ones who paid for the changes so they could control the game, expand its playoff, and profit off of entities supported by taxpayers.
Now smoke that over Ned. The vast majority of this forum is still in denial thinking that Petitti and Sankey are in charge respectively. They dance for the change from the pockets of ESPN and FOX, and those companies are merely loose change for their parent organizations. And the cost of college football as a school-by-school product is not born by them, but the taxpayers of our states and the donors of major private schools and that sir is the reality nobody wants to deal with!
Most of the time I try to only dole out what I believe people can handle, but if you can't see it now, there's nothing anyone can say to make you.
I have been as Frank the Tank could tell you, for a breakaway for at least 6 or 7 years because early on it became clear to me that it would be the only way any of our schools could reserve a modicum of control over their future, let alone their programs.
Sadly, there is quite a bit more industry impacted by corporate desires to coopt state entities. I'm just sorry the ramp up of collegiate sports continues to be funded by taxpayers rather than by the instutitutions purchasing the product, and that it remains unspupported by the massive corporate entity the NFL which would not exist very long without it, but contributes nothing to its farm system which again is funded by taxpayers. I believe there is something fundamentally wrong with that sleazy arrangement.