bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,900
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Big Ten Considering a New 24 Team Playoff Proposal, But...
(02-13-2026 01:24 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (02-13-2026 01:08 PM)JRsec Wrote: (02-13-2026 12:21 PM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote: (02-13-2026 11:59 AM)JRsec Wrote: ...the proposal calls for the elimination of conference championship games while suggesting that the sale of 4 more games could make it up for it. Maybe that works for replacing the Big Ten's CCG, but the SEC's brings in north of 70 million for the one game and the creation and sale of 4 more playoff games involving SEC schools does not.
I suspect this will be DOA in Birmingham.
That said there are some suggestions within the proposal that may be worth some discussion. https://www.espn.com/college-football/st...ship-games
I love removing CCGs especially if the 2 teams played already. Following the pro nonsensical belief of "Now it counts more." But Indiana didnt play Oregon and not sure who played in SEC (CFB ends in November for me) but they should only meet if they havent played already. Also look for teams to "opt-out" of CCG if they dont help in any way.
I liked no rematches in the first round and the playing of more games at the home sites of schools. I think both of those are good for the fans and sport. Twenty-four schools is kitty litter for the problems in selection we have at 16 or 12. They can increase the field but as they do the value of the first round games diminishes. A playoff should be a special event goal to attain, not a bloated redo of the season.
My guess is that Sankey will see this second, and mildly adapted proposal to move to 24 as a Big Ten stiff arm and it will serve as the catalyst for the SEC breaking away to do its own thing. Now when I say that, it's not just going to be the SEC going it alone, it will be the SEC with an acceptable concept for that action already agreed upon with ESPN. Networks are involved here. FOX knows that the larger the field the more games they will likely have to air because of calendar and contractual agreements at ESPN.
It's one reason that I see a SEC / ACC breakaway as being viable. ESPN keeps all regular season games in house except for away games at Notre Dame for ACC schools, or SEC schools in an exchange of games with the Irish. Scheduling agreements can also address the value of games making the most competitive in the ACC more money for games against the SEC's strongest draws for viewership.
What's the best way to keep the Big Ten from finding a Southern market? Keep the ACC whole. If the SEC wanted to move to 18 maybe FSU moves over and USF fills in also eliminating a possible future school of interest for the Big Ten and FOX. Toss in Kansas and the SEC/ESPN side beefs up the winter lineup as well. Between the two conferences ESPN has a national setup that stretches into the Bay Area of California and deeper into the Midwest while locking down the Southeast and Southwest's top brands.
Perhaps the Solution for the Playoff problem is for the Big Ten/former PAC schools to play it off for a champion and the SEC/ACC/former top Big 12 brands to do the same. The two emerging champions play for the title.
That way the Big 10 can utilize play in games in their own playoff if they desire and FOX can have access to their playoff games, and the ESPN can do the same with its own product. The number of marketable games increases, but the CCGs remain the sole property of the respective conferences, and very likely the 2nd and 3rd most watched games. It's the only way out of the current mess which keeps both groups of schools national while also remaining largely historical rivals in the sense of a North vs South arrangement, which is highly effective as a marketing strategy.
From there the final conflict for a new upper tier will be hashing out details about collective bargaining, contracts, and the defining of what constitutes a legitimate source of NIL.
There's a long way to go but allying to remain separate will help each work out their own peculiar internal issues and the lone championship game between the two groups seasonal winners will be extremely valuable for being bid upon, while each network and each collective group of schools make more playing their own championship out internally.
No rematches is just common sense, and extremely easy to implement. Last year swap Miami and Alabama, then swap Tulane and JMU. Nobody moves more than 1 spot, no rematches in the first round. Even better, swap Ole Miss with A&M so that they can't have a rematch with Georgia in the 2nd round, either.
The CFP home game, however...we had more fans at the Stamford game than we did for Miami. It was officially a sellout, but we were running 105-108k all season, except only 100k for Utah St in week 2 and only 104,200 for Miami. Anecdotally, most of my daughter's friends didn't go back to campus for the game, either. And this was with almost perfect weather for football in one of the most-Southern stadiums in the country. Don't get me wrong, I'm happy that we hosted a CFP game, I'm not ungrateful at all about this, but...
I googled "did any CFP first round games not sell out in 2025" and got this:
All four
CFP first-round games in December 2025 sold out, despite significantly lower secondary market ticket prices compared to the previous year. Played at on-campus sites, the games maintained high demand, with marquee matchups like Miami–Texas A&M leading secondary prices. The format featured seeds 5–12 in home-stadium game
I can tell you that the secondary market for that game was nothing like it was for any of our home SEC games. We have a huge, rabid fan base that hadn't sniffed success like this in decades, and we still struggled to sell all the tickets and had a lukewarm secondary market. I worry what an additional round would do, especially as that round would feature a whole lot of schools that have "been there before", perhaps many times.
On-campus for hypothetical additional future matchups might still be the best solution, I understand that, but the vibe is just very different than the regular season.
edit: resale ticket prices:
https://frontofficesports.com/cfp-first-...cond-year/
Miami at Texas A&M: $237
Tulane at Ole Miss: $190
Alabama at Oklahoma: $168
James Madison at Oregon: $63
The cost to attend this year’s first-round games is much lower than in the days leading up to 2024’s CFP. Last December, the cheapest resale tickets for Indiana–Notre Dame were more than $900, while Clemson-Texas and Tennessee–Ohio State each topped $300. This weekend’s games feature two Group of 6 visiting opponents in Tulane and JMU, and they don’t have the benefit of the massive fan bases that Notre Dame, Texas, and Ohio State carried last year.
re-edit: This quote from the ESPN article touches on something that I mentioned a lot last fall, how schools measure "success":
The idea has increased in conversation among coaches and athletic directors in the Power 4 leagues, as the coaches acknowledge a playoff-or-bust pressure and athletic directors want more postseason opportunities to justify rapidly increasing roster expenses.
More postseason opportunities = more job security for ADs and coaches that just spent $25m building up a roster that could compete for titles. Sure, maybe you didn't win the B1G or even make the CCG, but you did makes the CFP! It absolutely matters to the coaches/ADs, and it matters to the boosters, too.
Well with finals and school being out, attendance could be impacted. FCS typically draws smaller crowds in the postseason.
|
|