(02-11-2026 03:24 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (02-11-2026 01:22 AM)46566 Wrote: (02-10-2026 11:18 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (02-10-2026 10:39 PM)Just Joe Wrote: Unless I missed something (more than possible…) the Chambliss denial had nothing to do with not giving more than one medical redshirt. It was that the second medical redshirt wasn’t requested until years later and the NCAA ruled his documentation wasn’t good enough to verify. And if I were a betting man I’d say the Mississippi courts will overturn that soon enough anyway.
First redshirt was just a redshirt for Chambliss. Ferris St probably didn't bother to try to "medically" redshirt him in his 2nd year b/c they didn't realize he would develop into such a stud.
Tuliaupupu had FIVE redshirt seasons, which I'm struggling to understand:
1 normal redshirt
2 medical redshirt
3 covid "redshirt"
4 ??
5 ????
Seems based on the article as 2 extra medical red shirts for the last 2. Sounds like he only played 2 full seasons so maybe funny math or was "dropped" as a player before he counted as a year for eligibility? Since he was injured.
I thought you’ll onlet 1 medical redshirt though. Hmmmm:
Key Details on NCAA Medical Redshirts:
Requirements: The injury must be season-ending, occur in the first half of the season, and the athlete cannot have competed in more than 30% of the maximum allowed contests for that sport (or 4 games, whichever is greater).
Documentation: Proper medical documentation is required to prove the injury occurred within the allowed timeframe.
Five-Year Rule: Division I athletes typically have a five-year window to play four seasons. A medical redshirt allows a student-athlete to regain a year of eligibility, potentially extending their career if multiple serious injuries occur within that window.
Differences by Division: While D1 and D2 have specific waiver processes, D3 also allows medical redshirting if the injury occurred before the 1/3 mark of the season.
While rare, it is possible for an athlete to have more than one medical redshirt if they suffer multiple, distinct season-ending injuries throughout their career, though it is subject to NCAA review.
Ok, so you can get medical redshirts indefinitely, will an above average amount of resiliency and bad luck. But 3? Why don’t they just simplify things:
5 years of eligibility, of which you can play up to 4 years. 1 total redshirt, be that medical, Covid, normal redshirt, whatever. Clock starts the day you enroll, so if yu enroll on Jan 3rd of your hs senior year to get a “head start”, you risk exhausting eligibility if team makes the CFP in your 5th year. No more of these kids spending more time in college than most NFL players spend in college + pros combined.
That
is the current system for DI.
If you're asking why DI, DII, & DIII have different rules, it's because each of those divisions are made of different schools that have decided to do things differently. The DI schools have voted one way, the DII a different way, and DIII yet another. It's not the NCAA forcing different divisions to do things differently, it's each division
choosing to do it differently. Some of it comes down to the schools in each level having their own challenges and priorities.
As far as Chambliss, by my reading of his career, I don't think he should get the 2026 season under DI rules. The crux of the DI rule is that you get one free year that's
meant to be used for circumstances beyond control. If you
choose to use that for anything else(say development), you are also gambling that you won't need it for anything else. At its core, a developmental redshirt is a deliberate misusing of the system.
So for Chambliss:
2021 - Developmental redshirting (okay, you've burnt your freebie)
2022 - Lost year to respiratory illness (this is still counts as year 1 because of burnt dev redshirt)
2023 - Plays - year 2
2024 - Plays - year 3
2025 - Plays - year 4
2026 - Eligibility exhausted
Under DI rules, Chambliss and his coach played with fire by choosing to redshirt him in 2021 for developmental reasons. The only spanner in the works is that he was actually at a DII school at the time. But he's applying for the waiver as a DI student-athlete, so DI rules apply. He also started in college
after the 2020-21 season, so he doesn't get the free covid year. The only argument he could
possibly make is that the reason he didn't play in 2021 was
also due to chronic respiratory illness, but he'd have to have medical documentation of that, and it doesn't seem like he does.
As for Tuliaupupu:
First, it's important to note that you start the waiver process after your
second injury year, not your first. The first injury year is meant to be covered by the standard redshirt year.
2018 - Foot injury - normal redshirt freebie year
2019 - Foot injury again - extra year waiver
2020 - Knee injury - extra year waiver (also covid year)
2021 - Did not play - was originally year 1
2022 - Plays - year 2
2023 - Injured - extra year waiver
2024 - Plays partial season before illness - enough played that it's year 3
2025 - Plays - year 4
2026 - ???
What it looks like for Tuliaupupu is the waiver for 2026 is based on the fact that he didn't play in 2021 and USC should have applied for a waiver that year. Also that he only played part of 2024. I'm guessing they had medical documentation showing the knee injury from 2020 was still a problem in 2021 and the reason he didn't play that season. The free covid year shouldn't have been a factor because he was already injured that year anyway. Maybe USC didn't bother to submit medical paperwork that season because it was automatically covered by covid? Or maybe he always had an injury waiver for 2021 and the sources I'm using for this just didn't list it.
So if 2021 is given a waiver, then the revised career is:
2018 - Foot injury - normal redshirt freebie year
2019 - Foot injury again - extra year waiver
2020 - Knee injury - extra year waiver (also covid year)
2021 - Knee injury persists - extra year waiver
2022 - Plays - year 1
2023 - Injured - extra year waiver
2024 - Plays partial season before illness - enough games played that it's year 2
2025 - Plays - year 3
2026 - Will be year 4