(02-06-2026 02:31 PM)TUowl06 Wrote: Either way, this is a non-starter. The PL is more about growing/solidifying FCS than it is moving on from the subdivision...
I think when it comes to FCS full league members (Lehigh, Lafayette, Bucknell, Colgate Holy Cross) the PL is more about growing/solidifying FCS than it is moving on from the subdivision.
But it's different for the associate members. I have no idea what Georgetown gets out of football. I seem to the think the newbies (Richmond, WM and Villanova) are all "okay" with the PL for now but really just wanted off the sinking ship that is the CAA.
Then there's my alma mater.
Last spring Fordham brought in outside consultants to study the future of its football program. Apparently everything, from dropping the program to making the move to FBS, was on the table. So for us at least, we're not simply on autopilot inside the FCS world the way full PL members and all Ivy League members are.
Anyway, I reached out to a couple of people "inside the loop" and it seems as if the bulk of the study was spent on football members of the Pioneer Football League (no scholarship FCS football), our own Patriot League and the MAC. Our AD, Charlie Guthrie, comes from a MAC school and had earlier hired Joe Moorhead (our most famous HC after Sleepy Jim Crowley and Frank the Iron Major Cavanaugh) to that same school so I'm sure he knows the cost of doing business at a G-5. We have A-10 partners (Davidson and Dayton) who can give us an idea of how things work in the PFL and of course we already know what life is like in the PL.
In the end Fordham did decide to stay the course. To me that meant they'd toe the PL line just like the full members. But then I stumbled upon this Guthrie interview which kinda/sorta/maybe hints at a possible rift.
Link:
https://youtu.be/PXXSsk33FOk?si=08YAgJa2pACmgJpK&t=594
Guthrie clearly seems to think grad transfers are the answer to our football woes. The Patriot League however has a strict no grad transfers policy. So that got me wondering...
Does Fordham eventually get together with the PL newbies (Villanova, Richmond, WM) to later break away? I'm jumping ahead 4/5 years but maybe take Georgetown too if they ever got serious about football? Maybe add Duquesne from the NEC and/or Rhodey from the CAA as well?
That still wouldn't be a "New Patriots League in FBS" type setup but grad transfers in bigger schools and bigger markets would offer a higher ceiling than the PL's full members. Higher ceiling than the low one the Ivies built for themselves decades ago. Higher than whatever is left of the CAA too.