tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: No Baseball or Softball - List
(02-03-2026 12:58 PM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote: (02-03-2026 10:39 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: (02-01-2026 05:17 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (02-01-2026 04:56 PM)darkdragon99 Wrote: All "cold weather schools" should probably drop baseball. UConn is a very solid national level program and the season stars in a few weeks and right now in Connecticut its very cold and theres snow on the ground. UConn's schedule for 2026 is 20 home games and 36 road games. Why bother to field the sport if its going to be that much of a imbalance in scheduling.
On this board, the southern mindset with respect to college baseball seems to prevail and there's very little understanding of the northern mindset. Someone in this thread referred to college baseball as a *major* college sport. I don't think you find too many people in the north who agree with that. In the south, while this certainly is not true across the board, and depends at least to an extent on the relative success of a particular school in each sport, college baseball seems to be nearly on par with college basketball, or in some cases ahead of it. That's nowhere near true in the north. And in fact, in the north there are plenty of schools where baseball isn't even the #3 sport, even among schools that field a baseball team. As one example, Notre Dame plays in a conference generally considered to be a *power* baseball conference, and does field a baseball team. Yet an argument could be made that hockey, lacrosse and soccer all are ahead of baseball on the pecking order at Notre Dame. Of course, relative historical success does factor into that pecking order, and those sports all have been more successful, historically speaking, than baseball. But even at northern schools where baseball is the unquestioned #3 sport, there is a chasm between basketball and baseball (as well as between football and baseball, among schools that field FBS football teams) that doesn't seem to be there in the South, at least not on a universal basis the way it is in the North.
Assuming the OP's list is correct, and my count of that list is correct, there are 45 Division 1 schools that don't have a baseball team. While that's not a huge number, it's not an insignificant number either, as it encompasses well over 10% of Division 1 schools.
College baseball is considered by many a "major sport" in many states located in the Southeast, Southwest and West Coast. Outside those states, the sport is fairly popular in Indiana, Kansas (strong juco system) and Connecticut (lots of Division II and III programs).
College baseball (DI and otherwise) offers some popularity that is perhaps far more widespread than some folks realize.
I strongly consider baseball the "No. 4" NCAA Division I team sport (behind football, men's hoops and women's basketball). Women's volleyball might be No. 5 at this point (though softball is fairly popular).
College baseball could be the No. 4 D1 team sport. That sounds logical. But on the west coast, there is so much baseball, and it is played year-round, that it is hard to tell where college baseball lands. In California, there are 26 D1 schools and all 26 have baseball teams.
In Southern California, from Santa Barbara to San Diego, there are 3 MLB teams, 14 D1 baseball teams, 11 D2 teams, 4 minor league teams, and a lot of very good high school baseball. Winter league baseball is being played in Palm Springs.
It feels like the Dodgers dominate everything in Southern California and the talk is all about a Dodgers three-peat. UCLA, with their preseason No. 1 ranking, gets no attention. College baseball is huge at a school like Oregon State. But overall, on the west coast, college baseball is just not like it is in the South and some of the top recruits on the west coast have been going down to the South to play baseball. It's like SEC football. College baseball just means more in the South.
I would agree that, from an overall perspective, college baseball is probably the #4 college sport. But that doesn't necessarily make it a *major* college sport, at least not to my way of thinking. A lot differentiates college baseball from college football and college basketball in that regard.
One difference concerns quality of play. Among the best football players in the world in the 17-23 age range, the overwhelming majority play American college football. That number isn't quite as high in college basketball, because the NBA is more receptive to taking younger players, and there are a number of professional leagues overseas. But even still, college basketball provides clearly the most media interest for basketball below the NBA level, and NIL has leveled the playing field in the one area where college basketball lagged behind other options: financial compensation. Baseball, however, has a rather extensive professional minor league system in the United States, unlike football and basketball. A lot of the best younger players opt to go the minor league route rather than play college baseball even though minor league baseball is not terribly remunerative from a financial standpoint. One difference between the two is that minor league baseball mandates the use of wood bats, similar to the major leagues. Another issue is that baseball is also a very popular international sport, and a substantial number of the most talented young players in the world do not live in the U.S. Many of them live in Latin America or Japan and speak little to no English, so they aren't realistic possibilities for college baseball in the United States.
Then there's also fan interest. Much like California, there's little to no interest in college baseball in the northeast and midwest. And a large portion of the United States' population resides in these areas. Around here, there are plenty of baseball fans. The Yankees have the largest fan following, but the Red Sox, Mets and Blue Jays are all fairly well represented. There's also a smattering of Cardinals and Orioles fans from the days when the Red Wings were the top farm team of those teams (the Twins never caught on in the same fashion, and the Nationals haven't either). But college baseball fans are few and far between. If you come across a hardcore college baseball fan here, that person probably has a family member or close personal friend playing college baseball.
Another difference: at most schools college basketball is either the #1 or #2 sport. Football is the same way at schools that offer it. Offhand, the only school I can think of where men's basketball is not in the top two is Denver (I'd say hockey and lacrosse are both ahead of basketball), and UConn is probably the only school I can think of that plays FBS football where football isn't in the top two (I'd put men's and women's basketball ahead of football). Maybe there are others, but to find them you'd probably have to search pretty hard, and chances are it's because of a niche sport where they're hugely successful. By contrast, in baseball, there are plenty of schools that field a baseball team where baseball is not among the top four sports teams.
And of course, there's a massive dropoff in fan popularity between football, men's basketball, and everything else.
|
|