It will be interesting to see how Gonzaga does in the NIL era. They don't have a huge alumni base, they probably don't pay a ton in NIL and it's located in Spokane.
For Penny, this is life in the NIL era. He's going to have to hit the transfer portal every year and have ridiculous roster turnover - just like last year and this year. The days of a CDR staying 3 years is over and CDR was a guy who wasn't an absolute superstar out of HS. In his second year, CDR put up really good #'s and you know that in today's era, he would be gone to the highest bidder.
And, all the other AAC teams are probably doing the same, except we have more NIL money, but nothing compared to the P4 schools.
(01-13-2026 06:03 PM)drherenton Wrote: It will be interesting to see how Gonzaga does in the NIL era. They don't have a huge alumni base, they probably don't pay a ton in NIL and it's located in Spokane.
For Penny, this is life in the NIL era. He's going to have to hit the transfer portal every year and have ridiculous roster turnover - just like last year and this year. The days of a CDR staying 3 years is over and CDR was a guy who wasn't an absolute superstar out of HS. In his second year, CDR put up really good #'s and you know that in today's era, he would be gone to the highest bidder.
And, all the other AAC teams are probably doing the same, except we have more NIL money, but nothing compared to the P4 schools.
we have more than 80% if O4 schools. Penny has a lot now, he has not provided results so those that provided NIL do not do so any longer. New coach will get back to the NIL.
NIL is not automatic from donors if the product does not produce.
Do not be mislead, Memphis can and will be in the Top 20 again in NIL when and if another coach is in here. We are in year 8 with one ncaa win.
No one questions the importance of NIL, but the excuses here are just too much. I’d bet our NIL is easily the best in the AAC and more than the vast majority of teams. While others have more, we should be able to field a much better team than this year.
What about last year? That was a very competitive team.
….
Our 2024 preseason barttorvik and Kenpom rankings were still like 40 or 50, we just overachieved based on the kind of roster we put together. The plain fact of the matter is that in the NIL open enrollment era, we haven’t been able to put together a roster that people view as nationally relevant ex ante. There’s all kinds of reasons to move on from Hardaway at this point. But changing coaches isn’t going to fix what seems like a fundamental issue with the programs ability to compete on the level it’s used to.
(01-13-2026 12:21 PM)memtigbb Wrote: Yep, whomever asked how he has grown as a coach knew exactly what the answer was... not at all, in any way. Still doing the exact same thing as year 1 and making the exact same mistakes. No learning at all.
(01-13-2026 12:21 PM)memtigbb Wrote: Yep, whomever asked how he has grown as a coach knew exactly what the answer was... not at all, in any way. Still doing the exact same thing as year 1 and making the exact same mistakes. No learning at all.
I'll say at this point, when it is announced that CPH is no longer going to be our coach, when ever that ends up being, I will not cry, I will not shout, I will not get angry or sad. I will just wait for the announcement of the next coach.
(01-13-2026 02:50 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote: I thought the changing college landscape was supposed to benefit Penny? The old way of AAU fixers and politics was supposedly frustrating for Penny, so the move to the portal & older, mature, no-nonsense guys was right in his wheelhouse. Now, not so much.
Maybe Penny is just not a leader and struggles to manage people?
Yep. All the rules were just too hard for Penny. Now they take away the rules and now NIL is too hard for Penny. The truth is he is just a bad coach. When you cannot win, good players are not going to come whether you pay them or not. The guy could not win with guaranteed NBA players, he could not win with borderline NBA players, he dang sure cannot win with a team he actually has to develop.
(01-13-2026 11:17 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: Is there a reason our usual poster hasn't shared this interview?
CPH is correct in many of his statements, but the issue lies in the fact that he bears the brunt of his complaints. He even admits as much. But he has never and never will change his approach. He's just mailing it in now.
I don't care how this season plays out, but it needs to be his last. I want to return to my admiration for a beloved son of Memphis, a remarkable athlete and an exceptional ambassador for both the university and the city of Memphis.
I get that he doesn't want to walk away a failure. I wouldn't either. However, a smart person knows when to cut and run. It won't get any better for him. His star power means nothing in the age of NIL. The allure of being able to coach a young prospect into an actual NBA player is no longer there. Smart kids go to the program that pays them the most if they can cash in on their talent via NIL.
To those who seem willing to accept mediocrity and say, "But who else would do better in that situation?" I say anyone who understands fundamental basketball, who runs various schemes, who designs or sets plays and practices them so that execution is second nature, and who can inspire cooperation among teammates to unite in a common goal. Undoubtedly, it's a challenging task, but what are the potential consequences if we continue on this trajectory we've found ourselves on? We have already reached a critical juncture that, if not successfully navigated, could plunge us into utter irrelevance. One more season of underachieving and reduced season ticket sales—especially that aspect—could be the decisive factor.
NIL and the talent it brings won't guarantee a team success. We witnessed this firsthand when FAU humiliated us by kicking the preseason favorites' asses. A few programs have found success in finding a young, driven coach who can guide a group of 3 stars to punch up above their weight class.
Oh well, here it is, your award-winning, highly successful current head coach. For those few remaining who care...
Thanks for posting this. Hell, we have heard the same remarks for 7+ years. I could write his script. Funny how he never seems to notice Ashton jogging down the court on defense, and when the opponent shoots he is maybe as far as the head of the key. But Penny harps on seeing effort from the others.
(01-13-2026 06:03 PM)drherenton Wrote: It will be interesting to see how Gonzaga does in the NIL era. They don't have a huge alumni base, they probably don't pay a ton in NIL and it's located in Spokane.
For Penny, this is life in the NIL era. He's going to have to hit the transfer portal every year and have ridiculous roster turnover - just like last year and this year. The days of a CDR staying 3 years is over and CDR was a guy who wasn't an absolute superstar out of HS. In his second year, CDR put up really good #'s and you know that in today's era, he would be gone to the highest bidder.
And, all the other AAC teams are probably doing the same, except we have more NIL money, but nothing compared to the P4 schools.
we have more than 80% if O4 schools. Penny has a lot now, he has not provided results so those that provided NIL do not do so any longer. New coach will get back to the NIL.
NIL is not automatic from donors if the product does not produce.
Do not be mislead, Memphis can and will be in the Top 20 again in NIL when and if another coach is in here. We are in year 8 with one ncaa win.
No, we won't. Bill Laurie drives that bus, and he is being more restrictive than other billionaires with his NIL budget. Can't say that I blame him.
Top 20 programs these days are at $10M minimum. Because B10 and SEC schools get those big tv checks, they can divert booster funding to NIL. We still need booster funding to run the department. We ain't going to be $10M.
(01-13-2026 02:45 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took
Educate me please. What is the limit of $$ per year outside of university revenue sharing mandated by the NCAA? Is there even a limit?
University rev-share is capped somewhere in the low 20's. For now. Until someone takes them to court.
NIL is un-capped.
But supposedly the NIL deals must go thru some clearinghouse to determine their legitimacy. I’m guessing that a high NIL deal at Memphis would get denied while the same deal at a p4 school would be rubber stamped without a second thought.
(01-13-2026 02:25 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote: Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:
1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.
2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.
I think this is a perfect summary of the situation. The landscape has changed and the basketball program may have to make a change to adapt. Unless one of us wins a few hundred mil on Powerball, then our NIL situation isn’t changing. Trust me, if I won that $1.2 billion it was a few weeks ago, Tiger football and basketball would have rosters 2nd to none. $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took
Don't forget to get in the pockets of several officials, a few key players in NCAAT Committee and key media players.
Yep. The money is that big. That's where I believe the system is.
(01-13-2026 06:03 PM)drherenton Wrote: It will be interesting to see how Gonzaga does in the NIL era. They don't have a huge alumni base, they probably don't pay a ton in NIL and it's located in Spokane.
For Penny, this is life in the NIL era. He's going to have to hit the transfer portal every year and have ridiculous roster turnover - just like last year and this year. The days of a CDR staying 3 years is over and CDR was a guy who wasn't an absolute superstar out of HS. In his second year, CDR put up really good #'s and you know that in today's era, he would be gone to the highest bidder.
And, all the other AAC teams are probably doing the same, except we have more NIL money, but nothing compared to the P4 schools.
we have more than 80% if O4 schools. Penny has a lot now, he has not provided results so those that provided NIL do not do so any longer. New coach will get back to the NIL.
NIL is not automatic from donors if the product does not produce.
Do not be mislead, Memphis can and will be in the Top 20 again in NIL when and if another coach is in here. We are in year 8 with one ncaa win.
No, we won't. Bill Laurie drives that bus, and he is being more restrictive than other billionaires with his NIL budget. Can't say that I blame him.
Top 20 programs these days are at $10M minimum. Because B10 and SEC schools get those big tv checks, they can divert booster funding to NIL. We still need booster funding to run the department. We ain't going to be $10M.
Bill don’t like the new AD. This has nothing to do with Penny
What about last year? That was a very competitive team.
….
Our 2024 preseason barttorvik and Kenpom rankings were still like 40 or 50, we just overachieved based on the kind of roster we put together. The plain fact of the matter is that in the NIL open enrollment era, we haven’t been able to put together a roster that people view as nationally relevant ex ante. There’s all kinds of reasons to move on from Hardaway at this point. But changing coaches isn’t going to fix what seems like a fundamental issue with the programs ability to compete on the level it’s used to.
Oh jeez man. We were nationally relevant last year. We had two super solid scorers in Haggerty and Hunter. Dainja had a breakout year.
This one’s on Penny. He signed a terrible team. I agree we are behind many P4s in NIL, but we have to be the top of the AAC, yet we got humiliated by FAU. We should easily be the top team in the AAC.
Penny just can’t coach. Please tell me when you watch this team that they have any kind of offensive plan. It’s AAU ball when you have superior athletes (which we don’t this year).
I’m not buying the “we can’t compete” BS. What we can’t do is retain players. It’s ridiculous. No continuity.
The days of making a national championship may be in the past, but fielding a super competitive team are not.
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC
It's not a talent problem to me, it's more developing and coaching that talent
(01-13-2026 06:03 PM)drherenton Wrote: It will be interesting to see how Gonzaga does in the NIL era. They don't have a huge alumni base, they probably don't pay a ton in NIL and it's located in Spokane.
For Penny, this is life in the NIL era. He's going to have to hit the transfer portal every year and have ridiculous roster turnover - just like last year and this year. The days of a CDR staying 3 years is over and CDR was a guy who wasn't an absolute superstar out of HS. In his second year, CDR put up really good #'s and you know that in today's era, he would be gone to the highest bidder.
And, all the other AAC teams are probably doing the same, except we have more NIL money, but nothing compared to the P4 schools.
we have more than 80% if O4 schools. Penny has a lot now, he has not provided results so those that provided NIL do not do so any longer. New coach will get back to the NIL.
NIL is not automatic from donors if the product does not produce.
Do not be mislead, Memphis can and will be in the Top 20 again in NIL when and if another coach is in here. We are in year 8 with one ncaa win.
No, we won't. Bill Laurie drives that bus, and he is being more restrictive than other billionaires with his NIL budget. Can't say that I blame him.
Top 20 programs these days are at $10M minimum. Because B10 and SEC schools get those big tv checks, they can divert booster funding to NIL. We still need booster funding to run the department. We ain't going to be $10M.
Bill don’t like the new AD. This has nothing to do with Penny
What would be his source of contention? Just curious