CSNbbs
Penny post FAU loss presser - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html)
+----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html)
+------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html)
+------ Thread: Penny post FAU loss presser (/thread-1023303.html)

Pages: 1 2


Penny post FAU loss presser - TigerBlue4Ever - 01-13-2026 11:17 AM

Is there a reason our usual poster hasn't shared this interview?

CPH is correct in many of his statements, but the issue lies in the fact that he bears the brunt of his complaints. He even admits as much. But he has never and never will change his approach. He's just mailing it in now.

I don't care how this season plays out, but it needs to be his last. I want to return to my admiration for a beloved son of Memphis, a remarkable athlete and an exceptional ambassador for both the university and the city of Memphis.

I get that he doesn't want to walk away a failure. I wouldn't either. However, a smart person knows when to cut and run. It won't get any better for him. His star power means nothing in the age of NIL. The allure of being able to coach a young prospect into an actual NBA player is no longer there. Smart kids go to the program that pays them the most if they can cash in on their talent via NIL.

To those who seem willing to accept mediocrity and say, "But who else would do better in that situation?" I say anyone who understands fundamental basketball, who runs various schemes, who designs or sets plays and practices them so that execution is second nature, and who can inspire cooperation among teammates to unite in a common goal. Undoubtedly, it's a challenging task, but what are the potential consequences if we continue on this trajectory we've found ourselves on? We have already reached a critical juncture that, if not successfully navigated, could plunge us into utter irrelevance. One more season of underachieving and reduced season ticket sales—especially that aspect—could be the decisive factor.

NIL and the talent it brings won't guarantee a team success. We witnessed this firsthand when FAU humiliated us by kicking the preseason favorites' asses. A few programs have found success in finding a young, driven coach who can guide a group of 3 stars to punch up above their weight class.

Oh well, here it is, your award-winning, highly successful current head coach. For those few remaining who care...






RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtiger1987 - 01-13-2026 11:48 AM

Could Penny actually enjoy this? He looks miserable.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtigbb - 01-13-2026 12:21 PM

Yep, whomever asked how he has grown as a coach knew exactly what the answer was... not at all, in any way. Still doing the exact same thing as year 1 and making the exact same mistakes. No learning at all.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - MemTigers1998 - 01-13-2026 12:27 PM

Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtiger1987 - 01-13-2026 01:04 PM

(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - southpaw1 - 01-13-2026 01:28 PM

(01-13-2026 01:04 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.

Penny has had good assistant coaches on his staff almost every year. Many of them former head coaches, like Mike Davis this year. I know for a fact that Mike Davis knows how to coach up an offensive set or 2. We were witness to some of his really strong UAB teams. Penny just don't listen to them!!!!


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtiger1987 - 01-13-2026 02:01 PM

(01-13-2026 01:28 PM)southpaw1 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 01:04 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.

Penny has had good assistant coaches on his staff almost every year. Many of them former head coaches, like Mike Davis this year. I know for a fact that Mike Davis knows how to coach up an offensive set or 2. We were witness to some of his really strong UAB teams. Penny just don't listen to them!!!!

I thought Mike Davis’ teams were tough. I don’t know the “why”, but it’s obvious that they don’t run an offense. In the past, he’s had elite scorers that could make it happen. This year he doesn’t. It’s just hard to watch.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - GermantownTiger - 01-13-2026 02:25 PM

Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:

1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.

2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - MemTigers1998 - 01-13-2026 02:45 PM

(01-13-2026 02:25 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:

1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.

2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.

I think this is a perfect summary of the situation. The landscape has changed and the basketball program may have to make a change to adapt. Unless one of us wins a few hundred mil on Powerball, then our NIL situation isn’t changing. Trust me, if I won that $1.2 billion it was a few weeks ago, Tiger football and basketball would have rosters 2nd to none. $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - Marc Mensa - 01-13-2026 02:50 PM

I thought the changing college landscape was supposed to benefit Penny? The old way of AAU fixers and politics was supposedly frustrating for Penny, so the move to the portal & older, mature, no-nonsense guys was right in his wheelhouse. Now, not so much.

Maybe Penny is just not a leader and struggles to manage people?


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtiger1987 - 01-13-2026 03:35 PM

(01-13-2026 02:45 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 02:25 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:

1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.

2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.

I think this is a perfect summary of the situation. The landscape has changed and the basketball program may have to make a change to adapt. Unless one of us wins a few hundred mil on Powerball, then our NIL situation isn’t changing. Trust me, if I won that $1.2 billion it was a few weeks ago, Tiger football and basketball would have rosters 2nd to none. $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took

This doesn’t answer the question why we are losing to teams with a smaller budget. Yes NIL matters big time, but we should still be ahead of the rest of our conference.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - P3PPC - 01-13-2026 03:40 PM

(01-13-2026 11:17 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote:  Is there a reason our usual poster hasn't shared this interview?

CPH is correct in many of his statements, but the issue lies in the fact that he bears the brunt of his complaints. He even admits as much. But he has never and never will change his approach. He's just mailing it in now.

I don't care how this season plays out, but it needs to be his last. I want to return to my admiration for a beloved son of Memphis, a remarkable athlete and an exceptional ambassador for both the university and the city of Memphis.

I get that he doesn't want to walk away a failure. I wouldn't either. However, a smart person knows when to cut and run. It won't get any better for him. His star power means nothing in the age of NIL. The allure of being able to coach a young prospect into an actual NBA player is no longer there. Smart kids go to the program that pays them the most if they can cash in on their talent via NIL.

To those who seem willing to accept mediocrity and say, "But who else would do better in that situation?" I say anyone who understands fundamental basketball, who runs various schemes, who designs or sets plays and practices them so that execution is second nature, and who can inspire cooperation among teammates to unite in a common goal. Undoubtedly, it's a challenging task, but what are the potential consequences if we continue on this trajectory we've found ourselves on? We have already reached a critical juncture that, if not successfully navigated, could plunge us into utter irrelevance. One more season of underachieving and reduced season ticket sales—especially that aspect—could be the decisive factor.

NIL and the talent it brings won't guarantee a team success. We witnessed this firsthand when FAU humiliated us by kicking the preseason favorites' asses. A few programs have found success in finding a young, driven coach who can guide a group of 3 stars to punch up above their weight class.

Oh well, here it is, your award-winning, highly successful current head coach. For those few remaining who care...




Thanks for posting this. Hell, we have heard the same remarks for 7+ years. I could write his script. Funny how he never seems to notice Ashton jogging down the court on defense, and when the opponent shoots he is maybe as far as the head of the key. But Penny harps on seeing effort from the others.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - TigerBlue4Ever - 01-13-2026 03:42 PM

(01-13-2026 02:50 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote:  I thought the changing college landscape was supposed to benefit Penny? The old way of AAU fixers and politics was supposedly frustrating for Penny, so the move to the portal & older, mature, no-nonsense guys was right in his wheelhouse. Now, not so much.

Maybe Penny is just not a leader and struggles to manage people?

I believe that would be considered among his major failures.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - TigerBlue4Ever - 01-13-2026 03:46 PM

(01-13-2026 03:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 02:45 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 02:25 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:

1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.

2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.

I think this is a perfect summary of the situation. The landscape has changed and the basketball program may have to make a change to adapt. Unless one of us wins a few hundred mil on Powerball, then our NIL situation isn’t changing. Trust me, if I won that $1.2 billion it was a few weeks ago, Tiger football and basketball would have rosters 2nd to none. $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took

This doesn’t answer the question why we are losing to teams with a smaller budget. Yes NIL matters big time, but we should still be ahead of the rest of our conference.

Every team we play has a system of some sort for the most part. They have offensive and defensive schemes and run set plays, over and over and over, to great effect. And more often than not it's just fundamental basketball.

We are none of the above.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - TigerBlue4Ever - 01-13-2026 03:49 PM

(01-13-2026 03:40 PM)P3PPC Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 11:17 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote:  Is there a reason our usual poster hasn't shared this interview?

CPH is correct in many of his statements, but the issue lies in the fact that he bears the brunt of his complaints. He even admits as much. But he has never and never will change his approach. He's just mailing it in now.

I don't care how this season plays out, but it needs to be his last. I want to return to my admiration for a beloved son of Memphis, a remarkable athlete and an exceptional ambassador for both the university and the city of Memphis.

I get that he doesn't want to walk away a failure. I wouldn't either. However, a smart person knows when to cut and run. It won't get any better for him. His star power means nothing in the age of NIL. The allure of being able to coach a young prospect into an actual NBA player is no longer there. Smart kids go to the program that pays them the most if they can cash in on their talent via NIL.

To those who seem willing to accept mediocrity and say, "But who else would do better in that situation?" I say anyone who understands fundamental basketball, who runs various schemes, who designs or sets plays and practices them so that execution is second nature, and who can inspire cooperation among teammates to unite in a common goal. Undoubtedly, it's a challenging task, but what are the potential consequences if we continue on this trajectory we've found ourselves on? We have already reached a critical juncture that, if not successfully navigated, could plunge us into utter irrelevance. One more season of underachieving and reduced season ticket sales—especially that aspect—could be the decisive factor.

NIL and the talent it brings won't guarantee a team success. We witnessed this firsthand when FAU humiliated us by kicking the preseason favorites' asses. A few programs have found success in finding a young, driven coach who can guide a group of 3 stars to punch up above their weight class.

Oh well, here it is, your award-winning, highly successful current head coach. For those few remaining who care...




Thanks for posting this. Hell, we have heard the same remarks for 7+ years. I could write his script. Funny how he never seems to notice Ashton jogging down the court on defense, and when the opponent shoots he is maybe as far as the head of the key. But Penny harps on seeing effort from the others.

I was waiting for someone else to point that out. That entire situation is a whole other issue that no one in the media seems to want to bring up. In fact, the media tread very carefully around anything CPH related for some reason. Eventually the elephant in the room becomes too big to ignore.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - Marc Mensa - 01-13-2026 04:19 PM

The press treads lightly because Penny lost his mind on Geoff Caulkins after Geoff asked a very understandable question after a 2022 home loss to SMU… “Do you think you can still get it done?”

Sadly, 4 wasted years later, we’re still asking that question.

Penny’s response was embarrassing and the roster he lost with that night consisted of….
Jalen Duren
Emoni Bates
Tyler Harris
Earl Timberlake
Alex Lomax
Lester Quinones
Josh Minott
Malcolm Dandridge





RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - axdtigers - 01-13-2026 04:42 PM

(01-13-2026 01:04 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.

Did he really recruit all those players last year or did Stansbury? I've read conflicting reports on who did most of the recruiting.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - memtiger1987 - 01-13-2026 04:47 PM

(01-13-2026 04:42 PM)axdtigers Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 01:04 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.

Did he really recruit all those players last year or did Stansbury? I've read conflicting reports on who did most of the recruiting.

I don’t know. Except for this year, his teams have had talented players. I can’t say we’ve done alot with them though.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - Tiger87 - 01-13-2026 05:56 PM

(01-13-2026 03:35 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 02:45 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 02:25 PM)GermantownTiger Wrote:  Here're are two different perspectives to toss around:

1. The amount of NIL $$ being thrown around in the major conferences has skyrocketed even higher the past two years, dwarfing what teams like Memphis can pay. Players like Dainja, Haggerty, K. Davis, Hunter, etc. are becoming out of reach for our budget. The $$ divide is getting silly.

2. Penny was a smash hire 8 years ago when recruiting high school players wasn't about the $$ (for the most part) and our program was reeling. Now it's purely about the NIL $$. Penny's a great human being, amazing Tiger, but is more limited in his head coaching skills. Without being able to consistently recruit NBA-level talent anymore (thanks to NIL$), an excellent Xs and Os coach can beat an average coach on a typical night.

I think this is a perfect summary of the situation. The landscape has changed and the basketball program may have to make a change to adapt. Unless one of us wins a few hundred mil on Powerball, then our NIL situation isn’t changing. Trust me, if I won that $1.2 billion it was a few weeks ago, Tiger football and basketball would have rosters 2nd to none. $40mil? $50mil? $100mil? Whatever it took

This doesn’t answer the question why we are losing to teams with a smaller budget. Yes NIL matters big time, but we should still be ahead of the rest of our conference.

Most of the losses this year are to teams with vastly higher NIL than we have. FAU was a bad game - no doubt. It happens in basketball, and you move on.


RE: Penny post FAU loss presser - Tiger87 - 01-13-2026 06:00 PM

(01-13-2026 01:28 PM)southpaw1 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 01:04 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(01-13-2026 12:27 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  Now, probably more than ever, Memphis needs a coach who can evaluate talent, get players that attainable (meaning mid level portal guys and top 75-150 high school kids) and build a roster that fits a system the coach believes in. That’s about the only chance the Tigers have in the NIL world. Just don’t have the $ to build elite talent rosters. And let’s be honest, a coach who can do that and win here isnt going to be here long. Such is life in the AAC

What about last year? That was a very competitive team. We were able to get Haggerty, Hunter, and Dainja with our NIL budget. I’m not saying we are at the top of the NIL budget, but we’re not doing terrible. Penny just fielded a terrible team. We have a pretty good PG (who has to do too much) and a team full of role players.

Addressable problems are roster turnover and lack of coaching. We run very few offensive sets and it’s just a **** show. After all these years, Penny needs an assistant to basically coach the players. We have a high coaching staff turnover too, but Penny would be better to be the face of the program and lead recruiter. Let someone else manage the team. It would give him more time for golf too.

It’s obvious how bad the coaching is when he doesn’t have a strong lineup. He doesn’t have the players this year to cover up the lack of coaching. As said here often, we won’t fire Penny, but I hope he decides to resign.

Penny has had good assistant coaches on his staff almost every year. Many of them former head coaches, like Mike Davis this year. I know for a fact that Mike Davis knows how to coach up an offensive set or 2. We were witness to some of his really strong UAB teams. Penny just don't listen to them!!!!

Davis is a coach, for sure. He probably does well with game planning and player development. But I doubt he does much scouting, recruiting, navigating the transfer portal. And that is where this year's team failed.