bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-02-2026 09:01 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote: I will not start a Paul Feinbaum thread. This, however, is so predictable.
Calling Alabama football “now in shambles” is father extreme.
It’s in shambles,” said Finebaum when assessing Alabama football at this moment. “And I know that sounds like a remarkable statement, considering they were in the quarterfinals (on Thursday). But because it was on the grandest stage in college football, against a team that nobody in Alabama respected, and I’m talking about the fans, they look at Indiana and laugh.”
https://www.saturdaydownsouth.com/news/c...o-indiana/
Alabama got beat handily by Georgia and Indiana. So that has made the program fall apart? Keep it in perspective. Alabama. had a couple of glaring weaknesses, not often noted, all season that caught-up with them. Their running game had obvious flaws. That can be fixed if the coaching staff can prove their mettle.
Alabama right now is doing about as well as any of their fans could have hoped for 2 years into the post-Saban era. 20-8, made the SEC CCG and won a playoff game? If you'd told them the day after Saban announced he was retiring that would be their next 2 years, every single one of them would have signed up for that. The problem is the extreme overreaction people have from week to week. Teams, programs, even entire schools are only as good as their last 4 quarters. Lose to OU by 2 at home? WORST TEAM EVER. Beat OU on the road in a CFP first round game? ALABAMA IS BACK BABY. Lose to the best Indiana team in history by 35 in a rain-soaked Rose Bowl? DeBoer is DeWorst!
DeBoer has won more playoff games in the past 2 years than Kirby has.
|
|
| 01-03-2026 09:45 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 09:31 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: As to the hit on Stockton, that was a "bang-bang" play that we've seen called either way in the past and in other games.
I can see how Georgia fans would want a penalty called and how Ole Miss fans would not.
And if the situation were hypothetically reversed, Ole Miss fans would want a penalty called and Georgia fans would not.
Maybe 5 percent of fans of either program would be consistent and note that should always (or never) be called regardless of who is playing.
Fans will be fans. It's a penalty when it adversely affects their teams and it's not a penalty when it benefits their teams.
I feel a penalty should have been called.
The issue is other than this Bill. The issue is that since its inception targeting has never had clearly defined and universally applied standards. We now have AI that could confirm it upon review. But we leave it in the hands of subjective humans with personal biases, whether those biases are peculiar to the person, to the benefit of a specific conference, or to Las Vegas. And, I might add that the most subjective and game altering penalties that may be called, pass interference and holding, still control the outcome and point spread of way too many games and remain unreviewable. The primary issue is not spoken of by announcers, nor the retired and supplemented official in the booth who spouts platitudes dismissing the controversial nature of a lousy or crooked call 90% more of the time than they ever hint at anything critical of a bad call.
Officials are the least officially compensated party to any sporting event, and that leaves them wide open to corruption. A top SEC official will make a little over 3,000 dollars for a football game which may have 150 million bet on it. Basketball officials and umpires make way less. You tell me if a couple of million in a numbered account in the Cayman's will make a difference for the house? It's a pittance of what they stand to make if the closing line indicates a 60/40 split in the betting line.
It's not that P.T. Barnum is right, it's that most people want to believe in something and in order to do so, embrace a certain level of denial to maintain the illusion of fairness. And it is the latter more than the proclamation of the former that continues to generate suckers.
(This post was last modified: 01-03-2026 09:52 AM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 01-03-2026 09:49 AM |
|
thrill_house
1st String

Posts: 1,124
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
|
|
| 01-03-2026 11:36 AM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 11:36 AM)thrill_house Wrote: Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
of course next year none of these games would have been played probably after NYD- 1/1 next year is on a Friday.
|
|
| 01-03-2026 11:42 AM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 11:36 AM)thrill_house Wrote: Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
That was literally the Frisco Bowl this year where it was played at the Ford Center, which is the Cowboys’ indoor practice facility. Granted, they still have 12,000 seats there for high school football games and concerts. (Say what you will about Jerry Jones, but the guy has turned what is a practice facility expense for other NFL teams into a revenue generator.)
|
|
| 01-03-2026 11:46 AM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 11:46 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (01-03-2026 11:36 AM)thrill_house Wrote: Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
That was literally the Frisco Bowl this year where it was played at the Ford Center, which is the Cowboys’ indoor practice facility. Granted, they still have 12,000 seats there for high school football games and concerts. (Say what you will about Jerry Jones, but the guy has turned what is a practice facility expense for other NFL teams into a revenue generator.)
Yes, that's true, Frank. Jerreh knows how to make money.
stever: Exactly. (But don't tell those who hate bowl games that. Oh, wait. lol)
|
|
| 01-03-2026 03:53 PM |
|
OdinFrigg
Gone Fishing

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 09:49 AM)JRsec Wrote: (01-03-2026 09:31 AM)bill dazzle Wrote: As to the hit on Stockton, that was a "bang-bang" play that we've seen called either way in the past and in other games.
I can see how Georgia fans would want a penalty called and how Ole Miss fans would not.
And if the situation were hypothetically reversed, Ole Miss fans would want a penalty called and Georgia fans would not.
Maybe 5 percent of fans of either program would be consistent and note that should always (or never) be called regardless of who is playing.
Fans will be fans. It's a penalty when it adversely affects their teams and it's not a penalty when it benefits their teams.
I feel a penalty should have been called.
The issue is other than this Bill. The issue is that since its inception targeting has never had clearly defined and universally applied standards. We now have AI that could confirm it upon review. But we leave it in the hands of subjective humans with personal biases, whether those biases are peculiar to the person, to the benefit of a specific conference, or to Las Vegas. And, I might add that the most subjective and game altering penalties that may be called, pass interference and holding, still control the outcome and point spread of way too many games and remain unreviewable. The primary issue is not spoken of by announcers, nor the retired and supplemented official in the booth who spouts platitudes dismissing the controversial nature of a lousy or crooked call 90% more of the time than they ever hint at anything critical of a bad call.
Officials are the least officially compensated party to any sporting event, and that leaves them wide open to corruption. A top SEC official will make a little over 3,000 dollars for a football game which may have 150 million bet on it. Basketball officials and umpires make way less. You tell me if a couple of million in a numbered account in the Cayman's will make a difference for the house? It's a pittance of what they stand to make if the closing line indicates a 60/40 split in the betting line.
It's not that P.T. Barnum is right, it's that most people want to believe in something and in order to do so, embrace a certain level of denial to maintain the illusion of fairness. And it is the latter more than the proclamation of the former that continues to generate suckers.
Your analysis comes across as ‘spot on’ to me. There are times when I am watching a game, and the team I am cheering for, appears to have benefited from ‘bad calls and/or no calls”. Then I may think, “wow, my team just got a break”. When controversial officiating is a major factor in determining the outcome of a game, unsettling feelings about it may indeed linger.
I am sure there are instances whereby officials’ intentions are to be fair, but make obvious mistakes with their calls. Another annoyance, is having officials not appropriately focused on all the play action happening on the field or court. Then the official may soon say afterwards, “I didn’t see that”. One doing that multiple times, becomes a question of competence or a measure of detachment toward one team or another or both.
As to the corruption facet you mentioned, I believe it is more widespread than what casual fans ordinarily believe.
(This post was last modified: 01-03-2026 05:00 PM by OdinFrigg.)
|
|
| 01-03-2026 04:50 PM |
|
owl at the moon
Eastern Screech Owl

Posts: 21,699
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation: 3099
I Root For: rice,smu,uh,unt
Location: 23 mbps from csnbbs
|
Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 11:46 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (01-03-2026 11:36 AM)thrill_house Wrote: Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
That was literally the Frisco Bowl this year where it was played at the Ford Center, which is the Cowboys’ indoor practice facility. Granted, they still have 12,000 seats there for high school football games and concerts. (Say what you will about Jerry Jones, but the guy has turned what is a practice facility expense for other NFL teams into a revenue generator.)
Hell, when we were in CUSA they hung up a curtain and we played our basketball tournament in the Ford Center. 2 games going on simultaneously for the first two rounds, actually it was pretty awesome (although my view was in the minority of basketball fans!!)
|
|
| 01-03-2026 06:06 PM |
|
surrealpirate
GDP

Posts: 1,338
Joined: Dec 2003
Reputation: 199
I Root For: ECU
Location: The Western Front
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 09:45 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: Alabama right now is doing about as well as any of their fans could have hoped for 2 years into the post-Saban era. 20-8, made the SEC CCG and won a playoff game? If you'd told them the day after Saban announced he was retiring that would be their next 2 years, every single one of them would have signed up for that. The problem is the extreme overreaction people have from week to week. Teams, programs, even entire schools are only as good as their last 4 quarters. Lose to OU by 2 at home? WORST TEAM EVER. Beat OU on the road in a CFP first round game? ALABAMA IS BACK BABY. Lose to the best Indiana team in history by 35 in a rain-soaked Rose Bowl? DeBoer is DeWorst!
DeBoer has won more playoff games in the past 2 years than Kirby has.
Their fans? No. But definitely as well as most reasonable folks would have expected.
|
|
| 01-03-2026 07:06 PM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 07:06 PM)surrealpirate Wrote: (01-03-2026 09:45 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: Alabama right now is doing about as well as any of their fans could have hoped for 2 years into the post-Saban era. 20-8, made the SEC CCG and won a playoff game? If you'd told them the day after Saban announced he was retiring that would be their next 2 years, every single one of them would have signed up for that. The problem is the extreme overreaction people have from week to week. Teams, programs, even entire schools are only as good as their last 4 quarters. Lose to OU by 2 at home? WORST TEAM EVER. Beat OU on the road in a CFP first round game? ALABAMA IS BACK BABY. Lose to the best Indiana team in history by 35 in a rain-soaked Rose Bowl? DeBoer is DeWorst!
DeBoer has won more playoff games in the past 2 years than Kirby has.
Their fans? No. But definitely as well as most reasonable folks would have expected.
Agreed. That said, we're college sports fans. It's hard to find reasonable fans of their schools. Heck, I consider myself to be one of the most reasonable people on this entire board and even I give in to my fandom sometimes. I guess it's human nature or something? *shrugs*
|
|
| 01-06-2026 09:19 AM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
Time for the CFP semis!
Tonight, the Fiesta Bowl from Phoenix (Glendale, actually), to be played between Miami (FL) and Ole Miss. (Kind of a weird setup since they're both from the southeast part of the country.) And tomorrow night, the Peach Bowl from Atlanta, featuring a rematch of two Big Ten (I decided for me to continue using "B1G" is kinda dumb now lol) teams, Oregon and the number one team in the country: Indiana! (lol huh?)
This is gonna be fun! (At least I hope so, anyway. lol)
(This post was last modified: 01-08-2026 04:48 PM by GeminiCoog.)
|
|
| 01-08-2026 04:47 PM |
|
IWokeUpLikeThis
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-08-2026 04:47 PM)GeminiCoog Wrote: Time for the CFP semis!
Tonight, the Fiesta Bowl from Phoenix (Glendale, actually), to be played between Miami (FL) and Ole Miss. (Kind of a weird setup since they're both from the southeast part of the country.) And tomorrow night, the Peach Bowl from Atlanta, featuring a rematch of two Big Ten (I decided for me to continue using "B1G" is kinda dumb now lol) teams, Oregon and the number one team in the country: Indiana! (lol huh?)
This is gonna be fun! (At least I hope so, anyway. lol)
I bet Indiana will dominate that crowd. Bloomington/Indianapolis to Atlanta can be done in a one-day drive.
|
|
| 01-08-2026 04:51 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-03-2026 11:46 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (01-03-2026 11:36 AM)thrill_house Wrote: Friday's attendance numbers...
Armed Forces: 28,243 (lowest attendance since 2004)
Liberty: 21,908 (lowest attendance since 1964, weather played a factor here)
Mayo: 29,328 (lowest attendance in the bowls 24 year history)
Holiday: 30,062 (second lowest attendance number of all time)
Alright, message received
Your bowl game will have fans if it features local teams and/or takes place between December 26th-31st.
Otherwise, it's a made-for-TV product that they might as well play at an indoor practice field (especially if it features G6 teams).
That was literally the Frisco Bowl this year where it was played at the Ford Center, which is the Cowboys’ indoor practice facility. Granted, they still have 12,000 seats there for high school football games and concerts. (Say what you will about Jerry Jones, but the guy has turned what is a practice facility expense for other NFL teams into a revenue generator.)
In his early years as an owner, Jones was great, arguably revolutionary, at both winning and generating new sources of revenue and enhancing existing ones.
His touch for winning, at least winning big, left a long time ago, but his acumen on the money side never has.
|
|
| 01-08-2026 05:26 PM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-08-2026 04:51 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: (01-08-2026 04:47 PM)GeminiCoog Wrote: Time for the CFP semis!
Tonight, the Fiesta Bowl from Phoenix (Glendale, actually), to be played between Miami (FL) and Ole Miss. (Kind of a weird setup since they're both from the southeast part of the country.) And tomorrow night, the Peach Bowl from Atlanta, featuring a rematch of two Big Ten (I decided for me to continue using "B1G" is kinda dumb now lol) teams, Oregon and the number one team in the country: Indiana! (lol huh?)
This is gonna be fun! (At least I hope so, anyway. lol)
I bet Indiana will dominate that crowd. Bloomington/Indianapolis to Atlanta can be done in a one-day drive.
That honestly wouldn't surprise me. But I will say Oregon has picked up quite a few fans. I went to college with a guy originally from New Hampshire who turned out be a Ducks fan. Still loves 'em, by the way, even though he's now a game designer for a video game company in North Carolina.
quo: Exactly. Like I said in the first Bowl Thread, Jerreh definitely knows how to make money. (Whoops. I made that post eight posts back. My fault.)
(This post was last modified: 01-08-2026 05:31 PM by GeminiCoog.)
|
|
| 01-08-2026 05:28 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-08-2026 04:51 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: (01-08-2026 04:47 PM)GeminiCoog Wrote: Time for the CFP semis!
Tonight, the Fiesta Bowl from Phoenix (Glendale, actually), to be played between Miami (FL) and Ole Miss. (Kind of a weird setup since they're both from the southeast part of the country.) And tomorrow night, the Peach Bowl from Atlanta, featuring a rematch of two Big Ten (I decided for me to continue using "B1G" is kinda dumb now lol) teams, Oregon and the number one team in the country: Indiana! (lol huh?)
This is gonna be fun! (At least I hope so, anyway. lol)
I bet Indiana will dominate that crowd. Bloomington/Indianapolis to Atlanta can be done in a one-day drive.
I agree. Though beyond that I am not sure it will help them. This Ducks team looks different to me than all the others that have come up short the past 15 years. They have big, physical linemen, and I think they will learn lessons from their earlier defeat.
We'll see soon enough.
(This post was last modified: 01-08-2026 05:35 PM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 01-08-2026 05:34 PM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-08-2026 05:34 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (01-08-2026 04:51 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: (01-08-2026 04:47 PM)GeminiCoog Wrote: Time for the CFP semis!
Tonight, the Fiesta Bowl from Phoenix (Glendale, actually), to be played between Miami (FL) and Ole Miss. (Kind of a weird setup since they're both from the southeast part of the country.) And tomorrow night, the Peach Bowl from Atlanta, featuring a rematch of two Big Ten (I decided for me to continue using "B1G" is kinda dumb now lol) teams, Oregon and the number one team in the country: Indiana! (lol huh?)
This is gonna be fun! (At least I hope so, anyway. lol)
I bet Indiana will dominate that crowd. Bloomington/Indianapolis to Atlanta can be done in a one-day drive.
I agree. Though beyond that I am not sure it will help them. This Ducks team looks different to me than all the others that have come up short the past 15 years. They have big, physical linemen, and I think they will learn lessons from their earlier defeat.
We'll see soon enough.
Just not tonight because the Peach Bowl is tomorrow.  It's Fiesta Time tonight!
|
|
| 01-08-2026 06:35 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
early on looking like a mismatch for Miami.
|
|
| 01-08-2026 08:12 PM |
|
GeminiCoog
Saved by grace through faith.

Posts: 22,021
Joined: Sep 2010
Reputation: 2178
I Root For: Houston, Notre Dame
Location: Dayton, Texas, USA
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
(01-08-2026 08:12 PM)stever20 Wrote: early on looking like a mismatch for Miami.
So far, but it's only 3-0, and they're about to have to punt it away with less than a minute to go in the first quarter.
|
|
| 01-08-2026 08:23 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,903
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
Announcers convinced it was targeting, but it was overturned.
No launch and he turned his head and did not lead with the crown of the helmet. But it was a full speed violent helmet to helmet collision.
|
|
| 01-08-2026 08:28 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,351
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 958
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: Bowl Thread Part Deux.
How's that Miami mismatch doing for ya?
|
|
| 01-08-2026 08:30 PM |
|