Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
Look — you can disagree with the hire, but a lot of comments on here aren’t criticism… they're just ignorance wrapped in attitude. So here are the facts, point-blank.
Point-by-Point Facts for Most Complaints Being Thrown Around
1. “He’s a DEI hire because the AD is Black.”
This is lazy, borderline racist nonsense, and it falls apart the second you look at the man’s résumé.
National Championship coach under Nick Saban
Ranked No. 1 recruiter in the country (not No. 1 Black recruiter — No. 1 recruiter, period)
Developed multiple NFL players
Beat Notre Dame, App State, Virginia Tech
Top-3 recruiting classes in the Sun Belt at USM
Prestigious Broyles Award finalist
If any white coach had these credentials, this board would be calling him a “home-run steal.”
If the only argument someone has is “DEI,” they don’t have a football argument.
2. “This is a terrible hire!” → Okay, why? Name one football reason.
Not a single person saying “terrible hire” is citing:
scheme issues
recruiting failures
staff concerns
development concerns
culture problems
poor win expectancy
Because they can’t.
When you remove the emotional noise, the résumé speaks for itself.
Memphis hired one of the strongest recruiters available at a G5 price point.
3. “He was job-hunting while poaching players from Marshall.”
False — and it’s already been debunked.
Here are the actual facts:
EVERY G5 coach listens to job interest. That’s the business.
Marshall players followed him because he built real relationships — not because he “poached” them.
There is ZERO evidence of tampering.
When he left Marshall, their AD publicly thanked him and never accused him of anything improper.
People are taking two unrelated realities — the portal and ambition — and twisting them into a scandal that never happened.
4. “He didn’t win enough at Marshall or Southern Miss.”
He inherited two absolute rebuilds:
Marshall: roster turnover, internal issues, no NIL backbone
Southern Miss: one of the worst roster situations in the Sun Belt
Even with that:
He pulled major upsets
He elevated recruiting instantly
He was competitive in nearly every game against higher-resource programs
He improved talent profiles across the board
Coaches aren’t magicians.
They don’t snap their fingers and inherit an SEC roster.
His track record shows he builds a foundation — and Memphis needs a builder, not a splashy name.
5. “Why didn’t we get Mullen?”
Because Mullen had zero interest in building a G5 program from the ground up.
Let’s be honest:
He doesn’t love recruiting
He would command 2–3x the salary
NIL at Memphis isn’t at his required level
He likes media work
He wasn’t leaving ESPN unless someone backed up a bank truck
Acting like Memphis “missed” Mullen is like saying you “missed” a date with Beyoncé.
It was never happening.
6. “Helton/Huff/Mack… why not just go local?”
Memphis needs a national recruiter if it wants to fight for Power-Conference consideration.
Huff can walk into:
Atlanta
Mississippi
Alabama
Texas
Florida
DMV
Midwest
…and recruit immediately because he has actual name recognition with high school coaches.
Local comfort hires don’t move the national needle.
Recruiting does.
7. “Why should we trust this hire?”
Because for once Memphis didn’t chase a celebrity or a retread.
They hired:
A grinder
A builder
A recruiter
A coach players follow
A coach who’s beaten big programs
A guy with NFL development chops
This is how you win G5 conferences.
This is how you get ranked.
This is how you get noticed by Power Conferences.
And let’s keep it real:
Memphis fans have killed every hire at first — including Justin Fuente and Mike Norvell.
Winning changed everything.
Huff will get the same opportunity.
You don’t have to anoint Huff as the savior, but at least critique him with facts — not lazy race comments or rumor-mill nonsense. His résumé is better than any coach Memphis could realistically land at this stage. Let the man build before judging a season he hasn’t even coached yet.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
Per article in Daily Memphian:
“The timing of Silverfield’s departure coupled with the potential loss of players is why Memphis needed to hire a strong recruiter.
And now it has one in Huff who was ranked as 247Sports’ National Recruiter of the Year for his work in the 2021 recruiting cycle under Nick Saban at Alabama.”
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
Thank you for this well thought out post. It can’t be refuted. Although everyone here loves the Tigers, there are some truly vile, despicable people among us. It was an ugly thing to see to seen them come out yesterday.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
Friendly Marshall side of the story---
He inherited a team that (albeit due to Covid) was in the top 25 and the conference championship the year before. We returned a lot including the QB to go 7-6 due to some really poor clock management and game strategy. That year went sideways. He interviewed for jobs and lied about them after in year one. A lot were out here.
In 2022 we had a shot had Henry Colombi not gotten hurt. He got hurt at BGSU after ND and then our season just didn't live up to what you'd hope it would be beating ND. In 2023 he rolled out a QB in Cam Fancher who was rough the year prior and not much better than next year. Our O in 2023 was rough to watch. Then after emotions bubbled he threw Cam and the fans under the bus when Fancher was transferring to the point his parents had to step in. We got hit by a lot of buses by him in the media.
Fast forward to 2024 and until he finally settled on Braxton we were the same. Stone Earle was terrible. Pennington was ehh. How they got the nod over Braxton is wild. Further he cost us a game that year by rotating Earle and Braxton. On that 2024 championship team, Chuck Montgomery, AJ Turner and Ethan Payne were the only three skill guys who got PT that were there in 2023. The rest was portals. Given what Southern Miss did this year I can't speak that he develops overall. I think without Braxton he's a .500 coach at best, but we could say that about any decent coach and QB.
What you will get is this for positives. His players in Huntington, great. You didn't hear much of anything about player issue. He does recruit the portal like a wizard. I think you have to throw out the So. Miss year with it being heavy Marshall players, but he portaled well in Huntington. His OL recruits and development has been great. DLs and DBs also did well under him. Good family. Assistant choices have largely been solid. For the most part he had an amazing support staff. He's got a shot with Memphis' resources. But ultimately I think he's gone in a year to a P5 using the money to portal solid talent next year. Thats probably the best case as well. Wish you all the most success from the eastern part of the state.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
(12-07-2025 09:44 AM)batman Wrote: Thank you for this well thought out post. It can’t be refuted. Although everyone here loves the Tigers, there are some truly vile, despicable people among us. It was an ugly thing to see to seen them come out yesterday.
Why can’t it be refuted? Why was he the best guy for the job? It’s just a bunch of gibberish that’s sold as facts.
I’m not against Huff. The more I see, the more I like. We’ll see soon enough by the players he brings with him and those he tecruits (including our current players). I have the feeling he’ll do well.
But the search looked botched from the beginning. A typical Memphis hiring process. Did we use the search firm that brought us Norvell and Fuente? Again, I’m not against Huff, but was he really the best we could do? Scott mentioned a “splash hire”, is this it? It’s an ok hire, but I’d think our top G5 peers did better.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
Huff will get every opportunity and Memphis fans should give him a chance but clearly he wasn’t the first option. Common sense and putting two and two together on the timing of the announcement tells anyone willing to be honest. Maybe he’s the best person in hindsight but he wasn’t the clear choice
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
(12-07-2025 10:45 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote:
(12-07-2025 09:44 AM)batman Wrote: Thank you for this well thought out post. It can’t be refuted. Although everyone here loves the Tigers, there are some truly vile, despicable people among us. It was an ugly thing to see to seen them come out yesterday.
Why can’t it be refuted? Why was he the best guy for the job? It’s just a bunch of gibberish that’s sold as facts.
I’m not against Huff. The more I see, the more I like. We’ll see soon enough by the players he brings with him and those he tecruits (including our current players). I have the feeling he’ll do well.
But the search looked botched from the beginning. A typical Memphis hiring process. Did we use the search firm that brought us Norvell and Fuente? Again, I’m not against Huff, but was he really the best we could do? Scott mentioned a “splash hire”, is this it? It’s an ok hire, but I’d think our top G5 peers did better.
When I said it can’t be refuted was in reference to his resume and accomplishments. I don’t think you mean those things didn’t happen. You can refute if he was the best candidate all day long but his credentials are his crendentials.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
(12-07-2025 11:51 AM)batman Wrote:
(12-07-2025 10:45 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote:
(12-07-2025 09:44 AM)batman Wrote: Thank you for this well thought out post. It can’t be refuted. Although everyone here loves the Tigers, there are some truly vile, despicable people among us. It was an ugly thing to see to seen them come out yesterday.
Why can’t it be refuted? Why was he the best guy for the job? It’s just a bunch of gibberish that’s sold as facts.
I’m not against Huff. The more I see, the more I like. We’ll see soon enough by the players he brings with him and those he tecruits (including our current players). I have the feeling he’ll do well.
But the search looked botched from the beginning. A typical Memphis hiring process. Did we use the search firm that brought us Norvell and Fuente? Again, I’m not against Huff, but was he really the best we could do? Scott mentioned a “splash hire”, is this it? It’s an ok hire, but I’d think our top G5 peers did better.
When I said it can’t be refuted was in reference to his resume and accomplishments. I don’t think you mean those things didn’t happen. You can refute if he was the best candidate all day long but his credentials are his crendentials.
He has credentials. Some major programs and some success in the G5. But his winning percentage against winning teams is unimpressive (much like Silverfield). But, I think it’s a decent hire, but nothing great for a program desperately wanting into a P4.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
“Because Mullen had zero interest in building a G5 program from the ground up.”
From ground up? Seems disingenuous.
“Because for once Memphis didn’t chase a celebrity or a retread.”
For once? Also feels disingenuous.
“Memphis fans have killed every hire at first — including Justin Fuente and Mike Norvell.”
This is a lie and you know it, Norvell was wildly celebrated and accepted by the fan base.
“You don’t have to anoint Huff as the savior, but at least critique him with facts”
Don’t lecture people about facts and turn around and misrepresent your so called facts.
For the record I support the hire and am excited about the future of the program. What I cannot digest is your hyperbolic approach to your post. The above examples are straight up fabricated to back up your argument, stance, rant, lecture or whatever you feel like you’re doing in this post.
RE: Some of y’all need to calm down and get educated about Charles Huff.
I have no issue with this thread and is one that needed posting. Every coach will be missing some checkboxes but he checks some good ones. One concern of mind in doing research is that he seemingly likes a power run game. I think talented linemen to run this are harder to come by. I do like the mind set of teams that can run though. I am optimistic about the hire