(01-05-2026 09:09 PM)antoniovaldez7777 Wrote: You’re not actually agreeing—you’re talking past the point. The disagreement isn’t about whether Dean could have produced at Rice, it’s about what scouts can see without guessing. Saying he would’ve put up bigger numbers is still speculation, while UH gave scouts direct film showing how he performs with better teammates against stronger athletes. Stats get adjusted for competition, but scouts care more about how plays are made, not just yardage. UH didn’t magically raise his upside, but it reduced the amount of assumption scouts had to make—and that matters more than hypotheticals, even well-reasoned ones.
Dude… respectfully…. Scouts are still guessing. That’s how Tob Brady becomes a 6th round pick and Johnnie Manziel goes in the first. Those examples may be exceptional in their degree of success an failure, but the list of examples of both is massive.
Just a few posts ago, you mentioned that Dean’s 125 yards against LSU was impressive…. And now you say yardage doesn’t matter. You’re literally all over the place. The only hypothetical I am making is the same one you are, just in reverse. There is no way to know if Dean improved his draft profile vs last year because he wasn’t in the draft last year. There is also no way to know what he would have done at Rice in this offense vs UH in theirs because he didn’t play for a rice in this offense.
I agree and essentially said that they care more about how yards are made… and with a good OL and a diverse offense at UH that keeps the defense from stacking the box, he was often on the secondary before having to make a cut or break a tackle…. While at Rice, he more often was making moves in the backfield and breaking tackles of DL and LBs
My comment about yards wasn’t remotely that he would have rushed for more yards/that would have been more impressive…. It was that you would expect that he would rush for fewer yards against better competition/more yards against weaker competition.
On deans late TD, it could have been 20 yards or 99… limited only by how far downfield they were. The line blocked everyone and Dean showed good vision and a cut back against a LB…. Something he did countless times at Rice, but without as good blocking. Pro scouts also have the ability to project if they have a good or weak line themselves so that they don’t spend a high draft choice on someone who has amazing speed and cuts but is easily armed tackled if they are a poor blocking team.
At any rate, this whole discussion is speculative, by both of us. I’m glad Dean got to win more and play on a bigger stage. I don’t think it changed his pro prospects one bit. It’s fine if you disagree…. But don’t act like I’m the only one speculating. The days of pro scouts not being able to project talent into g5 are decades in the past.