GermantownTiger
Don't Tread On Me!

Posts: 13,823
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 483
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: G'town
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-10-2025 09:16 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: The “playoff” is an ESPN invitational. They tried to avoid litigation by including the G5 but the nightmare of 2 G5 teams in a ratings driven 12 team college football playoff is Just too much to bear. The talking heads have been non-stop bashing since the brackets were announced and anything less than single digit differential outcomes will result on a year long nonstop barrage to change the criteria. Too, if this comes down to political climate in Washington, I doubt the G5 will find much support on Capitol Hill, as more pressing issues will drowned out any anti-trust claims they can make.
The irony is JMU is every bit as good on the field as Virginia, and had the Cavaliers won, they wouldn’t be any more competitive as James Madison, but the talking heads would have a larger audience & more appealing pitch to sell the matchup.
The solution is pretty simple and financially rewarding for every stakeholder.
Expand the playoff to 16 or 24 teams to satisfy both the G5 qualifiers while also allowing for plenty of extra at-large bids to satisfy the P2 (and Notre Dame lol).
|
|
| 12-10-2025 09:26 AM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-10-2025 09:16 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: The “playoff” is an ESPN invitational. They tried to avoid litigation by including the G5 but the nightmare of 2 G5 teams in a ratings driven 12 team college football playoff is Just too much to bear. The talking heads have been non-stop bashing since the brackets were announced and anything less than single digit differential outcomes will result on a year long nonstop barrage to change the criteria. Too, if this comes down to political climate in Washington, I doubt the G5 will find much support on Capitol Hill, as more pressing issues will drowned out any anti-trust claims they can make.
The irony is JMU is every bit as good on the field as Virginia, and had the Cavaliers won, they wouldn’t be any more competitive as James Madison, but the talking heads would have a larger audience & more appealing pitch to sell the matchup.
The real issue is that there are likely only 4-6 teams (the highest ranked teams) that can actually win a national championship any given year. The difference between those 4-6 teams and others in the tournament is exaggerated by game pairings. And while the media rails against the G-5 teams included, in most years the G-5 rep, if playing against the ACC or B12 rep (not necessarily the conference champ), could expect to win about 40% of the time. But the match-ups against the P-2 schools are more likely blowouts. Further the fact that SMU was competitive in it's first ACC season demonstrates the relative weakness of the ACC. So this isn't just a G-5 issue there is also relative weakness in the ACC & B12 in some years too but they are not the focus arbitrarily which is unfair to the G-5 selection.
I'd argue for a 8 team playoff with a preliminary play-in bracket from an additional 16 schools which would include the champ from each FBS conference not in the top ranked 4 plus at-large highest ranked schools selected via a computer evaluation using SOS, SOR, W/L etc & do away with the committee resulting in the to 4 from the play in bracket joining the top 4 in the to 8 play off.
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2025 09:41 AM by Atlanta.)
|
|
| 12-10-2025 09:33 AM |
|
TigerBlue4Ever
Saved by the grace of God

Posts: 86,007
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 9651
I Root For: Jesus
Location: Feels like Amerika
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:10 AM)shere khan Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:01 AM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: You know how... you KNOW things? Like, they are just a sense in the back of your mind, and then one day they all coalesce into a truth you hadn't formally recognized until now? It just happened to me yesterday.
A G6 team will NEVER win a playoff game.
(Qualifier... Short of a rule change in College Football)
Because they are not good enough? Because they are not talented enough? Neither. Boise beat Oklahoma in 07, the BigXII champs. That certainly would be similar to beating a 5th seeded team in the 12 team bracket. Chris Petersen went on to coach the Broncos for 6 more years after that. I think that will always be one of the wildest of exceptions instead of the rule.
It will NEVER happen to another G6 team because they won't have a full coaching staff whom is fully committed. (BTW... I am CAPITALIZING NEVER in a shameless attempt to pull a rope-a-dope on the football gods).
But it goes like this:
The BEST G6 team let's just saaaay.... Tulane, who is obviously head and shoulders above the rest (in this average year scenario - not THIS year in particular), gets "contacted" about 8 games into the season by some mid to upper tier P4 school. So he either takes his eye off the ball, or blatantly tanks one or two games down the stretch so as to not have to stay at Tulane through the playoff game. That right there takes Tulane off the table as a team that might WIN a playoff game. But fine. Let's just say you give Joe Coach the benefit of the doubt, and he "stays" through the first playoff game. What does HE care if he wins the first game. He's about to go to the power structure where it would NOT be good for a G6 team to win a playoff game. His incentive is to LOSE BIG in that first game. Thereby demonstrating that his next new level (P4) are the only ones worthy of playoff spots.
So In my first scenario, that shifts the playoff spot to lets saaaayyy... Boise. Boise's coach has ALSO been contacted. HE has no incentive to win even his CCG. Most likely this keeps going on down the line of Mountain West, then the New Pac, the MAC until the C-USA conference champions are the playoff team. Some 9-4 team out of the Sunbelt. You can argue about the order of the conferences, but you get my point.
Mainly being:
The Playoff will NEVER get the best out of the G6. That team (coaches and/or players) will have evaporated by the time that first game is played, one way or another.
THE ONLY HOPE is if you get a hometown guy that is actually good GREAT. Someone who will reject all offers. A unicorn hire. Maybe Penny grows into that guy. That would be an example, without the success so far. Football? Who has come out of Memphis with that kind of ability? Former walk-on players that go into coaching right out of college? IDK...
Thoughts?
Why are we waiting on the outcome of the cusa champ game
Penny is done growin
I thought, and may still think, that he reached his ceiling also, and at 1-4 I demanded his head. However, he appears to have righted the ship. If he can bring this disparate group together and keep them performing like they did against Baylor, I'll reluctantly admit that he may have finally learned something from his years of experience here.
If he gets out of his own way, he may finally develop into the coach we've been hoping for over the last few years. If he doesn't, and our trajectory continues to decline, he should do the right thing and retire before the administration is forced to fire him.
Some here alluded to his shortened rotations off the bench, something I've longed for since he arrived, but those could have been by necessity considering the unavailability of three important players. I would prefer it be that he recognized how disruptive to momentum and rhythm that methodology is and has decided on 7 or 8 key players.
I have wanted so badly for Penny to be very successful here, but he just hasn't really done anything to excite me much, at least nothing like the good Cal years.
I know you don't care much about hoops, but it's my first love.
|
|
| 12-10-2025 11:30 AM |
|
TigerBlue4Ever
Saved by the grace of God

Posts: 86,007
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 9651
I Root For: Jesus
Location: Feels like Amerika
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
 
|
|
| 12-10-2025 11:36 AM |
|
TigerBlue4Ever
Saved by the grace of God

Posts: 86,007
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 9651
I Root For: Jesus
Location: Feels like Amerika
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:03 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
me too <wipes small tear away>
Of all the coaches that we've let get away in this century, he is the one we needed to keep. I know we didn't actually "let him get away," but man, just thinking of what might have been had he somehow stayed here and had continued success makes me misty-eyed as well.
|
|
| 12-10-2025 11:42 AM |
|
Tiger46
Legend

Posts: 25,038
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 343
I Root For: Tigers
Location: Colleyville, TX
|
RE: The G6 curse
Anything can happen. Remember FL State being 13-0 and when their QB got hurt they couldn't even compete in the next game.
|
|
| 12-10-2025 05:07 PM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-10-2025 11:42 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:03 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
me too <wipes small tear away>
Of all the coaches that we've let get away in this century, he is the one we needed to keep. I know we didn't actually "let him get away," but man, just thinking of what might have been had he somehow stayed here and had continued success makes me misty-eyed as well.
Funny how things look thinking back. Just doing a little math for our attendance decline over the 6 yrs since Novell left, we could have easily doubled his salary in an attempt to get him to stay (not suggesting we should have). Even so, I think Norvell still would have taken the FSU job. I think OM will find the same thing regarding Kiffin, given the revenue they are likely to lose over the next few years, they could have made Kiffin the highest paid coach in the country but he might not have stayed either. And hey, maybe Huff will be the 2nd coming of Nick Saban & we'll have to do this all over again in 2-3 yrs.
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2025 10:16 PM by Atlanta.)
|
|
| 12-10-2025 10:13 PM |
|
Keeper
Heisman

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
|
RE: The G6 curse
Maybe this time we get lucky. After 3 years and 2 championships maybe we get into a P5 conference and Huff sticks around for a few more years.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 01:32 AM |
|
TigerBlue4Ever
Saved by the grace of God

Posts: 86,007
Joined: Feb 2008
Reputation: 9651
I Root For: Jesus
Location: Feels like Amerika
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-10-2025 10:13 PM)Atlanta Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:42 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:03 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
me too <wipes small tear away>
Of all the coaches that we've let get away in this century, he is the one we needed to keep. I know we didn't actually "let him get away," but man, just thinking of what might have been had he somehow stayed here and had continued success makes me misty-eyed as well.
Funny how things look thinking back. Just doing a little math for our attendance decline over the 6 yrs since Novell left, we could have easily doubled his salary in an attempt to get him to stay (not suggesting we should have). Even so, I think Norvell still would have taken the FSU job. I think OM will find the same thing regarding Kiffin, given the revenue they are likely to lose over the next few years, they could have made Kiffin the highest paid coach in the country but he might not have stayed either. And hey, maybe Huff will be the 2nd coming of Nick Saban & we'll have to do this all over again in 2-3 yrs.
You're absolutely right. And while he may not have stayed even with the higher salary due to the siren call of a power conference, it would have shown everyone else that we are serious about our 2 key programs. Like you, it is my wish that Huff does become the 2nd coming of Saban.
I watched his post presser—the one where no one seemed to be imaginative enough to pass around a wireless mic to the people asking questions. I was thoroughly impressed by the man, by his demeanor, by his intelligence, and by his ability to clearly articulate. Some here will probably accuse me of a racist comment in that last sentence, but being able to communicate effectively is a critical component in anyone's toolbox regardless of profession. He may very well code-switch when talking to his players and close associates, and that's fine, or he may speak that way as a matter of course, but when you're on a podium representing an organization, it's important to enunciate and articulate your speech correctly lest those in attendance think less of your intelligence. He left no doubt about his ability to do that.
I am overall greatly impressed by his personality and the persona he projects. I hope he floors us all with his performance.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 07:56 AM |
|
TIGERBUDDY
All American

Posts: 3,729
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 278
I Root For: MEMPHIS TIGERS
Location: Germantown/Sarasota
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-11-2025 07:56 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-10-2025 10:13 PM)Atlanta Wrote: (12-10-2025 11:42 AM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:03 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
me too <wipes small tear away>
Of all the coaches that we've let get away in this century, he is the one we needed to keep. I know we didn't actually "let him get away," but man, just thinking of what might have been had he somehow stayed here and had continued success makes me misty-eyed as well.
Funny how things look thinking back. Just doing a little math for our attendance decline over the 6 yrs since Novell left, we could have easily doubled his salary in an attempt to get him to stay (not suggesting we should have). Even so, I think Norvell still would have taken the FSU job. I think OM will find the same thing regarding Kiffin, given the revenue they are likely to lose over the next few years, they could have made Kiffin the highest paid coach in the country but he might not have stayed either. And hey, maybe Huff will be the 2nd coming of Nick Saban & we'll have to do this all over again in 2-3 yrs.
You're absolutely right. And while he may not have stayed even with the higher salary due to the siren call of a power conference, it would have shown everyone else that we are serious about our 2 key programs. Like you, it is my wish that Huff does become the 2nd coming of Saban.
I watched his post presser—the one where no one seemed to be imaginative enough to pass around a wireless mic to the people asking questions. I was thoroughly impressed by the man, by his demeanor, by his intelligence, and by his ability to clearly articulate. Some here will probably accuse me of a racist comment in that last sentence, but being able to communicate effectively is a critical component in anyone's toolbox regardless of profession. He may very well code-switch when talking to his players and close associates, and that's fine, or he may speak that way as a matter of course, but when you're on a podium representing an organization, it's important to enunciate and articulate your speech correctly lest those in attendance think less of your intelligence. He left no doubt about his ability to do that.
I am overall greatly impressed by his personality and the persona he projects. I hope he floors us all with his performance.

|
|
| 12-11-2025 08:31 AM |
|