memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,078
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:06 PM |
|
Gusrob2.0
1st String

Posts: 1,797
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 221
I Root For: My Alma Mater - MEMPHIS
Location: Robinson Hall dorm
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
Strength in the trenches and speed on the outside are hard to determine between 2 teams who haven't played the same opponents. I was hopeful against Penn St. I knew we had the speed on the outside. At halftime, I was celebrating how well our lines were holding up.
Games are played for a reason.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:11 PM |
|
2021 Tiger Football!!
All American

Posts: 2,858
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
At kickoff I’d told myself if we stayed within 2TDs it would be a victory. We won as far as I was concerned. Happy.
It was a fun day inside Jerry’s World.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:11 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,078
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:11 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
Strength in the trenches and speed on the outside are hard to determine between 2 teams who haven't played the same opponents. I was hopeful against Penn St. I knew we had the speed on the outside. At halftime, I was celebrating how well our lines were holding up.
Games are played for a reason.
We were much more evenly matched with Penn State than the G5 teams vs the top teams. It was before NIL/transfer portal and the gaps were smaller. We did great, but came up a little short. They ran the same running play against us over and over again and we just couldn’t stop it. But we played well and I thought we had a very good chance to win.
Texas/Vandy are two teams that might miss the playoffs (Vandy especially). But they’d absolutely run all over us and the G5 top teams. I think the best G5s can hang with the Dukes of the world for sure. They’re just not going to compete with the top P4s. Yes, they play the game for a reason, but it will be an absolute beat down.
Could we beat Ohio State? It’s certainly possible, but extremely unlikely.
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 12:21 PM by memtiger1987.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:19 PM |
|
Original Sabretooth
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,820
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 284
I Root For: BMFS
Location: Shady Thicket, GA
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:19 PM |
|
Gusrob2.0
1st String

Posts: 1,797
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 221
I Root For: My Alma Mater - MEMPHIS
Location: Robinson Hall dorm
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:19 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:11 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
Strength in the trenches and speed on the outside are hard to determine between 2 teams who haven't played the same opponents. I was hopeful against Penn St. I knew we had the speed on the outside. At halftime, I was celebrating how well our lines were holding up.
Games are played for a reason.
We were much more evenly matched with Penn State than the G5 teams vs the top teams. It was before NIL/transfer portal and the gaps were smaller. We did great, but came up a little short. They ran the same running play against us over and over again and we just couldn’t stop it. But we played well and I thought we had a very good chance to win.
Texas/Vandy are two teams that might miss the playoffs (Vandy especially). But they’d absolutely run all over us and the G5 top teams. I think the best G5s can hang with the Dukes of the world for sure. They’re just not going to compete with the top P4s. Yes, they play the game for a reason, but it will be an absolute beat down.
Could we beat Ohio State? It’s certainly possible, but extremely unlikely.
I simply won't accept defeat without being defeated. I've never understood guys who walk into a gym and lose all hope before the tip/kickoff.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:37 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,078
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:37 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:19 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:11 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I absolutely did think we’d compete. I went to that game and thought we had a great chance.
JMU vs Vandy/Texas. Gonna be a slaughter. If we played either, it would be the same.
Look what happened when Navy played ND. Bloodbath.
Strength in the trenches and speed on the outside are hard to determine between 2 teams who haven't played the same opponents. I was hopeful against Penn St. I knew we had the speed on the outside. At halftime, I was celebrating how well our lines were holding up.
Games are played for a reason.
We were much more evenly matched with Penn State than the G5 teams vs the top teams. It was before NIL/transfer portal and the gaps were smaller. We did great, but came up a little short. They ran the same running play against us over and over again and we just couldn’t stop it. But we played well and I thought we had a very good chance to win.
Texas/Vandy are two teams that might miss the playoffs (Vandy especially). But they’d absolutely run all over us and the G5 top teams. I think the best G5s can hang with the Dukes of the world for sure. They’re just not going to compete with the top P4s. Yes, they play the game for a reason, but it will be an absolute beat down.
Could we beat Ohio State? It’s certainly possible, but extremely unlikely.
I simply won't accept defeat without being defeated. I've never understood guys who walk into a gym and lose all hope before the tip/kickoff.
I get it. Is it possible? Yes. Is it likely? No.
I’m a believer in never giving up. But the oddsmakers would set a huge spread in a matchup of Texas vs UNT. Again, I’d love for Memphis to be in the CFP. You never know until the game is played, although the odds of us beating Alabama are incredibly low.
Navy thought the same a few weeks ago against ND. We all know how that turned out. Complete beat down.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:48 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,189
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If Duke wins and fails to get in, then the ACC is going to rewrite their CCG rules and have them in place by the following weekend.
But the bigger issue for the ACC is their football strength. With their top two teams floundering, nobody else is proving to be good. Some look to be good until they get exposed.
I thought it was an immense error to bring in the west coast schools when the conference was already needing help in both football and basketball. (The acc has dropped off a cliff in basketball)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:55 PM |
|
Crazier
All American

Posts: 4,548
Joined: Jul 2010
Reputation: 206
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
You're right! Not because a g5 team couldn't beat a p4 team in the playoffs it's because they're gonna take away automatic qualifying spot for the g5 eventually.
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 01:01 PM by Crazier.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:58 PM |
|
2021 Tiger Football!!
All American

Posts: 2,858
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If the ACC eliminated their championship game then Virginia would be the ACC pick. Miami didn’t do what they needed to do.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:00 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,078
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:55 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If Duke wins and fails to get in, then the ACC is going to rewrite their CCG rules and have them in place by the following weekend.
But the bigger issue for the ACC is their football strength. With their top two teams floundering, nobody else is proving to be good. Some look to be good until they get exposed.
I thought it was an immense error to bring in the west coast schools when the conference was already needing help in both football and basketball. (The acc has dropped off a cliff in basketball)
SMU was a nice add. Got them cheap and they have the money and desire to improve their program. They’ve done well so far.
The west coast schools are trash. Make no sense geographically and will be anchors. They got in because of their ties to the other elitist schools. If the ACC went after the best programs available, the top 3 should have been us, Tulane, and USF (based off potential) rather than those 2 schools.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:03 PM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:00 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If the ACC eliminated their championship game then Virginia would be the ACC pick. Miami didn’t do what they needed to do.
On the other hand, in comparison to ND, except for ND's blowout of Syracuse, Miami had as good or better performance against their 4 common opponents & Miami did beat ND. Personally I think ND gets too much slack.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:05 PM |
|
bluecrew
1st String

Posts: 2,438
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 286
I Root For: A stable conference
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
Well the SEC just voted to increase their scholarship limit from 85 to 105, so it is going to be even harder out here on the outside. We are slowly being chocked off- just gotta work like hell to get somewhere else quickly.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:10 PM |
|
2021 Tiger Football!!
All American

Posts: 2,858
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:05 PM)Atlanta Wrote: (12-05-2025 01:00 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If the ACC eliminated their championship game then Virginia would be the ACC pick. Miami didn’t do what they needed to do.
On the other hand, in comparison to ND, except for ND's blowout of Syracuse, Miami had as good or better performance against their 4 common opponents & Miami did beat ND. Personally I think ND gets too much slack.
If you’re gonna lose do it early.
ND did whip USC which helps their resume. Miami hasn’t really beaten anybody since ND. Miami has lost twice since mid October.
I agree it doesn’t seem right but all Miami had to do was not lose to two unranked teams.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:10 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,078
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:10 PM)bluecrew Wrote: Well the SEC just voted to increase their scholarship limit from 85 to 105, so it is going to be even harder out here on the outside. We are slowly being chocked off- just gotta work like hell to get somewhere else quickly.
Hence the importance of this hire. Odds are not in our favor for moving up, but go down to zero if our football team falls off hard. Obviously, winning big certainly helps our case. We’ve done a lot recently (mainly put $$$ into our stadium) and we need to keep up the momentum.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:17 PM |
|
CKMcDan
1st String

Posts: 1,728
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 71
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
In a 12-team playoff, A G5 team beating a P4 team will depend on the matchups.
There is the opinion that the G5 will perennially get into the 12-team CFP field as the #11 or #12 slot. That didn't happen last year, though.
The 2024 Boise team was a quality team with a Heisman-nominated RB. Had Boise been #6, they would have been favored in their 1st round game vs. #11 SMU. Or... had Boise been #5 instead of Texas, I believe Boise would have also been favored against #12 Clemson. Spenser Danielson didn't leave Boise after their playoff run, and he is still HC at Boise.
The other example I offer is Cincinnati making it to the CFP in 2021. That was a 4-team playoff, not a 12-team field, and Cincinnati was a G5 in 2021. If that Cincinnati team, or an equally talented and successful G5 team comes about in upcoming years, I expect we will see a G5 win in the CFP. Luke Fickell coached the year after Cincinnati's CFP berth, and didn't leave for Wisconsin until after the 2022 season.
As the CFP grows to 16 or more teams, the G5's odds only improve.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:24 PM |
|
gotigers1
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,289
Joined: Feb 2005
Reputation: 405
I Root For: Tigers!
Location: Memphis
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
We did compete, quite admirably I might say. I dare say we could have pulled off a win with Norvell calling the shots
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 01:40 PM by gotigers1.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:39 PM |
|
Original Sabretooth
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,820
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 284
I Root For: BMFS
Location: Shady Thicket, GA
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:00 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:19 PM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
I watched JMU play @ Louisville early in the year and thought they were pretty good. In my opinion, they are on par with Memphis or Tulane and would be better than Duke in the playoff. The travesty for the ACC is their system for selecting their champion. Miami is clearly the most marketable team in the ACC, but they have 2 losses (SMU & Louisville). Conferences are going to have to eliminate the championship games, which are financial windfalls, or move to allow ESPN Rankings to determine the conference championship teams. Again, JMU is as good as UVa and better than Duke, but the buying public doesn’t care.
If the ACC eliminated their championship game then Virginia would be the ACC pick. Miami didn’t do what they needed to do.
Would they? Both schools finished the conference season with 2 losses and Miami’s were a little less embarrassing… @ UL & @ SMU. Virginia lost at home to Wake. I think they’d go with the highest ranked team in the CFP rankings.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:45 PM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:39 PM)gotigers1 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
We did compete, quite admirably I might say. I dare say we could have pulled off a win with Norvell calling the shots
I think we score more points against PSU than anyone in the B1G that season
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:57 PM |
|
CKMcDan
1st String

Posts: 1,728
Joined: Apr 2006
Reputation: 71
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 01:39 PM)gotigers1 Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
We did compete, quite admirably I might say. I dare say we could have pulled off a win with Norvell calling the shots
We had 545 yards of offense in that game. Riley Patterson hit long field goals on 6 drives, and we gave up a pick-6. Micah Parsons was certainly a factor, but our defense giving up almost 400 rushing yards was the difference in that game. Norvell calling plays wouldn't have changed that.
I'd say we represented ourselves well in that Cotton Bowl game. We can't blame that loss on Silverfield.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 01:59 PM |
|