geosnooker2000
I got Cleopatra in the basement

Posts: 27,188
Joined: Aug 2006
Reputation: 1582
I Root For: MemTigerFootball
Location: Somerville, TN
|
The G6 curse
You know how... you KNOW things? Like, they are just a sense in the back of your mind, and then one day they all coalesce into a truth you hadn't formally recognized until now? It just happened to me yesterday.
A G6 team will NEVER win a playoff game.
(Qualifier... Short of a rule change in College Football)
Because they are not good enough? Because they are not talented enough? Neither. Boise beat Oklahoma in 07, the BigXII champs. That certainly would be similar to beating a 5th seeded team in the 12 team bracket. Chris Petersen went on to coach the Broncos for 6 more years after that. I think that will always be one of the wildest of exceptions instead of the rule.
It will NEVER happen to another G6 team because they won't have a full coaching staff whom is fully committed. (BTW... I am CAPITALIZING NEVER in a shameless attempt to pull a rope-a-dope on the football gods).
But it goes like this:
The BEST G6 team let's just saaaay.... Tulane, who is obviously head and shoulders above the rest (in this average year scenario - not THIS year in particular), gets "contacted" about 8 games into the season by some mid to upper tier P4 school. So he either takes his eye off the ball, or blatantly tanks one or two games down the stretch so as to not have to stay at Tulane through the playoff game. That right there takes Tulane off the table as a team that might WIN a playoff game. But fine. Let's just say you give Joe Coach the benefit of the doubt, and he "stays" through the first playoff game. What does HE care if he wins the first game. He's about to go to the power structure where it would NOT be good for a G6 team to win a playoff game. His incentive is to LOSE BIG in that first game. Thereby demonstrating that his next new level (P4) are the only ones worthy of playoff spots.
So In my first scenario, that shifts the playoff spot to lets saaaayyy... Boise. Boise's coach has ALSO been contacted. HE has no incentive to win even his CCG. Most likely this keeps going on down the line of Mountain West, then the New Pac, the MAC until the C-USA conference champions are the playoff team. Some 9-4 team out of the Sunbelt. You can argue about the order of the conferences, but you get my point.
Mainly being:
The Playoff will NEVER get the best out of the G6. That team (coaches and/or players) will have evaporated by the time that first game is played, one way or another.
THE ONLY HOPE is if you get a hometown guy that is actually good GREAT. Someone who will reject all offers. A unicorn hire. Maybe Penny grows into that guy. That would be an example, without the success so far. Football? Who has come out of Memphis with that kind of ability? Former walk-on players that go into coaching right out of college? IDK...
Thoughts?
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:01 AM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:01 AM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: You know how... you KNOW things? Like, they are just a sense in the back of your mind, and then one day they all coalesce into a truth you hadn't formally recognized until now? It just happened to me yesterday.
A G6 team will NEVER win a playoff game.
(Qualifier... Short of a rule change in College Football)
Because they are not good enough? Because they are not talented enough? Neither. Boise beat Oklahoma in 07, the BigXII champs. That certainly would be similar to beating a 5th seeded team in the 12 team bracket. Chris Petersen went on to coach the Broncos for 6 more years after that. I think that will always be one of the wildest of exceptions instead of the rule.
It will NEVER happen to another G6 team because they won't have a full coaching staff whom is fully committed. (BTW... I am CAPITALIZING NEVER in a shameless attempt to pull a rope-a-dope on the football gods).
But it goes like this:
The BEST G6 team let's just saaaay.... Tulane, who is obviously head and shoulders above the rest (in this average year scenario - not THIS year in particular), gets "contacted" about 8 games into the season by some mid to upper tier P4 school. So he either takes his eye off the ball, or blatantly tanks one or two games down the stretch so as to not have to stay at Tulane through the playoff game. That right there takes Tulane off the table as a team that might WIN a playoff game. But fine. Let's just say you give Joe Coach the benefit of the doubt, and he "stays" through the first playoff game. What does HE care if he wins the first game. He's about to go to the power structure where it would NOT be good for a G6 team to win a playoff game. His incentive is to LOSE BIG in that first game. Thereby demonstrating that his next new level (P4) are the only ones worthy of playoff spots.
So In my first scenario, that shifts the playoff spot to lets saaaayyy... Boise. Boise's coach has ALSO been contacted. HE has no incentive to win even his CCG. Most likely this keeps going on down the line of Mountain West, then the New Pac, the MAC until the C-USA conference champions are the playoff team. Some 9-4 team out of the Sunbelt. You can argue about the order of the conferences, but you get my point.
Mainly being:
The Playoff will NEVER get the best out of the G6. That team (coaches and/or players) will have evaporated by the time that first game is played, one way or another.
THE ONLY HOPE is if you get a hometown guy that is actually good GREAT. Someone who will reject all offers. A unicorn hire. Maybe Penny grows into that guy. That would be an example, without the success so far. Football? Who has come out of Memphis with that kind of ability? Former walk-on players that go into coaching right out of college? IDK...
Thoughts?
NIL. The top programs are like the NE Patriots with Brady and we’re playing in the XFL. They take our best players and pay them more. And, since there are no contracts, they do this every year.
They poach our coaches too. But, in the end, they have better players and much deeper benches.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:05 AM |
|
geosnooker2000
I got Cleopatra in the basement

Posts: 27,188
Joined: Aug 2006
Reputation: 1582
I Root For: MemTigerFootball
Location: Somerville, TN
|
RE: The G6 curse
Well, I always go back to the numbers on that argument. There are (more or less) the same number of players coming out of high school every year, and until the NCAA allows the P4 teams to have MORE players on their roster, the same "4* and 5*" players are all going to go to the P4 leagues. Just like they always have.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:09 AM |
|
shere khan
Southerner

Posts: 76,777
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10834
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:01 AM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: You know how... you KNOW things? Like, they are just a sense in the back of your mind, and then one day they all coalesce into a truth you hadn't formally recognized until now? It just happened to me yesterday.
A G6 team will NEVER win a playoff game.
(Qualifier... Short of a rule change in College Football)
Because they are not good enough? Because they are not talented enough? Neither. Boise beat Oklahoma in 07, the BigXII champs. That certainly would be similar to beating a 5th seeded team in the 12 team bracket. Chris Petersen went on to coach the Broncos for 6 more years after that. I think that will always be one of the wildest of exceptions instead of the rule.
It will NEVER happen to another G6 team because they won't have a full coaching staff whom is fully committed. (BTW... I am CAPITALIZING NEVER in a shameless attempt to pull a rope-a-dope on the football gods).
But it goes like this:
The BEST G6 team let's just saaaay.... Tulane, who is obviously head and shoulders above the rest (in this average year scenario - not THIS year in particular), gets "contacted" about 8 games into the season by some mid to upper tier P4 school. So he either takes his eye off the ball, or blatantly tanks one or two games down the stretch so as to not have to stay at Tulane through the playoff game. That right there takes Tulane off the table as a team that might WIN a playoff game. But fine. Let's just say you give Joe Coach the benefit of the doubt, and he "stays" through the first playoff game. What does HE care if he wins the first game. He's about to go to the power structure where it would NOT be good for a G6 team to win a playoff game. His incentive is to LOSE BIG in that first game. Thereby demonstrating that his next new level (P4) are the only ones worthy of playoff spots.
So In my first scenario, that shifts the playoff spot to lets saaaayyy... Boise. Boise's coach has ALSO been contacted. HE has no incentive to win even his CCG. Most likely this keeps going on down the line of Mountain West, then the New Pac, the MAC until the C-USA conference champions are the playoff team. Some 9-4 team out of the Sunbelt. You can argue about the order of the conferences, but you get my point.
Mainly being:
The Playoff will NEVER get the best out of the G6. That team (coaches and/or players) will have evaporated by the time that first game is played, one way or another.
THE ONLY HOPE is if you get a hometown guy that is actually good GREAT. Someone who will reject all offers. A unicorn hire. Maybe Penny grows into that guy. That would be an example, without the success so far. Football? Who has come out of Memphis with that kind of ability? Former walk-on players that go into coaching right out of college? IDK...
Thoughts?
Why are we waiting on the outcome of the cusa champ game
Penny is done growin
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 11:11 AM by shere khan.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:10 AM |
|
geosnooker2000
I got Cleopatra in the basement

Posts: 27,188
Joined: Aug 2006
Reputation: 1582
I Root For: MemTigerFootball
Location: Somerville, TN
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:10 AM)shere khan Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:01 AM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: You know how...
Why are we waiting on the outcome of the cusa champ game
Penny is done growin
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:16 AM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:09 AM)geosnooker2000 Wrote: Well, I always go back to the numbers on that argument. There are (more or less) the same number of players coming out of high school every year, and until the NCAA allows the P4 teams to have MORE players on their roster, the same "4* and 5*" players are all going to go to the P4 leagues. Just like they always have.
It’s not just getting the best recruits, it’s also poaching our players. In the past, we could find “diamonds in the rough”, or develop under recruited players. Sitting out a year to transfer was a big obstacle. Now, it’s just unlimited free agency. We develop the players, and they pay them more to play for them. We’re just a farm league now. There are almost no Seth Henigan’s out there. Look at the better AAC QBs, playing for P4s now. Brown (USF) was an exception, but he’ll be gone next year.
It’s an awful system and stacks the deck towards programs willing to pay millions for certain players. We just can’t compete.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:17 AM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
Note: Josh Pate and all of these podcasters and media personalities screaming about G5 needing their own playoffs will NEVER talk about them EVER again just like Division 2, once they go ahead and do it. That’s why G5 programs correctly resists those calls because they know the networks and media will make them irrelevant and the money will really dry really up and their programs will flounder
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 11:18 AM by BigTigerMike.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:18 AM |
|
Gusrob2.0
1st String

Posts: 1,797
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 221
I Root For: My Alma Mater - MEMPHIS
Location: Robinson Hall dorm
|
RE: The G6 curse
Well thought out and well expressed point. There are many biases to overcome at Memphis. Systems to obtain championship are skewed against us - AAC gets 1 team in 68 team bracket! CFP sham! Recruiting skewed against us. Land James Wiseman and then NCAA rules against us (would it do that a blue blood? NO).
We HAVE to get a seat at the big table SOON. Then we can help some of this. And right now our FB HC hire is on full display. We are auditioning for the big table, whether Ed Scott sees it or not.
Side note: I hope Dr Scott is worried about Memphis' positioning, not his own career positioning. In other words, don't try to be MrBigStuff and botch this deal just to show you're more powerful than some think.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:21 AM |
|
geosnooker2000
I got Cleopatra in the basement

Posts: 27,188
Joined: Aug 2006
Reputation: 1582
I Root For: MemTigerFootball
Location: Somerville, TN
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:21 AM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Well thought out and well expressed point. There are many biases to overcome at Memphis. Systems to obtain championship are skewed against us - AAC gets 1 team in 68 team bracket! CFP sham! Recruiting skewed against us. Land James Wiseman and then NCAA rules against us (would it do that a blue blood? NO).
We HAVE to get a seat at the big table SOON. Then we can help some of this. And right now our FB HC hire is on full display. We are auditioning for the big table, whether Ed Scott sees it or not.
Side note: I hope Dr Scott is worried about Memphis' positioning, not his own career positioning. In other words, don't try to be MrBigStuff and botch this deal just to show you're more powerful than some think.
That right there is just another phase of the same thing my OP was about. Good call.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:29 AM |
|
Original Sabretooth
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,820
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 284
I Root For: BMFS
Location: Shady Thicket, GA
|
RE: The G6 curse
There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:41 AM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:46 AM |
|
MemTigers1998
Hall of Famer

Posts: 20,665
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 2757
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
Put Tulane, NT, JMU, Virginia and Duke into a “mini” conference and let them all play. UVA and Duke finish 4th and 5th. What is gonna happen is 12 team all at large. The p2 doesn’t even want the B12 and especially the ACC in this thing
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 11:48 AM by MemTigers1998.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:46 AM |
|
MemTigers1998
Hall of Famer

Posts: 20,665
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 2757
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:21 AM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Side note: I hope Dr Scott is worried about Memphis' positioning, not his own career positioning. In other words, don't try to be MrBigStuff and botch this deal just to show you're more powerful than some think.
Like I said in another thread, turning off a fan base that is already losing interest by ignoring your boosters and making a lazy hire, isnt a good look
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:51 AM |
|
AlonsoWDC
Hall of Famer

Posts: 11,967
Joined: Sep 2015
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Memphis
Location: East Memphis
|
RE: The G6 curse
It's all.by design too.
There won't be a G6 playoff berth come next contract.
Hell, ACC and Big XII oughta worry about that too.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:52 AM |
|
shere khan
Southerner

Posts: 76,777
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10834
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:51 AM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:21 AM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Side note: I hope Dr Scott is worried about Memphis' positioning, not his own career positioning. In other words, don't try to be MrBigStuff and botch this deal just to show you're more powerful than some think.
Like I said in another thread, turning off a fan base that is already losing interest by ignoring your boosters and making a lazy hire, isnt a good look
This isnt true is it. Cant be this stupid. Just cant be
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 11:56 AM by shere khan.)
|
|
| 12-05-2025 11:56 AM |
|
Gusrob2.0
1st String

Posts: 1,797
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 221
I Root For: My Alma Mater - MEMPHIS
Location: Robinson Hall dorm
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:00 PM |
|
EarthBoundMisfit
Tongue tied and twisted

Posts: 18,713
Joined: May 2005
Reputation: 1548
I Root For: CardiacAblation
Location: Madisonville,KY
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:01 PM |
|
Gusrob2.0
1st String

Posts: 1,797
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation: 221
I Root For: My Alma Mater - MEMPHIS
Location: Robinson Hall dorm
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 12:01 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-05-2025 12:00 PM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:46 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:41 AM)Original Sabretooth Wrote: There could be 2 G5 schools in this 12 team playoff & if that happens I think ESPN will kill the G5 qualifier. Its not about competition… its about money and people are not going to buy tickets and watch games pitting Ole Miss v Tulane & Oregon vs JMU. I think they’re willing to sacrifice 1 game to appease the G5, but 2 games would be too much… even though JMU is better than Duke & likely on par with UVa.
Let’s be real here. How would JMU stack up against a Texas or Vandy?
Games are played on the field. Everything else is speculation. ESPN loves to use BS fodder like this to dictate rankings as well as NCAAT and CFP.
Did you think we'd compete well against Penn St in 2019 Cotton Bowl? A defense with Micah Parsons, Jayson Oweh, Amani Oruwariye......
I'd have liked our chances better with Norvell calling the plays
 me too <wipes small tear away>
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:03 PM |
|
Marc Mensa
You'll Get Nothing and Like It

Posts: 16,312
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 934
I Root For: The Underdog
Location: Samaria
|
RE: The G6 curse
There is a finite amount of talent that can compete at P4 level and that cutoff really does not extend beyond a dozen or so G5 schools, which is why I have continually called for a combining of the best of the PAC, MWC & the American. Beyond a dozen or so schools within those conferences, the drop off in financial commitment drops precipitously. The Sun Belt, CUSA & MAC can’t hold onto their players and can no longer field a team capable of competing against the middle tier of the P4; and there are bottom feeders within the AAC that are more similar to Ark State than Tulane. Yes, JMU is a unicorn and likely should be picked up by the American but the rest of those leagues can’t compete. If we are going to survive and not get lumped in with the dregs of the G5, then we have to form a best of the rest.
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:03 PM |
|
MemTigers1998
Hall of Famer

Posts: 20,665
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 2757
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: The G6 curse
(12-05-2025 11:56 AM)shere khan Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:51 AM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: (12-05-2025 11:21 AM)Gusrob2.0 Wrote: Side note: I hope Dr Scott is worried about Memphis' positioning, not his own career positioning. In other words, don't try to be MrBigStuff and botch this deal just to show you're more powerful than some think.
Like I said in another thread, turning off a fan base that is already losing interest by ignoring your boosters and making a lazy hire, isnt a good look
This isnt true is it. Cant be this stupid. Just cant be
If you believe what is being said here and a few other places, it is. People saying the boosters want Mullen and have agreed to make it happen. Then again, Mullen might not even be interested. But you can’t tell me that Memphis & UNLV are on equal footing as far as football programs go. Playing in Allegient over LBMS is about the only advantage they have. Or maybe Mullen prefers Vegas casinos & hookers over Tunica and crack ho’s here. IDK
|
|
| 12-05-2025 12:05 PM |
|