GoBuckeyes1047
All American

Posts: 3,076
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
|
RE: If the FBS Conferences still had divisions....
(12-06-2025 05:32 AM)schmolik Wrote: (12-05-2025 07:30 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (12-05-2025 06:11 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: (12-03-2025 09:15 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Thank goodness we've removed them.
Removing divisions was a good idea in theory, but it's been poor in execution, especially this season. These arbitrary tiebreaker rules make no sense at all.
How is it that a 7-5 Duke team can get in over a 10-2 Miami (FL) team?
If divisions were still in use, Virginia would probably be playing Miami (FL) tomorrow.
I was kind enough to not comment on your Big Ten divisions list in the Big Ten thread, because I didn't want to rip up a proposal I assumed you put little effort into, and because I've made my feelings on the Big Ten divisions quite clear over the years and didn't feel the need to do so again but okay, here it goes since you liked it enough to turn it into a whole thread.
Your Big Ten proposal stunk. It resulted in Northwestern and Illinois, in-state rivals, playing eachother once every nine years. Or, if that rivalry was protected, in those schools playing other teams from the other division never in-conference in the regular season. At best you could switch Illinois and Wisconsin in a way that keeps in-state rivalries intact but destroys Wisconsin's two big out of state series. Or do the same with OSU-Michigan, which I am sure will go over swimmingly. The only thing which has gone wrong with divisionless so far is the ACC doing tie-breakers wrong. But unlike with a bad division you can actually fix tie-breakers in the off season.
Speaking of bad divisions, there is literally zero way to guarantee that a divisional set-up actually gets the two best, or even two good, teams in. In 2013 the third best Legend team was sent to the CCG due to OSU and PSU being under sanction- and won! That was followed with a solid decade of east-west divisions in the Big Ten and rather than help out or even out the conference the gulf in quality and media interest only widened. And instead of ensuring the CCG always had two good teams it instead made it a joke, ensuring that the "real Big Ten Championship" was played a week early in Columbus or Ann Arbor.
And the ACC, with an un-even number of teams, literally cannot do divisions without one or another team playing more or fewer conference games than the others. Its not like Duke has been avoiding the key ACC players this year anyway. They played GT, they played UVA, thats two of the three teams ranked higher than them and doesn't even bring up OOC matches with now-ranked Tulane, then ranked Illinois and usually good but not this year Clemson. Duke doesn't have a weak ACC schedule problem at all, their problem was OOC scheduling, losing two tough and entirely unnecessary OOC match ups in a row and then a third to shockingly good UConn. And having divisions still doesn't get Miami in the CCG, assuming they shared that division with SMU.
With 18 teams, you have to break some pair up. Technically Penn State is "Unrivaled" but oh heck no are you moving us out West, not to mention it defeats any geographic saving of divisions if the Western schools have to travel to PSU. You could move Michigan State out West but then what about UM-MSU?
I can't speak for all Illinois alumni including those on this board but I was never fully on board with Northwestern as a rival and if you had to break up any rivalry in the middle I'd say break us up, especially if we get to stay in the East. I'd probably think of Northwestern the way Tennessee thinks of Vanderbilt. They're not the little brother, they're the nerdy brother we're embarrassed to be associated with.
When I was at Illinois we played Northwestern in October all four years. Illinois and Northwestern played October 1 in ... 2011 (although Illinois and Northwestern was the Big Ten season finale 1999-2010)! Meanwhile Michigan and Ohio State haven't played earlier than November 17 (they used to not play Thanksgiving weekend) since ... 1933! Indiana-Purdue? 1905!!!! Actually Minnesota-Wisconsin was a recent Rivalry Weekend addition, they played in October as late as 2012. It looks like Iowa-Minnesota was more often the Rivalry Weekend game in the 1990's and 2000's, obviously Nebraska replaced Minnesota as Iowa's Rivalry Weekend rival and Minnesota got Wisconsin. You wouldn't know that last weekend though when Minnesota stormed the field against a four win Wisconsin .
Honestly, IF we went back to true divisions, and we won't, it's probably Leaders and Legends again with protected rivals.
Best guess, something like this trying to preserve as many rivalries as possible.
Ohio St.-Michigan
Penn St.-Michigan St.
Maryland-Rutgers
Purdue-Indiana
Nebraska-Iowa
Illinois-Wisconsin
Northwestern-Minnesota
USC-UCLA
Washington-Oregon
Illinois and Northwestern could alternate Wisconsin and Minnesota as protected rivals, but I think keeping Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa in a division together is a must. I thought about having USC-UCLA in 1 division and Oregon-Washington in the other division so they could alternate playing each other like I did with Northwestern-Illinois and Wisconsin-Minnesota, but it would be unfair for 1 division having an annual game in Cali unless you swapped the west coast teams every 2 years. Again, this won't ever happen, especially with 9 conference games because you'd have 8 teams you would never play outside CCG, potential WCGs, or maybe the CFP/bowl games.
Obviously, the more realistic option is a modified 1-8/8 with defacto divisions while still playing everyone 3x in 6 years unless you have more than or less than 1 annual rival as I would keep current flex protect rivalries intact, but Michigan, Illinois, and Purdue would see Iowa, Minnesota, and Wisconsin just 2x in 6 years to ensure their multiple rivals are still annual while Iowa sees another 3 teams just 2x in 6 years while Penn St. would pick up those 3 teams for 4x in 6 years to make up for no protected rivals (probably 3 of Rutgers, Maryland, Michigan St., Ohio St., and maybe Indiana). That in my opinion can better balance schedules while ensuring teams play each other more frequently (currently 2 or 3 times in 5 years depending on number of rivals protected) and you could establish divisions with this, though it would probably confuse casuals fans with teams changing divisions every 1-3 seasons so probably best to stick to the divisionless format officially or defacto divisions.
|
|