(12-01-2025 07:33 AM)billybobby777 Wrote: These conferences are just too bloated. They need to be thinned down to 9 or 10 so everyone can play each other and you get a true conference champion. Several schools should form their own “Independent” coalition to thin the ranks out:
Texas
ND
USC
Washington
Stanford
CAL
Miami
Florida St
Louisville
West Virginia
Memphis
Tulane
Cincinnati
ECU
SMU
UCF
USF
Navy
Army
Uconn
Those would be FB only and they could make some regional basketball Olympic sports schedules together in a new Olympic sports confederation if they have to move those sports out of their current conferences.
As a fan of a team that is independent, on a personal level I'd love to see more independents. But I seriously doubt it will happen.
As a practical matter, how many college football programs could pull off ND-style independence? Fifteen, maybe? And that number probably errs on the side of generosity.
And as Frank points out, conference membership means a bigger media rights payout due to the fact that a conference has a much larger inventory available. it's also worth noting that independence works, if at all, only for football. Basketball and olympic sports still require conference membership. That adds an additional level of complexity to independence that a lot of athletic departments simply don't want to deal with.
Notre Dame elected to remain at least nominally independent largely because independence is part of our DNA, as well as part of our tradition. That's something that a lot of non-Notre Dame fans apparently don't understand.
As a practical matter, who might be candidates for ND-style independence? There were rumors for awhile that Texas wanted to go independent for football, which might help explain why Texas pushed for ND to join the Big XII for basketball/olympic sports when the first iteration of the Big East began to fall apart. But since Texas joined the SEC that appears to be off the table. So who's left? Maybe Michigan and USC, if opposition to the B1G's proposed private equity deal is a hill they're willing to die on. Maybe Florida State, if they really want out of the ACC and if a P2 offer is not forthcoming. That about it, though. In fact, I'd argue that football independence is seen as too difficult a road for many. Stanford and Cal joined the ACC rather than go independent for football. Nothing against the ACC in that regard, and Stanford and Cal were joining a number of like-minded institutions in so doing. But it created travel nightmares for both schools, particularly in olympic sports.
And even if you did see Michigan, USC and Florida State go independent, what's next? For a basketball/olympic sports conference, the ACC appears unlikely in this scenario -- there would be bad blood between the ACC and Florida State, and there appears still to be resentment of the ACC from ND over the ACC taking Miami's side in the CFP dispute (ND likely would have to mediate some of the negotiations.) Perhaps they could form a new conference with enough other football playing schools to have a football conference, I don't know.
As for the OP's list, the second part of that list is definitely a non-starter. As things currently stand, those teams at least have nominal access to the CFP (three of them play in A4 conferences). If they go independent, they lose that access, and it doesn't come back unless the CFP expands to
at least 24 teams, without the B1G's coveted multi-AQ bids per conference.