(11-30-2025 05:18 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: The Big 12 didn't have the leverage/hierarchical power.
No one was leaving the SEC for another conference.
No one was leaving the Pac-12 and the Rose Bowl for the Big 12 (until the Pac-12 became untenable in 2022). There's a reason Colorado left the Big 12 for the Pac-12 and a handful of other Big 12 schools almost did circa 2010.
The hierarchical power wasn't as established in 2010 as it was in 2023.
Academically, the Big 12 was a superior conference to the SEC. It had AAU schools in Nebraska, Colorado, ISU, Kansas, Missouri, Texas, and TAMU. I think the SEC only had Vanderbilt and Florida. I think it was only behind the B1G and the PAC in terms of AAU membership. For many years, Texas perceived the SEC as academically inferior and bad alignment for their institution. A&M had a much stronger cultural affinity and did not share the same concerns.
The Big 12's status eroded because it was good to great at many things but was never the "best" in any category (athletics, academics, markets, etc.) It's location is both blessing and curse. Being centralized meant you could have teams conceivably join from anywhere or be poached from anywhere. In the first rounds of realignment this hurt the conference, but in later rounds it has helped.
Institutionally, the Big 12 schools were never totally aligned on anything. Texas wants more money, more eyeballs, more markets. A&M wants to get out of UT's shadow and wants in the SEC. OU shifted from their associations in the Big 8 to prioritizing their relationship with UT above all else. Mizzou wanted to be a B1G school. Colorado wanted to join the more progressive and academically elite PAC.
Nebraska resented the success of OU and Texas and the loss of the Neb/OU annual rivalry games.
Many of the larger programs felt that they owed nothing to the smaller the smaller programs and felt that equal sharing or a conference network would result in less money for Texas' of the world. Frankly, the larger programs did not consider themselves to be peers with the rest of the conference and would act in their own interests instead of as a cohesive whole. Long term this killed the conference.
Expansion wasn't really on the radar because there weren't incentives to expand without a network. BYU has always been a P4 level program and IMO should've been in the PAC or Big 12 long before now, but their background and rules make them somewhat of a pariah amongst the academics and university presidents. A series of games is fine, but a business arrangement with equal membership? For many, that was a no. Utah was rising program but without any history with the Big 12 or Big 8.
Expansion didn't occur after Nebraska and Colorado left. Moving to a round robin was considered an enhancement rather than adding weaker programs. Colorado was considered an addition by subtraction. Nebraska was irreplaceable. Expansion only became necessary once A&M and Mizzou left. The additions of TCU and WVU were only used to support the media contract requirements. Then Texas fought expansion tooth and nail for the next decade. Their AD would float ridiculous notions of netting Notre Dame and then miss out on actual strategic targets like Louisville.
If the Big 12 was cohesive whole during this time, I do think there may have been a window or path to growing the conference bigger and into something that would've competed with the B1G and SEC. But market dynamics changed and Texas eventually relented on their posturing with the SEC and joined.
I think A&M to the SEC was probably the biggest and most understated shift in the conference balance. They were/are a real threat to Texas' dominance over the state of Texas. The teams A&M plays in the SEC are by far of more interest to the casual football fan in Texas than teams from the PAC or B1G. Even with teams like OU in a package deal, I don't believe Texas could maintain their cultural dominance if they were in the PAC or B1G. I think Texas also realized this, along with the fundamental changes in college sports, and decided to join A&M.