Fresno Fanatic
1st String

Posts: 1,082
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 90
I Root For: Fresno State
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 05:07 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote: (11-30-2025 04:51 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
^THIS!^ is how it “should” be!!!
But it won’t happen because this is CFP LLC, not, NFL LLC (or whatever their respective legal terms are).
EVERY TEAM that wants to be in the CFP…and it SHOULD be 16, and NO MORE than…HAS to play 13 games!!
*I will add that BOTH ccg participants MUST be in the top 25 for their respective conference(s) to get autobid status for their ccg winner. So…ACC better NOT have Duke in their ccg! LMAO
**And 5 loss Duke better NOT be in the final CFP top 25 poll!!!
As things stand today, w/ 12 team playoffs…
1). Miami “should be” OUT!
2). Notre Dame “should be” OUT!
3). Big12 runner up “should be” OUT!
4). American champ “should be” IN!
5). JMU “should be” IN if Duke is ACC Champ and JMU beats Troy!!!
So we BETTER go to 16 AND “should” follow what AndyBible proposes…IF, the CFP “wants” to be “just”.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:28 PM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 04:30 PM)bill dazzle Wrote: As many on the board know, I'm a fan of both Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. But if both programs ever make it to the 12-team playoff (UM from the AC and MTSU from C-USA), both the playoff specifically and college football in general will have some problems.
Two members of the G leagues this year could land invites to the playoff if Duke beats Virginia. And if that happens, we can all be assured the system will be updated so as to prevent that from ever taking place again.
Is it fair? Not necessarily. Would I like to see two G members go? In many respects, yes. But the big boys are not going to play around with this situation. If say James Madison and North Texas/Tulane both make it this year ... change will be in order.
The easiest way to do that, it would appear, would be for the ACC to copy a page from the AC and add CFP ranking to its tiebreakers. As it happened this year, the ACC had a five-way tie for second place between Duke, Georgia Tech, Miami, Pitt and SMU. Obviously, head-to-head wasn't going to break that tie. Had they inserted CFP rankings in their tiebreakers behind head-to-head, Miami wins the tiebreaker and faces Virginia in the ACC CCG. I don't know exactly how Duke won the tiebreaker, but apparently they did.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:33 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 05:33 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-30-2025 04:30 PM)bill dazzle Wrote: As many on the board know, I'm a fan of both Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. But if both programs ever make it to the 12-team playoff (UM from the AC and MTSU from C-USA), both the playoff specifically and college football in general will have some problems.
Two members of the G leagues this year could land invites to the playoff if Duke beats Virginia. And if that happens, we can all be assured the system will be updated so as to prevent that from ever taking place again.
Is it fair? Not necessarily. Would I like to see two G members go? In many respects, yes. But the big boys are not going to play around with this situation. If say James Madison and North Texas/Tulane both make it this year ... change will be in order.
The easiest way to do that, it would appear, would be for the ACC to copy a page from the AC and add CFP ranking to its tiebreakers. As it happened this year, the ACC had a five-way tie for second place between Duke, Georgia Tech, Miami, Pitt and SMU. Obviously, head-to-head wasn't going to break that tie. Had they inserted CFP rankings in their tiebreakers behind head-to-head, Miami wins the tiebreaker and faces Virginia in the ACC CCG. I don't know exactly how Duke won the tiebreaker, but apparently they did.
I think it was conference winning percentage of the opponents...
For something like basketball, could make sense. But for football having it go to the CFP rankings make a ton of sense.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:40 PM |
|
Fresno Fanatic
1st String

Posts: 1,082
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 90
I Root For: Fresno State
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 05:10 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: (11-30-2025 05:07 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote: (11-30-2025 04:51 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
^THIS!^ is how it “should” be!!!
But it won’t happen because this is CFP LLC, not, NFL LLC (or whatever their respective legal terms are).
EVERY TEAM that wants to be in the CFP…and it SHOULD be 16…HAS to play 13 games!!!!
I expanded it to 24 teams since that's how many teams participate at the FCS level.
Yep. And, right fn on!
Every team in the cfplayoffs SHOULD play 13 games!!
If Notre Dame gets a sweetheart deal, so should the rest of the top 24/25!!!!!…and/or ND needs to PROVE their fn selves!!!
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:42 PM |
|
andybible1995
Banned
Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 05:42 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote: (11-30-2025 05:10 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: (11-30-2025 05:07 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote: (11-30-2025 04:51 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
^THIS!^ is how it “should” be!!!
But it won’t happen because this is CFP LLC, not, NFL LLC (or whatever their respective legal terms are).
EVERY TEAM that wants to be in the CFP…and it SHOULD be 16…HAS to play 13 games!!!!
I expanded it to 24 teams since that's how many teams participate at the FCS level.
Yep. And, right fn on!
Every team in the cfplayoffs SHOULD play 13 games!!
If Notre Dame gets a sweetheart deal, so should the rest of the top 24/25!!!!!…and/or ND needs to PROVE their fn selves!!!
Well, I'm not sure about a 13th game, unless everyone is willing to play on Week 0. However, a 16 team CFP is not going to be enough. The ACC and Big XII will complain about a lack of representation.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 06:11 PM |
|