lance99
1st String

Posts: 1,284
Joined: Jun 2013
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Akron Zips
Location:
|
How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify having 4+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2025 03:03 PM by lance99.)
|
|
| 11-30-2025 02:30 PM |
|
The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
Step one, UNC, Duke, Clemson and FSU join the SEC....
Or, alternately, step one, the playoffs expand to 32 teams...
|
|
| 11-30-2025 02:48 PM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,549
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify have 5+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
Oh the naïveté. I’m hardly an SEC fan, but whenever I see a statement based on how the Committee supposedly cannot justify X number of SEC teams in the playoff (regardless of the year or circumstances), the Committee’s retort is, “Hold my beer.” That is where the rabbit hole gets stomped out quickly.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 02:52 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
The SEC Butthurt is real. Very real.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 02:55 PM |
|
IWokeUpLikeThis
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,109
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
Steps 1 and 2: Reality
Step 3: Fantasy
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:06 PM |
|
Lurker Above
1st String

Posts: 2,232
Joined: Apr 2011
Reputation: 330
I Root For: UGA
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify have 4+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
Even if all of that happened, there would not be 3 G5 schools in the playoffs. The SEC, B1G and Big12 champions would still be in the playoffs ranked higher than any G5 conference champion, and none of the G5 champions would be in the top 10, so that would leave only the 4th and 5th highest rated conference champions available for the playoffs.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:06 PM |
|
Native Georgian
Legend

Posts: 31,618
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1428
I Root For: TULANE+GA.STATE
Location: Decatur GA
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
The Committee would invite an 8-4 team from SEC or B1G before they would allow 3(!!!) G5 teams to participate. No, seriously, they would do that, if the alternative was having UNLV, JMU, and UNT/Tulane all in the same Playoff.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:08 PM |
|
wleakr
Special Teams

Posts: 697
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 17
I Root For: Eastern Mich
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
What you suggest isn’t happening no matter how many steps you analyze.
There are 5 spots for champs: BIG, SEC AND B12 champs will get 3 spots regardless of who wins the CCG.
American champ will definitely get a spot.
The other spot would go to JMU if they win or Virginia if they win.
If both of them lose, Duke over UNLV.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:08 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 03:06 PM)Lurker Above Wrote: (11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify have 4+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
Even if all of that happened, there would not be 3 G5 schools in the playoffs. The SEC, B1G and Big12 champions would still be in the playoffs ranked higher than any G5 conference champion, and none of the G5 champions would be in the top 10, so that would leave only the 4th and 5th highest rated conference champions available for the playoffs.
Right.
Oh and Miami Ohio winning the MAC title game is MEANINGLESS even in this mornoic scenario. North Texas is a G5 team.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:09 PM |
|
lance99
1st String

Posts: 1,284
Joined: Jun 2013
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Akron Zips
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:52 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Oh the naïveté. I’m hardly an SEC fan, but whenever I see a statement based on how the Committee supposedly cannot justify X number of SEC teams in the playoff (regardless of the year or circumstances), the Committee’s retort is, “Hold my beer.” That is where the rabbit hole gets stomped out quickly.
Hold on Frank.
I wanted to include Vanderbilt and New Mexico in my post(I wanted their Day in the Sun), but they started so far behind and with the Vandy losses and the MWC Tiebreaker Rules, I could not do it.
It is safe to assume that we all know that the SEC got too many teams since this Playoff started year over year and I am no SEC Fan.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 03:54 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:52 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify have 5+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
Oh the naïveté. I’m hardly an SEC fan, but whenever I see a statement based on how the Committee supposedly cannot justify X number of SEC teams in the playoff (regardless of the year or circumstances), the Committee’s retort is, “Hold my beer.” That is where the rabbit hole gets stomped out quickly.
How quickly we forget that the SEC only had 3 teams in the CFP a year ago. The Big 12 was a serious threat to get 3 in this year up until the very last minute, and the B1G could have easily gotten 4 in (for the 2nd year in a row!) if Michigan had beaten OSU yesterday.
This feels like a variation upon Quo's claims about how incredibly, mind-bogglingly great every single SEC team and schedule are compared to any other schools/conferences, only with an anti- rather than pro-SEC slant. Instead of looking at Conferences as a whole, we need to evaluate each team, each week. Alabama's schedule is FAR tougher than Ole Miss' schedule in 2025, even though they're in the same conference. A&M's is somewhere in the middle. What any of us did in 2024, or what the other teams in their conference did back then, that's all meaningless. All that matters is what any team the Committee is looking is looking at has done in 2025. Now, I might get extremely peeved at them for putting too much weight on the eye test or not enough weight on SOS, and don't get me started on injured QBs, but at least I think they're TRYING to put the 12 best teams of the current year into the CFP, just as they have in every year that we've had a committee (though it used to be 4 instead of 12 ofc). The only 2 clearly incorrect moves they've made since the formation of the committee were putting Alabama ahead of FSU in 2023 and putting Alabama BEHIND SMU in 2024. Sucks for FSU, and I ranted about that one until I was blue in the face as many of you no doubt remember, but, overall, I'd say that every Conference thus far is all square.
If the SEC ends up with #s 3-9, go ahead and complain. Until then, let's see how the CCGs shake out and wait for the final rankings.
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2025 04:11 PM by bryanw1995.)
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:03 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,944
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 03:08 PM)Native Georgian Wrote: The Committee would invite an 8-4 team from SEC or B1G before they would allow 3(!!!) G5 teams to participate. No, seriously, they would do that, if the alternative was having UNLV, JMU, and UNT/Tulane all in the same Playoff.
Well, it's certainly not happening this year. Could it happen in the future? Absolutely! The Committee has more and more begun to track the AP poll. You wanna see 3 g5 teams in the CFP in the future? Figure out a way to get 3 g5 teams in the top 10 of the final AP poll.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:13 PM |
|
bill dazzle
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast

Posts: 18,670
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2038
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
As many on the board know, I'm a fan of both Memphis and Middle Tennessee State. But if both programs ever make it to the 12-team playoff (UM from the AC and MTSU from C-USA), both the playoff specifically and college football in general will have some problems.
Two members of the G leagues this year could land invites to the playoff if Duke beats Virginia. And if that happens, we can all be assured the system will be updated so as to prevent that from ever taking place again.
Is it fair? Not necessarily. Would I like to see two G members go? In many respects, yes. But the big boys are not going to play around with this situation. If say James Madison and North Texas/Tulane both make it this year ... change will be in order.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:30 PM |
|
lance99
1st String

Posts: 1,284
Joined: Jun 2013
Reputation: 35
I Root For: Akron Zips
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2025 04:41 PM by lance99.)
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:40 PM |
|
Fresno Fanatic
1st String

Posts: 1,082
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 90
I Root For: Fresno State
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
This topic = Non starter
…MUCH to my dismay, however, LETS BE REAL!
*I do love your thinking, tho, AkZip fan, Lance99….(BIG!) BUT!…
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:42 PM |
|
andybible1995
Banned
Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. #23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Texas Tech
#6 Ole Miss
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. #23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Miami (FL) vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Vanderbilt vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
(This post was last modified: 11-30-2025 05:34 PM by andybible1995.)
|
|
| 11-30-2025 04:51 PM |
|
Fresno Fanatic
1st String

Posts: 1,082
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 90
I Root For: Fresno State
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 04:51 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
^THIS!^ is how it “should” be!!!
But it won’t happen because this is CFP LLC, not, NFL LLC (or whatever their respective legal terms are).
EVERY TEAM that wants to be in the CFP…and it SHOULD be 16, and NO MORE than…HAS to play 13 games!!
*I will add that BOTH ccg participants MUST be in the top 25 for their respective conference(s) to get autobid status for their ccg winner. So…ACC better NOT have Duke in their ccg! LMAO
**And 5 loss Duke better NOT be in the final CFP top 25 poll!!!
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:07 PM |
|
andybible1995
Banned
Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 05:07 PM)Fresno Fanatic Wrote: (11-30-2025 04:51 PM)andybible1995 Wrote: Here's my solution that I posted in another thread:
Expand the playoff to 24 teams using the rankings from the Coaches poll and the AP poll.
Here's the rankings from the Coaches poll:
First round bye:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Tennessee
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Georgia Tech
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Navy is left out.
Now here's the rankings from the AP poll:
#1 Ohio State
#2 Indiana
#3 Georgia
#4 Oregon
#5 Ole Miss
#6 Texas Tech
#7 Texas A&M
#8 Oklahoma
First round games (on-campus):
#9 Notre Dame vs. #24 Georgia Tech
#10 Alabama vs. # 23 Navy
#11 BYU vs. #22 Arizona
#12 Vanderbilt vs. #21 Tulane
#13 Miami (FL) vs. #20 North Texas
#14 Texas vs. #19 James Madison
#15 Utah vs. #18 Michigan
#16 Virginia vs. #17 USC
#25 Missouri is left out.
Now, I know this will never EVER happen IRL, and even if it did happen IRL it would be subject to change due the CCG next Saturday and the Army vs. Navy game the following Saturday.
^THIS!^ is how it “should” be!!!
But it won’t happen because this is CFP LLC, not, NFL LLC (or whatever their respective legal terms are).
EVERY TEAM that wants to be in the CFP…and it SHOULD be 16…HAS to play 13 games!!!!
I expanded it to 24 teams since that's how many teams participate at the FCS level.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:10 PM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
(11-30-2025 02:30 PM)lance99 Wrote: I am just thinking out loud, but hear the plausible scenario out for this to happen:
Step One:
-Duke MUST beat Virginia. This whole thing falls apart if this does not happen. Not only it will ice out Miami, there is no way the Committee put a 5 Loss Conference Campion in the Playoff(Notre Dame still gets in because they are Notre Dame)
Step Two:
-James Madison Takes care of business against Troy(Convincing Win). This plays into Step One due to they will leapfrog Duke.
Step Three:
-Alabama Lose the SEC Title Game and get blown out by Georgia. Sorry SEC Fans, but the Committee cannot justify having 4+ Schools from your Conference in the Playoff, especially if Alabama has lost Three games.
Step Four:
-UNLV blows out Boise. This is the long shot. That game will be close, IMHO. But if they blow out Boise, they still need help.
Step Five:
-Miami(OH) Wins the MAC Title Game. That actually helps UNLV due to they beat a Conference Champion Vs North Texas needing OT to beat Western Michigan.
I know that this is a deep Rabbit Hole I am going down, but you could see the AAC Champion, JMU and UNLV in the playoff  
Not really, you can't.
There are only five AQ bids in the CFP. There is no way the conference champions of the Big Ten (Ohio State-Indiana winner), SEC (Georgia-Alabama winner) or Big XII (Texas Tech-BYU winner) miss the CFP. That leaves only two remaining AQ bids.
If Duke wins the ACC, that gives you a maximum of two AQ bids available for G5 teams. The third team would need to get an at-large bid. No way UNLV gets that bid, in light of the fact that they are currently unranked.
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:16 PM |
|
TroyFootball05
1987 Man of the Year

Posts: 11,409
Joined: Feb 2009
Reputation: 671
I Root For: Good Times
Location: 8-Bit Pizza Bar
|
RE: How to get 3 G5 Teams into the Playoffs
Is there a loophole where they just decide not to rank a fifth champion (JMU in the scenario where Duke is not ranked), and move directly to at large bidding?
|
|
| 11-30-2025 05:24 PM |
|