(10-03-2025 04:02 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (10-03-2025 03:53 PM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: I haven't been following this, but what's the legitimate differences between them not being allowed to move up independent but Liberty being allowed?
Liberty was given an exception for the official reason that they were rich enough to fund independent FBS football and the unofficial reason that they would sue -and win- a religious discrimination lawsuit due to no-one being willing to let them join their conferences largely due to political/religious issues. Sac State is being excluded due to having poor facilities and no financial plan.
What The Beaver said.
On the one hand, Liberty had a big fat file of on-the-record and off-the-record statements from FBS athletic directors and presidents about Liberty's religious affiliation making them "not a fit" etc etc, and some of those comments were pretty salty. This is, after all, Jerry Falwell's university, widely regarded as snake-handling televangelist barely literate con artists, with an online school attached that is / was widely regarded as a diploma mill, run at the time by Jerry Falwell Jr, who sprouted rightwing positions on various issues publicly while not-so-privately enjoying watching his wife get railed by the pool boy.
So Liberty had an excellent chance of winning a lawsuit based on the premise that their exclusion was based on religious discrimination -- what we would now call "woke" college administrators having animus against Liberty University's flavor of Christianity and demographic base.
The other pincer of Liberty's case is that the reasons that the conference invite rules are supportable at all do not apply in Liberty's case. The conference invite rule is justifiable (probably) because it helps to ensure that Division I-A or FBS schools are able to put together a competiitve FBS schedule and to finance a competitive FBS program. The conference invite
allows the NCAA to offload that decision-making onto the conferences. If the Mountain West determines that UC Davis is FBS caliber and that Sacramento State is not, that's good enough for the NCAA. When Liberty applied for the waiver, they had tentative contracts for an FBS schedule for 2018, and could easily show that they had the financial backing to exist and compete in lower-FBS football.
Within a few months of Liberty getting their FBS waiver (February 2017), they were able to announce their 2018 FBS schedule (May 2017)
https://www.underdogdynasty.com/2017/5/1...inion-nmsu
Sacramento State doesn't have either of those two factors working for them.