Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-14-2025 07:28 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (10-14-2025 07:11 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-14-2025 06:30 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (10-01-2025 10:15 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: (09-20-2025 10:17 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I know that the top SEC game was 8.03m last year and the #2 game was 5.5m, and maybe I’ll make a separate thread for all the P4 conference ratings, but I’m not looking to dig at the B1G tbh. Oh, I also remember that CBS was 3.54m and NBC was more like 4.5m last year. I would have compared whatever CBS brought in ahead of the SEC gotw, it just happens that it was a B1G 2nd or 3rd tier game. If CBS had gotten the B1G gotw then they would have been fine, their error was paying about the same for mostly lesser games, the #2 or #3 game most weeks in the B1G, than they could have gotten by working a tiny bit harder to be better partners for the SEC. Not even the exact terms that ESPN paid for the SEC gotw, but just paying pro rata when A&M and Missouri joined. Less than $10m a year for a decade, and they would have had the SEC gotw through 2034. Penny wise and pound foolish.
Still baffles me how intransigent CBS was for years and years despite the fact they knew they had an incredible value on their hand. Oh well.
I think CBS's attitude was simply to milk that incredible value for the duration of what was a very long contract, 15 years, and they successfully did that.
I do agree though that CBS was dumb not to do a deal, after Mizzou and TAMU joined, to do a pro-rata. They could have done IIRC what ESPN did, and trade that and a boost in exchange for an extension out to 2034 to match ESPN's deal.
While this would have cut into their short-term profits, they still would have profited, and the extension signed in 2013 would have been for far less $$$ than ESPN is paying right now for those GOTW rights.
CBS refusing to do that basically saved the SEC, IMO, as otherwise it would be in the same position as the ACC, and there would be a mutiny of schools joining the B1G, I think.
It’s a reminder that networks are run by human beings… and those human beings often have different incentives than “CBS” or “NBC” or whoever else as an entity. The entities where they are guided by people in it through the long haul - see Rupert Murdoch with Fox or Bob Iger with Disney - will take a long-term view and are incentivized as such since their wealth is tied to the long-term value of the company. Most people at the networks or frankly all of corporate America, though, are at-will salaried employees that are incentivized on a short-term basis. They get judged on profits and how much they lowered expenses for the next year or quarter and rarely get credit because they made some savings for the company that may not be realized for 10 or 15 years down the line.
That’s likely what happened here. This wasn’t hubris by “CBS” as an entity, but rather executives at the time made a decision based on their own personal incentives. They were being judged on how much money that they saved CBS in 2013 and acted accordingly. There are very few or no people at CBS Sports that were there in 2013 that are still there in 2025, so why would have they acted any different from a rational perspective?
And frankly, it wasn’t irrational even from an CBS entity perspective. The SEC contract was going to run for another decade-plus at the time, so what CBS was looking at was locking in a higher expense for a very long period when they weren’t obligated to do so. We can also pretend that the SEC maybe would have then treated CBS nicer in the negotiations this decade, but Greg Sankey was rightfully going to take the highest bid for that Game of the Week package and ESPN offered the most. If CBS had bid the most and the SEC turned them down in favor of a *lower* bid from ESPN, then *that* would have been personal, but that’s not what happened. We can try to create drama because it’s way more interesting for forum fodder, but this was ultimately a standard vanilla choice of the SEC taking the highest bidder. That’s not personal - that’s just business.
To your point, CBS essentially saved the SEC from itself because they would have extended a bad Game of the Week contract even longer and we would have been looking at the league getting even more underpaid for its media rights until 2034 than they are now.
I agree with all this.
CBS was IMO in a no-lose situation, because in 2008 they signed what turned out to be an amazingly good deal. I think Aresco was the one who negotiated it, and he's an example of the kind of personnel moves you talk about, as he was gone from CBS by 2012.
So in 2013 they were in a position of either milking that deal for 15 long years, or surrendering some of those 2013 to 2024 profits in return for (what turned out to be) even more profits out to 2034. They chose the former, which may end up being less overall profitable than had they not saved the SEC from itself, but they still made an incredible amount of money.
What is ironic to me is that I believe that still to this day there is ire within the SEC about CBS refusing to do a pro-rata for any of the additions, while not seeming to realize that had CBS done that deal, which surely would have involved an extension as well, there would have been no $20m per school per year money-bomb boost in 2024 that is the only reason the SEC is now ball-park with the B1G, and thus isn't facing a mutiny where Alabama, LSU, Georgia, Florida, etc. are not all suing the league to get out of the GOR and join the B1G.
Heck, Texas and OU likely do not join in 2021 without the promise of that money-bomb (which IMO is itself less than it should be, but that's another story).
Heck - Jim Delany didn’t even hide the fact that ESPN executives straight up told him that the Big Ten starting the BTN was a stupid move. He felt personally insulted by it and threw it back in ESPN’s face every chance that he got when BTN ended powering a ton a revenue to the point that ESPN knew that it needed to the same to create conference networks for the SEC and ACC.
Yet, note that the Big Ten *still* signed two more deals with ESPN *after* that happened. ESPN paid up to the Big Ten in those next two contracts and the conference took them because that made the most financial sense despite the very personal grudge that the league had. The only reason why ESPN didn’t get any Big Ten rights in the current cycle is that there were *four* bidders ahead of them in terms of money: Fox, CBS, NBC, and Amazon (the latter of which actually bid more money than NBC for the prime time games but the university presidents wanted the over-the-air package). If ESPN had bid the most, then there would still be Big Ten games on ABC/ESPN, but that didn’t occur.
|
|