astr083
Special Teams

Posts: 600
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 3
I Root For: Ohio State & MAC
Location: Atlanta
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 11:10 AM)epasnoopy Wrote: (11-20-2025 10:31 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote: (11-20-2025 04:53 AM)epasnoopy Wrote: BG got renewed interest
Yes, we did. Bowling Green had wonderful attendance this season until the team started flailing with a fourth-string quarterback.
Quote:Look at BG's most recent Tuesday game. There were maybe 3-4k in the seats? BG reported nearly 10k.
Yes. It was raining and close to freezing and the team was 3-7, so yes, the number of people who decided to actually come out to the stadium for a Tuesday night pillow fight was light. Many people who enthusiastically bought tickets earlier in the season for that game decided to instead stay home.
All who did buy tickets for that game are counted in the 9,000+ attendance figure, even if they didn't come to the stadium. This is a very common and reasonable way to count attendance. No need to imply there is a conspiracy afoot here.
And Buffalo sold 15.2k tickets last night and only 2k showed up even though it was dry out and they were in contention for MAC title game.
The NDSU fan was worried about attendance for weekday games. He has good reason to be, no one goes to the games in contention for the MAC or not.
NIU fans don't even show up for Saturday games..... Not sure what point you are trying to make. NIU fans are probably less likely to do so in the MWC where the nearest conference mate is.....Wyoming?!
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2025 12:41 PM by astr083.)
|
|
| 11-20-2025 12:34 PM |
|
BeatWestern!
Heisman

Posts: 5,681
Joined: Feb 2018
Reputation: 575
I Root For: Central Michigan
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2025 12:40 PM by BeatWestern!.)
|
|
| 11-20-2025 12:35 PM |
|
astr083
Special Teams

Posts: 600
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 3
I Root For: Ohio State & MAC
Location: Atlanta
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-19-2025 07:31 PM)epasnoopy Wrote: (11-19-2025 04:16 PM)astr083 Wrote: (11-19-2025 03:49 PM)epasnoopy Wrote: (11-19-2025 03:28 PM)freshtop Wrote: Conference NET ratings:
2025: MVC-10th, MAC-23rd
2024: MVC-10th, MAC-23rd
2023: MVC-15th, MAC-19th
2022: MVC-11th, MAC-20th
2021: MVC-11th, MAC-15th
Averages:
MVC - 11.4
MAC - 20
Illinois State would have to be ready to focus on FBS at the expense of basketball to make the move, similar to UMass leaving the A10.
Correct, there is some false notion that with NIU leaving the MAC is jumping to multiple bids and top 10 Net conference ratings so the teams will get #8 seeds and higher now. Yet the MAC hasn't had multiple bids since 1990s. MVC was 10th rated and only got an 11 seed last tournament.
No one said the MAC is jumping to multiple bids, but with NIU gone, the conference rating should increase dramatically, year in and year out. There is not one team in the league that has been consistently as bad as NIU in basketball. They are nearly always finishing in last place with a 300+ rating. They continually drop the MAC's ranking as a conference. With them gone and with the addition of UMass, the MAC will definitely rise in both men's and women's basketball.
Incorrect, prior to last season the data shows NIU with an average 245 KenPom rating over previous 10 years.
What exactly is the MAC going to do with its higher Net ranking? Let's say they go from a Net 20 average to Net 15 average. Is NCAA going to give the MAC more money for a higher Net rating? Is ESPN going to give the MAC more money for its renewed basketball prowess?
A 245 average over 10 years... Wow...Impressive....Bahahaha
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2025 12:44 PM by astr083.)
|
|
| 11-20-2025 12:44 PM |
|
EP Bison Fan
Bench Warmer

Posts: 107
Joined: Aug 2023
Reputation: 25
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 10:24 AM)Steve1981 Wrote: OK folks, the pros and cons of adding 2 Dakota teams and feel free to add what I miss.
Cons
1. It’s a part time member not fully invested in the conference.
2. Additional travel expenses
3. They may dominate the MAC aka Marshall.
4. Smaller per share payouts with more members
5. More competition for recruits.
Pros
1. Media Partner has 24 more slots to pick from and additional time zone
2. Perhaps can offset that with negotiation for x number of protected rivalry games. Say 5 teams and the MAC decides on a yearly bases since the media partner has additional games in the inventory.
3. Perhaps negotiate an additional ESPN 2 game or heaven forbid ESPN. Would ESPN agree to an ESPN main channel for a matchup.
4. More protection to a major shuffle that some predict will happen in the early 2030’s.
5. Strengthens the MAC football ratings among G6 conferences.
6. Add home games by requiring the Dakota schools to play 1 or 2 away games in selected sports as basketball.
Picking a scenario on media contract of 20M for 12 teams and 22M for 14 teams to be conservative.
Con #1: Pro #6 is a partial offset, but still exists.
Con 2 and 4: Pro #2 can offset this with 5-8k additional home game attendances for the Saturday protected rivalry games. Winners and losses in the league.
Con 3: have no offset here.
Con 5: can cut both ways.
I think this is a reasonable list and you might have a compelling narrative to pitch ESPN. Get back into the central time zone, 14 team inventory with better football. You could throw out going to 9 conference games for even more games. Maybe 63 vs 48 games would be a value add, OCC scheduling is going to get harder with the P4 moving to 9 games anyway.
The MAC might have some leverage with Maction anyway. They can't force the AAC to do midweek until like 2032 with their next deal, so play hard ball. Max Maction should two games per program one home, one away all on ESPN 2. Same per team payout as today. It would still be the cheapest FBS content available until the AAC gets beat down in 5 years. With NIU leaving and ESPNU ratings hurting the conference should try to have some more backbone in the next contract.
|
|
| 11-20-2025 01:00 PM |
|
BeatWestern!
Heisman

Posts: 5,681
Joined: Feb 2018
Reputation: 575
I Root For: Central Michigan
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 01:00 PM)EP Bison Fan Wrote: (11-20-2025 10:24 AM)Steve1981 Wrote: OK folks, the pros and cons of adding 2 Dakota teams and feel free to add what I miss.
Cons
1. It’s a part time member not fully invested in the conference.
2. Additional travel expenses
3. They may dominate the MAC aka Marshall.
4. Smaller per share payouts with more members
5. More competition for recruits.
Pros
1. Media Partner has 24 more slots to pick from and additional time zone
2. Perhaps can offset that with negotiation for x number of protected rivalry games. Say 5 teams and the MAC decides on a yearly bases since the media partner has additional games in the inventory.
3. Perhaps negotiate an additional ESPN 2 game or heaven forbid ESPN. Would ESPN agree to an ESPN main channel for a matchup.
4. More protection to a major shuffle that some predict will happen in the early 2030’s.
5. Strengthens the MAC football ratings among G6 conferences.
6. Add home games by requiring the Dakota schools to play 1 or 2 away games in selected sports as basketball.
Picking a scenario on media contract of 20M for 12 teams and 22M for 14 teams to be conservative.
Con #1: Pro #6 is a partial offset, but still exists.
Con 2 and 4: Pro #2 can offset this with 5-8k additional home game attendances for the Saturday protected rivalry games. Winners and losses in the league.
Con 3: have no offset here.
Con 5: can cut both ways.
I think this is a reasonable list and you might have a compelling narrative to pitch ESPN. Get back into the central time zone, 14 team inventory with better football. You could throw out going to 9 conference games for even more games. Maybe 63 vs 48 games would be a value add, OCC scheduling is going to get harder with the P4 moving to 9 games anyway.
The MAC might have some leverage with Maction anyway. They can't force the AAC to do midweek until like 2032 with their next deal, so play hard ball. Max Maction should two games per program one home, one away all on ESPN 2. Same per team payout as today. It would still be the cheapest FBS content available until the AAC gets beat down in 5 years. With NIU leaving and ESPNU ratings hurting the conference should try to have some more backbone in the next contract.
One of the primary reasons the MAC hired Chris Turner to be its new Deputy Commissioner/COO two years ago is to work closely with ESPN and CBS Sports on a new and improved MMR contract. Turner has 25 years experience at ESPN, including nearly seven years as the Vice President of SEC Network.
https://getsomemaction.com/news/2023/6/2...r-coo.aspx
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2025 01:44 PM by BeatWestern!.)
|
|
| 11-20-2025 01:42 PM |
|
EP Bison Fan
Bench Warmer

Posts: 107
Joined: Aug 2023
Reputation: 25
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 01:42 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: (11-20-2025 01:00 PM)EP Bison Fan Wrote: (11-20-2025 10:24 AM)Steve1981 Wrote: OK folks, the pros and cons of adding 2 Dakota teams and feel free to add what I miss.
Cons
1. It’s a part time member not fully invested in the conference.
2. Additional travel expenses
3. They may dominate the MAC aka Marshall.
4. Smaller per share payouts with more members
5. More competition for recruits.
Pros
1. Media Partner has 24 more slots to pick from and additional time zone
2. Perhaps can offset that with negotiation for x number of protected rivalry games. Say 5 teams and the MAC decides on a yearly bases since the media partner has additional games in the inventory.
3. Perhaps negotiate an additional ESPN 2 game or heaven forbid ESPN. Would ESPN agree to an ESPN main channel for a matchup.
4. More protection to a major shuffle that some predict will happen in the early 2030’s.
5. Strengthens the MAC football ratings among G6 conferences.
6. Add home games by requiring the Dakota schools to play 1 or 2 away games in selected sports as basketball.
Picking a scenario on media contract of 20M for 12 teams and 22M for 14 teams to be conservative.
Con #1: Pro #6 is a partial offset, but still exists.
Con 2 and 4: Pro #2 can offset this with 5-8k additional home game attendances for the Saturday protected rivalry games. Winners and losses in the league.
Con 3: have no offset here.
Con 5: can cut both ways.
I think this is a reasonable list and you might have a compelling narrative to pitch ESPN. Get back into the central time zone, 14 team inventory with better football. You could throw out going to 9 conference games for even more games. Maybe 63 vs 48 games would be a value add, OCC scheduling is going to get harder with the P4 moving to 9 games anyway.
The MAC might have some leverage with Maction anyway. They can't force the AAC to do midweek until like 2032 with their next deal, so play hard ball. Max Maction should two games per program one home, one away all on ESPN 2. Same per team payout as today. It would still be the cheapest FBS content available until the AAC gets beat down in 5 years. With NIU leaving and ESPNU ratings hurting the conference should try to have some more backbone in the next contract.
One of the primary reasons the MAC hired Chris Turner to be its new Deputy Commissioner/COO two years ago is to work closely with ESPN and CBS Sports on a new and improved MMR contract. Turner has 25 years experience at ESPN, including nearly seven years as the Vice President of SEC Network.
https://getsomemaction.com/news/2023/6/2...r-coo.aspx
Nice hire.
|
|
| 11-20-2025 01:51 PM |
|
astr083
Special Teams

Posts: 600
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 3
I Root For: Ohio State & MAC
Location: Atlanta
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 01:51 PM)EP Bison Fan Wrote: (11-20-2025 01:42 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: (11-20-2025 01:00 PM)EP Bison Fan Wrote: (11-20-2025 10:24 AM)Steve1981 Wrote: OK folks, the pros and cons of adding 2 Dakota teams and feel free to add what I miss.
Cons
1. It’s a part time member not fully invested in the conference.
2. Additional travel expenses
3. They may dominate the MAC aka Marshall.
4. Smaller per share payouts with more members
5. More competition for recruits.
Pros
1. Media Partner has 24 more slots to pick from and additional time zone
2. Perhaps can offset that with negotiation for x number of protected rivalry games. Say 5 teams and the MAC decides on a yearly bases since the media partner has additional games in the inventory.
3. Perhaps negotiate an additional ESPN 2 game or heaven forbid ESPN. Would ESPN agree to an ESPN main channel for a matchup.
4. More protection to a major shuffle that some predict will happen in the early 2030’s.
5. Strengthens the MAC football ratings among G6 conferences.
6. Add home games by requiring the Dakota schools to play 1 or 2 away games in selected sports as basketball.
Picking a scenario on media contract of 20M for 12 teams and 22M for 14 teams to be conservative.
Con #1: Pro #6 is a partial offset, but still exists.
Con 2 and 4: Pro #2 can offset this with 5-8k additional home game attendances for the Saturday protected rivalry games. Winners and losses in the league.
Con 3: have no offset here.
Con 5: can cut both ways.
I think this is a reasonable list and you might have a compelling narrative to pitch ESPN. Get back into the central time zone, 14 team inventory with better football. You could throw out going to 9 conference games for even more games. Maybe 63 vs 48 games would be a value add, OCC scheduling is going to get harder with the P4 moving to 9 games anyway.
The MAC might have some leverage with Maction anyway. They can't force the AAC to do midweek until like 2032 with their next deal, so play hard ball. Max Maction should two games per program one home, one away all on ESPN 2. Same per team payout as today. It would still be the cheapest FBS content available until the AAC gets beat down in 5 years. With NIU leaving and ESPNU ratings hurting the conference should try to have some more backbone in the next contract.
One of the primary reasons the MAC hired Chris Turner to be its new Deputy Commissioner/COO two years ago is to work closely with ESPN and CBS Sports on a new and improved MMR contract. Turner has 25 years experience at ESPN, including nearly seven years as the Vice President of SEC Network.
https://getsomemaction.com/news/2023/6/2...r-coo.aspx
Nice hire.
I hope you're being sarcastic.... LOL
|
|
| 11-20-2025 02:46 PM |
|
Steve1981
Heisman

Posts: 6,909
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
Sounds like the 2021 expansion that almost happened is the main choice. Great if it can happen. I can wait 6 months, which would not rule out even a FCS team, though sounds like barely on the radar.
(This post was last modified: 11-20-2025 03:30 PM by Steve1981.)
|
|
| 11-20-2025 03:29 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
WKU would bring something to the MAC and Kentucky is not far from the conference office.
Delaware is a nice academic/cultural fit for the MAC.
I don't see the mutual benefit for the MAC with Middle Tennesse.
|
|
| 11-20-2025 06:37 PM |
|
NIU05
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,501
Joined: Jan 2008
Reputation: 50
I Root For: TRUTH
Location: Eternity
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 06:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
WKU would bring something to the MAC and Kentucky is not far from the conference office.
Delaware is a nice academic/cultural fit for the MAC.
I don't see the mutual benefit for the MAC with Middle Tennesse.
Agree on Delaware. Doesn't WKU need Middle Tenn to join as well? Seems odd for them to join being the only Southern school and not quite a cultural fit. I like them and it would be good for the MAC, but they would not get a big paycheck. Maybe surviving would be their goal, IDK.
|
|
| 11-20-2025 08:24 PM |
|
BisonFan02
Water Engineer

Posts: 1
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 2
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
Offer both NDSU and SDSU an all sports invite and we'd both go. The Summit isn't stable and we need a good D1 home for non-football as well. You don't need UND and USD in this scenario. Both stayed behind in D2 when both NDSU/SDSU moved up the first time....we don't need them. LOL
TV deals would be interesting for the locals though....we already kinda have a "love/hate" relationship with ESPN. They are the current "deal" with the MVFC and we HATE being their "game of the week". The Bison are covered much better (in production/quality) by statewide/regional ABC...was once NBC. We would bump Notre Dame games... ESPN took "The Marker" game between NDSU/SDSU and crammed it on ESPNU. Locals were pissed.....it got WAY worse ratings than it would've got on our regular contract.
|
|
| 11-20-2025 11:39 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 08:24 PM)NIU05 Wrote: (11-20-2025 06:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
WKU would bring something to the MAC and Kentucky is not far from the conference office.
Delaware is a nice academic/cultural fit for the MAC.
I don't see the mutual benefit for the MAC with Middle Tennesse.
Agree on Delaware. Doesn't WKU need Middle Tenn to join as well? Seems odd for them to join being the only Southern school and not quite a cultural fit. I like them and it would be good for the MAC, but they would not get a big paycheck. Maybe surviving would be their goal, IDK.
WKU is college town which fits the MAC and has alumni in the Louisville & Cincinnati metros that could travel to some of the MAC schools as well as Cleveland. Close proximity is something they won't have in general with CUSA or SBC if they want that one.
MT doesn't have alumni near enough to Ohio for it to make a difference. MAC might as well add FIU if they are just looking for a market.
|
|
| 11-21-2025 01:15 AM |
|
Schadenfreude
Professional Tractor Puller

Posts: 11,565
Joined: Jun 2003
Reputation: 515
I Root For: Bowling Green
Location: Colorado
 
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
I love posts like this from BeatWestern.
On Western Kentucky: I do think they would fit into our conference academically. They are also good at football, and they have a nice basketball tradition.
On the other hand, I don't really see how they enhance our television value, and they don't raise the bar academically. So, I'm surprised to see it said that MAC presidents have them at the top of a potential expansion list. What are they seeing that I am not?
Is there an argument that that 14 might be better for our television partners than 12? (Is the ability to provide more content fundamentally better for all of us?)
Also: Why has a Hilltopper fan not already chimed in here to say that this is crazy and that Western Kentucky has absolutely no interest in the MAC?
(This post was last modified: 11-21-2025 10:13 AM by Schadenfreude.)
|
|
| 11-21-2025 10:12 AM |
|
astr083
Special Teams

Posts: 600
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 3
I Root For: Ohio State & MAC
Location: Atlanta
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-21-2025 10:12 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
I love posts like this from BeatWestern.
On Western Kentucky: I do think they would fit into our conference academically. They are also good at football, and they have a nice basketball tradition.
On the other hand, I don't really see how they enhance our television value, and they don't raise the bar academically. So, I'm surprised to see it said that MAC presidents have them at the top of a potential expansion list. What are they seeing that I am not?
Is there an argument that that 14 might be better for our television partners than 12? (Is the ability to provide more content fundamentally better for all of us?)
Also: Why has a Hilltopper fan not already chimed in here to say that this is crazy and that Western Kentucky has absolutely no interest in the MAC? 
I agree, WKU and MTSU are both VERY blah additions, and academically they would be the worst in the conference. Culturally they do not fit, geographically they are southern, and both Murfreesboro & Bowling Green, KY are small, have small television markets, and quite honestly are not very nice towns. I do not see the appeal for either. Plus they were not that receptive when discussed the first time around. They also both struggle with fan support - MTSU especially. Even the worst MAC teams bring in better attendance.
Marshall.... Really?!? Again!?! So many reasons not to add them.
Temple.....I like this, but also agree they would not leave the AAC for the MAC unless it imploded, which is possible. It is also likely the AAC would backfill with the best of the other G5 conferences. Even then, I think the MAC is the better spot to land in for current conference teams, and ones that are closer regionally.
I absolutely love the idea of Delaware, but it does not get us into a neighboring state unless Temple is brought in.
I have always loved the idea of Stoney Brook, but they are FCS, so that seems to go against what the Presidents want....
Illinois State is also a meh add, and FCS, but I would rather have them over WKU or MTSU
Will be very interesting to see what happens.
(This post was last modified: 12-01-2025 11:49 AM by astr083.)
|
|
| 11-21-2025 02:45 PM |
|
GRBRONCO
All American

Posts: 2,525
Joined: Nov 2016
Reputation: 45
I Root For: WMU
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
Absolutely no reason to add any. 12 is perfect # for conference. I could see Ohio/Miami leaving for Sunbelt someday and possibly Toledo and/or Buffalo to the AAC. But if that happens nobody will want to join the MAC anyway.
(This post was last modified: 11-21-2025 03:03 PM by GRBRONCO.)
|
|
| 11-21-2025 03:02 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-21-2025 02:45 PM)astr083 Wrote: (11-21-2025 10:12 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
I love posts like this from BeatWestern.
On Western Kentucky: I do think they would fit into our conference academically. They are also good at football, and they have a nice basketball tradition.
On the other hand, I don't really see how they enhance our television value, and they don't raise the bar academically. So, I'm surprised to see it said that MAC presidents have them at the top of a potential expansion list. What are they seeing that I am not?
Is there an argument that that 14 might be better for our television partners than 12? (Is the ability to provide more content fundamentally better for all of us?)
Also: Why has a Hilltopper fan not already chimed in here to say that this is crazy and that Western Kentucky has absolutely no interest in the MAC? 
I agree, WKU and MTSU are both VERY blah addition, and academically they would be the worst in the conference. Culturally they do not fit, geographically they are southern, and both Murfreesboro & Bowling Green, KY are small, have small television markets, and quite honestly are not very nice towns. I do not see the appeal for either. Plus they were not that receptive when discussed the first time around. They also both struggle with fan support - MTSU especially. Even the worst MAC teams bring in better attendance.
Marshall.... Really?!? Again!?! So many reasons not to add them.
Temple.....I like this, but also agree they would not leave the AAC for the MAC unless it imploded, which is possible. It is also likely the AAC would backfill with the best of the other G5 conferences. Even then, I think the MAC is the better spot to land in for current conference teams, and ones that are closer regionally.
I absolutely love the idea of Delaware, but it does not get us into a neighboring state unless Temple is brought in.
I have always loved the idea of Stoney Brook, but they are FCS, so that seems to go against what the Presidents want....
Illinois State is also a meh add, and FCS, but I would rather have them over WKU or MTSU
Will be very interesting to see what happens.
The thing with Marshall is they really are only in the SBC since the Virginia schools are there and they may be headed to the American. Backfill into SBC will probably be someone like Liberty. There becomes a point where the MAC is the more attractive option.
That also goes back to the SBC East splt idea. That split is DOA if JMU/ODU find spots in the American.
A MAC+ with 14 teams makes the most sense. ESPN pushed the American to go to 14 in order to have more inventory so it could happen with the MAC. WKU and UDel would be my picks if I had to make them. WKU has different recruitng grounds than other MAC schools for a slight advantage. I see them as an 8 and 8 school (8 wins in FB & Top 8 in men's BB) year in and out.
Pods:
I: Delaware, UMass, Buffalo
II: Toledo, BGSU, Kent St, Akron
III: Ohio, Miami, Ball St, WKU
IV: CMU, EMU, WMU
Any new additions have to work into the pod alignment so taking Delaware in the east and Western Kentucky in the west provides good balance.
At the end of the day I doubt the MAC will fail us and invite someone like Austin Peay or Youngstown St. It definitely sounds as if they have a list of solid add. Middle Tennessee I don't why they are stil on the list as they rejected expansion on 2021 and are a top SBC backfill candidate. MT's FB team is also bad right now so don't believe they add much. They were stronger 10-15 years ago IMO.
|
|
| 11-21-2025 05:58 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-21-2025 03:02 PM)GRBRONCO Wrote: Absolutely no reason to add any. 12 is perfect # for conference. I could see Ohio/Miami leaving for Sunbelt someday and possibly Toledo and/or Buffalo to the AAC. But if that happens nobody will want to join the MAC anyway.
That's why it makes sense for the MAC to get to 14 to pad the numbers against defections. To also prevent schools from being enticed away.
|
|
| 11-21-2025 06:01 PM |
|
Schadenfreude
Professional Tractor Puller

Posts: 11,565
Joined: Jun 2003
Reputation: 515
I Root For: Bowling Green
Location: Colorado
 
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-21-2025 05:58 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: The thing with Marshall is they really are only in the SBC since the Virginia schools are there and they may be headed to the American.
Marshall? To the American? That is difficult for me to imagine. I'm not sure what direction they would go, but I feel like there have to be better options on the board in terms of market size and potential.
**EDIT** In reading this again, I think you imagine a Virginia school leaving. That makes more sense to me.
If I'm picking two schools for the MAC, I would probably pick Stony Brook and Illinois State. But I'm not opposed to doubling down in the East with Delaware or even Albany.
(This post was last modified: 11-21-2025 07:15 PM by Schadenfreude.)
|
|
| 11-21-2025 07:07 PM |
|
wmubroncopilot
Heisman

Posts: 8,975
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 150
I Root For: WMU
Location: Anchorage, AK
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-20-2025 06:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
WKU would bring something to the MAC and Kentucky is not far from the conference office.
Delaware is a nice academic/cultural fit for the MAC.
I don't see the mutual benefit for the MAC with Middle Tennesse.
The main benefit of MTSU is that WKU probably doesn't come without them (although this might be a thing of the past anyway).
That said, they aren't chopped liver by MAC standards either. Their on field results suck right now, but their recent history would be perfectly competitive in the MAC. They also "bring the Nashville market"-- I'm skeptical of how important this actually is for lower tier G5s, but it's something conferences seem to value. Solid enrollment and academically not much different than most of the MAC.
|
|
| 11-21-2025 07:36 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: Next TV deal
(11-21-2025 07:36 PM)wmubroncopilot Wrote: (11-20-2025 06:37 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (11-20-2025 12:35 PM)BeatWestern! Wrote: Gentlemen, these are safe assumptions:
1) Any MAC expansion will most definitely be tied to a new and improved MMR contract which would begin 01 July 2027.
2) IF the MAC expands, I would fully expect and be VERY SURPRISED if WKU is not one of the schools.
3) The MAC has indicated a preference for current FBS schools in expansion and although Temple and Marshall would be desirable adds, they're unlikely to make the move from their current conferences. I would list the order of precedence by the MAC Presidents as MTSU, Delaware, Illinois State and Stony Brook.
4) Conferences and prospective members talk frequently. IF the MAC is going to expand, effective July 1, 2027, we should know for sure within six months.
WKU would bring something to the MAC and Kentucky is not far from the conference office.
Delaware is a nice academic/cultural fit for the MAC.
I don't see the mutual benefit for the MAC with Middle Tennesse.
The main benefit of MTSU is that WKU probably doesn't come without them (although this might be a thing of the past anyway).
That said, they aren't chopped liver by MAC standards either. Their on field results suck right now, but their recent history would be perfectly competitive in the MAC. They also "bring the Nashville market"-- I'm skeptical of how important this actually is for lower tier G5s, but it's something conferences seem to value. Solid enrollment and academically not much different than most of the MAC.
This is like Kent State brings the Cleveland market.
|
|
| 11-21-2025 08:09 PM |
|