Morning MAC
Bench Warmer

Posts: 120
Joined: Jan 2025
Reputation: 12
I Root For: Michigan ASU MAC
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-15-2025 11:31 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 10:19 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: (07-15-2025 09:19 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:46 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (07-15-2025 08:02 AM)Tiger1983 Wrote: The composite shows Boise (#27) and Tulane (#29) neck and neck for the CFP G6 slot. The school with a stronger conference would have an advantage.
I don't think the stronger conference is actually any advantage at the G5 level for getting the bid. The only advantage strength of conference brings is if you have multiple top 25 teams in the league. The level of consideration I suspect the committee gives between winning a bunch of games against 75-80 ranked G5 schools vs 100-120 ranked G5 schools is next to zero. Lists of things I think they consider at the G5 level.
1. Did you beat a P4 school?
2. Did you play a really good P4 school close?
3. What's your overall record?
4. Did you happen to beat a ranked G5 school?
Don't think it goes a bit further than that. I think the actual best thing for maximizing the chances of getting the playoff bid for a G5 league would be a top 3 or so that is consistently ranked or close to it and then the rest of the league is pure trash that never beats the top. There's no benefit to being the "SEC of the G5" where everyone in the league is good enough to beat everyone.
Bolded is most important....and equally important is that they play in the CCG.
At the end of the year if a G6 conference has two teams ranked in the Top 25 playing in their conference championship game, the winner is likely to get the bid. The only caveat might be if another conference has someone ranked HIGHER than BOTH of the other conference's teams...then they likely wont drop with a win.
In the past, there was a correlation between earning a NY6/CFP spot and conference strength as measured by Massey Composite. I do not recall the factor, but it was material (although not +1). Correlation does not mean causation, but it is meaningful.
It makes sense because SOS is a consideration for selection and the reader may recall AAC members use to state with confidence a one-loss AAC school had an edge over an undefeated squad from another conference.
The old AAC by the end of the season would have 2-3 teams in the top 25 and usually another 2-3 teams receiving votes. The big key is getting late season and championship game ranked vs ranked matchups.
In basketball the bottom of the league being more respectable than awful matters a lot for getting multiple bids for the league. In football what matters more is there being enough quality at the top, and the bottom being awful doesn't really harm that prospect. The league can't have just exclusively bottom teams, but having 3 top 25 caliber teams and then bad teams that can't ever beat the 3 good teams doesn't hurt you because basically the committee barely cares about the details of the overall strength of G5 leagues.
^^THIS^^
In the G6, if your conference has 5 'good' programs:
- the goal would be to have 2 ranked at the end of the season.
- there will be 10 'good' intraconference games between those 5 'good' teams,
one a week during the conference season ( 1 'prize'  matchup a week) for tv.
- a larger bottom of the league bumps up the 'good' schools' records
- who cares if the rest of the league is 9 schools or 3 schools
(other than they siphon more dollars from the top schools)
|
|
| 09-10-2025 02:10 PM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,301
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-14-2025 09:59 PM)SkullyMaroo Wrote: I wonder what this would look like if you took the 10 year Massey Composite average ranking for each school and then averaged those out. I might piggyback of your post and calculate that tomorrow. That might give us more of an indication of what we could expect since lifting just one season doesn’t take into account the schedule differences some of these teams would have had. It also might not take into account teams that had an out of place season (either good or bad).
A problem with using MC data over time is that the components of the average change from week to week and year to year. And, the composite includes poll rankings which don't rank all schools. Consistency is the main reason why I prefer to use the Sagarin ratings for long term comparisons.
Sagarin's 10 year conference averages by 2026 alignment:
67 PAC
62 SBC
61 AAC
60 MWC
58 MAC
56 USA
It should be noted that Oregon State's and Washington State's ratings include data from years when they were playing in the PAC 12 with P5 budgets. There is no way to tell how much future ratings will be lower because they are playing in the nPAC.
If they decline by 10 points each, taking them to the bottom of the nPAC, the conference average would decline by 2.6 points.
(This post was last modified: 09-10-2025 08:41 PM by ken d.)
|
|
| 09-10-2025 08:06 PM |
|
Gemofthehills
Heisman

Posts: 5,172
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-10-2025 08:06 PM)ken d Wrote: (07-14-2025 09:59 PM)SkullyMaroo Wrote: I wonder what this would look like if you took the 10 year Massey Composite average ranking for each school and then averaged those out. I might piggyback of your post and calculate that tomorrow. That might give us more of an indication of what we could expect since lifting just one season doesn’t take into account the schedule differences some of these teams would have had. It also might not take into account teams that had an out of place season (either good or bad).
A problem with using MC data over time is that the components of the average change from week to week and year to year. And, the composite includes poll rankings which don't rank all schools. Consistency is the main reason why I prefer to use the Sagarin ratings for long term comparisons.
Sagarin's 10 year conference averages by 2026 alignment:
67 PAC
62 SBC
61 AAC
60 MWC
58 MAC
56 USA
It should be noted that Oregon State's and Washington State's ratings include data from years when they were playing in the PAC 12 with P5 budgets. There is no way to tell how much future ratings will be lower because they are playing in the nPAC.
If they decline by 10 points each, taking them to the bottom of the nPAC, the conference average would decline by 2.6 points.
And CUSA and SBC have schools who were playing with FCS budgets. These ratings have little to no value during this time span.
|
|
| 09-10-2025 09:09 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-10-2025 01:24 PM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (09-10-2025 12:35 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (07-14-2025 09:59 PM)SkullyMaroo Wrote: I wonder what this would look like if you took the 10 year Massey Composite average ranking for each school and then averaged those out. I might piggyback of your post and calculate that tomorrow. That might give us more of an indication of what we could expect since lifting just one season doesn’t take into account the schedule differences some of these teams would have had. It also might not take into account teams that had an out of place season (either good or bad).
I don't think that you can do that. Unlimited transfers and NIL have only been around for a few years, I think that at the least you should introduce a 2x/3x/4x/etc weighting to more recent seasons.
Mhmm, especially at the G5 level it's going to be the norm to be adding 40-50 new players a year. What you were able to accomplish prior to this reality means very little.
G6 a most programs still recruit to a system where lower P4 programs try to collect second tier studs that can wash out with a bad attitude.
Coaching staff becomes so important.
|
|
| 09-10-2025 09:11 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-10-2025 01:17 PM)quo vadis Wrote: I love the MC, but IMO no computers, or composites of computers, are worth looking at before six or so games have been played, as there are too few data points for meaningful analysis.
Agreed but the polls of the MC mostly if not nearly all have prior year biases included in the ratings.
|
|
| 09-10-2025 11:06 PM |
|
Side.Show.Joe
Heisman

Posts: 7,127
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 1344
I Root For: North Texas
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(07-14-2025 08:29 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: The 2025 Massey composite rankings only have so far 5 polls but interesting to look at because it includes new teams for 2025.
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
PAC 80.5
SBC 95
AAC 95.5
MWC 105
MAC 106.5
CUSA 121.5
-The nuPAC is the best G6 conference, definitely as step up from MWC 3.0 who is bouyed somewhat by the addition of Northern Illinois.
-SBC 16 with Ohio, Toledo, WKU instead of LaTech would have had a median ranking of 87 which closes about half the gap between itself and nuPAC.
-The MAC is closer in strength to SBC/AAC than what it is CUSA. WKU at 95 would help the MAC a little bit and always reliable to make the MAC Tournament (Top 8 qualify) along with making a bowl game.
-The AAC without Memphis & Tulane clocks in at 105.5 which puts it right around MWC/MAC level and substantially below the SBC.
I think the results we have seen through the first two weeks proves that Massey and the other experts can't accurately predict anything in the age of the Portal.
|
|
| 09-11-2025 10:35 AM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.
|
|
| 09-17-2025 12:36 PM |
|
HP-TBDPITL
Heisman

Posts: 5,528
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
(This post was last modified: 09-17-2025 01:15 PM by HP-TBDPITL.)
|
|
| 09-17-2025 01:14 PM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,301
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
|
|
| 09-17-2025 07:34 PM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 07:34 PM)ken d Wrote: The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
I'm an proponent of having the previous season biases included in the rating until the data is more connected 5 or 6 weeks in. Massey doesn't seem to be doing that in his numbers based on what you are posting above.
FWIW, he does seem to be using less data sources in his composite this year around 45-46 rankings compared to 125+ in previous years.
|
|
| 09-18-2025 09:14 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,301
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-18-2025 09:14 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: (09-17-2025 07:34 PM)ken d Wrote: The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
I'm an proponent of having the previous season biases included in the rating until the data is more connected 5 or 6 weeks in. Massey doesn't seem to be doing that in his numbers based on what you are posting above.
FWIW, he does seem to be using less data sources in his composite this year around 45-46 rankings compared to 125+ in previous years.
Unfortunately, that just gives even greater weight to an outlier like BC Moore, who also ranks Texas #37 this week. I guess his logic is that if you can't even beat the #28 team (Ohio State) you should be penalized for that.
|
|
| 09-18-2025 10:42 AM |
|
Garden_KC
Heisman

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-18-2025 10:42 AM)ken d Wrote: (09-18-2025 09:14 AM)Garden_KC Wrote: (09-17-2025 07:34 PM)ken d Wrote: The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
I'm an proponent of having the previous season biases included in the rating until the data is more connected 5 or 6 weeks in. Massey doesn't seem to be doing that in his numbers based on what you are posting above.
FWIW, he does seem to be using less data sources in his composite this year around 45-46 rankings compared to 125+ in previous years.
Unfortunately, that just gives even greater weight to an outlier like BC Moore, who also ranks Texas #37 this week. I guess his logic is that if you can't even beat the #28 team (Ohio State) you should be penalized for that.
Obviously the rankings are still shaping up since its only been 3-4 weeks.
|
|
| 09-18-2025 11:18 AM |
|
mturn017
ODU Homer

Posts: 18,901
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1828
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Roanoke, VA
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 07:34 PM)ken d Wrote: The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
LOL, I don't know seems legit to me.
|
|
| 09-18-2025 11:21 AM |
|
USF_Bullsharks
Special Teams

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 07:34 PM)ken d Wrote: The Massey rankings include the rankings of BC Moore. When I google him it appears he primarily ranks Iowa high schools. Looking at his college ranking this week in the MC, his Top 30 in order from 1-30 are:
Oklahoma
Utah
Illinois
Oregon
Georgia
Arkansas
USC
Indiana
Vanderbilt
TCU
Memphis
Florida State
Iowa State
Penn State
Houston
East Carolina
Old Dominion
Kansas
Cincinnati
Texas Tech
Alabama
Michigan
Ole Miss
Missouri
BYU
Mississippi State
Tennessee
Ohio State
California
Miami
It's hard for me to see this guy as a legitimate judge of college teams if he ranks Ohio State #28 and Old Dominion #16. Does Massey vet the services he includes in the Composite, or can just anybody play?
I think Miami should be at least top 25.
|
|
| 09-18-2025 11:43 AM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,182
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 01:14 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
I bet if you averaged each conference's top 4 teams massey composite for each year, it would be a great predictor of which conference got the access/playoff spot.
It doesnt matter if a conference had no bottom dwellers. They need a strong top of the conference in order to snag the bid.
|
|
| 09-19-2025 07:43 AM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-19-2025 07:43 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-17-2025 01:14 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
I bet if you averaged each conference's top 4 teams massey composite for each year, it would be a great predictor of which conference got the access/playoff spot.
It doesnt matter if a conference had no bottom dwellers. They need a strong top of the conference in order to snag the bid.
IIRC, the only time a conference wasn't in the top two in terms of top to bottom strength (not top four) but got the NY6 bid was Liberty two years ago. And Liberty would have failed the "top four" test too, as CUSA was awful that year.
Western Michigan, from the MAC, may also fit this profile as well, but again, I bet the MAC that year would fail both top four and top to bottom.
Anyway, as an aside, I don't care to use top to bottom as a predictor of who gets the NY6/CFP bid, because IMO they are separate things. Who the best G-team is has nothing necessarily to do with who the best conference is. Again, Liberty in 2023 was the best G, but were from a putrid conference.
The silliest idea someone can have (and no, I am not accusing you of having it) is to think that because conference X had a team get the CFP bid that this means they were the best conference. They might have been the best conference, but we would have to check and see.
(This post was last modified: 09-19-2025 09:05 AM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 09-19-2025 09:04 AM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,182
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-19-2025 09:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-19-2025 07:43 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-17-2025 01:14 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
I bet if you averaged each conference's top 4 teams massey composite for each year, it would be a great predictor of which conference got the access/playoff spot.
It doesnt matter if a conference had no bottom dwellers. They need a strong top of the conference in order to snag the bid.
IIRC, the only time a conference wasn't in the top two in terms of top to bottom strength (not top four) but got the NY6 bid was Liberty two years ago. And Liberty would have failed the "top four" test too, as CUSA was awful that year.
Western Michigan, from the MAC, may also fit this profile as well, but again, I bet the MAC that year would fail both top four and top to bottom.
Anyway, as an aside, I don't care to use top to bottom as a predictor of who gets the NY6/CFP bid, because IMO they are separate things. Who the best G-team is has nothing necessarily to do with who the best conference is. Again, Liberty in 2023 was the best G, but were from a putrid conference.
The silliest idea someone can have (and no, I am not accusing you of having it) is to think that because conference X had a team get the CFP bid that this means they were the best conference. They might have been the best conference, but we would have to check and see.
LIberty was likely the lone exception. And the committee has said that was a mistake that they dont plan on making again.
|
|
| 09-19-2025 10:09 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,878
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-19-2025 10:09 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-19-2025 09:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-19-2025 07:43 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-17-2025 01:14 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: (09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
I bet if you averaged each conference's top 4 teams massey composite for each year, it would be a great predictor of which conference got the access/playoff spot.
It doesnt matter if a conference had no bottom dwellers. They need a strong top of the conference in order to snag the bid.
IIRC, the only time a conference wasn't in the top two in terms of top to bottom strength (not top four) but got the NY6 bid was Liberty two years ago. And Liberty would have failed the "top four" test too, as CUSA was awful that year.
Western Michigan, from the MAC, may also fit this profile as well, but again, I bet the MAC that year would fail both top four and top to bottom.
Anyway, as an aside, I don't care to use top to bottom as a predictor of who gets the NY6/CFP bid, because IMO they are separate things. Who the best G-team is has nothing necessarily to do with who the best conference is. Again, Liberty in 2023 was the best G, but were from a putrid conference.
The silliest idea someone can have (and no, I am not accusing you of having it) is to think that because conference X had a team get the CFP bid that this means they were the best conference. They might have been the best conference, but we would have to check and see.
LIberty was likely the lone exception. And the committee has said that was a mistake that they dont plan on making again.
Maybe Western Michigan during their unbeaten season.
|
|
| 09-19-2025 10:24 AM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,182
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-19-2025 10:24 AM)bullet Wrote: (09-19-2025 10:09 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-19-2025 09:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-19-2025 07:43 AM)UofMstateU Wrote: (09-17-2025 01:14 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote: Just looking at the top of the Massey makes the most sense. You could probably go 4 down to get the best idea of the top strength of the conference.
I will say it is early in terms of computer rankings...after 5 or 6 games is a much better indicator because it removes preseason rankings pretty much entirely.
As you said, with both North Texas and USF not on the AC list, it really does look like the AC champ has a big lead for the CFP spot (although the committee doesnt look at Massey).
I bet if you averaged each conference's top 4 teams massey composite for each year, it would be a great predictor of which conference got the access/playoff spot.
It doesnt matter if a conference had no bottom dwellers. They need a strong top of the conference in order to snag the bid.
IIRC, the only time a conference wasn't in the top two in terms of top to bottom strength (not top four) but got the NY6 bid was Liberty two years ago. And Liberty would have failed the "top four" test too, as CUSA was awful that year.
Western Michigan, from the MAC, may also fit this profile as well, but again, I bet the MAC that year would fail both top four and top to bottom.
Anyway, as an aside, I don't care to use top to bottom as a predictor of who gets the NY6/CFP bid, because IMO they are separate things. Who the best G-team is has nothing necessarily to do with who the best conference is. Again, Liberty in 2023 was the best G, but were from a putrid conference.
The silliest idea someone can have (and no, I am not accusing you of having it) is to think that because conference X had a team get the CFP bid that this means they were the best conference. They might have been the best conference, but we would have to check and see.
LIberty was likely the lone exception. And the committee has said that was a mistake that they dont plan on making again.
Maybe Western Michigan during their unbeaten season.
yep. Now that I'm thinking it over, the only time the top 4 massey average likely didnt dictate the winner is when someone other than the AAC got the slot.
|
|
| 09-19-2025 10:46 AM |
|
freshtop
All American

Posts: 4,807
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation: 345
I Root For: WKU
Location:
|
RE: G6 median massey composite w/ new 2026 lineups
(09-17-2025 12:36 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: Top 3 of the G6 composite by conference this week:
https://masseyratings.com/ranks
AAC
Tulane 33 (3-0)
Memphis 46 (3-0)
Navy 52 (3-0)
MWC
UNLV 61 (3-0)
New Mexico 88 (2-1)
Hawaii 94 (3-1)
MAC
Toledo 64 (2-1)
Ohio 70 (1-2)
Bowling Green 85 (2-1)
PAC
Boise St 66 (1-1)
Fresno St 73 (3-1)
Texas St 74 (2-1)
SBC
Old Dominion 68 (2-1)
James Madison 72 (1-1)
South Alabama 82 (1-2)
CUSA
Western Kentucky 86 (2-1)
Jacksonville St 92 (1-2)
Liberty 109 (1-2)
-AAC looks like its running away with the playoff spot, even with USF's loss this week. They still have 4 undefeated teams including North Texas who doesn't make the Top 3 yet.
-UNLV is the only undefeated team outside of the AAC. The MWC and the MAC are the only two conferences outside of the AAC with multiple teams in the Top 70.
-CUSA is looking even weaker this week after Liberty's loss to Bowling Green.

And yet Massey still has the MAC as the lowest rated FBS conference:
https://masseyratings.com/cf/fbs/ratings?c=1
|
|
| 09-19-2025 10:47 AM |
|